Why I despise the Truthers

I already did as far as my observations. Beyond that I have no access to any physical evidence and as you probably well know even NIST had limited access in that area.

How about you?
I'm not arrogant enough to make unqualified assertions. Especially ones which lead to accusation of murder.

How about you? Oh wait, you already have.
 
ZEN, what "physical evidence" to you require access to in order perform your calculations?
 
ZEN, what "physical evidence" to you require access to in order perform your calculations?
Being that I don’t have a lab and I don’t think my neighbors would appreciate me performing any fire tests in my basement I'd have to say none for myself personally.

I would point out though that if NIST did perform many fire tests where collapse “did not occur” and derived some numbers from that testing one would think they wouldn’t stray too far from those numbers just to work backwards towards a pre-determined conclusion.

I would also think that NIST should have looked deeper into investigating the rapid corrosion phenomenon FEMA found in their steel examinations and felt was in need of closer look.
 
Why do people here keep responding to someone they feel is such an arrogant unqualified person? And asking them questions no less. Why is that?
Speaking personally, I feel it's important to point out when people are making baseless and unfounded accusations. I feel it's important to point out and keep pointing out when unqualified people make baseless and unsubstantiated claims.

Personally, I know you're blowing smoke out your butt, but there may be new lurkers who haven't caught on to that disingenuous game you CTists play.
 
Good so what's invalid the computer model or the physical fire test? What’s more likely?
Fallacy, false dichotomy. For the third time, NIST was establishing a baseline performance for a scale model of the WTC floor design. There were numerous differences between the standardized test and the actual conditions in the WTC tower. Thus, the two results cannot be compared directly.
Actually I sited NCSTAR 1-6 on the very thread you speak of before you ever replied to me. I know all about the NIST theory of collapse initiation. I suggest you go back and read their own disclaimers before you go reciting NIST as Gospel on the collapse of the towers.
I noticed that you didn't bother to address my objection.
Because there is no video evidence of the inside of the towers or things like 42 inches of sag.
So video evidence is the only way to prove that something is happening?
Lucky for them.
I'll take that to mean, "I concede the point."
Yes I know all about the problems NIST had with the complexity of their own computer modeling.
Problems or challenges? And I'm talking about the infeasability of modeling a post collapse initiation event, not of modeling the events to collapse initiation.
Maybe that’s why they needed to tweak the numbers?
Per our discussion in the other thread, if you have a stochastic model, you need to fit it to global parameters. NIST chose the model that most closely matched the observed photographic and video evidence. That's not tweaking the numbers, that's rejecting scenarios that don't reflect reality.
I agree it would be hard to marry real life and the official version of the WTC collapse. Maybe Hollywood should try.

Sarcasm is a poor rhetoric tool. It's not just hard, it's impossible without making wild, unrealistic assumptions and simplifications. That's why it's done in Hollywood, not in science.
 
No, what I'm saying is that, depending on the building codes in force at the time of construction, the wtc tower steel would have be given fire protection designed to resist the effects of fire for a given period of time.

Actually the opposite would be true for the still standing Windsorhttp://ncdr.nat.gov.tw/iwerr/doc/pdf/S12%20PDF/s12-1.pdf
• The lack of a sprinkler system
• Incorrect installation of spandrels
• The lack of fire prevention regulations in Spain

Fire proofing isn't a matter of just applying any old inert material at any old thickness. It is DESIGNED to protect for as long as it is deemed necessary to evacuate the building and to give the firefighters a chance to control the blaze.

Ok?

The Windsor tower had fireproofing. It did it's job. But the steel eventually failed.

The trade centers had fire proofing. The sheering off of this fire-proofing is a theory by NIST.

Purdue also had a theory for their model that it burned off then the seel was heated enough to initiate collapse.

They’re both just theories to try and explain how the steel could possibly fail as quick as it did.

The WTC towers had impact from large commercial aircraft. The structures were damaged. It is not unreasonable to speculate that the fireproofing was also damaged. This means that some areas of the towers were effectively unprotected against fire.
You now jump to the matter of how the structure above the damage zone managed to destroy the structure below it. I will assume, therefore, that you now understand that steel will fail in fire and that fireproofing is applied in order to delay this failure. Perhaps we're making progress with you.

It’s not unreasonable to speculate that the fireproofing was knocked off of pieces of steel that were damaged by the plane on impact. Most of that steel is already compromised by the impact. How did the plane knock off the fireproofing on steel that didn’t fail until an hour later that wasn’t damaged by the plane?

Now, once again you argue from ignorance on the subject of the global collapse.

Let's say you have a suspension bridge and you cause a large number of the supporting cables to break. What happens? Well, if you break enough then the bridge deck will fail because it is no longer supported. But you never broke the bridge deck, you broke the cables. Amazing, huh?

What would happen if you stacked 80 of them on top of each other. Would they all fall straight down to dust and no pieces longer then what a flat bed could haul away?

This goes to show that structures are interdependent upon their various elements. The bridge deck may be sound and undamaged, but remove the support it requires and it fails.

The WTC towers were engineered structures. They were Dependant on the various
structural elements in order to remain standing. Remove the perimeter columns and the fall down. Remove the floors and they fall down.

When the wtc towers failed it was because the floor trusses were no longer able to withstand the fires. Did they lose fireproofing during the plane impacts? It would be amazing if they had not.

Once the floor trusses started to fail they pulled at the perimeter columns. These columns were not designed to take this amount of lateral load. They failed.

We then had a fall of material from the point of failure, down onto the sound structure below.

But this structure was designed to accept normal live and dead loads calculated upon normal usage and environmental conditions.

The failure of the upper structure overloaded the lower structure. Floors below the initiation point failed. As the floors failed, so did the lateral restraint to the perimeter columns. These columns, unrestrained but still transferring a load from above, moved out of upright, something they were not designed to do. The columns then failed.

Get it now?

The following begs to differ.

Several building design features have been identified as key to the buildings' ability to remain standing as long as they did and to allow the evacuation of most building occupants. These included the following:
• robustness and redundancy of the steel framing system
• adequate egress stairways that were well marked and lighted
• conscientious implementation of emergency exiting training programs for building tenants

Similarly, several design features have been identified that may have played a role in allowing the buildings to collapse in the manner that they did and in the inability of victims at and above the impact floors to safely exit. These features should not be regarded either as design deficiencies or as features that should be prohibited in future building codes. Rather, these are features that should be subjected to more detailed evaluation, in order to understand their contribution to the performance of these buildings and how they may perform in other buildings. These include the following:
•the type of steel floor truss system present in these buildings and their structural robustness and redundancy when compared to other structural systems
•use of impact-resistant enclosures around egress paths
•resistance of passive fire protection to blasts and impacts in buildings designed to provide resistance to such hazards
•grouping emergency egress stairways in the central building core, as opposed to dispersing them throughout the structure

http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/wtc/WTC_ch2.htm
 
Being that I don’t have a lab and I don’t think my neighbors would appreciate me performing any fire tests in my basement I'd have to say none for myself personally.

So you readily admit that A) you have no access to physical evidence that you imply would be necessary to conduct testing and B) you lack the proper facilities and equipment to conduct testing. This leads one to the obvious conclusion that you have actually not done any sort of proper scientific analysis to support your claims.

This being the case, how can you possibly assume your conclusions are correct?
 
So now there's a pre-requisite for posting on JREF?
Of course not. And of course I never said or implied there was.

Stop dodging. If you're going to claim someone unworthy to debate the official version of 9-11 then present your own worthiness and stop hiding behind Architect. What are you his agent?
This is growing tiresome.

First, I am not dodging. I am not making a claim in regard to the subject at hand; you are. It's true that I side with the conventional wisdom, but that is because I have been persuaded by all manner of pertinent work, published and reviewed by the thousands of engineers and analysists who have put their names to it. You may stop dodging and attempting to shift the burden of proof to me, however.

Second, I have not suggested you are unworthy to debate. However, it would be interesting to know if you are qualified to hold forth on subjects related to high-rise construction and demolition.

Third, I am not "hiding behind Architect" in any way, shape, or manner. You, however, have evaded his offer to discuss the subject in general or in detail.

He asked me to debate not the other way around.

Why is that?
Who knows? Furthermore, what difference does it make? Do you have facts and the educational background to articulate and defend them? It's a yes or no question.
 
Last edited:
Speaking personally, I feel it's important to point out when people are making baseless and unfounded accusations. I feel it's important to point out and keep pointing out when unqualified people make baseless and unsubstantiated claims.

Personally, I know you're blowing smoke out your butt, but there may be new lurkers who haven't caught on to that disingenuous game you CTists play.

You mean it's not obvious to everyone? Do you feel you have to point it out to the stupid people? Who's arrogant?
 
Who knows? Furthermore, what difference does it make? Do you have facts and the educational background to articulate and defend them? It's a yes or no question.

Do you have the facts or education to dispute them? After all you are the one who dug the qualifications hole for yourself.
 
This being the case, how can you possibly assume your conclusions are correct?


I didn't dispute what NIST found in the physical fire test. They found collapse "did not occur". Is that not the version you believe? I'm pointing to how when NIST could not reproduce collapse in their own fire tests they went to the computer and tweaked the numbers. If you want proof read the report.
 
Just a mo. And that means all of you.

Zen, I do intend to come back to the NIST steel failure assessment/fire concerns you have. But first, looking at the last few posts, it may be helpful if we just stop and check that we're coming at this from the same direction.

What is your understanding of the collapse initiation process, as set out by NIST?
 
Last edited:
The trade centers had fire proofing. The sheering off of this fire-proofing is a theory by NIST.

Purdue also had a theory for their model that it burned off then the seel was heated enough to initiate collapse.

They’re both just theories to try and explain how the steel could possibly fail as quick as it did.



It’s not unreasonable to speculate that the fireproofing was knocked off of pieces of steel that were damaged by the plane on impact. Most of that steel is already compromised by the impact. How did the plane knock off the fireproofing on steel that didn’t fail until an hour later that wasn’t damaged by the plane?

So, you're saying that only the steel which was damaged by the plane impact could have had it's fireproofing knocked off? It's all or nothing, right?

If a steel truss was hit by fast moving pieces of landing gear but wasn't destroyed by it, you're saying the fireproofing wasn't damaged either?

It is the nature of fireproofing materials that they tend to be brittle. What if the fireproofing on a structural member wasn't completely knocked off but was reduced in thickness by two thirds? Wouldn't you agree that this would have a profound affect on it's ability to protect the steel? If not, then why is the thickness specified in the first place? Why any thickness at all? Why not just a few microns of material to provide 4 hours fireprotection?

The odds are in favour of the fire proofing material being knocked off by the plane impacts.
What would happen if you stacked 80 of them on top of each other. Would they all fall straight down to dust and no pieces longer then what a flat bed could haul away?

I would say that dropping one bridge on to the stack of bridges below would cause sufficient damage for the failure to progress down through the stack. More so because you didn't cut the cables all at once and so the top bridge is tilted and when it falls it falls eccentrically and concentrates it's load on a smaller area of the lower stack.

That part of the lower bridge then fails before the rest of it and it too hits the next bridge down eccentrically.

And so forth.

All the way down.

The following begs to differ.

Several building design features have been identified as key to the buildings' ability to remain standing as long as they did and to allow the evacuation of most building occupants. These included the following:
• robustness and redundancy of the steel framing system
• adequate egress stairways that were well marked and lighted
• conscientious implementation of emergency exiting training programs for building tenants

Nothing wrong with that. The structures survived the impact of the planes. The remaining undamaged columns and trusses were able to accept the increased load transferred to them after failure of the damaged elements.

But, just like the Windsor building, the steel structure was going to fail eventually, unless the fires were put out. But they failed before the fires could be put out because the compromised fireproofing started to allow weakening of the remaining structure which was already accepting greater loading than before.

Similarly, several design features have been identified that may have played a role in allowing the buildings to collapse in the manner that they did and in the inability of victims at and above the impact floors to safely exit. These features should not be regarded either as design deficiencies or as features that should be prohibited in future building codes. Rather, these are features that should be subjected to more detailed evaluation, in order to understand their contribution to the performance of these buildings and how they may perform in other buildings. These include the following:
•the type of steel floor truss system present in these buildings and their structural robustness and redundancy when compared to other structural systems
•use of impact-resistant enclosures around egress paths
•resistance of passive fire protection to blasts and impacts in buildings designed to provide resistance to such hazards
•grouping emergency egress stairways in the central building core, as opposed to dispersing them throughout the structure

http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/wtc/WTC_ch2.htm

Nothing wrong with any of that either.

Trusses are a compromise between robustness and handling. A solid 'I' beam would have survived the plane impacts much better than an engineered beam made up of many members. With an engineered beam, if you damage or remove some of the struts and ties you destroy it's loadbearing capacity. But trusses are easier to handle than solid steel beams (and they add less load to the supporting structure from their own self weight).

So, what's your point?

The towers performed well in some respects and poorly in others. But as NIST have said, rather than change building codes, it is better to stop a plane being flown in to the building in the first place.

And if you would prefer building codes to be changed we will see the end of elegant, slender steel structures and everything will end up being constructed in reinforced concrete (though the twin towers in kuala Lumpur are reinforced concrete, and they didn't do a bad job of that, but it wasn't an easy project and they actually had to develop a new mix of concrete to carry it out)
 
Just a mo. And that means all of you.

Zen, I do intend to come back to the NIST steel failure assessment/fire concerns you have. But first, looking at the last few posts, it may be helpful if we just stop and check that we're coming at this from the same direction.

What is your understanding of the collapse initiation process, as set out by NIST?
Post 547

The NIST theory claims the force of the planes damaged or destroyed columns and sheered off fireproofing. Jet fuel though burning up in 10 to 20 minutes ignited building contents and weakened the steel that the fire proofing was sheered off of. The sheered off fire-proofing also allowed the fires to spread. Some have claimed the asbestos fireproofing that was in the lower floors of WTC1 would have done a better job. This all led to sagging which pulled inward thus according to NIST caused collapse initiation. This theory though different from the FEMA findings which blamed the fire more then the structural damage in my opinion is more in line with the original Bazant findings as stated in “Why did the World Trade Center towers collapse?”
 
So, you're saying that only the steel which was damaged by the plane impact could have had it's fireproofing knocked off? It's all or nothing, right?

If a steel truss was hit by fast moving pieces of landing gear but wasn't destroyed by it, you're saying the fireproofing wasn't damaged either?

It could be sheered of by fragments of a plane according to NIST but probably not evenly distributed sheering. If it's knocked off as you say by a bigger piece of plane that would be in essence shaking it off then one could assume it's also causing pretty severe damage to the steel itself.

It is the nature of fireproofing materials that they tend to be brittle. What if the fireproofing on a structural member wasn't completely knocked off but was reduced in thickness by two thirds? Wouldn't you agree that this would have a profound affect on it's ability to protect the steel? If not, then why is the thickness specified in the first place? Why any thickness at all? Why not just a few microns of material to provide 4 hours fireprotection?

It certainly would have an effect on the steel but not profound in less then an hour from pockets of fire.

I would say that dropping one bridge on to the stack of bridges below would cause sufficient damage for the failure to progress down through the stack. More so because you didn't cut the cables all at once and so the top bridge is tilted and when it falls it falls eccentrically and concentrates it's load on a smaller area of the lower stack


That part of the lower bridge then fails before the rest of it and it too hits the next bridge down eccentrically.

And so forth.

All the way down.

I would say the odds are it would fall over the side enough during the collapse that it stops before it even gets halfway through.


Nothing wrong with that. The structures survived the impact of the planes. The remaining undamaged columns and trusses were able to accept the increased load transferred to them after failure of the damaged elements.

But, just like the Windsor building, the steel structure was going to fail eventually, unless the fires were put out. But they failed before the fires could be put out because the compromised fireproofing started to allow weakening of the remaining structure which was already accepting greater loading than before.

The Windsor was engulfed in flames for hours.

Nothing wrong with any of that either.

Trusses are a compromise between robustness and handling. A solid 'I' beam would have survived the plane impacts much better than an engineered beam made up of many members. With an engineered beam, if you damage or remove some of the struts and ties you destroy it's loadbearing capacity. But trusses are easier to handle than solid steel beams (and they add less load to the supporting structure from their own self weight).

So, what's your point?.

My point being that once the plane impact was over and the load bearing stood it should have kept standing unless there was significant increase in the load bearing or something like an earthquake or explosion occured.

The towers performed well in some respects and poorly in others. But as NIST have said, rather than change building codes, it is better to stop a plane being flown in to the building in the first place.

And if you would prefer building codes to be changed we will see the end of elegant, slender steel structures and everything will end up being constructed in reinforced concrete (though the twin towers in kuala Lumpur are reinforced concrete, and they didn't do a bad job of that, but it wasn't an easy project and they actually had to develop a new mix of concrete to carry it out)

Now this is something of real importance that you touch on that doesn't seem to get enough attention at all as far as I'm concerned. Building codes do need to be looked at and should have before ground was broken to rebuild on ground zero or anywhere else there are plans for a new high-rise. If I never see another person jump out of a window to their death because of terrorism of a fire it won't be too soon. There’s got to be a better way.
 
Last edited:
I'm looking for Global collapse from a full tanker of fuel.

What would you define as a global collapse? The entire overpass? Including the areas that were not subject to fire?
The overpass doesn't compare but I didn't bring it up.

Overpass - Steel Structure
WTC - Steel Structure
Overpass - Subjected to fire
WTC - SUbjected to fire AND impacts
Overpass - Support beams buckled when fire weakened supporting steel
WTC - Support beams buckled when fire weakened supporting steel

Yeah, no comparison.

Yes we all know about gravity. My point was according to the official version on the WTC the floors pulverized in midair as they fell and hit the next floor.

Please source your claim that the floors pulverized in mid-air and not while colliding with other floors.

Don't they equate? One mass design with a certain strength falling on one of equal strength. No? In fact I believe the floors of the WTC were lighter at the top.

Source that the bridges were of equal strength?
Source that the WTC floors were lighter @ the top?
Source that one floor of the WTC could support the weight of another floor falling on it?

The tanker was a full tank of fuel though I don't know how many gallons that is. NIST estimated the tanks in the planes were about half full with most of it burning up in the fireball. All other Jet fuel 10-15 minutes later. Office content fires burned up in any give area in about 20-25 minutes. I also saw something once where Jet fuel doesn't burn as hot as gasoline but I'll have to see if I can confirm this.

The office contents continued to burn after the jet fuel was incinerated.

http://digg.com/offbeat_news/Tanker_Fire_Literally_Melts_Freeway_Pics?t=6406121
by nakedtruth on 04/30/2007
Gasoline burns at a much higher temperature than does jet fuel. Even the "9/11 debunkers" at Popular Mechanics admit that jet fuel only burns between 800 and 1500 degrees C. Gasoline burns at over 2000 degrees C putting it MUCH higher than temperature of jet fuel.

So, fire heats up the bridge and what happens...the steel becomes softer and softer until it collapses.

How hot would the steel in the WTC have to get in order for it to collapse?

Fire does weaken steel. But the question is how hot and for how long to cause Global collapse of multiple supports at the same time.

If enough supports collapse sequentially, eventually the load on the remaining supports will be too great and they will collapse simultaneously. Ever try lifting something so heavy that it takes 8 or 10 people? If one person lets go, then another...eventually the weight on the remaining people will be so great that they will all fail simultaneously. Same principle.
 
why are you guys still entertaining this troll? he is not interested in debate, as proven by his claims and non-answers. he just loves to hear himself speak.
 
Me said:
Who knows? Furthermore, what difference does it make? Do you have facts and the educational background to articulate and defend them? It's a yes or no question.
Do you have the facts or education to dispute them? After all you are the one who dug the qualifications hole for yourself.
Mine was a yes or no question. Try again, please.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom