Why I despise the Truthers

That site also lists a victim from the day? That is disgusting

Its OP

Many engineers and architects have expressed significant criticism of the 9/11 Commission Report. Several even allege government complicity in the terrible acts of 9/11. This section is a collection of their public statements. This website is not an organization and it should be made clear that none of these individuals are affiliated with this website.

Listed below are statements by more than 190 engineers and architects that contradict or are critical of the 9/11 Commission Report. Their collective voices give credibility to the claim that the 9/11 Commission Report is tragically flawed.

How can the dead guy question the 911 commission?

Also Jowenko, but funnily enough they do not mention debri damage to him about WTC7, why is that? They only mention fire?
 
If there were a prize about having to re-qualify assertions you would win the gold hands down.

Now. Perhaps is the time to do some investigating and actually find out who your beloved experts really are on patriotsquestion911.com.

Unless you believe them without question. Do you? Do you hold your sites and evidence to the same scrutiny as you do ours?
Who are yours? Did you find out before you put your faith into them? I mean don't go look for them now. Name them.

Who's you physicist and where's his paper?
 
I still haven't seen any of your experts or their papers.

Here (physicist, 20+ years experience, 30+ papers on photonics and related subjects). You won't find any papers from a physics perspective on the WTC collapses, for the simple reason that the gross features of the WTC collapses are explained perfectly satisfactorily by the laws of thermodynamics and Newtonian mechanics, hence there's no new physics involved. You'll find quite a few structural engineering papers on the WTC collapses, as the collapse of a 110-storey building had not occurred before 9-11 and there is a considerable amount of engineering analysis to be done on understanding the collapses in detail. You may find, however, that the content of the structural engineering papers is universally not to your liking.

Dave
 
I though there were "no actual physicists ".

That's what will never be true regardless of how many times liars swear it is.
And it will never make his findings any less untrue, at least according to all other physicists in the world considered his equal or greater.

See how that works? That's rhetorical obviously, keep telling yourself you have a point.
 
What exactly do you mean by no actual physicists believe that the collapses of the towers defy any scientific laws? Now if you are saying no physicists disagree with the official version then what is Steven Jones if not a physicist?

Steven Earl Jones is an American physicist. Jones earned his bachelor's degree in physics, magna cum laude, from Brigham Young University in 1973, and his Ph.D. in physics from Vanderbilt University in 1978. Jones conducted his Ph.D. research at the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (from 1974 to 1977), and post-doctoral research at Cornell University and the Los Alamos Meson Physics Facility. - wiki


You have problems understanding what people write. You parroted the twoofer nonsense about "impossible physics." I pointed out that no actual physicists have noticed any violations of the physical laws that govern the universe, and for a very good reason: those laws cannot be violated.

You offer the discredited Steven Jones, a man who has been repudiated by his own department for his failure to meet professional standards, a man who refuses to submit any of his work for peer review.

Are you acknowledging, then, that conspiracy liars have no science to support their pernicious falsehoods and fabrications?
 
Last edited:
You have problems understanding what people write. You parroted the twoofer nonsense about "impossible physics." I pointed out that no actual physicists have noticed any violations of the physical laws that govern the universe, and for a very good reason: those laws cannot be violated.

You offer the discredited Steven Jones, a man who has been repudiated by his own department for his failure to meet professional standards, a man who refuses to submit any of his work for peer review.

Are you acknowledgeing, then, that conspiracy liars have no science to support their pernicious falsehoods and fabrications?
Give it up.
 
Ok which ones and where?

Look, this really isn't something we're particularly interested in, as physicists. There is no unexplained physics in the WTC collapses. If I wrote and submitted a paper to a physics journal explaining how the collapses agree with known laws of physics, the rejection slip would read something along the lines of "Well, duh!" Pomeroo should really have pointed out the unanimity of peer-reviewed papers from structural engineers in their opinion that the collapse was due to fire and structural damage. There are actually a few physicists who are sufficiently out of touch with the real world that they do believe there's something wrong about the WTC collapses (A. K. Dewdney is another). They're idiots, and I apologise for them on behalf of my profession, but they exist. However, I defy you to find a single anonymously peer-reviewed paper in any discipline which supports the controlled demolition theory, whereas there are plenty that categorically reject it.

Dave
 
This isn't Gravy's site is it? Well whoever's site it is how is it any more valid then any other CT site?

Just because you agree with it?


Well I still haven't seen a CT site that has actually provided an paper published by anyone with credentials. Usually they just break it down and only post what they believe is wrong with it.

On the other hand, Gravy provides all information in its true and full form.

If you have a problem with Brazant's paper, maybe you should talk to Dr. Greening (Apollo20). He might be of some assistance.
 
This isn't Gravy's site is it? Well whoever's site it is how is it any more valid then any other CT site?

Just because you agree with it?

I simply submitted it for your perusal, without comment, because you asked for papers by experts supporting the official story. The paper has quite a bit of links to experts' opinions and papers concerning the collapses.

If you have a problem with any of the facts on that site you are more than welcome to address them, but that's not the issue.

The issue is that your support by true experts is dubious at best. Since you aren't any more qualified to judge these papers than I am, we both have to rely on these experts quite a bit. It's important to me that they actually are experts.

Doesn't that matter to you?
 
If you have a problem with Brazant's paper, maybe you should talk to Dr. Greening (Apollo20). He might be of some assistance.

Zen doesn't have a problem with the paper, Gordon Ross does. Zen has no idea if what Ross is saying makes sense or not. That's why, as you suggest, Greening is critical as a 'second opinion'.

Zen is content to believe Ross. I on the other hand wasn't sure so I DID RESEARCH and found Greening. Having both sides of the subject, I then took into account the prevailing expert opinion and came to my conclusion.

I have no idea if Zen actually did that.

Did you, Zen?
 
I simply submitted it for your perusal, without comment, because you asked for papers by experts supporting the official story. The paper has quite a bit of links to experts' opinions and papers concerning the collapses.

If you have a problem with any of the facts on that site you are more than welcome to address them, but that's not the issue.

The issue is that your support by true experts is dubious at best. Since you aren't any more qualified to judge these papers than I am, we both have to rely on these experts quite a bit. It's important to me that they actually are experts.

Doesn't that matter to you?
Back up.

I was told there are no actual physicists that say the laws physics were defied on 9-11. I never claimed there was.

I only said Steven Jones is a real physicist who disputes the official version. Then of course we have to go down the same old tired road about peer review and if it's valid peer review and blah blah blah.

So I asked what physicist supports the official version and with what paper.

I was given Bazant which although he has a diploma in physics he is really more of an engineer. But that's fine. He just doesn't have the credentials of Jones in physics. I gave a link of a whole list of engineers and architects. Discredit them all it’s just your opinion.

I was also given Gravy's paper. Fine. Gravy has no degrees in Physics or Engineering or anything that I know of. So who was the one who brought up actual physicist in the first place?

Me?
 
Zen doesn't have a problem with the paper, Gordon Ross does. Zen has no idea if what Ross is saying makes sense or not. That's why, as you suggest, Greening is critical as a 'second opinion'.

Zen is content to believe Ross. I on the other hand wasn't sure so I DID RESEARCH and found Greening. Having both sides of the subject, I then took into account the prevailing expert opinion and came to my conclusion.

I have no idea if Zen actually did that.

Did you, Zen?
Does Greening fully support the official version?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom