Why I despise the Truthers

Zen as I've mentioned before, outside of this issue we're probably not that far off on many, many things. So I can at least pretend you consider me one of the "not completely brainwashed by the gummit" voices here when I say this:

You're coming across as VERY dishonest here. "We haven't got that far yet" is going to be taken, REGARDLESS of your intent, as "you know what I'm saying but I'd like to make some points before admitting it."

If that's not what you're saying, come right out and say so. If it is, then stop playing games and state clearly WHY this is a valid mindset.

Really, dude. In my heart I'm rooting for you. :)
What is so hard to understand or is so unbelievable that I don't think there has been a valid investigation into 9-11? If I truly believe this then you tell me how I can take anything off the table including inside job until it's done properly? Remember I was posting here and saying the same thing before Quinitere comments became an issue. I never said he believes inside job or even the possibility of one. What I claimed was that Quinitere has problems with the investigation done by NIST that touch on serious issues other then just his area of expertise. Then all I get back is a bunch of excuses trying to diminish his charges. I won’t have it.

When you look at the some of the comments from Hamilton and Kean on the 9-11 commission that they were part of.

When you feel there is problems with the NIST investigation and then someone from inside NIST also has problems with it.

Then you compound it all with the question surrounding 9-11 to begin with.

I don't think it's so far out to want a real unimpeded investigation into 9-11.

Anyone who thinks they know the facts surrounding 9-11 based on the official investigations to date is either lying or delusional.
 
What evidence do you currently have handy that makes a strong case for a new investigation...because so far I haven't seen any from you or anybody else?

Any official investigation done to date is nothing more then a whitewash as far as I'm concerned. A whitewash to cover-up. If I want to believe what they are covering is the worse thing possible then it’s my porogative.

Think of it this way. I have the same problems with the official version that any of you have for any conspiracy theory. Prove it. It's just another unproven conspiracy theory from where I’m sitting. There is yet to be a complete real accounting of that day whether you are talking about loose change or the 9-11 commission report. The fact is you believe a conspiracy theory. Not completely confirmed factual evidence just another possible theory. And a wild theory at that. The best you can do is argue that your theory is better or more believable then another not that it’s true or a proven fact. Everyone in the JREF conspiracy theory thread is a conspiracy theory believer.

19 hijackers is still a conspiracy is it not?
 
so your saying until someone builds new exact replica WTC towers - lets you inspect them so you can comfirm the bombs and thermite is not present and then lets you fly and crash planes into them then resurrects you - so that you watch them collapse -- so until this x-file dream happens it is all a lie?
 
Anymore evidence of the official version today or just another chink in the armor?
Have you read the PM book or just taken everybody's word that it's nothing more than a piece of kindling on the cover-up fire?

If we believed the government version on its own you'd have every right to make that statement. But it's not the fact it's an "official version," it's the fact that everyone, in the private and public sector, who can possibly be considered an expert in their respective field... INCLUDING those who can't stand the politics that currently define our country... validate it.

I hope beyond hope you can grasp this some day. Not tomorrow or anything, hell it took me years.
 
19 hijackers is still a conspiracy is it not?

Ummm...no. Your confusion with the situation is between you and...well...you. I trust the experts. I don't, however, trust the those who are not qualified to make the call. That, of course, would be you.
 
You haven't answered to all the quotes I displayed. You simply bold the word fire and assert that he's only talking about fire safety when he's clearly talking about more then just that. If you can't find the word fire in the entire paragraph you go find another one that does have the word fire in it. What a joke.
The only joke here is your deplorable reading comprehension skills. For every single one of Quintiere's quotes you provided, I pointed out to you its true meaning. Your response to that is nothing more than that of a child sticking his fingers in his ears and shouting "La, la la, La!" No honest or intelligent debate. Just childish denial.

He talks about the collapse mechanism, computer models, wtc7, the politics surrounding NIST, etc. etc. but you just keep pretending like you don't know any better. Keep playing stupid see what it gets you.
He certainly does talk about all those things. In relation to the issue of fire-safety because he is a fire-safety specialist!

Give it up.
Speaking of giving up, am I to assume you are unable to provide the quotes that I have requested multiple times? Duly noted.
 
I’m sorry wasn’t this your quote?

“I'm still waiting for those physical fire tests where NIST tested partially, or fully unclad trusses, Zen.


Actually you were supposed to show me what test NIST used to come up with 42 inches of sag to put into their computer model. Now NIST did test Steel with what they called different amounts of fire-proofing.

So I’m still waiting big mouth.

Which part of "partially, or fully unclad" do you fail to understand? Insult report.
 
So if you agree with NIST you agree woth Quintiere?

How do you figure that? They do agree that the fire and impacts caused the towers to collapse, they disagree about why, in fact are at totally different ends of the scale in what the factor was. The point is that they both disagree with you and the one you are holding up as relaible, not only disagrees with you, but claims that the reprt you're trying to flame is far too conservative. You're esentially claiming a report that says the US can only win in Iraq by increasing it's troops and ferreting out the enemy is wrong and inhumane by waving one that says the only way to win is to nuke the place. Listen really carefully. Quintiere HURTS your arguments by claiming there was no need for Fireproofing damage, so NIST is wrong. If you agree that he is right in his claim that NIST is wrong, then you HAVE to accept that the towers would have collasped sans fireproofing damage. There isn't a way around that without looking stupid because if you try you're saying. This guy is saying a heap of garbage, but since he's attacking my foe, I'm going to support him anyway. So which is it? Is he right, and thus his claims against NIST are valid, or is he wrong and thus they are invalid?

Good so you agree there should be an INDEPENDENT review of the NIST report.

All science should be independantly reviewed, that's what science is. People are still reviewing Einstein's work.

You know... and investigation of the investigation.

A Review isn't an investigation, it's a review. An investigation determines what happened by gathering evidence and running studies and tests, a review looks over the already gathered evidence and sees if it agrees with the conclusions made.

Got any names yet for that review?

Why ask us, we aren't the ones calling for a review, ask Dr Quintiere, he, like you, is the one calling for for it.
 
so until this x-file dream happens it is all a lie?

Prove it any way you want but until it's proven it's just another CT. You think you have the answer but based on what? Certainly not the credibility of the people behind putting the official version together. Take 9-11 out of the equation and these same people have not proven themselves credible on just about anything else. Where's this faith come from? And I'm talking about the complete 9-11 story not just the towers and how they did or didn't fall but the whole 9-11 story passed off as the truth. What led up to 9-11, the day of, and what's happened since.

Take for instance why they claim we were attacked.

Because they hate our freedom? Is that really credible?
 
Ummm...no. Your confusion with the situation is between you and...well...you. I trust the experts. I don't, however, trust the those who are not qualified to make the call. That, of course, would be you.
Yeah well it seems these days the very experts you believe don't even seem to completely agree with them selves isn't that right? Which one is right?
 
Prove it any way you want but until it's proven it's just another CT. You think you have the answer but based on what? Certainly not the credibility of the people behind putting the official version together. Take 9-11 out of the equation and these same people have not proven themselves credible on just about anything else. Where's this faith come from? And I'm talking about the complete 9-11 story not just the towers and how they did or didn't fall but the whole 9-11 story passed off as the truth. What led up to 9-11, the day of, and what's happened since.

Take for instance why they claim we were attacked.

Because they hate our freedom? Is that really credible?

You, my friend, are an emotional mess. The science behind 9/11 is very, very, very sound. We're truly sorry that you don't understand it or that it doesn't fit into you political dissonance. You do realize that there is no "official version" right. It's the version of events that can be proven by science. It doesn't have a government seal. You do realize this, right? You obviously have no idea what you're actually discussing. Take 9/11 out of the equation and you're back to your "JUGGS" magazine and plethora of Kleenex brand tissues. The faith comes from trusting those people smarter and more qualified to determine how things played out. Not to trust internwebz truthers, such as yourself.

It's obvious that you don't understand why the terrorists did what they did. It's also obvious that you've never offered any alternative reason why these events happened. Once again...you have failed to bring anything substantial...or even interesting to the table.

Why do you constantly come here when it's apparent that you're ill equiped to converse on such intricate topics?
 
Last edited:
"All of these have been submitted to NIST, but never acknowledged or answered. I will list some of these.

1. Why is not the design process of assigning fire protection to the WTC towers fully called out for fault? The insulation thickness of the truss members varied from 0.5 inches at its construction, changed to a specification of 1.5 inches in 1995, and was taken on its face as 2.5 inches for the North tower fire floors based on a PA report. This extraordinary range of thicknesses bears an in depth investigation. Why were no hearings held or witness testimonies heard on this critical design process?

So he wants to know about the fireproofing.

2. Why were not alternative collapse hypotheses investigated and discussed as NIST had stated repeatedly that they would do? Their current explanation for the collapse of the towers is critically based on an assumption that the insulation was removed from the steel in the path of the aircraft, particularly the core columns. NIST does not show calculations or experiments to satisfactorily confirm that the insulation was removed in the core. As some large aircraft components went directly through the buildings, and NIST indicates the others were splintered on impact, can they explain why these small splinters could still denude the steel?

The "alternative collapse hypotheses" he is talking about is based on an incorrect understanding of NIST's report. He claims that the fireproofing was removed from the CORE which then failed. NIST don't say that, they say it was the Trusses that lost their fireproofing and failed, pulling in the exterior columns. NIST did in fact considera number of alternatives, the dear Dr hasn't got a clue with this one. In the end the only difference between his alternative and NIST's final solution is the fireproofing or lack there of.

3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?

Has been shown to be wrong.

4. NIST used computer models that they said have never been used in such an application before and are the state of the art. For this they should be commended for their skill. But the validation of these modeling results is in question. Others have computed aspects with different conclusions on the cause mechanism of the collapse. Moreover, it is common in fire investigation to compute a time-line and compare it to known events. NIST has not done that.

So here he says that they did it and come up with a different answer. He complains that NIST didn't do a time line, that's wrong, they did. Whoops, he make a mistake, oh well it happens.

5. Testing by NIST has been inconclusive. Although they have done fire tests of the scale of several work stations, a replicate test of at least & of a WTC floor would have been of considerable value. Why was this not done? Especially, as we have pointed out to NIST that they may have underestimated the weight of the furnishings in the North Tower by a factor of 3. As fire effects on structure depend on temperature and time, this likely longer burning time is significant in the NIST analyses. Other tests of the trusses in the UL furnaces show that the steel attains critical temperatures in short times, and these temperatures correspond to NIST's own computation of truss failure for a single truss. Why have these findings seemingly been ignored in the NIST analyses?

Okay so not about the fireproofing really, rather again he complains that NIST is over conservative in their estimates. He claims that there was 3 times the amount of fuel that NIST does. Oooops, how does that help you argument? He's saying that the fires were bigger and hotter then NIST claims. Isn't that the exact opposite of what you need? Way to shoot yourself in the foot, again.

6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?He also has these problems with the NIST report….

This is a complaint that the WTC 7 report is slow, how is that a complaint against the WTC 1 and 2 papers?

“They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF, which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."


Again he's wrong in a number of points, NIST did do a lot of interviews. It boils down to more "They are trying to hide the fact the towewrs would have fallen over anyways and the Lawyers are trying to make sure no one finds out."

So tell me how is this only about fire-proofing?

Just because you say so?

Okay, it's about his belief that the fireproofing was irellevant to whether the towers would have come down, and he things that NIST and the PANYNJ lawyers are covering it up. He basis this on having 3 times the fuel load in the towers and patchy fireproofing that he believes was inadequately applied. How does this help your case one bit? If he's right then the PANYNJ is guilty of incompetence and flauting regulations that they didn't actually by law have to follow, and the towers still fell down due to big planes, big impacts and big fires.
 
How do you figure that? They do agree that the fire and impacts caused the towers to collapse; they disagree about why...

They don't completely agree on a theory. It’s not as easy to disagree about facts.

All science should be independently reviewed, that's what science is. People are still reviewing Einstein's work.

So why the resistance? Quintere's been saying this stuff for a couple years now. Why don't they answer his questions?

A Review isn't an investigation, it's a review. An investigation determines what happened by gathering evidence and running studies and tests, a review looks over the already gathered evidence and sees if it agrees with the conclusions made.

He already has done that and doesn't agree with their conclusions. He's looking to go beyond that now.

Why ask us, we aren't the ones calling for a review, ask Dr Quintiere, he, like you, is the one calling for it.

I posted what 911physics stated about wanting an independent investigation. Then I was asked for names. What's the difference?
 
You, my friend, are an emotional mess. The science behind 9/11 is very, very, very sound. We're truly sorry that you don't understand it or that it doesn't fit into you political dissonance. You do realize that there is no "official version" right. It's the version of events that can be proven by science. It doesn't have a government seal. You do realize this, right? You obviously have no idea what you're actually discussing. Take 9/11 out of the equation and you're back to your "JUGGS" magazine and plethora of Kleenex brand tissues. The faith comes from trusting those people smarter and more qualified to determine how things played out. Not to trust internwebz truthers, such as yourself.

It's obvious that you don't understand why the terrorists did what they did. It's also obvious that you've never offered any alternative reason why these events happened. Once again...you have failed to bring anything substantial...or even interesting to the table.

Why do you constantly come here when it's apparent that you're ill equiped to converse on such intricate topics?
No. The 9-11 commission report is not science.

The NIST report is a theory not a fact of only one aspect of 9-11. And a
highly disputed theory at that.

I'm sorry you wish it was more. I'm sorry you like to think that by just asserting that it's more makes it so.
 
OP

It has to be their blind political bias showing as they suspend rational thought and bring out the thermite, or the beam weapons or just hearsay bs talk.

It is also their lack of facts, they just talk and bring up Iraq, or what Bush said, chanting "inside job" and not supporting their incomplete conclusions with evidence. Zero evidence, no real ideas on what really happen.

Hearsay, they only use what other people make up; Griffin is the big example I see. Or pick any of the current truthers not really saying anything.

No ties to reality; no coherent story of what did happen.

Bringing up or trying to tear down NIST, when they do not even know the goals of the NIST report. Is that due to truthers can not read 10,000 pages that may contain real fact and information without being dustified?

Do not tell them NIST is not needed to solve 9/11. I also find the lack of fact to be the real weakness. Look at the current set of truthers who post, just talk, totally reactive, no real proactive approach of presenting what happen with facts and evidence.
 
Which part of "partially, or fully unclad" do you fail to understand? Insult report.
Report all you want. Just be sure to answer the question when you are done.

If they didn't test any steel without ANY fire-proofing how does this help them come up with the numbers they put into their computer model?

In other words what's your point in relation to my original question?
 
The most important thing is he has established there was a cover-up which was politically motivated.


Dr. Quintiere said he originally “had high hopes” that NIST would do a good job with the investigation. “They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF [Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives], which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”

I'd imagine these lawyers would suggest what was blocked was a matter of national security.

No the important thing is what he thinks was covered up and what he specifically states did not happen.

Consider this. In 1978 an Air New Zealand DC 10 flew into the side of Mt Erebus in Antarctica, the one and only ever fatal crash of an Air New Zealand plane. The investigating Judge called Air New Zealand's story a "Litany of lies" because they tried to blame the pilot. It turned out that the ground crew were told to change the plane's course, but the pilot wasn't told of the flight plan change. Caught in a white out, he didn't realise that he was heading straight for a mountain, and so trying to get below the clouds, hit the side of the volcano. There was definitely a cover-up, but just because there was a cover-up doesn't mean that there was a plot inside the boardroom of Air New Zealand to kill off that pilot by crashing him into a mountain. It was a cover-up to protect their butts after a SNAFU.

In the same way, Dr Quintiere believes that the PANYNJ has been caught in a SNAFU and has put political pressure on NIST to cover up the inadequacies of the fireproofing job. Whether or not that cover up exists is totally irrelevant to if 9/11 was an inside Job, a hypothesis Dr Quintiere specifically rejects.

Continuing to wave the paper about as a flagship is only hurting your own credibility. This guy thinks that the Towers would have fallen with less damage than NIST does. You are supporting a guy who's claims make the so called offical version even stronger. Why can't you see that? Are you so blind that you'd happy shoot your own cause down in an attempt to take on a strawman? Man that is totally dumb.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom