Why I despise the Truthers

Explain or retract you statement.

Outside of the topic of fire safety...what were his issues as they related to the NIST report?
 
Explain or retract you statement.

Outside of the topic of fire safety...what were his issues as they related to the NIST report?
Outside of fire safty?

Encompasses more then just fire saftey.

Know the difference?

I think you do.
 
LOL

Keep spinning. All of you.

I love it when you all dance for me.

Just go back and read. It's hilarious.

What part of his disagreement being related to the fire protection don't you understand ?

Spinning again with the strawman?

What strawman ? Are you saying now tha this criticism is ONLY about the insulation ?

Encompasses more then just fire safety.

Make up your mind.

Outside of fire safty?

Encompasses more then just fire saftey.

Know the difference?

Those aren't even sentences.
 
What part of his disagreement being related to the fire protection don't you understand ?



What strawman ? Are you saying now tha this criticism is ONLY about the insulation ?



Make up your mind.



Those aren't even sentences.
Originally he tried to claim Quintere problem was a small issue with fire saftey only. Nothing else.

Now it's changing. Now its all of a sudden I said Quinteres problems were independent of fire saftey. And that I claim Quintere supports a conspiracy theory.

I didn't.

I said it was fire saftey and more. It can be both no?

How are the following statements just about a "small issue" of fire safty and nothing else?

3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?

6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?He also has these problems with the NIST report….

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."
 
Originally he tried to claim Quintere problem was a small issue with fire saftey only. Nothing else.
Let's take a look at what I actually instead of relying on your biased interpretation of it:

"Quintiere's criticism of the NIST report was only about a very small issue (that being one of fire safety) and not of the report as a whole. Not only is this issue a small one, but it is entirely inconsequential to NIST's ultimate conclusions."

Here are some other things I have said regarding this issue:

"The 'conclusions' referred to here are that A) either the insulation was intact or B) it wasn't. It doesn't refer to the ultimate conclusions of the NIST report that the combination of structural damage and heat-weakened steel initiated the collapse."

"The only 'conclusion' Quintiere questions is the one regarding the loss of fire-proofing. NIST has claimed that the fire-proofing was removed during impact, Quintiere maintains that the fire-proofing was insufficient to begin with."

"He only challenges the claim of fire-proofing loss and whether or not there was even enough to begin with."

"As long as you understand that the criticisms he levels are geared specifically towards the issue of fire safety."

"The only thing that Quintiere calls into question is NIST's assumption that the jetliner impact removed the fire-proofing from the steel trusses thus faciliting their weakening. He instead contends that the fire-proofing wasn't necessarily removed, but rather was insufficient to begin with."

"Quintiere's statement's regarding the NIST report only pertained to issues of fire safety and absolutely nothing else."

Now it's changing.
No, it's not. My position has remained consistent, as the above quotes indicate. I defy you to point where I have said anything to the contrary. That's Lie #1 for you, sport.

Now its all of a sudden I said Quinteres problems were independent of fire saftey.
I never said that. Lie #2

And that I claim Quintere supports a conspiracy theory.
Or that. Lie #3

I said it was fire saftey and more. It can be both no?
It sure can. But it isn't.

How are the following statements just about a "small issue" of fire safty and nothing else?

Because Dr. Quintiere is a fire safety specialist. His field of expertise is fire safety. Also, he qualified his entire statement by saying this right up front:

"I wish I had wished for clear and complete analyses and evidence to determine the full cause of the factors behind and the reasons for the collapse of the WTC buildings, as they bear on the fire safety design of current and future buildings."

If you are going to persist in your asinine allegations that the fire safety specialist meant for his criticisms to pertain to something other than fire safety, then please provide a quote of his that explicitly states this.

I have provided you with numerous quotes where Dr. Quintiere explicitly states he is talking about fire safety.

Your turn.
 
Quintiere's criticism of the NIST report was only about a very small issue (that being one of fire safety)

One more time.


Try to answer if you can. Come on spin it some more for me. You must be pretty dizzy by now.

How are the following statements just about a "small issue" of fire safty and nothing else?

“3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?”

“6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?”

He also has these problems with the NIST report….

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST (not of the report as a whole?) falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."

lol
 
One more time.


Try to answer if you can. Come on spin it some more for me. You must be pretty dizzy by now.
Please provide an example of where I have done any spinning. I am not the one trying to wedge Dr. Quintiere's statements into a different meaning. That would be you. Any dizziness you are experiencing is most likely from lack of blood flow to your brain.

How are the following statements just about a "small issue" of fire safty and nothing else?
You mean the ones you take out of context? I'll try and help you out. Please pay attention this time.

The first one is fairly easy, because you're not bright enough to realize you've provided a quote that contradicts your position. Notice the very first sentence, especially the part I have bolded:

“3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?”

See, the entire passage is about how NIST didn't properly deal with the WTC wreckage as a "fire scene". Why? Because Dr. Quintiere is a fire safety specialist, and that is his area of expertise, and therefore his sole concern when critiquing the NIST report.

The next portion is a bit trickier because as per your usual dishonest debate tactics you've taken it out of context, making it difficult to determine what he is specifically talking when it appears on it's own:

“6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?”

So what else does Dr. Quinitere have to say about WTC7 that might shed a little more light on the above statement? Let's take a look:

"It’s more important to take a look at that. Maybe there was damage by the debris falling down that played a significant role. But other than that you had fires burning a long time without fire department intervention. And firefighters were in that building. I have yet to see any kind of story about what they saw. What was burning? Were photographs taken? Nothing!"

Once again, he is talking in terms of a fire investigation. Why? Oh yeah, because he is a fire safety specialist.

He also has these problems with the NIST report….
Once again, you have to cheat in order to try and bolster your claims. You're taking what he said out of context.

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST (not of the report as a whole? That's correct. See below.) falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."

This is what Dr. Quinitiere had to say about the NIST report in the opening remarks of his statement:

"I wish I had wished for clear and complete analyses and evidence to determine the full cause of the factors behind and the reasons for the collapse of the WTC buildings, as they bear on the fire safety design of current and future buildings."

Pretty clear cut.

Again, I have provided you with quotes where Dr. Quintiere explicitly states his criticisms are specific to issues of fire safety.

You contend that he has criticisms that extend into other areas. I have asked you to provide quotes that explicitly demonstrate this. You have failed to do so. Instead, you present ambiguous quotes that appear so because they are taken out of context, and you try to hang some broader meaning on them.

All in all, you're not very good at this.
 
Man you are losing it!

LOL

This is his quote.


“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."


the WTC investigation by NIST
 
Man you are losing it!

LOL

This is his quote.


“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."


the WTC investigation by NIST

I see. So you don't have any quotes that explicitly state he is speaking about something other than fire safety. Just more out of context nonsense. Why am I not surprised.

Since you seem particularly fond of this passage (Remember a few posts back when you had multiple quotes by Quintiere to supposedly prove your point? What happened to all those? Oh yeah... I completely dimsantled your argument, and now you won't refer to them anymore out of embarassment.), let's take a closer look at at, and test your reading comprehension skills:

"In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause"

What "cause" is Quintiere referring to here? "Cause" of what?

"by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause,"

There's that "cause" again. What "cause' is he talking about? And what "recommendations" is he referring to?

Are you able to answer these questions, ZEN? Or are you just going to dodge them like you do every other pertinent question presented to you?

Here's a tip to help: Since the above passage is out of context, you'll need to go back and read the rest of his statement to know to what he is specifically referring. Good luck!
 
So do you believe he thinks it was an inside job then?
I never said he did. We haven't got that far yet. Like I keep saying there would first have to be a real investigation to determine if an inside job on any kind of level happened or if it is off the table. That has yet to be done.
 
I never said he did. We haven't got that far yet. Like I keep saying there would first have to be a real investigation to determine if an inside job on any kind of level happened or if it is off the table. That has yet to be done.
Zen as I've mentioned before, outside of this issue we're probably not that far off on many, many things. So I can at least pretend you consider me one of the "not completely brainwashed by the gummit" voices here when I say this:

You're coming across as VERY dishonest here. "We haven't got that far yet" is going to be taken, REGARDLESS of your intent, as "you know what I'm saying but I'd like to make some points before admitting it."

If that's not what you're saying, come right out and say so. If it is, then stop playing games and state clearly WHY this is a valid mindset.

Really, dude. In my heart I'm rooting for you. :)
 
What evidence do you currently have handy that makes a strong case for a new investigation...because so far I haven't seen any from you or anybody else?
 
Here's a tip to help: Since the above passage is out of context, you'll need to go back and read the rest of his statement to know to what he is specifically referring. Good luck!

You haven't answered to all the quotes I displayed. You simply bold the word fire and assert that he's only talking about fire safety when he's clearly talking about more then just that. If you can't find the word fire in the entire paragraph you go find another one that does have the word fire in it. What a joke.

He talks about the collapse mechanism, computer models, wtc7, the politics surrounding NIST, etc. etc. but you just keep pretending like you don't know any better. Keep playing stupid see what it gets you.

Give it up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom