Why I despise the Truthers

Additionally, I think we can all agree that even un-fireproofed steel will not melt until reaching red-hot temperatures of nearly 3000F

So freakin WHAT? Steel expands or contrracts every time its temperature changes. That breaks joints. The steel in the towers changed repeatedly, with a temperature gradient of hundreds of degrees over at least 45 minutes.

To give you an idea how much steel expands and contracts, I off the example of an elderly friend of mine who wiped out most of an armor battalion by placing coins between the rails of a track, especially taking care to stuff the expansion joints properly, in the cool of the night. The next morning, the tracks warmed up, expanded, and separated from the ties when they buckled, derailing the next train.

Night time temperatures to the morning sun is a small gradient, compared to what happened in the towers.
 
I mean why else would you be trying to make a big deal about a typo for days now?
See, now that's funny! A typo would be writing 3.5 instead of 35. The quotes you posted had entirely different meanings and were far beyond being a mere typo.

What's that say about your debating skills? I keep you pretty busy don't I? Do I bother you?
Getting a bit testy, are we? Poor Zen, you don't like being caught posting contradictory information do you? You don't like being caught not checking your facts and presented info very carefully do you?

Perhaps it will serve as a reminder to you in the future to read more closely the material you post to support whatever point it is you are trying to make.
 
Perhaps it will serve as a reminder to you in the future to read more closely the material you post to support whatever point it is you are trying to make.

Frankly, Zen could care less about that. It's not about quality, it's about quantity.
 
One could possibly assume as much prior to Dr. Quintiere's revelations to the NIST report. Put the two together and obviously NIST is no more than a single perspective document with no acedemic crediabilty. The NIST report was a huge waste of tax payers money.

And you are of course aware that Dr. Quintiere's main revelation, apart from the fact he doesn't seem to have read the report since he keeps asking questions the report itself answers, is that he believes that the Towers would have collapsed with the fireproofing intact while NIST says that they would have stood. You do realise that this is the reason he thinks that NIST is being hampered by Lawyers, becasue he thinks that the PANYNJ should take responsiblity for the poor fireproofing and that NIST is shielding them. You are aware that Dr. Quintiere has specifically rejected the idea that the Towers were destroyed by any form of CD?

Since you keep waving his name about, you obviously think he is reliable. This being the case,why do you not accept his premiss that the Towers would have collapsed from the impacts and fire, that the removal of the fireproofing was irrellevant to this occuring, and that the Towers were not demolished. If you don't agree with his conclusions, how can you agree with his reservations about NIST, since those very reservations are based on his own conclusions. If you reject one, you must reject the other. You can't support his reservations without supporting the conclusions that lead him there. Either both are right, or both are wrong. You can't say the reservations are right, but the conclusions are wrong.

So which is it, do you support Dr. Quintiere's conclusions or not?
 
And you are of course aware that Dr. Quintiere's main revelation, apart from the fact he doesn't seem to have read the report since he keeps asking questions the report itself answers, is that he believes that the Towers would have collapsed with the fireproofing intact while NIST says that they would have stood. You do realise that this is the reason he thinks that NIST is being hampered by Lawyers, becasue he thinks that the PANYNJ should take responsiblity for the poor fireproofing and that NIST is shielding them. You are aware that Dr. Quintiere has specifically rejected the idea that the Towers were destroyed by any form of CD?

Since you keep waving his name about, you obviously think he is reliable. This being the case,why do you not accept his premiss that the Towers would have collapsed from the impacts and fire, that the removal of the fireproofing was irrellevant to this occuring, and that the Towers were not demolished. If you don't agree with his conclusions, how can you agree with his reservations about NIST, since those very reservations are based on his own conclusions. If you reject one, you must reject the other. You can't support his reservations without supporting the conclusions that lead him there. Either both are right, or both are wrong. You can't say the reservations are right, but the conclusions are wrong.

So which is it, do you support Dr. Quintiere's conclusions or not?


An excellent summary, PhantomWolf, but if Zen were compelled to read it out loud ten times, he would still find ways of misrepresenting what Quintiere says.
 
Actually accept the governments account of 911.

I've got a really nice bridge for sale if you're interested.

Is that a No True Scottsman fallacy ? You said NO ONE had any idea how it happened. I show you people who do and have done real scientific work to support their conclusions, and then you say that they're not good enough because they're part of this fantasy monolithic "government" you keep blabbering about ?
 
What a load of nonsense. Just more excuses.

“at least be reasonably assured…” ?

Yeah that sounds confident.

So what's your satisfactory level of proof, then ? Absolute 100% certainty ?

Doesn't exist except through self-delusion, you know.

"people here"?

Just who are "people here" to tell me anything but their opinion?

nothing else

Cute dodge.
 
Ummm, Zen, all of the trusses in these firetests had Fireproofing, that is not what I asked for. I want you to show that NIST physically tested unfireproofed trusses, if you cannot do that, you claim that their tests are incompatable with their figures for trusses with damages and removed fireproofing is wrong.


I’m sorry wasn’t this your quote?

“I'm still waiting for those physical fire tests where NIST tested partially, or fully unclad trusses, Zen.


Actually you were supposed to show me what test NIST used to come up with 42 inches of sag to put into their computer model. Now NIST did test Steel with what they called different amounts of fire-proofing.

So I’m still waiting big mouth.
 
See, now that's funny! A typo would be writing 3.5 instead of 35. The quotes you posted had entirely different meanings and were far beyond being a mere typo.

Getting a bit testy, are we? Poor Zen, you don't like being caught posting contradictory information do you? You don't like being caught not checking your facts and presented info very carefully do you?

Perhaps it will serve as a reminder to you in the future to read more closely the material you post to support whatever point it is you are trying to make.
Still nothing huh?
 
And you are of course aware that Dr. Quintiere's main revelation, apart from the fact he doesn't seem to have read the report since he keeps asking questions the report itself answers, is that he believes that the Towers would have collapsed with the fireproofing intact while NIST says that they would have stood. You do realise that this is the reason he thinks that NIST is being hampered by Lawyers, becasue he thinks that the PANYNJ should take responsiblity for the poor fireproofing and that NIST is shielding them. You are aware that Dr. Quintiere has specifically rejected the idea that the Towers were destroyed by any form of CD?

Since you keep waving his name about, you obviously think he is reliable. This being the case,why do you not accept his premiss that the Towers would have collapsed from the impacts and fire, that the removal of the fireproofing was irrellevant to this occuring, and that the Towers were not demolished. If you don't agree with his conclusions, how can you agree with his reservations about NIST, since those very reservations are based on his own conclusions. If you reject one, you must reject the other. You can't support his reservations without supporting the conclusions that lead him there. Either both are right, or both are wrong. You can't say the reservations are right, but the conclusions are wrong.

So which is it, do you support Dr. Quintiere's conclusions or not?
So if you agree with NIST you agree woth Quintiere?

Good so you agree there should be an INDEPENDENT review of the NIST report.


You know... and investigation of the investigation.

Got any names yet for that review?
 
Last edited:
An executive at Underwriters Laboratories (UL), the company that certified the steel used in the construction of the World Trade Center, has questioned the common theory that fuel fires caused the Twin Towers to collapse.

Three falsehoods in his first paragraph alone.
 
So if you agree with NIST you agree woth Quintiere?

Good so you agree there should be an INDEPENDENT review of the NIST report.
Sure, why not? No one here has ever stated that this review shouldn't take place, and many have actually voiced their support of it.

See, what you Truthers don't understand is that we don't fear scrutiny like you do. We relish it. It's the driving mechanism behind scientific method and rational thought, and therefore your enemy, not ours.


Got any names yet for that review?
Oh, I see what you did there... since we're always asking you for the names of the people you want to perform the new investigation you're demanding, now you're asking us who should perform this "investigation of the investigation". You totally turned that around on us! ZEN you are just so darn clever!

Let me explain to you how you are wrong (which seems to be a fulltime job): We're not the one asking for this review. Dr. Quintiere is. You would need to ask him for this list of names.

For you convenience, here is his e-mail address, so you can do just that:[email protected].

And while you're at it, maybe ask him to explain to you all the ways in which he disagrees with the CT, since you are struggling to process that concept as your repeated uses of him as a reference demonstrate.
 
Sure, why not? No one here has ever stated that this review shouldn't take place, and many have actually voiced their support of it.

See, what you Truthers don't understand is that we don't fear scrutiny like you do. We relish it. It's the driving mechanism behind scientific method and rational thought, and therefore your enemy, not ours.


Oh, I see what you did there... since we're always asking you for the names of the people you want to perform the new investigation you're demanding, now you're asking us who should perform this "investigation of the investigation". You totally turned that around on us! ZEN you are just so darn clever!

Let me explain to you how you are wrong (which seems to be a fulltime job): We're not the one asking for this review. Dr. Quintiere is. You would need to ask him for this list of names.

For you convenience, here is his e-mail address, so you can do just that:[email protected].

And while you're at it, maybe ask him to explain to you all the ways in which he disagrees with the CT, since you are struggling to process that concept as your repeated uses of him as a reference demonstrate.
Congratulations on contradicting yourself there genius. All in one post. Classic.

"No one here has ever stated that this review shouldn't take place, and many have actually voiced their support of it."

"We're not the one asking for this review. "

Now go back and read and see where I quoted Physics911.org on the independent investigation when I was then asked for names.
 
See, what you Truthers don't understand is that we don't fear scrutiny like you do. We relish it. It's the driving mechanism behind scientific method and rational thought, and therefore your enemy, not ours.
Man, that's so dead-on accurate I wouldn't mind getting the quote as a chest tattoo. :)
 
Congratulations on contradicting yourself there genius. All in one post. Classic.

"No one here has ever stated that this review shouldn't take place, and many have actually voiced their support of it."

"We're not the one asking for this review. "

Now go back and read and see where I quoted Physics911.org on the independent investigation when I was then asked for names.

wait a sec....how did he contradict himself, exactly?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom