Why I despise the Truthers

Report all you want. Just be sure to answer the question when you are done.

If they didn't test any steel without ANY fire-proofing how does this help them come up with the numbers they put into their computer model?

In other words what's your point in relation to my original question?

Your original point was that they did do tests and the numbers were not consistant. Are you willing to admit that you were wrong and that no such tests were done?
 
It has to be their blind political bias showing as they suspend rational thought and bring out the thermite, or the beam weapons or just hearsay bs talk.

It is also their lack of facts, they just talk and bring up Iraq, or what Bush said, chanting "inside job" and not supporting their incomplete conclusions with evidence. Zero evidence, no real ideas on what really happen.

Hearsay, they only use what other people make up; Griffin is the big example I see. Or pick any of the current truthers not really saying anything.

No ties to reality; no coherent story of what did happen.

Bringing up or trying to tear down NIST, when they do not even know the goals of the NIST report. Is that due to truthers can not read 10,000 pages that may contain real fact and information without being dustified?

Do not tell them NIST is not needed to solve 9/11. I also find the lack of fact to be the real weakness. Look at the current set of truthers who post, just talk, totally reactive, no real proactive approach of presenting what happen with facts and evidence.
If the goals of the NIST report wasn't to find out completely what happen to the towers from the point of impact until it was nothing but a pile of smoldering rubble then fine.

Just don't point to their theory of collapse initiation as complete proof of what happened on 9-11.

It's not. Sorry.
 
If the goals of the NIST report wasn't to find out completely what happen to the towers from the point of impact until it was nothing but a pile of smoldering rubble then fine.

NIST's job was to determine what caused the collapses and to recommend ways to prevent such things occuring in the future.

Just don't point to their theory of collapse initiation as complete proof of what happened on 9-11.

It's not. Sorry.

No one ever said it was, but it is the best theory so far advanced and is the best supported of any theory out there. Where is the CT computer model showing that the towers could have only collapsed by CD? Where is the CT model of anything? If you want to prepare and present a well supported theory with your own models, then go for it, but till them, NIST is the best we have.
 
Prove it any way you want but until it's proven it's just another CT. You think you have the answer but based on what?
Science

Certainly not the credibility of the people behind putting the official version together. Take 9-11 out of the equation and these same people have not proven themselves credible on just about anything else.
Really i guess their degrees/research are just useless- what in your eyes makes them credible- oh and your sources are credible?

Where's this faith come from? And I'm talking about the complete 9-11 story not just the towers and how they did or didn't fall but the whole 9-11 story passed off as the truth. What led up to 9-11, the day of, and what's happened since.
its not a faith - my only faith is in god and my own free will

Take for instance why they claim we were attacked.
Because they hate our freedom? Is that really credible?
Yes its a common occurance around the world now and in the past - sometimes cultures, religions, societies clash. Did you ever take a world history class?
 
If the goals of the NIST report wasn't to find out completely what happen to the towers from the point of impact until it was nothing but a pile of smoldering rubble then fine.

Just don't point to their theory of collapse initiation as complete proof of what happened on 9-11.

It's not. Sorry.
The WTC collapsed due to impact and fire. Facts, not theory. I do not need NIST, and you do not even have a coherent ides what happened on 9/11.

You have not even presented one fact about it. The fact is steel fails in fire. The impacts on 9/11 were 7 to 11 times greater than the design impact the chief engineer planned on. More Facts. You still have not presented facts. The buildings were damaged by the energy of impacts equal to 1300 and 2200 pounds of TNT. Like big bombs the planes damaged like bombs would. The fuel from just the jets, each jet, released 315 TONS of TNT energy in HEAT. Then the buildings fire protection damaged, and fire control systems inop, lead to the failure of the steel as the office fires added to the destruction. Facts.

You have yet to present facts, you present hearsay at best and talk about NIST, but not what happen. The NIST model is not needed, the actually thing happened on 9/11. There were zero visual evidence of explosive, and no supporting evidence. These are facts too.

The fact is you are fact less in a fact filled debate, you have demonstrated with precision you have no idea what NIST goals are, or what you are talking about. You are just all talk, no action, no research, no clue about what happened on 9/11. So how did it really go down, where is this Pulitzer Prize evidence that will rock my world?
 
Your original point was that they did do tests and the numbers were not consistant. Are you willing to admit that you were wrong and that no such tests were done?
I only said they did fire tests on steel and documented the sag and if collapse occurred or not. For some reason you wanted to know if they did any partially or unclad steel. I showed where they did tests with different amounts of fire-proofing sprayed on. Someone else pointed to some grainy picture of a “hanging object” in the building. How anyone could attribute this hanging object to anything other then the plane impact I still don’t know.

The best answer I got was that the physical fire tests were done just for comparisons not to determine what to put into the computer model. That’s fine but it still doesn’t answer my question.

Whatever they were for or whether or not they did any tests without fire-proofing doesn't answer how they came up with 42 inches of sag.

That was my question What test did NIST perform warranted 42 inches of sag into their computer model? The only answer I got was video.

Video? Is that it?
 
If the goals of the NIST report wasn't to find out completely what happen to the towers from the point of impact until it was nothing but a pile of smoldering rubble then fine.

Just don't point to their theory of collapse initiation as complete proof of what happened on 9-11.

It's not. Sorry.

I think a lot of people misunderstand the goals of the NIST and their investigation regarding the world trade center, so I'm glad you have brought this up. You can read their statement as to their purpose here:

http://wtc.nist.gov/

But, I'll post the relevant section:

In response to the WTC tragedy, the National Institute of Standards and Technology conducted a 3-year building and fire safety investigation to study the factors contributing to the probable cause (or causes) of post-impact collapse of the WTC Towers (WTC 1 and 2) and WTC 7; expanded its research in areas of high-priority need such as prevention of progressive collapse, fire resistance design and retrofit of structures, and fire resistive coatings for structural steel; and is reaching out to the building and fire safety communities to pave the way for timely, expedited considerations of recommendations stemming from the investigation.
(their bolding)

As a design professional in the building industry, I would like to state, emphatically, that we're not really interested in arresting a collapse that has already begun. That's silly. It is far better to prevent it from starting in the first place. That's why the NIST is tasked with investigating collapse initiation, not the progression.

http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/releases/n02-14.htm

In fact, were the NIST To devote any amount of time or monies to researching these things you have questions about, which are outside of those things they have been asked to look into, they would be guilty of wasting taxpayer dollars. The idea is to make suggestions to improve building design, update codes, and keep professionals informed as to what potential issues may exist, not to answer every question from laypeople who have doubts or simply don't understand the subject.

http://wtc.nist.gov/media/WTCplan_new.htm
 
I think a lot of people misunderstand the goals of the NIST and their investigation regarding the world trade center, so I'm glad you have brought this up. You can read their statement as to their purpose here:

http://wtc.nist.gov/

But, I'll post the relevant section:

(their bolding)

As a design professional in the building industry, I would like to state, emphatically, that we're not really interested in arresting a collapse that has already begun. That's silly. It is far better to prevent it from starting in the first place. That's why the NIST is tasked with investigating collapse initiation, not the progression.

http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/releases/n02-14.htm

In fact, were the NIST To devote any amount of time or monies to researching these things you have questions about, which are outside of those things they have been asked to look into, they would be guilty of wasting taxpayer dollars. The idea is to make suggestions to improve building design, update codes, and keep professionals informed as to what potential issues may exist, not to answer every question from laypeople who have doubts or simply don't understand the subject.

http://wtc.nist.gov/media/WTCplan_new.htm


OK?

I understand what they did and what they claim. I also understand it's a theory as to what happened the WTC up until collapse initiation so it's not even complete as far as what occurred all the way to the end of the collapse. I understand why they claim they stopped at collapse initiation.

I just don’t believe their theory.
 
The WTC collapsed due to impact and fire. Facts, not theory. I do not need NIST, and you do not even have a coherent ides what happened on 9/11.

You have not even presented one fact about it. The fact is steel fails in fire. The impacts on 9/11 were 7 to 11 times greater than the design impact the chief engineer planned on. More Facts. You still have not presented facts. The buildings were damaged by the energy of impacts equal to 1300 and 2200 pounds of TNT. Like big bombs the planes damaged like bombs would. The fuel from just the jets, each jet, released 315 TONS of TNT energy in HEAT. Then the buildings fire protection damaged, and fire control systems inop, lead to the failure of the steel as the office fires added to the destruction. Facts.

You have yet to present facts, you present hearsay at best and talk about NIST, but not what happen. The NIST model is not needed, the actually thing happened on 9/11. There were zero visual evidence of explosive, and no supporting evidence. These are facts too.

The fact is you are fact less in a fact filled debate, you have demonstrated with precision you have no idea what NIST goals are, or what you are talking about. You are just all talk, no action, no research, no clue about what happened on 9/11. So how did it really go down, where is this Pulitzer Prize evidence that will rock my world?
These are not facts these are disputed theories. Do I have to have my own theory just because I don't believe the theory that's presently being pushed?

You don't believe something just because it's the only explanation offered up.
 

The NIST report is just a theory not a fact.

Really i guess their degrees/research are just useless- what in your eyes makes them credible- oh and your sources are credible?

There are plenty with the same degrees and knowledge that disagree.

its not a faith - my only faith is in god and my own free will

All this tells me is you could be prone to blind faith. Nothing scientific about that.

Yes its a common occurance around the world now and in the past - sometimes cultures, religions, societies clash. Did you ever take a world history class?

There is no credibility to the sound bite “They Hate Our Freedom”.
 
OK?

I understand what they did and what they claim. I also understand it's a theory as to what happened the WTC up until collapse initiation so it's not even complete as far as what occurred all the way to the end of the collapse. I understand why they claim they stopped at collapse initiation.

I just don’t believe their theory.

But why do you feel that you need to know what happened after collapse initiation?
 
what is the op anyway? you are one of the reasons

These are not facts these are disputed theories. Do I have to have my own theory just because I don't believe the theory that's presently being pushed?

You don't believe something just because it's the only explanation offered up.
Do you have a problem identifying facts. Do you have problems posting to the OP?

I stated a bunch of facts, why are you unable to identify the facts? Are you unable to figure out energy, like E=1/2MVV? Did you miss physics class, we can help you with physics, there are many here who took physics in high school and college and are now those engineers, and some are just very smart rational think people who post here. We can help you, but you have not presented any thing rational yet on 9/11; or asked some real good questions. I don't need NIST. But they sure did a lot of work for people to use.

BTW, there are hundreds of reports on the WTC from other sources that support, impact, fire, collapse. You have lost the edge to see the big picture by concentrating on the NIST BS. The other reports are being used, have been used, to improve buildings that are being built now and have been built since 9/11. You my poor mislead truther type person are being left behind as the world moves on and leaves you fringe guys holding the lie bag on 9/11. What will you do when you finally understand you are in the biggest fraud movement of the decade if not the next 100 years.
 
Last edited:
The NIST report is just a theory not a fact.
No science is science I never mentioned anything about NIST



There are plenty with the same degrees and knowledge that disagree.
if by plenty you mean a SMALL MINORITY



All this tells me is you could be prone to blind faith. Nothing scientific about that.
All this tells me is that you ate lead paint as a child



There is no credibility to the sound bite “They Hate Our Freedom”
more lead paint. you dont even make sense - one culture believes another should bow to its will. Do you think Radical Islam support Democracy or Free Speech?
 
The NIST report is just a theory not a fact.
You might want to read this to help you better understand this concept with which you are struggling.

There are plenty with the same degrees and knowledge that disagree.
Really? The same degrees and knowledge as the experts who put together the NIST report? Please list these experts whose credentials are the equivalent of those of the NIST researchers that disagree with the official theory.

All this tells me is you could be prone to blind faith. Nothing scientific about that.
You'll find all the scientific data you require in the NIST report. Your choosing to disbelieve it does not render it invalid. You actually have to refute it. With more science. Got any? I didn't think so.

There is no credibility to the sound bite “They Hate Our Freedom”.
You're the only one trying to pass that soundbite off as the only explanation that's been put forth. Plenty has been written by very knowledgable people. Of course, none of this has been made available on Youtube, so that's probably why you missed it. You'll find most of this information in something called "books".
 
Personally I would like to second Johnny's request that Zen provide some experts with the same credentials as the contributers to the NIST report who disagree with the official story.
 
Originally he tried to claim Quintere problem was a small issue with fire saftey only. Nothing else.

Now it's changing. Now its all of a sudden I said Quinteres problems were independent of fire saftey. And that I claim Quintere supports a conspiracy theory.

I didn't.

Doesn't change the fact that his problem is a small issue with fire insulation only.

I said it was fire saftey and more. It can be both no?

Sure, but only if you can provide evidence that it is.

3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?

I don't think that means what you think it means. ReEad it again.

6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?

Again, without context we can't know why he feels 7 WTC's report should've been out sooner.
 
Man you are losing it!

How is pointing out your misinterpretation or outward misrepresentation of someone else's words "losing it" ?

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."

Congratulations! You've removed the part that Karate thought was important. It's a nice sleigh of hand, assuming you could do it without being caught, which you've now realised, you can't.

I never said he did. We haven't got that far yet.

"I didn't say that! Strawman!! But I DO believe that, and I WILL say it, eventually..." :rolleyes:

You simply bold the word fire and assert that he's only talking about fire safety when he's clearly talking about more then just that.

If it's THAT clear you'll have no problem bolding the other part of the text which you feel is significant.

He talks about the collapse mechanism, computer models, wtc7, the politics surrounding NIST, etc. etc.

All of which could relate to the fire unless you can clearly show that it doesn't, since we've already seen that he's talking at least about the fires.

Keep playing stupid see what it gets you.

There, there, now. That's not the way an adult debates. You're not supposed to start claiming the opponent doesn't believe what he says he believes. Otherwise you open a Pandora's box and you might not like what's inside.

What is so hard to understand or is so unbelievable that I don't think there has been a valid investigation into 9-11?

It's quite easy to believe. If that was the only thing you wanted to prove, you've succeeded. What WE've been trying to understand, is WHY you think so.
 
If I truly believe this then you tell me how I can take anything off the table including inside job until it's done properly?

[...]

Anyone who thinks they know the facts surrounding 9-11 based on the official investigations to date is either lying or delusional.

Your bias is showing, Zen. Button up.

Any official investigation done to date is nothing more then a whitewash as far as I'm concerned. A whitewash to cover-up.

Cover up what, pray tell ?

And what's your evidence ? If you think the investigation was inadequate, then how do you know the twoof ?

Prove it.

Then I guess it all comes down to this: what level of proof would satisfy you ? Obviously, the level found in the NIST document doesn't.

19 hijackers is still a conspiracy is it not?

Yes, indeed. But it's not one that defies the laws of physics.

Everyone in the JREF conspiracy theory thread is a conspiracy theory believer.

That's because you don't know what "conspiracy theory" means. I suggest looking it up.

Where's this faith come from?

Evidence. Which of course means it's not faith at all.

Yeah well it seems these days the very experts you believe don't even seem to completely agree with them selves isn't that right? Which one is right?

Again, no matter which one wins, you lose.

Because they hate our freedom? Is that really credible?

It's a colourful way to put it, but yes. Religious extremists, especially Muslim fundamentalists, hate our way of life because they see it as decadent and against god. And since they're extremists... well you can do the math.

No ?

72 virgins. There. Beat that, Christians!

No. The 9-11 commission report is not science.

Indeed. We're talking about NIST, here.

The NIST report is a theory not a fact

You DO understand what "theory" means, right ?

And a highly disputed theory at that.

"Highly" ? No. A handful of malcontent truthers don't amount to "high" dispute.
 
Just don't point to their theory of collapse initiation as complete proof of what happened on 9-11.

It's not. Sorry.

Are you now claiming that the towers would not have collapsed completely after initiation ?

And are you ever going to adress the point about you championing a guy who hurts your cause ?

I understand what they did and what they claim. I also understand it's a theory as to what happened the WTC up until collapse initiation so it's not even complete as far as what occurred all the way to the end of the collapse.



I understand why they claim they stopped at collapse initiation.

I just don’t believe their theory.

Now you're just being sillier and sillier, Zen. You're simply being stubborn for no reason. This is turning into a religious argument from you.

These are not facts these are disputed theories.

Steel DOESN'T fail in a fire ? Please, Zen. Stop this.

You don't believe something just because it's the only explanation offered up.

Apparently, YOU don't believe something because you don't like the person or organisation that's saying it.
 
But why do you feel that you need to know what happened after collapse initiation?
The same reason I want to know any of it. I want to see how it could happen. It doesn't make sense. It's my opinion they left it out not because they weren't commissioned to show it I think they left it out because the couldn't do explain it. The report is on everything from evacuation procedures to emergency response to a very detailed explanation of this collapse initiation theory. That should show it follow through to further support the initiation theory.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom