Why I despise the Truthers

what if said uncomprised independent investigation says they got it right the first time? would you accept this or claim it had been compromised or was not independent?
Page number Correction

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-6.pdf

Figure 3-11 (p 49) PDF page 131 Physical fire test
Figure 3-15 (p 52) PDF page 134 Physical fire test
Figure 9-6 (p 301) PDF page 383 (Probable collapse sequence)
 
I believe I posted a chart of the NIST fire test and findings. What else needs to be addressed? Read it.

Yeah, why the hell would YOU bother to state any conclusions ?

Video evidence witnessed through smoke and darkness of the inside of the building is hardly enough to draw a conclusion from.



Explosives, you say ?

Fire testing results of steel which was fabricated to match the WTC steel wasn’t consistent with what NIST took the liberty to input into their computer model.

Evidence ?

This computer model is the NIST primary source for their collapse initiation theory.

I doubt it.

Even if it were to ever be proven to be even remotely accurate it still never addresses how this collapse initiation developed into a global collapse that followed through all the way to ground level at the speed witnessed.

Zen, you're not very good at this and it's unfortunate that you don't realise it. It's obvious to anyone with a modicrum of knowledge in buildings, demolitions, collisions and fires that once the collapse began, nothing was going to stop it. Your refusal to understand that does not change the facts.
 
http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-6.pdf

Figure 3-11 (p 49) PDF page 131
Figure 3-15 (p 52) PDF page 134
Figure 9-6 (p 297) PDF page 297

These are all consistent with NIST's conclusions. This is why I asked you to explain "specifically".

I believe I posted a chart of the NIST fire test and findings. What else needs to be addressed? Read it.

Read it, it supports NIST's conclusions

Video evidence witnessed through smoke and darkness of the inside of the building is hardly enough to draw a conclusion from. Fire testing results of steel which was fabricated to match the WTC steel wasn’t consistent with what NIST took the liberty to input into their computer model.

The fire testing was done with steel that had intact fireproofing, and used to determine whether a properly-protected truss would fail as quickly as the ones in the WTC (which suffered impact damage).

This computer model is the NIST primary source for their collapse initiation theory. Even if it were to ever be proven to be even remotely accurate it still never addresses how this collapse initiation developed into a global collapse that followed through all the way to ground level at the speed witnessed.

Do you, for some reason, believe that once the collapse initiated it should have either slowed down or stopped without any outside intervention?
 
Page number Correction

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-6.pdf

Figure 3-11 (p 49) PDF page 131 Physical fire test
Figure 3-15 (p 52) PDF page 134 Physical fire test
Figure 9-6 (p 301) PDF page 383 (Probable collapse sequence)

Zensmack, would you consider adding page 141 of NCSTAR 1 to your list? It explains, very clearly, what the purpose of the scale model test was and how its results were used in conjunction with the computer model.
 
Zensmack, would you consider adding page 141 of NCSTAR 1 to your list? It explains, very clearly, what the purpose of the scale model test was and how its results were used in conjunction with the computer model.
I don't see exactly what you are referring to because you didn't exactly site it. But if you are referring to disclaimers about how physical truss tests were not intended to model real world performance but were done as more of a comparison of performance then fine. I also understand that NIST wasn't taxed with task of going any further then the collapse initiation itself and that's fine also.

So if the physical fire tests are not a real life representation of what actually happened and the mechanisms of the collapse itself is nothing more then an alluded to assumption then what good is any of it? And when I say that I mean what good is any of it as far as pointing to it as proof of what actually happen on 9-11?
 
So if the physical fire tests are not a real life representation of what actually happened and the mechanisms of the collapse itself is nothing more then an alluded to assumption then what good is any of it? And when I say that I mean what good is any of it as far as pointing to it as proof of what actually happen on 9-11?

It was pretty obvious to most engineers what happened on 9/11. The purpose of the truss tests was to determine if the building was up to the proper standards and whether or not it would have failed absent the impact and fireproofing damage.

They already know that the building would collapse due to impact and fire damage (it happened 2x on 911), the question was, would it collapse with fire alone?

Example: I dropped my phone in water, and whenever I use it in an environment where the temperature is over 105 degrees, it crashes.

The way to determine whether the heat is causing the crash is to use a phone with no water damage in 105 degree heat.
 
I don't see exactly what you are referring to because you didn't exactly site it.
It's an extremely simple process. Simply go to wtc.nist.gov and download the NCSTAR 1 report. Open the report in Adobe Acrobat and look at the numbers at the bottom right side of each page. These are page numbers. Advance the pages until you get to page 141. I have provided you a citation including page number and volume number.
But if you are referring to disclaimers about how physical truss tests were not intended to model real world performance but were done as more of a comparison of performance then fine.
I'm glad that you acknowledge this difference. One of your talking points thus far has been to state that NIST found only 3 inches of deflection in a physical test, but required 42 in the computer model. That would indicate that you believe the tests are equivalent and should yield similar results. The truth is that the physical test and the computer model are meant to test very different conditions, despite the fact that both reported deflections as a result of the test. Their results cannot be compared.
I also understand that NIST wasn't taxed with task of going any further then the collapse initiation itself and that's fine also.
That's great.
So if the physical fire tests are not a real life representation of what actually happened
They are, in fact, an ASTM standard test. Frankly, no ASTM standard actually tests real life conditions, though the results are often correlated to real life performance.
and the mechanisms of the collapse itself is nothing more then an alluded to assumption then what good is any of it?
The mechanisms were modeled in a computer program using experimentally verified input values. Values such as heat transfer, thermal conductivity, modulus of elasticity, compressive strength, etc., are not tested using tests that approximate the conditions in the WTC towers. Each value is determined in a carefully controlled analytical test.
And when I say that I mean what good is any of it as far as pointing to it as proof of what actually happen on 9-11?
When the proper values are input into a model, mathematics shows us what the conclusion most likely is.

That particular branch of mathematics is known as partial differential calculus. The biggest problem with PDC is that the solutions are frequently not exact (deterministic). When you don't have a deterministic solution, you have to iteratively solve the equations. This is the basis for computer modeling, and its little brother, finite element analysis.

The point is that, in order to model a solution which is mathematically valid, you need only determine the initial conditions and the rate at which the system is changing. That was largely the purpose of the tests listed on page 141 and of others such as the paint-chip analysis.

The last step in validating the model is to apply it to global characteristics. Thus, if the all of the thousands of equations working in conjunction with each other are able to correctly predict behavior that can be experimentally identified, the model is validated. In the case of the WTC towers, the model that correctly matched the observed deflection of the towers and the considerable deformation of the columns was chosen as the most valid model.
 
It's an extremely simple process. Simply go to wtc.nist.gov and download the NCSTAR 1 report. Open the report in Adobe Acrobat and look at the numbers at the bottom right side of each page. These are page numbers. Advance the pages until you get to page 141. I have provided you a citation including page number and volume number.

PDF pages and actual NIST pages are different.

I'm glad that you acknowledge this difference.
That's great.

Glad your glad but I was looking for someone to show me something NIST did to warrant their computer input other then video and working backwards.

The mechanisms were modeled in a computer program using experimentally verified input values. Values such as heat transfer, thermal conductivity, modulus of elasticity, compressive strength, etc., are not tested using tests that approximate the conditions in the WTC towers. Each value is determined in a carefully controlled analytical test.

Not of the collapse itself just the initiation. And I disagree that it's valid to assume what exactly occurred after this assumed initiation. Experimentally verified is relative.

When the proper values are input into a model…

Opinion as to proper values. There are those who debate this very subject.

http://911research.wtc7.net/essays/nist/index.html

The point is that, in order to model a solution which is mathematically valid, you need only determine the initial conditions and the rate at which the system is changing.

Yes you need to determine initial conditions not assert.

The last step in validating the model is to apply it to global characteristics. Thus, if the all of the thousands of equations working in conjunction with each other are able to correctly predict behavior that can be experimentally identified, the model is validated.

"If" is correct. And exactly what I feel wouldn't have validated in a model of collapse initiation following through to the end of the collapse.

In the case of the WTC towers, the model that correctly matched the observed deflection of the towers and the considerable deformation of the columns was chosen as the most valid model.

“most” is not necessarily accurate. Out of NY, PN, and OH, Ohio is the closet to where I live but none of them are actually close to me.
 
Yea, speaking of debate there's a lot of debate by REAL experts about whether those folks at 911research are remotely qualified to credibly debate the NIST report.
 
Irrelevant. You still posted contradictory information. Which quote do you believe, the first you made or the second? Do you always post information that is contradictory? Did you not notice the two quotes contradicted each other? Should that not have raised a red flag with you if you were earnestly evaluating those quotes as sources of information?
 
Irrelevant. You still posted contradictory information. Which quote do you believe, the first you made or the second? Do you always post information that is contradictory? Did you not notice the two quotes contradicted each other? Should that not have raised a red flag with you if you were earnestly evaluating those quotes as sources of information?
Gad yer thick. Go back and read a little will you. I wasn't even commenting on the cost. I was commenting on the demolition technique. That's why I posted the differing quotes to show where the original site might have got that billion number from.
 
Yes there seems to be more then a few at odds with some of NIST's practices and conclusions. I think there was another beef that came out just the other day if I remember...
Dodge noted.

So why didn't you catch the contradictions in the quotes you posted? I noticed it the very time time after finishing reading both. Which quote do you think is correct - the first one or the second?
 
Dodge noted.

So why didn't you catch the contradictions in the quotes you posted? I noticed it the very time after finishing reading both. Which quote do you think is correct - the first one or the second?

Oh brother give it a rest…

I was talking about the demolition technology not the cost.

Someone asked me about the cost in the quote on the demo tech. I didn't even notice the cost listed when I posted it.

I told them I don't know if it's a typo I think they just got it wrong and included the rebuilding cost also. I couldn't find the site I got the original quote from. So I offered up two other quotes one that was an estimate before the clean-up and was in the billions for clean-up and rebuilding and one that showed the cost of just the clean-up after it was done and how it came in well under the original estimate and was under a million.

They were all quotes. I don't endorse any of them. Just pointing to them as an explanation as to where someone might have came up with that original statement in the billions. Someone asked. I showed them what I found.

That's it.
 
lol

yeah right safety

As in it's unsafe to be in a building that might collapse on your head since no one can explain for certain how it happened on 9-11.

Maybe you should go through the NIST report and fix some of that. You know... try to make sense of it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom