Why I despise the Truthers

Would they all fall straight down to dust and no pieces longer then what a flat bed could haul away?
http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/wtc/WTC_ch2.htm

Important point I neglected to make:

The reason why the pieces were no longer than a flat bed could haul away was...........

......... (exciting isn't it?)..................

....... because that's how the pieces got there in the first place!!

I've always loved it when 'truthers' see significance in the short lengths of steel which resulted from the collapse. I mean, it's almost as if the imaginary controlled demolition also made sure the steels were cut into easily handled lengths.

And, of course, this fantasy reinforces the fact that 'truthers' have not the faintest idea about which they speak. The columns (as our friend Zen no doubt knows already) were not long, continuous lengths of steel from ground to roof. They were (relatively) short lengths bolted together. And (gasp!) what's the weakest pont on two solid steel members bolted together? The bolts! Amazing, aint it?

So, as those massive towers tore themselves to pieces on the way down to the ground they.... ummmmm... tore themselves to the same size pieces they were originally delivered to the site as. On the back of lorries.
 
why are you guys still entertaining this troll? he is not interested in debate, as proven by his claims and non-answers. he just loves to hear himself speak.

You should bear in mind that though one may be responding to the post of a 'truther', it might not actually be the 'truther' itself to whom the post is directed. ;)
 
So, as those massive towers tore themselves to pieces on the way down to the ground they.... ummmmm... tore themselves to the same size pieces they were originally delivered to the site as. On the back of lorries.


Yeah...
Every single bolt and weld right?
 
Last time around on this stupid overpass

What would you define as a global collapse? The entire overpass? Including the areas that were not subject to fire?

Was every floor of the WTC hit by a plane or even on fire? Did the entire WTC fall down?

Overpass - Steel Structure
WTC - Steel Structure
Overpass - Subjected to fire
WTC - SUbjected to fire AND impacts
Overpass - Support beams buckled when fire weakened supporting steel
WTC - Support beams buckled when fire weakened supporting steel

Yeah, no comparison.

It was insinuated to me on my comparisons like the Windsor that it doesn’t compare because it wasn't hit by a plane.

Please source your claim that the floors pulverized in mid-air and not while colliding with other floors.

mid-air as in before ground level.

Source that the bridges were of equal strength?.

That's my question. Sources that they weren't, please.

Source that the WTC floors were lighter @ the top?

I'll try to find this for you. I know I read it somewhere.

Source that one floor of the WTC could support the weight of another floor falling on it?

That was the comparison to the overpass that did support the falling road.

The office contents continued to burn after the jet fuel was incinerated.

Yes. Did I dispute this? How long did officie contents take to burn up in any given area? NIST claims 20 -25 minutes.

So, fire heats up the bridge and what happens...the steel becomes softer and softer until it collapses.

The bolts most likley failed. Not exactly truss failure. And how thick is that steel in the overpass? hmmmmm

How hot would the steel in the WTC have to get in order for it to collapse?

NIST never found out. They only got as far as 3 inches of sag after 2 hours. Twice as long as it took the WTC to collapse.


If enough supports collapse sequentially, eventually the load on the remaining supports will be too great and they will collapse simultaneously. Ever try lifting something so heavy that it takes 8 or 10 people? If one person lets go, then another...eventually the weight on the remaining people will be so great that they will all fail simultaneously. Same principle.

That's a very poor comparison of the obvious way the towers were witnessed to collapse. If it did happen like your comparison it might of made more sense. The towers fell like everyone let go at the same time.
 
http://911blogger.com/node/10779

Former Chief of NIST's Fire Science Division Calls for Independent Review of World Trade Center Investigation

Dr. Quintiere, one of the world’s leading fire science researchers and safety engineers, also encouraged his audience of fellow researchers and engineers to scientifically re-examine the WTC collapses. “I hope to convince you to perhaps become 'Conspiracy Theorists', but in a proper way,” he said.
 
http://911blogger.com/node/10779

Former Chief of NIST's Fire Science Division Calls for Independent Review of World Trade Center Investigation

Dr. Quintiere, one of the world’s leading fire science researchers and safety engineers, also encouraged his audience of fellow researchers and engineers to scientifically re-examine the WTC collapses. “I hope to convince you to perhaps become 'Conspiracy Theorists', but in a proper way,” he said.
And of course you are ignoring the entire thread on that topic that you could have posted in, the one where it is posted:

Although Dr. Quintiere was strongly critical of NIST’s conclusions and its investigatory process, he made it clear he was not a supporter of theories that the TwinTowers were brought down by pre-planted explosives.
 
You’re the third CTists to bring this up in the past few hours. In fact you overlooked a thread dedicated to it. Are you ready for the big shocker? None of you included his quotes where he states he doesn’t support a CT. Plus, when he’s looking for alternative theories, the alternative he’s thinking of is just a variation on the NIST theory.

Disingenuous, arrogance and ignorance, three attributes of the common CTist.

But please, keep posting, you are a great spokesman for the CT crowd, you guys do more to hurt your cause then anyone on this forum could ever hope to do :D
 
Last edited:
You’re the third CTists to bring this up in the past few hours. In fact you overlooked a thread dedicated to it. Are you ready for the big shocker? None of you included his quotes where he states he doesn’t support a CT. Plus, when he’s looking for alternative theories, the alternative he’s thinking of is just a variation on the NIST theory.

Can you hear me laughing?

Disingenuous, arrogance and ignorance, three attributes of the common CTist.

attributes? maybe for you.

But please, keep posting

Oh you can bet on it.
 
Yeah...
Every single bolt and weld right?


You tell me. You're the one claiming that the towers collapsed into individual pieces which could be fitted on a flatbed and taken away. I guess those pictures of the clean-up crews cutting steel on the site were faked then.

If there were short sections it was because they started out as short sections and the joints failed during the collapse. Simple as that.

But then you knew this already.
 
You tell me. You're the one claiming that the towers collapsed into individual pieces which could be fitted on a flatbed and taken away. I guess those pictures of the clean-up crews cutting steel on the site were faked then.

If there were short sections it was because they started out as short sections and the joints failed during the collapse. Simple as that.

But then you knew this already.
Controlled Demolition, Inc. [CDI] - the company that received a reported $35 billion for the cleanup of the WTC site - boasts on their website about their DREXS demolition technology, which conveniently segments buildings and other structures into sizes that match their clientele's removal equipment. They also mention that their demolitions "facilitate the fast-track debris removal required by ODDC to meet the site clearance schedule".

So DREXS demolition technology is just a sales pitch? Buildings just automatically fall to the right size for easily removal anyway?
 
So DREXS demolition technology is just a sales pitch? Buildings just automatically fall to the right size for easily removal anyway?

All buildings are identical, right?

Doesn't matter if they're masonry, reinforced concrete or steel, every building should behave just like every other. Is that what you're saying?

And can you prove that the wtc towers completely disintegrated into their component parts without any need for cutting by the clean up contractors?

You're the one making this claim, not me.

All I'm saying is that if you end up with some elements which happen to fit on the back of a truck without the need to cut them on site, well that's how they got there in the first place so why is it so surprising that the joints between members are the point of failure resulting in those members ending up in the same state (lengthwise) as before the towers were constructed?
 
Well walk me through this maybe I'm missing something.

The fire started at 23:00 hours all floors above the 21st floor were on fire at 00:00 hours and the first collapse occurred at 4:00 hours?

What did the WTC look like after this much time had passed?

Oh, gee darn! They didn't collapse in the exact same amount of time so comparison is impossible. Thanks Zen!

I'm looking for Global collapse from a full tanker of fuel.

Irrelevant. You've been shown steel structure collapses. Ergo, steel structures can fail due to fire alone. Add a 767 in the mix...

My point was according to the official version on the WTC the floors pulverized in midair as they fell and hit the next floor.



Gasoline burns at a much higher temperature than does jet fuel. Even the "9/11 debunkers" at Popular Mechanics admit that jet fuel only burns between 800 and 1500 degrees C. Gasoline burns at over 2000 degrees C putting it MUCH higher than temperature of jet fuel.

At what temperature does a carpet burn ? A computer ? A desk ?

Fire does weaken steel. But the question is how hot and for how long to cause Global collapse of multiple supports at the same time.

Depends on the size of the aircraft that crashed into it.

How about the top of the WTC should last at least as long as the top of the Windsor. I think NIST found only 3 inches of sag after 2 hours but needed 42 inches in an hour to just initiate collapse in the computer model.



 
Why I despise the Truthers...

I was on a gaming site (of all places) and I happen upon a run-of-the-mill Jonesian truther who'd just posted a Youtube "Pull It". I decide to take him on.

The guy not only violently brushes my rebuttals off, about the only things he can really reply are insults against my intelligence and accuses me of being a "CIA Disinformation blogger.. Eventually he deletes my comments and proclaims me "pwned," though I actually took the liberty of copying the conversation to my own blog. That was quite a few months ago. Sometime after that he threatened to murder Maddox in his sleep for his anti-CT rant.

Later on when things have calmed down a bit he sends me a poll with a number of basic and broad questions about 9/11 and the War on Terror. I answer it and later the results come back in the usual biased manner (turns out he hand-picked whom he was asking) and added that most of America stood against "fulfilling jew[sic] prophesies." Wth. He later got banned for calling a news editor he disliked a Jew.

What really bugs me is that I saw my first truthers when I was on vacation in NYC back in July of 2005, and I actually thought "Just an extremist fringe." Thought they were leftists too. Crazy how these things turn out.
 
The trade centers had fire proofing. The sheering off of this fire-proofing is a theory by NIST.

Crashing 767s tend to do that.

Purdue also had a theory for their model that it burned off then the seel was heated enough to initiate collapse.

They’re both just theories to try and explain how the steel could possibly fail as quick as it did.

Yeah. Usually when something happens your theories will seek to explain why it happened. What's wrong with that ?

It certainly would have an effect on the steel but not profound in less then an hour from pockets of fire.

There's that ridicule again. "Pockets" of fire are what was described on the 78th floor of 2 WTC, below the area of greater damage.

I would say the odds are it would fall over the side enough during the collapse that it stops before it even gets halfway through.

Why ? HOW would the rest of the building stop such a falling mass ? So far, nobody has offered such a theory except crazy Judy.

The Windsor was engulfed in flames for hours.

Apples <> Oranges

My point being that once the plane impact was over and the load bearing stood it should have kept standing unless there was significant increase in the load bearing or something like an earthquake or explosion occured.

That's a lie. You've admitted that fire destroys steel elements, and I hope you don't deny there was a fire in the WTC towers.

 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom