Why I despise the Truthers

Was every floor of the WTC hit by a plane or even on fire? Did the entire WTC fall down?

So undamaged structures are invincible ?

mid-air as in before ground level.

Ah! So their contact with OTHER structural members can damage them ?


That's my question. Sources that they weren't, please.

There's that burden of proof again.

NIST never found out. They only got as far as 3 inches of sag after 2 hours. Twice as long as it took the WTC to collapse.

Well explosives don't produce sag, do they ?

Can you hear me laughing?

Yes. I can tell that this is just a game to you.
 
please tell me this is just a typo, i dont want to believe you are this dumb

I was just commenting on the DREXS. I don't know if it's a typo I think they just got it wrong and included re-building costs with the clean-up cost. I can't find the site again but I did find this...

"Waste Industry, Others Help with Cleanup at World Trade Center Site
Implosion consultant Controlled Demolition Inc. (CDI), Phoenix, Md., has reported that it could take up to 14 months to remove all of the debris. New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuliani has estimated that cleanup could take up to one year. Total estimated cost for cleanup and rebuilding is $39 billion." -Waste Age (11/01/21) - http://killtown.911review.org/wtc7/collapse.html


"A May 30 ceremony will mark the end of the cleanup and recovery work at the World Trade Center site, as the last heap of Sept. 11 debris is removed, Mayor Michael Bloomberg said on Thursday. The excavation will be completed three months ahead of what city officials had predicted, and will have cost about $750 million — about one-tenth of the initial estimate of $7 billion." -CBS (05/16/02)

More on DREXS...

"Controlled Demolition Incorporated’s implosion capabilities and DREXS (Directional Remote Explosive Severance) System facilitate the demolition or dismantling of all types of steel and concrete facilities to provide the safe, expeditious and cost-effective removal of industrial structures." -CDI

"Our DREXS (Directional Remote Explosives Severance) systems are engineered and applied to segment steel components into pieces matching the lifting capacity of the available equipment. State of the art, proprietary underwater blasting techniques guarantee fragmentation of concrete and masonry piers to removal limits, and maximize efficiency of debris removal." - CDI-UK

"CDI’s international affiliate, CDI UK, Ltd. acted as a subcontractor to CDI for implosion preparation supervision and explosives-handling operations." -CDI

"Using its DREXS (Directional Remote Explosive Severance) System, Controlled Demolition Incorporated segmented the spans into 300 ton sections which matched the lifting capabilities of Tidewater's equipment." -CDI
 
I was just commenting on the DREXS. I don't know if it's a typo I think they just got it wrong and included re-building costs with the clean-up cost. I can't find the site again but I did find this...
plus the fact that CDI wasnt the only company involved in the cleanup, in fact CDI wasnt even one of the 4 initial contractors (they were hired on by one of the contractors) so even if you find how much the cleanup itself cost, not all of that would have been paid to CDI
 
So undamaged structures are invincible?

No just undamaged.

Ah! So their contact with OTHER structural members can damage them?

Apparently not in the case of the lower overpass.

There's that burden of proof again.

That’s what I said.

Well explosives don't produce sag, do they?

They don’t need to.

Yes. I can tell that this is just a game to you.

Just a spectator enjoying a game of spin. It makes me laugh.
 
Was every floor of the WTC hit by a plane or even on fire? Did the entire WTC fall down?

1 - No, and no. But the floors most damaged are the ones which caused the global collapse.

2 - Yes, the entire wtc fell down when these floors collapsed on the others.

It was insinuated to me on my comparisons like the Windsor that it doesn’t compare because it wasn't hit by a plane.

It doesn't. I'm not comparing them on every level. Only on the fact that in both cases, fire caused steel to weaken. Period.

mid-air as in before ground level.

Concrete traveling 60mph into other concrete won't cause breakage?

nicepants said:
Source that the bridges were of equal strength?.
That's my question. Sources that they weren't, please.

You claimed:

"One mass design with a certain strength falling on one of equal strength."

So the onus of a source is on YOU.

That was the comparison to the overpass that did support the falling road.

Just because an overpass can support the weight of another overpass falling on it, it doesn't mean that one floor of an office building can support the weight of multiple floors above it.

Yes. Did I dispute this? How long did officie contents take to burn up in any given area? NIST claims 20 -25 minutes.

Then the fire would move to another area, unlike the bridge, where the tanker was the only source of fuel.

The bolts most likley failed. Not exactly truss failure. And how thick is that steel in the overpass? hmmmmm

Hmm...what were the bolts made of? Why did they fail?

NIST never found out. They only got as far as 3 inches of sag after 2 hours. Twice as long as it took the WTC to collapse.

They used a 1/2 and a 1/4 scale slab.
If the floor trusses didn't sag, what was pulling in on the exterior columns?

That's a very poor comparison of the obvious way the towers were witnessed to collapse. If it did happen like your comparison it might of made more sense. The towers fell like everyone let go at the same time.

LOL. Even looking at videos of the collapse we can see that your statement is bunk. You can see columns buckling...one, then another, then a few more, then all at once the rest begin. It all happens very quickly.


You're missing the big point here...the hotter metal gets, the more it weakens. Period. I hope we can agree on that.
 
1 - No, and no. But the floors most damaged are the ones which caused the global collapse.

2 - Yes, the entire wtc fell down when these floors collapsed on the others.



It doesn't. I'm not comparing them on every level. Only on the fact that in both cases, fire caused steel to weaken. Period.



Concrete traveling 60mph into other concrete won't cause breakage?



You claimed:

"One mass design with a certain strength falling on one of equal strength."

So the onus of a source is on YOU.



Just because an overpass can support the weight of another overpass falling on it, it doesn't mean that one floor of an office building can support the weight of multiple floors above it.



Then the fire would move to another area, unlike the bridge, where the tanker was the only source of fuel.



Hmm...what were the bolts made of? Why did they fail?



They used a 1/2 and a 1/4 scale slab.
If the floor trusses didn't sag, what was pulling in on the exterior columns?



LOL. Even looking at videos of the collapse we can see that your statement is bunk. You can see columns buckling...one, then another, then a few more, then all at once the rest begin. It all happens very quickly.


You're missing the big point here...the hotter metal gets, the more it weakens. Period. I hope we can agree on that.
http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/releases/ULTestResults.pdf
 
No just undamaged.

Undamaged structures remain undamaged no matter what ? You're weird.

That’s what I said.

No, you're trying to have people DISPROVE your UNPROVEN theory.

They don’t need to.

Why not ? Pray tell, what destroyed the WTC towers if not planes and fires ?

And if you say thermite, you're disqualified, because that STILL wouldn't explain the "molten steel".

Just a spectator enjoying a game of spin. It makes me laugh.

That's what I'm talking about. Truthers don't care about the 3000 people who died that day. It's all a game to get attention.

Want to get attention ? Go to school, learn stuff, work, contribute.
 
[sigh, shakes head]

Zen

You need to focus. You're skipping about from issue to issue without properly debating any of them.

Or are you just trying to present a moving target in order to put off the inevitable?
 
[sigh, shakes head]

Zen

You need to focus. You're skipping about from issue to issue without properly debating any of them.

Or are you just trying to present a moving target in order to put off the inevitable?
I know the world only revolves around you in your delusional little universe but try to remember I'm responding to multiple people here not just the self appointed representative of all architects.

Now what's the inevitable and what's taking it so long?
 
ZENSMACK89 said:
...Just a spectator enjoying a game of spin. It makes me laugh.
For uncontrollable giggles, try conceiving that the ignorant, toothless, lying "truth" movement is ever going to amount to more than a dropped pebble's ripple in the ocean of reality.
 
NIST never found out. They only got as far as 3 inches of sag after 2 hours. Twice as long as it took the WTC to collapse.

When they tested SMALLER scale trusses WITH fireproofing ON.

These tests where to determine if the fireproofing that had been originally applied was actually succient to stand up to the regulations that they were supposed to have met, they weren't tests to check that the Truss sag theory was correct. The results showed that in most cases that the Trusses would have meet the regulations with the original fireproofing levels, but that in some cases it didn't. You have no idea what you are talking about.
 
When they tested SMALLER scale trusses WITH fireproofing ON.

These tests where to determine if the fireproofing that had been originally applied was actually succient to stand up to the regulations that they were supposed to have met, they weren't tests to check that the Truss sag theory was correct. The results showed that in most cases that the Trusses would have meet the regulations with the original fireproofing levels, but that in some cases it didn't. You have no idea what you are talking about.
Wrong. No NIST physical fire test indicated anything near the 42 inches of sag they took the liberty of inputting into their computer model.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom