Why I despise the Truthers

An executive at Underwriters Laboratories (UL), the company that certified the steel used in the construction of the World Trade Center, has questioned the common theory that fuel fires caused the Twin Towers to collapse.




Text of an e-mail letter from Kevin Ryan to Frank Gayle, Nov. 11:

[NOTES: Kevin R. Ryan is Site Manager of the Environmental Health Laboratories at South Bend, Indiana (company site at www.ehl.cc). EHL is a division of Underwriters Laboratories, Inc. (company site at www.ul.com). Frank Gayle is Deputy Chief of the Metallurgy Division, Material Science and Engineering Laboratory, at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). Gayle heads the "NIST and the World Trade Center" project, see wtc.nist.gov. Dr. Gayle's biography is at wtc.nist.gov/pi/wtc_profiles.asp?lastname=gayle. The following text is taken from an e-mail forward, from Ryan to David Ray Griffin. Emphases are ours. - 911Truth.org]

---------

From: Kevin R Ryan/SBN/ULI
To: [email protected]

Date: 11/11/2004



Dr. Gayle,

Having recently reviewed your team's report of 10/19/04, I felt the need to contact you directly.

As I'm sure you know, the company I work for certified the steel components used in the construction of the WTC buildings. In requesting information from both our CEO and Fire Protection business manager last year, I learned that they did not agree on the essential aspects of the story, except for one thing - that the samples we certified met all requirements. They suggested we all be patient and understand that UL was working with your team, and that tests would continue through this year. I'm aware of UL's attempts to help, including performing tests on models of the floor assemblies. But the results of these tests appear to indicate that the buildings should have easily withstood the thermal stress caused by pools of burning jet fuel.

There continues to be a number of "experts" making public claims about how the WTC buildings fell. One such person, Dr. Hyman Brown from the WTC construction crew, claims that the buildings collapsed due to fires at 2000F melting the steel (1). He states "What caused the building to collapse is the airplane fuel . . . burning at 2,000 degrees Fahrenheit. The steel in that five-floor area melts." Additionally, the newspaper that quotes him says "Just-released preliminary findings from a National Institute of Standards and Technology study of the World Trade Center collapse support Brown's theory."

We know that the steel components were certified to ASTM E119. The time temperature curves for this standard require the samples to be exposed to temperatures around 2000F for several hours. And as we all agree, the steel applied met those specifications. Additionally, I think we can all agree that even un-fireproofed steel will not melt until reaching red-hot temperatures of nearly 3000F (2). Why Dr. Brown would imply that 2000F would melt the high-grade steel used in those buildings makes no sense at all.

The results of your recently published metallurgical tests seem to clear things up (3), and support your team's August 2003 update as detailed by the Associated Press (4), in which you were ready to "rule out weak steel as a contributing factor in the collapse". The evaluation of paint deformation and spheroidization seem very straightforward, and you noted that the samples available were adequate for the investigation. Your comments suggest that the steel was probably exposed to temperatures of only about 500F (250C), which is what one might expect from a thermodynamic analysis of the situation.

However the summary of the new NIST report seems to ignore your findings, as it suggests that these low temperatures caused exposed bits of the building's steel core to "soften and buckle"(5). Additionally this summary states that the perimeter columns softened, yet your findings make clear that "most perimeter panels (157 of 160) saw no temperature above 250C". To soften steel for the purposes of forging, normally temperatures need to be above 1100C (6). However, this new summary report suggests that much lower temperatures were be able to not only soften the steel in a matter of minutes, but lead to rapid structural collapse.

This story just does not add up. If steel from those buildings did soften or melt, I'm sure we can all agree that this was certainly not due to jet fuel fires of any kind, let alone the briefly burning fires in those towers. That fact should be of great concern to all Americans. Alternatively, the contention that this steel did fail at temperatures around 250C suggests that the majority of deaths on 9/11 were due to a safety-related failure. That suggestion should be of great concern to my company.

There is no question that the events of 9/11 are the emotional driving force behind the War on Terror. And the issue of the WTC collapse is at the crux of the story of 9/11. My feeling is that your metallurgical tests are at the crux of the crux of the crux. Either you can make sense of what really happened to those buildings, and communicate this quickly, or we all face the same destruction and despair that come from global decisions based on disinformation and "chatter".

Thanks for your efforts to determine what happened on that day. You may know that there are a number of other current and former government employees that have risked a great deal to help us to know the truth. I've copied one of these people on this message as a sign of respect and support. I believe your work could also be a nucleus of fact around which the truth, and thereby global peace and justice, can grow again. Please do what you can to quickly eliminate the confusion regarding the ability of jet fuel fires to soften or melt structural steel.
 
Kevin Ryan?


Is that all you got?

Kevin Ryan has no idea what ASTM E119 is. His background was a water tester for UL....


UL DOESN'T CERTIFY THE STEEL, THEY CERTIFY THE FIREPROOFING


Research ASTM E119...find out for yourself or even email UL.


ROFL
 
Kevin Ryan?


Is that all you got?

Kevin Ryan has no idea what ASTM E119 is. His background was a water tester for UL....


UL DOESN'T CERTIFY THE STEEL, THEY CERTIFY THE FIREPROOFING


Research ASTM E119...find out for yourself or even email UL.


ROFL


An executive at Underwriters Laboratories (UL), the company that certified the steel used in the construction of the World Trade Center, has questioned the common theory that fuel fires caused the Twin Towers to collapse.
 
Once again it appears NIST fails the test. Yet some beaver discounts even the company which certified the steel.

Very important passage if you haven't read the email.

Additionally, I think we can all agree that even un-fireproofed steel will not melt until reaching red-hot temperatures of nearly 3000F (2). Why Dr. Brown would imply that 2000F would melt the high-grade steel used in those buildings makes no sense at all.
 
An executive at Underwriters Laboratories (UL), the company that certified the steel used in the construction of the World Trade Center, has questioned the common theory that fuel fires caused the Twin Towers to collapse.

Wrong.

http://www.mindfully.org/Reform/2004/Kevin-R-Ryan22nov04.htm
"UL does not certify structural steel, such as the beams, columns and trusses used in World Trade Center," said Paul M. Baker, the company's spokesman.

http://wtc.nist.gov/pubs/factsheets/faqs_8_2006.htm
UL did not certify any steel as suggested. In fact, in U.S. practice, steel is not certified at all; rather structural assemblies are tested for their fire resistance rating in accordance with a standard procedure such as ASTM E 119 (see NCSTAR 1-6B). That the steel was “certified ... to 2000 degrees Fahrenheit for six hours” is simply not true.
 
Former NIST employee James Quintiere Ph.D Fire Science Division of NIST

Dr. Quintiere, one of the world’s leading fire science researchers and safety engineers, also encouraged his audience of fellow researchers and engineers to scientifically re-examine the WTC collapses. “I hope to convince you to perhaps become 'Conspiracy Theorists', but in a proper way,” he said.


“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding.


“They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF [Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives], which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”
 
Additionally, I think we can all agree that even un-fireproofed steel will not melt until reaching red-hot temperatures of nearly 3000F (2). Why Dr. Brown would imply that 2000F would melt the high-grade steel used in those buildings makes no sense at all.

At what temperature does fireproofed steel melt or weaken?
 
There is no set temp that it suddenly weakens, it's linear. The more heat, the less strength. I think it's something like 1000 degrees where it loses half its strength. But others here can say for sure.

And it depends on the kind of steel. Melting point is often 2500 degrees F.
 
An executive at Underwriters Laboratories (UL), the company that certified the steel used in the construction of the World Trade Center, has questioned the common theory that fuel fires caused the Twin Towers to collapse.

Which executive would that be?
 
OldSchool, please, if you're going to lie, stay here and do it, 'kay?


http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=14500


Just posted this on the JREF forum. They're quiet currently not much to say.

This is appended to your repeat of your post on the old tired Kevin Ryan tale. You posted it on LCF, about half-an-hour after you posted the Ryan rehash above, and after you'd been referred to answers by at least two forumites.

Water Boy is no executive at UL. He was a field manager of some sort, and he was fired for stating personal opinions on company letterhead (or something akin - Water Boy fans can straighten me out on this).

Troofer Heavy, indeed! You post a three year old story as though it's breaking news. You ignore the responses. You then go over and try to make some attention for yourself on LCF with the same old tired crap, and sing a rousing chorus of JERF On The Run! (And the only person who even responded to your boring rehashed crap on LCF is a debunker who happens to be one of our own enfants terribles.)
 
Oh, and UL did NOT certify the steel.


Text of an e-mail letter from Kevin Ryan to Frank Gayle, Nov. 11:

Dr. Gayle,

Having recently reviewed your team's report of 10/19/04, I felt the need to contact you directly.As I'm sure you know, certified the steel components used in the construction of the WTC buildings. In requesting information from both our CEO and Fire Protection business manager last year, I learned that they did not agree on the essential aspects of the story, except for one thing - that the samples we certified met all requirements.
 
OldSchool, please, if you're going to lie, stay here and do it, 'kay?


http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=14500




This is appended to your repeat of your post on the old tired Kevin Ryan tale. You posted it on LCF, about half-an-hour after you posted the Ryan rehash above, and after you'd been referred to answers by at least two forumites.

Water Boy is no executive at UL. He was a field manager of some sort, and he was fired for stating personal opinions on company letterhead (or something akin - Water Boy fans can straighten me out on this).

Troofer Heavy, indeed! You post a three year old story as though it's breaking news. You ignore the responses. You then go over and try to make some attention for yourself on LCF with the same old tired crap, and sing a rousing chorus of JERF On The Run! (And the only person who even responded to your boring rehashed crap on LCF is a debunker who happens to be one of our own enfants terribles.)

So what if he was fired just reinforces the fact members of the company didn't agree with NIST.
 
Nobody has yet to respond to the fact both professionals from the company certified the steel and a an actual employee of NIST both challenge there findings. This forum, if it is really as educated as it claims, should by now accept NIST if falling to pieces.

Nobody here of course wants to discuss:

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding.



“They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF [Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives], which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”

When you link UL and Quintiere together looks pretty good doesn't it. rolf
 
So what if he was fired just reinforces the fact members of the company didn't agree with NIST.


You can keep attempting to peddle this ancient falsehood to people who know much more about the subject than you do, or you can do the unthinkable (for a twoofer) and actually learn something.

There is a reason why Kevin Ryan ran off with his tail between his legs after Mark accepted his bogus "challenge" to a debate.
 
You can keep attempting to peddle this ancient falsehood to people who know much more about the subject than you do, or you can do the unthinkable (for a twoofer) and actually learn something.

There is a reason why Kevin Ryan ran off with his tail between his legs after Mark accepted his bogus "challenge" to a debate.

One could possibly assume as much prior to Dr. Quintiere's revelations to the NIST report. Put the two together and obviously NIST is no more than a single perspective document with no acedemic crediabilty. The NIST report was a huge waste of tax payers money.
 
One could possibly assume as much prior to Dr. Quintiere's revelations to the NIST report. Put the two together and obviously NIST is no more than a single perspective document with no acedemic crediabilty. The NIST report was a huge waste of tax payers money.


Why are Quintiere's opinions "revelations"? His is one voice against hundreds. NIST showed that the impacts of the planes caused structural damage and extensive fires which led to the eventual collapses of the buildings. Where is the disagreement on that conclusion? Dr. Greening, a chemist, emphasizes chemical reactions; Quintiere stresses his professional concerns over fireproofing. What serious researcher lends any credence to the conspiracy liars' fantasies about explosives?
 
Nobody here of course wants to discuss:

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding.



“They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF [Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives], which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”

If only because it's been discussed into the ground in about half a dozen other threads. As matter of fact, I'm pretty sure you took part in some of that discussion.

Hey look everybody, the guy from Memento posts here now!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom