Why is Rachel Maddow on The Onion?

Bill Thompson

Banned
Joined
Oct 23, 2006
Messages
6,171
The world keeps getting stranger and stranger. I wonder what this means. What is Rachel Maddow doing on The Onion? While I am left trying to formulate a theory, I wonder what people here think. Is she saying "gotcha ! I was never a serious journalist anyway !"?
 
Last edited:
Maybe she just enjoys their work and took the opportunity for an appearance? Or she wanted to have some self-referential/self-deprecating humor after she publicly fell for satire? Did Bill O'Reilly showing up on the Colbert Report indicate that he doesn't consider himself a serious journalist?
 
We obviously need a law that makes sure that everyone is dead-serious at all times.
This "I'm just having a bit of fun" attitude is disrupting the whole country.







Sigh.
 
Maybe she just enjoys their work and took the opportunity for an appearance? Or she wanted to have some self-referential/self-deprecating humor after she publicly fell for satire? Did Bill O'Reilly showing up on the Colbert Report indicate that he doesn't consider himself a serious journalist?

But there is a difference. Bill O'Reilly would not agree to be part of one of Colbert's bits. Bill would not appear in charater and go along with an act pretending to be someone they are not and referring to something that is not real as if it was real.
 
But there is a difference. Bill O'Reilly would not agree to be part of one of Colbert's bits. Bill would not appear in charater and go along with an act pretending to be someone they are not and referring to something that is not real as if it was real.

Yeah, but Bill doesn't know how tides work. So he concentrates on being unintentionally funny. No time for the other kind.
 
So we agree O'Reilly is a bad example to draw a comparison to Maddow.

So, putting him aside, Is there any other example of someone who -- let's suppose -- wants to be respected as a journalist and decides to play a part in a news parody in character, appart from Maddow?

Also, what is the joke? What did her remark contribute? Was if funny, in your opinion, or just wierd? Someone suggested she did it because she has a sense of humor. I doubt that.
 
Last edited:
So we agree O'Reilly is a bad example to draw a comparison to Maddow.

So, putting him aside, Is there any other example of someone who -- let's suppose -- wants to be respected as a journalist and decides to play a part in a news parody in character, appart from Maddow?

Also, what is the joke? What did her remark contribute? Was if funny, in your opinion, or just wierd? Someone suggested she did it because she has a sense of humor. I doubt that.

Actually, I really do not care. She is smart, she is funny, she is knowledgable and she is on the right side of most topics (except guns).
 
So we agree O'Reilly is a bad example to draw a comparison to Maddow.

Comparing Bile-O to a rationall human being is laughable.

Also, what is the joke?

It was a parody of how rivals who are supposed to be part of the same team talk to each other on camera when one of them has an event to celebrate. How many people would like to say that in front of an audience about some annoying schmuck in the same office?

What did her remark contribute? Was if funny, in your opinion, or just wierd? Someone suggested she did it because she has a sense of humor. I doubt that.

Best laugh I had all day. Why do you think Maddow is as popular asshe is, if not for her ability to talk intelligently and with a wry humor? Did you think it was because we all have the flaming hots for her?
 
So, putting him aside, Is there any other example of someone who -- let's suppose -- wants to be respected as a journalist and decides to play a part in a news parody in character, appart from Maddow?

Well, not exactly analogous, but one of our party leaders (of the Leftist party, if you're curious) here in Sweden appeared in a rather funny sketch where he bought stolen wheel rims and car radios in a back alley.
 
So, putting him aside, Is there any other example of someone who -- let's suppose -- wants to be respected as a journalist and decides to play a part in a news parody in character, appart from Maddow?

Doesn't the Giant Head Of Brian Williams occasionally give Jon Stewart journalism advice? I believe Williams also appears on 30 Rock playing a parody of himself somewhat regularly.
 
Mike Huckabee appeared in the same episode, thanking The Onion for not destroying him as they surely could.
 
Do you think Jon Stewart would add his talents to an Onion bit?
Somehow I can't imagine he really would.

Although he does his comedy bits on his show, you can tell by his expression when he is being serious. Well, I can.

Maddow has the same broad smile no matter what she is saying. But I had assumed that she wanted people to take her serously since she covered serious topics.
 
Do you think Jon Stewart would add his talents to an Onion bit?
Somehow I can't imagine he really would.

Although he does his comedy bits on his show, you can tell by his expression when he is being serious. Well, I can.

Maddow has the same broad smile no matter what she is saying. But I had assumed that she wanted people to take her serously since she covered serious topics.


So Bill Thompson doesn't take Maddow seriously anymore because of this. I'm sure she just lost a big fan.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom