Why I despise the Truthers

Here is Dr. Quintiere's e-mail address: [email protected]

Since you can't seem to understand what his statement's regarding NIST actually mean, and you don't believe us when we try and tell you, why don't you contact him yourself for clarification?

Please let us know what he has to say.


Funny thing--I did exactly that. Much more to follow in the next few days.
 
Because I'm not the one who needs clarification. I understand he has a problem with more then just one very small issue. In fact in his earlier statement to the U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Science, on October 26, 2005 he states at least six of them…

http://commdocs.house.gov/committees/science/hsy24133.000/hsy24133_0f.htm

"All of these have been submitted to NIST, but never acknowledged or answered. I will list some of these.

1. Why is not the design process of assigning fire protection to the WTC towers fully called out for fault? The insulation thickness of the truss members varied from 0.5 inches at its construction, changed to a specification of 1.5 inches in 1995, and was taken on its face as 2.5 inches for the North tower fire floors based on a PA report. This extraordinary range of thicknesses bears an in depth investigation. Why were no hearings held or witness testimonies heard on this critical design process?

2. Why were not alternative collapse hypotheses investigated and discussed as NIST had stated repeatedly that they would do? Their current explanation for the collapse of the towers is critically based on an assumption that the insulation was removed from the steel in the path of the aircraft, particularly the core columns. NIST does not show calculations or experiments to satisfactorily confirm that the insulation was removed in the core. As some large aircraft components went directly through the buildings, and NIST indicates the others were splintered on impact, can they explain why these small splinters could still denude the steel?

3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?

4. NIST used computer models that they said have never been used in such an application before and are the state of the art. For this they should be commended for their skill. But the validation of these modeling results is in question. Others have computed aspects with different conclusions on the cause mechanism of the collapse. Moreover, it is common in fire investigation to compute a time-line and compare it to known events. NIST has not done that.

5. Testing by NIST has been inconclusive. Although they have done fire tests of the scale of several work stations, a replicate test of at least & of a WTC floor would have been of considerable value. Why was this not done? Especially, as we have pointed out to NIST that they may have underestimated the weight of the furnishings in the North Tower by a factor of 3. As fire effects on structure depend on temperature and time, this likely longer burning time is significant in the NIST analyses. Other tests of the trusses in the UL furnaces show that the steel attains critical temperatures in short times, and these temperatures correspond to NIST's own computation of truss failure for a single truss. Why have these findings seemingly been ignored in the NIST analyses?

6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?He also has these problems with the NIST report….

“They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF, which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."

So tell me how is this only about fire-proofing?

Just because you say so?
 
NYCEMT86: I'm a ex-truther I guess you would say. I think truthers come in many varieties. While some just think this administration allowed those events to take place, others might think it was space weapons and girl scout cookies. Other than the ones who say the FDNY and NYPD were involved, do you despise them all, or do you think some of them might be good people with good intentions who are just scared and confused?
 
NYCEMT86: I'm a ex-truther I guess you would say. I think truthers come in many varieties. While some just think this administration allowed those events to take place, others might think it was space weapons and girl scout cookies. Other than the ones who say the FDNY and NYPD were involved, do you despise them all, or do you think some of them might be good people with good intentions who are just scared and confused?

I despise the ones who say the FDNY and NYPD are involved. That brings things to a very personal level.

There is nothing wrong with asking questions...but once they only refer to LC and Scholars for Truth have taken it to another level, especially when they refuse to look beyond that. They have crossed that point of no return.
 
Because I'm not the one who needs clarification. I understand he has a problem with more then just one very small issue. In fact in his earlier statement to the U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Science, on October 26, 2005 he states at least six of them…

http://commdocs.house.gov/committees/science/hsy24133.000/hsy24133_0f.htm

"All of these have been submitted to NIST, but never acknowledged or answered. I will list some of these.

1. Why is not the design process of assigning fire protection to the WTC towers fully called out for fault? The insulation thickness of the truss members varied from 0.5 inches at its construction, changed to a specification of 1.5 inches in 1995, and was taken on its face as 2.5 inches for the North tower fire floors based on a PA report. This extraordinary range of thicknesses bears an in depth investigation. Why were no hearings held or witness testimonies heard on this critical design process?

2. Why were not alternative collapse hypotheses investigated and discussed as NIST had stated repeatedly that they would do? Their current explanation for the collapse of the towers is critically based on an assumption that the insulation was removed from the steel in the path of the aircraft, particularly the core columns. NIST does not show calculations or experiments to satisfactorily confirm that the insulation was removed in the core. As some large aircraft components went directly through the buildings, and NIST indicates the others were splintered on impact, can they explain why these small splinters could still denude the steel?

3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?

4. NIST used computer models that they said have never been used in such an application before and are the state of the art. For this they should be commended for their skill. But the validation of these modeling results is in question. Others have computed aspects with different conclusions on the cause mechanism of the collapse. Moreover, it is common in fire investigation to compute a time-line and compare it to known events. NIST has not done that.

5. Testing by NIST has been inconclusive. Although they have done fire tests of the scale of several work stations, a replicate test of at least & of a WTC floor would have been of considerable value. Why was this not done? Especially, as we have pointed out to NIST that they may have underestimated the weight of the furnishings in the North Tower by a factor of 3. As fire effects on structure depend on temperature and time, this likely longer burning time is significant in the NIST analyses. Other tests of the trusses in the UL furnaces show that the steel attains critical temperatures in short times, and these temperatures correspond to NIST's own computation of truss failure for a single truss. Why have these findings seemingly been ignored in the NIST analyses?

6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?He also has these problems with the NIST report….

“They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF, which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."

So tell me how is this only about fire-proofing?

Just because you say so?
No, because Quintiere says so. Read the above passages again, paying special attention to the parts I bolded.

And again, I am not suggesting you take my word for it. Contact Dr. Quintiere yourself and see what he has to say. Ask him flat out if he has issues with the NIST report beyond issues of fire safety. If you are so confident of his positon, why wouldn't you want to take this opportunity to stick it to me and the rest of us arrogant JREFers?

And to further drive the point home, here is some more of Quintiere's statement regarding his criticisms of NIST recommendations:

"The eight group-headings of the NIST recommendations are not specific, as they cannot connect directly to their findings. Instead they speak to developing, improving or advancing technology for safety from fire. Hence, they really cry out for more research, technology adaptation, and education with respect to fire. This is understandable as the NIST role has been to be a leader in research, and a source of new knowledge for codes and standards. The Science Committee and the Congress should take note of the needs underlying the nature of these recommendations. They are more a need for research to assist standards."

Here's that email address again: [email protected]
 
NYCEMT86: I'm a ex-truther I guess you would say. I think truthers come in many varieties. While some just think this administration allowed those events to take place, others might think it was space weapons and girl scout cookies. Other than the ones who say the FDNY and NYPD were involved, do you despise them all, or do you think some of them might be good people with good intentions who are just scared and confused?

Welcome to the forum, Jp.

Personally, I despise anyone who is willfully ignorant, i.e. who refuses to learn about a subject that is supposedly important to him/her even when offered the possibility, just as Zen has shown a few posts ago.
 
1. Why is not the design process of assigning fire protection to the WTC towers fully called out for fault? The insulation thickness of the truss members varied from 0.5 inches at its construction, changed to a specification of 1.5 inches in 1995, and was taken on its face as 2.5 inches for the North tower fire floors based on a PA report. This extraordinary range of thicknesses bears an in depth investigation. Why were no hearings held or witness testimonies heard on this critical design process?

2. Why were not alternative collapse hypotheses investigated and discussed as NIST had stated repeatedly that they would do? Their current explanation for the collapse of the towers is critically based on an assumption that the insulation was removed from the steel in the path of the aircraft, particularly the core columns. NIST does not show calculations or experiments to satisfactorily confirm that the insulation was removed in the core. As some large aircraft components went directly through the buildings, and NIST indicates the others were splintered on impact, can they explain why these small splinters could still denude the steel?

3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?

4. NIST used computer models that they said have never been used in such an application before and are the state of the art. For this they should be commended for their skill. But the validation of these modeling results is in question. Others have computed aspects with different conclusions on the cause mechanism of the collapse. Moreover, it is common in fire investigation to compute a time-line and compare it to known events. NIST has not done that.

5. Testing by NIST has been inconclusive. Although they have done fire tests of the scale of several work stations, a replicate test of at least & of a WTC floor would have been of considerable value. Why was this not done? Especially, as we have pointed out to NIST that they may have underestimated the weight of the furnishings in the North Tower by a factor of 3. As fire effects on structure depend on temperature and time, this likely longer burning time is significant in the NIST analyses. Other tests of the trusses in the UL furnaces show that the steel attains critical temperatures in short times, and these temperatures correspond to NIST's own computation of truss failure for a single truss. Why have these findings seemingly been ignored in the NIST analyses?

6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?He also has these problems with the NIST report….

“They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF, which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."


LOL

No you read it again. Now tell me how this is only about fire-proofing.

You're a Joke.
 
"E-mailing him would potentially put my fantasy in jeopardy. I shan't do that."



Independent from what ?

And exactly what would your renewed investigation reveal, then ?
Nice and slow Belz

Quintiere is asking for an independent review of the NIST report.

Maybe you should email him if you have question.
 
1. Why is not the design process of assigning fire protection to the WTC towers fully called out for fault? The insulation thickness of the truss members varied from 0.5 inches at its construction, changed to a specification of 1.5 inches in 1995, and was taken on its face as 2.5 inches for the North tower fire floors based on a PA report. This extraordinary range of thicknesses bears an in depth investigation. Why were no hearings held or witness testimonies heard on this critical design process?

2. Why were not alternative collapse hypotheses investigated and discussed as NIST had stated repeatedly that they would do? Their current explanation for the collapse of the towers is critically based on an assumption that the insulation was removed from the steel in the path of the aircraft, particularly the core columns. NIST does not show calculations or experiments to satisfactorily confirm that the insulation was removed in the core. As some large aircraft components went directly through the buildings, and NIST indicates the others were splintered on impact, can they explain why these small splinters could still denude the steel?

3. Spoliation of a fire scene is a basis for destroying a legal case in an investigation. Most of the steel was discarded, although the key elements of the core steel were demographically labeled. A careful reading of the NIST report shows that they have no evidence that the temperatures they predict as necessary for failure are corroborated by findings of the little steel debris they have. Why hasn't NIST declared that this spoliation of the steel was a gross error?

4. NIST used computer models that they said have never been used in such an application before and are the state of the art. For this they should be commended for their skill. But the validation of these modeling results is in question. Others have computed aspects with different conclusions on the cause mechanism of the collapse. Moreover, it is common in fire investigation to compute a time-line and compare it to known events. NIST has not done that.

5. Testing by NIST has been inconclusive. Although they have done fire tests of the scale of several work stations, a replicate test of at least & of a WTC floor would have been of considerable value. Why was this not done? Especially, as we have pointed out to NIST that they may have underestimated the weight of the furnishings in the North Tower by a factor of 3. As fire effects on structure depend on temperature and time, this likely longer burning time is significant in the NIST analyses. Other tests of the trusses in the UL furnaces show that the steel attains critical temperatures in short times, and these temperatures correspond to NIST's own computation of truss failure for a single truss. Why have these findings seemingly been ignored in the NIST analyses?

6. The critical collapse of WTC 7 is relegated to a secondary role, as its findings will not be complete for yet another year. It was clear at the last NIST Advisory Panel meeting in September that this date may not be realistic, as NIST has not demonstrated progress here. Why has NIST dragged on this important investigation?He also has these problems with the NIST report….

“They’re the central government lab for fire. There are good people there and they can do a good job. But what I also thought they would do is to enlist the service of the ATF, which has an investigation force and a laboratory of their own for fire. And I thought they would put people out on the street and get gumshoe-type information. What prevented all of this? I think it’s the legal structure that cloaks the Commerce Department and therefore NIST. And so, instead of lawyers as if they were acting on a civil case trying to get depositions and information subpoenaed, those lawyers did the opposite and blocked everything.”

“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding."


LOL

No you read it again. Now tell me how this is only about fire-proofing.
Because every single passage you have quoted is at some point qualified with a reference to "fire protection" or "fire safety" or something about "fire", as my previous post clearly demonstrated.

So when you quote Quintiere as saying "Why were not alternative collapse hypotheses investigated and discussed as NIST had stated repeatedly that they would do?", you're ignoring the very next sentence where he clarifies this statement by saying "Their current explanation for the collapse of the towers is critically based on an assumption that the insulation was removed from the steel in the path of the aircraft, particularly the core columns." and then "NIST does not show calculations or experiments to satisfactorily confirm that the insulation was removed in the core." The two following sentences indicate quite clearly that what he meant by "alternative collapse hypothesis" relate specifically to fire-proofing.

Your sad attempts to try and twist his words into something else will only be met with failure and further embarrassment for you and your dying movement. Although you are too much of a coward to contact Dr. Quintiere for fear of having your fragile little fantasy shattered, others will (as pomeroo has demonstrated), and eventually your pathetic attempt at deception will be revealed.

I'll make a deal with you, ZEN. If pomeroo, or someone else, is able to get a hold of Dr. Quintiere and he affirms your contention (that his criticisms of NIST go beyond issues of fire safety and fire investigation), I'll admit I was wrong.

Will you be man enough to do the same when it goes the other way?
 
Because every single passage you have quoted is at some point qualified with a reference to "fire protection" or "fire safety" or something about "fire", as my previous post clearly demonstrated.

Duh the WTC was on fire. Much of what NIST investigated was about that fire. What's your point? Quintere has a problem with much of the report?

I'll make a deal with you, ZEN. If pomeroo, or someone else, is able to get a hold of Dr. Quintiere and he affirms your contention (that his criticisms of NIST go beyond issues of fire safety and fire investigation), I'll admit I was wrong.

Bull. Stop changing it. You’re a weasel. Your exact claim was…

Quintiere's criticism of the NIST report was only about a very small issue (that being ONE of fire safety)

Quinteres exact words

"I will list some of these"

Not ONE of these

some of these

Then he goes on to bullet six different items not just one thing. If it was just ONE thing then why bullet it?

And what exactly is it you claim is my contention is? Another straw man argument?

You have nothing.
 
Zen, How does what Quinteres says support anything ever claimed by the truthers?
 
Zen's a used chewing gum, no more juice out of this one.

Yup. As per most truthers, he will now bog the thread down for pages in minutiae, meanings of words, irrelevant issues, and ignoring evidence that contradicts his theory instead of actually presenting any compelling evidence of an inside job on 911.
 
Another ass-handing. Nice work.
 

Attachments

  • Silver Platter Guy zen.jpg
    Silver Platter Guy zen.jpg
    54.9 KB · Views: 1
Duh the WTC was on fire. Much of what NIST investigated was about that fire. What's your point? Quintere has a problem with much of the report?
Actually, the NIST report is an engineering report dealing primarily with issues related to engineering. Had the NIST investigation been as much about the fires as you are erroneously claiming, then Quintiere probably wouldn't have taken issue with it. You should really read the NIST report before embarassing yourself by making idiotic claims about its contents.

Stop changing it. You’re a weasel. Your exact claim was…
Nothing has been changed. Dr. Quintiere is a fire safety specialist. All of his criticisms regarding the NIST report relate specifically to his field of expertise. This has been my contention all along, and remains so now. If you're too much of a coward to accept my challenge, just say so.


Quinteres exact words

"I will list some of these"

Not ONE of these

some of these
Imagine that. You're taking Quintiere's statements out of context again. Are you able to comprehend that Quintiere has multiple criticisms all relating to one specific issue? Are you able to wrap your head around such a complex concept?

But hey, don't take my word for it. Here's what Quintiere had to say in his statement (you'll find it just preceding the above out of context quote you used):

"I wish I had wished for clear and complete analyses and evidence to determine the full cause of the factors behind and the reasons for the collapse of the WTC buildings, as they bear on the fire safety design of current and future buildings."

Then he goes on to bullet six different items not just one thing. If it was just ONE thing then why bullet it?
See above. As I have already demonstrated, all of those bullet points relate to fire safety. It's not my fault you lack reading comprehension skills.

And what exactly is it you claim is my contention is? Another straw man argument?
Your contention is that Dr. Quintiere's statements have a broader meaning than they actually do, therefore undermining the entire NIST investigation.

And another you thing we can add to the list of things you fail to understand: What a strawman argument actually is.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom