PhantomWolf
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2007
- Messages
- 21,203
I'm still waiting for those physical fire tests where NIST tested partially, or fully unclad trusses, Zen.
http://wtc.nist.gov/WTC_Conf_Sep13-15/session6/6Gross2.pdfI'm still waiting for those physical fire tests where NIST tested partially, or fully unclad trusses, Zen.
As in it's unsafe to be in a building that might collapse on your head since no one can explain for certain how it happened on 9-11.
And yet, even a modicum of research will reveal which is the right one to consider, seeing as how there are only two possibilities. Personally, since I work from a hard copy of the NCSTAR, I post actual page numbers.PDF pages and actual NIST pages are different.
You operate on the enthymeme that videos, photographs and eyewitness testimony are not proper ways to validate a computer model. This stands not only in opposition to the entirety of rational scientific debate, but also to most of the truth movement as well.Glad your glad but I was looking for someone to show me something NIST did to warrant their computer input other then video and working backwards.
1) NIST was not directed to study the post-initiation phase of the tower collapse. Any reference to a computer model used by NIST necessarily eliminates post initiation events because the computer model was designed only to analyze a quasi-static system.Not of the collapse itself just the initiation. And I disagree that it's valid to assume what exactly occurred after this assumed initiation.
No, it is not. The basis for the entirety of the scientific method.Experimentally verified is relative.
I noticed that none of the essays you've linked to debate the actual values input into the system. Am I to assume that said researchers agree with NIST's inputs?Opinion as to proper values. There are those who debate this very subject.
http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/nist/index.html
The initial conditions were determined in scientifically rigorous ways. An FEA model of the airplane was created in addition to a model of the WTC towers. Frame by frame, NIST reconstructed how the planes entered, where the debris went and what damage was caused. At each step, NIST validated the model with pictures, videos and eyewitness testimony. I would add that none of the researchers working on "alternative theories" such as Dr. Jones have done this. Jones did not bother to determine the initial conditions, and it would be excellent for you to remember that the initial conditions are necessary for any "alternative theory."Yes you need to determine initial conditions not assert.
NIST's quasi-static pre-initiation model could never even begin to validate itself through complete collapse. In truth, there is no model in existence today which is capable of handling and calculating all of the variables necessary to replicate the exact conditions of the collapse in an analytical way."If" is correct. And exactly what I feel wouldn't have validated in a model of collapse initiation following through to the end of the collapse.
Again, the problem with stochastic solutions is that, while they are mathematically valid, the possibility arises where one can acquire multiple solutions. Stochasticism and chaos theory are two interdependent issues when dealing with a situation as complicated as the WTC towers.“most” is not necessarily accurate. Out of NY, PN, and OH, Ohio is the closet to where I live but none of them are actually close to me.
Zen said:Experimentally verified is relative.
I don't disagree that it's a theory. It's just not the only theory.That's a very fine way to ignore any and all scientific theories that do not please you.
And yet, even a modicum of research will reveal which is the right one to consider, seeing as how there are only two possibilities. Personally, since I work from a hard copy of the NCSTAR, I post actual page numbers.
You operate on the enthymeme that videos, photographs and eyewitness testimony are not proper ways to validate a computer model. This stands not only in opposition to the entirety of rational scientific debate, but also to most of the truth movement as well.
1) NIST was not directed to study the post-initiation phase of the tower collapse. Any reference to a computer model used by NIST necessarily eliminates post initiation events because the computer model was designed only to analyze a quasi-static system.
2) It's perfectly valid to assume that once a floor loses its support, it will fall down. Frank Greening did the mathematics to show that there was sufficient potential energy in the towers to overcome the resistance provided by each floor. There are no assumptions in post-initiation events, only facts and the law of gravity.
No, it is not. The basis for the entirety of the scientific method.
I noticed that none of the essays you've linked to debate the actual values input into the system. Am I to assume that said researchers agree with NIST's inputs?
The initial conditions were determined in scientifically rigorous ways. An FEA model of the airplane was created in addition to a model of the WTC towers. Frame by frame, NIST reconstructed how the planes entered, where the debris went and what damage was caused. At each step, NIST validated the model with pictures, videos and eyewitness testimony. I would add that none of the researchers working on "alternative theories" such as Dr. Jones have done this. Jones did not bother to determine the initial conditions, and it would be excellent for you to remember that the initial conditions are necessary for any "alternative theory."
NIST's quasi-static pre-initiation model could never even begin to validate itself through complete collapse. In truth, there is no model in existence today which is capable of handling and calculating all of the variables necessary to replicate the exact conditions of the collapse in an analytical way.
To be clear, NIST's model DID correctly match the observed experimental conditions. There is no "if" to it.
Again, the problem with stochastic solutions is that, while they are mathematically valid, the possibility arises where one can acquire multiple solutions. Stochasticism and chaos theory are two interdependent issues when dealing with a situation as complicated as the WTC towers.
In the case of the WTC towers, the term "most" is quantifiable, whereas your example is not. If I don't know where you live, I can't determine how close the closest state is. But since I do know the global characteristics of the tower before collapse, I can quantify the accuracy of the model.
I haven't been cryptic at all. My point is that NIST did not intend to use the fire test to directly verify the deflection viewed in the model, as you have repeatedly claimed. I then provided you a page number to read to verify my assertion. Have you done so?Yes but you were replying to my source of a PDF. Should I have assumed otherwise? You also were cryptic about whatever the point was you were trying to make. Why? Just spit it out.
What factors did they fail to account for? Why should NIST not pick the scenario that best reflects observed reality?No I operate under the observed fact of the NIST practice to cherry pick factors and worse case scenarios.
Sneaky, but it is my claim that they were not commissioned to study the collapse, not commissioned not to study the collapse. There is a distinct difference there.Yeah we’ve already established what they were commissioned not to do.
Why can we not assume that gravity is the cause of the collapse?Yes we all watched it fall but that doesn’t mean we assume how.
Frankly, that's your opinion, and it has no bearing on this debate.All factors were not verified. They were picked from a selected pool of factors that supported a pre-determined conclusion.
Would you care to post a citation for that assertion?No they don’t. Especially for example when they removed every support that even had just a small percent of damage to it.
How does the Purdue model change, discredit or undermine the NIST report?This is even challenged in more recent computer models. For example does the Purdue model give the same cause for how the fire-proofing was compromised? Are all of the NIST factors verified or not?
This argument makes no sense. You're criticizing NIST for failing to publish conclusions in an area they did not study because they have photographic evidence. You've paired your complaint with the conclusion "it's not determined" as though your objection were support. That's called "begging the question."“At each step, NIST validated the model with pictures, videos and eyewitness testimony.”
They had all of this for the collapse also. Yeah I know… that’s not what they were commissioned to do. So it’s not determined.
But only one "if" matched reality.There was plenty of “if” to it thus the multiple scenarios.
Were there no way to validate the model, this would be the case. However, because we have global parameters, the solution that matches those is the right one.Yes that is the problem. They can aquire multiple solutions or even miss one all together.
This is arguably the most childish response I've ever read.I live in the United States quantify it.
May I posit that my explanations appear to be "dressed up" because you do not have the requisite education or experience to argue on my level? I've noticed that you do not appear to respond to any point I make specifically, but rather choose to make generalized contrarian arguments that do nothing more than dogmatically repeat your position.Most of this is just a bunch of dressed up excuses. But that seems to be the norm these days for anyone who endorses the NIST theory. To do so forces one to become an apologist for them.
I don't disagree that it's a theory. It's just not the only theory.
Yeah we’ve already established what they were commissioned not to do.
They were picked from a selected pool of factors that supported a pre-determined conclusion.
What factors did they fail to account for? Why should NIST not pick the scenario that best reflects observed reality?
I haven't been cryptic at all. My point is that NIST did not intend to use the fire test to directly verify the deflection viewed in the model, as you have repeatedly claimed.
Would you care to post a citation for that assertion?
How does the Purdue model change, discredit or undermine the NIST report?
To be clear, I'm arguing NIST's case by default. I'm not arguing that it is perfect, but rather that it is more accurate and more complete than any other counter theory. Pertaining to this debate, I'm arguing that your assertions against the NCSTAR are false.
The deflections seen in the photographic evidence, both global and localized.So what did they use especially in light of this admission?
Imagine a tunnel going down at a steep angle. You attach a rope to a fully loaded mine cart and lower it into the tunnel. Once the mine cart is obscured in darkness, you can assume that the mine cart is the reason for the tension in the rope despite the fact that you cannot see the mine cart. You know the rope is connected to the mine cart, and that gravity works even in darkness.wtc.nist.gov/pubs/NCSTAR1-5ExecutiveSummary.pdf
"Fires deeper than a few meters inside the building could not be seen because of the smoke obscuration and the steep viewing angle of nearly all the photographs."
http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1CollapseofTowers.pdf
PDF page 150 actual NIST page 100
“The two Tower models included the core columns, the floor beams, and the concrete slabs from the impact and fire zones to the highest floor below the hat truss structure: from the 89th floor to the 106th floor for WTC 1 and from the 73rd floor to the 106th floor for WTC 2. Within these floors, aircraft-damaged structural components were removed. (p 100/150)”
No they don’t. Especially for example when they removed every support that even had just a small percent of damage to it.
Why are you quoting from an author who is summarizing Purdue's position without reference to the original work? Have you not read Purdue's research yourself?It differs in its own so-called verified conclusions.
http://georgewashington.blogspot.com/2007/06/purdue-simulation-full-of-hot-air.html
"1. Were columns on the south face of WTC severed by aircraft impact? NIST says maybe one, but Purdue now suggests several. NCSTAR1, p. 22-23.
2. Was there any jet fuel in AA11's center fuel tank? NIST says no, but Purdue now says yes, it was completely full. NCTSAR1-5A, p liii, lviii.
3. How did the fireproofing get "widely dislodged"? NIST suggests the aircraft debris turned into shotgun blasts to affect this. Purdue now suggests the jet fuel did it. Thanks to Purdue for invalidating NIST's work. NCSTAR1, p 119."
I'm defending NIST against baseless accusations and criticisms based on nothing more than fantasy and a complete misunderstanding of engineering and collapse forensics.To be clear you're apologizing for them. More or most is not necessarily correct. And it’s not good enough.
"1. Were columns on the south face of WTC severed by aircraft impact? NIST says maybe one, but Purdue now suggests several. NCSTAR1, p. 22-23.
2. Was there any jet fuel in AA11's center fuel tank? NIST says no, but Purdue now says yes, it was completely full. NCTSAR1-5A, p liii, lviii.
3. How did the fireproofing get "widely dislodged"? NIST suggests the aircraft debris turned into shotgun blasts to affect this. Purdue now suggests the jet fuel did it. Thanks to Purdue for invalidating NIST's work. NCSTAR1, p 119."
Good. I thought I was the only one who noticed zen wasn't addressing ANY of The Almond's technical points directly but was repeating his position in slightly different words over and over again.
Imagine a tunnel going down at a steep angle. You attach a rope to a fully loaded mine cart and lower it into the tunnel…. Beyond it is another dimension - a dimension of sound, a dimension of sight, a dimension of mind. You're moving into a land of both shadow and substance, of things and ideas. You've just crossed over into the Twilight Zone.
These statements do not support each other.
Why are you quoting from an author who is summarizing Purdue's position without reference to the original work? Have you not read Purdue's research yourself?
I'm defending NIST against baseless accusations and criticisms based on nothing more than fantasy and a complete misunderstanding of engineering and collapse forensics.
Purdue has considered the evidence, and now offers some modifications to NIST's findings in the light of their own work. This is how the scientific method works.
Anyway, isn't it rather obvious that Purdue's findings indicate that the initial damage was greater than NIST found, and therefore that if Purdue are correct then collapse due to damage and fire is an even more reasonable conclusion?
You are perpetrating a classic case of falsely assuming that any discrepancy in the official findings necessarily supports the conspiracy theory, whereas in fact Purdue's findings simply show it to be even more unlikely than it already was.
I'm defending NIST against baseless accusations and criticisms based on nothing more than fantasy and a complete misunderstanding of engineering and collapse forensics.
It’s not baseless when much of the same kind of criticism of the NIST method also comes from a NIST insider. But I guess you would know better. Why is that? Don’t people from NIST know what they are talking about?
“In my opinion, the WTC investigation by NIST falls short of expectations by not definitively finding cause, by not sufficiently linking recommendations of specificity to cause, by not fully invoking all of their authority to seek facts in the investigation, and by the guidance of government lawyers to deter rather than develop fact finding. “ - James Quintiere, Ph.D., former Chief of the Fire Science Division of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST),