ZENSMACK89
Banned
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2007
- Messages
- 2,068
I wasn't the first one to ask for an independent investigation. I'm only supporting and welcoming it when I was asked for names.wait a sec....how did he contradict himself, exactly?
I wasn't the first one to ask for an independent investigation. I'm only supporting and welcoming it when I was asked for names.wait a sec....how did he contradict himself, exactly?
Neither is Quintiere. Calling for a review != calling for an independent investigation.I wasn't the first one to ask for an independent investigation. I'm only supporting and welcoming it when I was asked for names.
Who would be part of that independent review? Do they not have names?Neither is Quintiere. Calling for a review != calling for an independent investigation.
Oh probably more people that are cited by Popular Mechanics.Who would be part of that independent review? Do they not have names?
Congratulations on contradicting yourself there genius. All in one post. Classic.
"No one here has ever stated that this review shouldn't take place, and many have actually voiced their support of it."
"We're not the one asking for this review. "
Now go back and read and see where I quoted Physics911.org on the independent investigation when I was then asked for names.
Additionally, I think we can all agree that even un-fireproofed steel will not melt until reaching red-hot temperatures of nearly 3000F (2). Why Dr. Brown would imply that 2000F would melt the high-grade steel used in those buildings makes no sense at all.
At what temperature does fireproofed steel melt or weaken?
Pot, meet kettle. Kettle, meet pot.Congratulations on contradicting yourself there genius.
Mmmmmm, pot.Pot, meet kettle. Kettle, meet pot.
How exactly is calling for an independent review of the NIST report not questioning it?And Zen when are you going to admit that Quintiere unquestionably supports the official explanation of what brought down the towers, and his objections with the NIST report are totally unrelated to your little fantasy?
It's as if I grabbed hold of somebody in your movement who, while still thinking 911 was an inside job, found no planers to be idiots, and I used him to declare that a member of the truth movement supports the official story.
How exactly is calling for an independent review of the NIST report not questioning it?
Why does it have to be an independent review if he's not questioing NIST and their practices?
How exactly is calling for an independent review of the NIST report not questioning it?
Why does it have to be an independent review if he's not questioing NIST and their practices?
What is wrong with you? I can't believe you still don't get this!
His questioning of the NIST is totally different than YOUR questioning and your ludicrous inside job theory. He supports the official story. He is questioning the NIST report in ways TOTALLY unrelated to your fantasy.
I repeat. He supports the official explanation of how the collapse happened. You don't. Therefore it is comical in the extreme that you are using him to try to support your fantasy.
It's almost like any questioning of the NIST report, no matter for what reason, supports an inside job. (somebody speaks up saying they used the wrong sized salad forks in the NIST luncheon and wonders why the NIST would let such a travesty exist...INSIDE JOB!!!!)
You don't believe me? Email him and ask him.
I don't need to email him. I can read. I can comprehend. I never said he supported an inside job theory. I said he supports an independent review of the NIST report and that means he’s questioning it. You don't have a valid come back for this so of course you head down the strawman highway.
Do you not have an answer?
Why does he think the NIST report needs an independent review? Because it’s correct?
Why does it need to be independent? What would be wrong with NIST reviewing its own work?
And speaking of “Pot calls Kettle” do any of you big mouths have any names for that independent review? And who’s going to pay for it? You all seemed so concerned with this the other day.
So why would NIST or anyone be opposed to this?Okay here is an example of why someone would want an independent review.
This is the best way I can put it and I hope you understand.
During a fire ground operation, there are two things called Primary and Secondary Search.
Primary happens before and/or during fire suppression by one crew.
Secondary happens after the fire is out by a different crew from the primary.
Why? Because the first crew would be complacent if they had to perform both primary and secondary search. Especially if they reported negative find on the primary.
Now, when you bring in a different crew for the secondary search, they may find something the first crew missed.
So with NIST, if they reviewed themselves they may miss something that say an independent committee or panel wouldn't.
I hope this helped
So why would NIST or anyone be opposed to this?
Why did you raise your hand first on the easy question? Oldschool and questions are not a good combination.Fire protected steel will "melt or weaken" at the same temperature as unprotected steel. A protected assembly will take longer to heat up to the necessary temperature. That is the whole point of putting on fire protection.
Steel, whether protected or unprotected is unlikely to melt in a building fire. It will need to be far beyond red hot to melt.
Dave
Only the same one you have been given a dozen times, but still refuse to ackowledge. Quintiere's criticism of the NIST report was only about a very small issue (that being one of fire safety) and not of the report as a whole. Not only is this issue a small one, but it is entirely inconsequential to NIST's ultimate conclusions.I don't need to email him. I can read. I can comprehend. I never said he supported an inside job theory. I said he supports an independent review of the NIST report and that means he’s questioning it. You don't have a valid come back for this so of course you head down the strawman highway.
Do you not have an answer?
Only with regard to the quality of the fire-proofing on the steel trusses does Quintiere feel the NIST report is incorrect.Why does he think the NIST report needs an independent review? Because it’s correct?
For the same reason that anyone has someone else check their work: to have an objective eye critique it.Why does it need to be independent? What would be wrong with NIST reviewing its own work?
No one here is championing Quintiere's cause. The most positve response I've seen is along the lines of "His criticisms are legitimate, and maybe this review wouldn't be a bad idea." We do not speak for Dr. Quintiere. If you are truly that interested, contact him yourself.And speaking of “Pot calls Kettle” do any of you big mouths have any names for that independent review? And who’s going to pay for it? You all seemed so concerned with this the other day.