Why I despise the Truthers

Please confirm that you understand that the Steel Framed part of the Windsor Tower structure failed catastrophically during the fire and that the reinforced concrete part of the structure did not suffer a similar failure?

I would like to know that you understand this.

If these facts have now sunk in (or been reluctantly accepted by you) I trust you see how the Windsor Tower fire is a very BAD example for a 'truther' to use to illustrate how invincible steel structures are to fire, but it is a nice example of how fire can destroy a steel framed structure.

Get it now?
Please confirm that even the steel part of the Windsor Tower lasted much longer the WTC. An entire 1/3 of the Windsor tower was engulfed in flames for hours and additional fires reached as low as the 4th floor.

Get it yet? Any of it?
 
Please confirm that even the steel part of the Windsor Tower lasted much longer the WTC. An entire 1/3 of the Windsor tower was engulfed in flames for hours and additional fires reached as low as the 4th floor.

Get it yet? Any of it?

Windsor Fire Time frame

23:00
Fire started at the 21st Floor

23:05 ~ 23:20
After receiving a fire signal, the security guards went to the 21st floor and attempting to fight the fire before giving up

23:21
Fire brigade was called

23:25
Fire brigade arrived

23:30
Fire brigade started to fight the fire (news report)

00:00
All floors above the 21st floor were in fire (news report)

00:30
Fire brigade retreated and adopted a defensive position, preventing fire spread to adjacent buildings

02:00
Fire spread below the 17th floor

02:15
Chunks of facade started falling off (news report)

03:30
Fire spread below 16th floor, crossing over the upper technical floor

04:00
Floors at upper level collapsed (news report)

05:30
Fire spread below the 12th floor (news report)

08:30
Fire spread below the 4th floor

13:30
Fire was under controlled

17:00
Fire brigade declared the put out of the fire (news report)



Collapse Time frame

1:29
East face of the 21st floor collapsed

1:37
South middle section of several floors above the 21st floor gradually collapsed

1:50
Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:02
Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:11
Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:13
Floors above about 25th floor collapsed
Large collapse of middle section at about 20th floor

2:17
Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:47
Southwest corner of 1 ~ 2 floors below about 20th floor collapsed

2:51
Southeast corner of about 18th ~ 20th floors collapsed

3:35
South middle section of about 17th ~ 20th floors collapsed
Fire broke through the Upper Technical Floor

3:48
Fire flame spurted out below the Upper Technical Floor

4:17
Debris on the Upper Technical Floor fell down
 
Yes and that roadway was also elevated. Did it collapse?

No:

1 - It was a different roadway
2 - It was not subject to fire as the bridge was.

Point being, the steel structure of the bridge collapsed because fire weakened said structure. Therefore, such is possible without explosives. (Unless you have proof that explosives were used)
 
No:

1 - It was a different roadway
2 - It was not subject to fire as the bridge was.

Point being, the steel structure of the bridge collapsed because fire weakened said structure. Therefore, such is possible without explosives. (Unless you have proof that explosives were used)


OK

Were all the floors of the WTC on fire? I'm trying to see how this overpass equates not only to the WTC but how does one consider it a global collapse? I not saying the roadway that failed didn't collapse but if you are going to relate it to the WTC then what happen when the floors that were on fire in the WTC hit the floors below that weren’t on fire and not even from the same distance as the two roadways? What happen according to the official version that is? The fires of the WTC were also not as concentrated as a tanker full of fuel.
 
Windsor Fire Time frame

23:00
Fire started at the 21st Floor

23:05 ~ 23:20
After receiving a fire signal, the security guards went to the 21st floor and attempting to fight the fire before giving up

23:21
Fire brigade was called

23:25
Fire brigade arrived

23:30
Fire brigade started to fight the fire (news report)

00:00
All floors above the 21st floor were in fire (news report)

00:30
Fire brigade retreated and adopted a defensive position, preventing fire spread to adjacent buildings

02:00
Fire spread below the 17th floor

02:15
Chunks of facade started falling off (news report)

03:30
Fire spread below 16th floor, crossing over the upper technical floor

04:00
Floors at upper level collapsed (news report)

05:30
Fire spread below the 12th floor (news report)

08:30
Fire spread below the 4th floor

13:30
Fire was under controlled

17:00
Fire brigade declared the put out of the fire (news report)



Collapse Time frame

1:29
East face of the 21st floor collapsed

1:37
South middle section of several floors above the 21st floor gradually collapsed

1:50
Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:02
Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:11
Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:13
Floors above about 25th floor collapsed
Large collapse of middle section at about 20th floor

2:17
Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:47
Southwest corner of 1 ~ 2 floors below about 20th floor collapsed

2:51
Southeast corner of about 18th ~ 20th floors collapsed

3:35
South middle section of about 17th ~ 20th floors collapsed
Fire broke through the Upper Technical Floor

3:48
Fire flame spurted out below the Upper Technical Floor

4:17
Debris on the Upper Technical Floor fell down
Well walk me through this maybe I'm missing something.

The fire started at 23:00 hours all floors above the 21st floor were on fire at 00:00 hours and the first collapse occurred at 4:00 hours?

What did the WTC look like after this much time had passed?
 
Last edited:
OK

Were all the floors of the WTC on fire? I'm trying to see how this overpass equates not only to the WTC but how does one consider it a global collapse?

It collapsed...I don't know what else you're looking for.

I not saying the roadway that failed didn't collapse but if you are going to relate it to the WTC then what happen when the floors that were on fire in the WTC hit the floors below that weren’t on fire and not even from the same distance as the two roadways?

I'm not equating the entire structure to the WTC....my point is that the fire caused the steel to weaken, which caused the structure to succomb to gravity. That result was also seen in the WTC towers.

A highway overpass is designed to hold more weight than the floor of an office building, and the support structure was completely different, so after one floor collapses, the similarities end.

What happen according to the official version that is? The fires of the WTC were also not as concentrated as a tanker full of fuel.

On that highway, the tanker was the ONLY source of fuel. In the WTC...fuel sources were EVERYWHERE.. Offices, furniture, doors, desks, computers, carpet, jet fuel, etc.

Again, bottom line, fire causes steel to lose strength. Lose enough strength, and it fails to support its designed load. This will happen regardless of whether or not a global collapse is initiated.
 
Me said:
I'm not the one presenting opinions counter to the hundreds of experts in the relevant fields with regard to their findings on the subject of the events of 9/11.

I trust that my doctor knows what he's talking about when he offers a diagnosis. If you disagree with him, best you're not a short order cook.
So then you can match up to the two degrees in Physics Steven Jones has?
Are you Steven Jones?
I mean you did bring it up. Where's your qualifications?

I didn't ask to debate anyone. Someone who claims to be an architect asked me. Why is that?

Is it because I bring nothing to the table?

Why bother then?
Again, my qualifications are of no importance. It is you who are asserting things counter to the status quo. If you wish to remain coy about your background and education, don't be surprised when your thoughts are given less weight than those who sign their names to their work.

What you "bring to the table" is little more than oft-addressed points that have been refuted time and time again. You're welcome to try something new. But those pesky extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Why bother? Good question. When I first joined these discussions I was under the impression that those "asking questions" about 9/11 were sincerely interested in having them answered. It has become clear that the great majority are either ignorant and unwilling to do the work necessary to elevate themselves from their stupor, or agenda-driven liars. I "bother" because both types upset me just a bit.

Oh, and Architect has provided his credentials to several people on the forum, only choosing to refrain from making them fully public. You can do the same (say, PMing them to a moderator) if you like.
 
OK

Were all the floors of the WTC on fire? I'm trying to see how this overpass equates not only to the WTC but how does one consider it a global collapse? I not saying the roadway that failed didn't collapse but if you are going to relate it to the WTC then what happen when the floors that were on fire in the WTC hit the floors below that weren’t on fire and not even from the same distance as the two roadways? What happen according to the official version that is? The fires of the WTC were also not as concentrated as a tanker full of fuel.

Once the support was destroyed, the tower was basically seperated into two seperate structures, with the upper one being "dropped" on the lower one. Notice during the collapse, the entire "upper structure" begins to fall as a unit (it slowly disintegrates on the way down). So you don't have the weight of one floor falling onto another floor, you have the weight of 14 (or however many, etc) floors falling onto one floor and collapsing it.
 
The fire started at 23:00 hours all floors above the 21st floor were on fire at 00:00 hours and the first collapse occurred at 4:00 hours?

What did the WTC look like after this much time had passed?

So, steel structure collapsed through fire alone? Yes? You get it now?

OK

How long do you think the wtc towers should have survived the fires there?

1. 30 minutes?
2. 60 minutes?
3. 120 minutes?
4. 480 minutes?
5. Indefinately

Go on, give it your best guess. Trust me, it is possible to estimate this. (unless you go for (5) in which case you need a check up from the neck up)
 
It collapsed...I don't know what else you're looking for.

I'm looking for Global collapse from a full tanker of fuel.

I'm not equating the entire structure to the WTC....my point is that the fire caused the steel to weaken, which caused the structure to succomb to gravity. That result was also seen in the WTC towers.

The overpass doesn't compare but I didn't bring it up. Yes we all know about gravity. My point was according to the official version on the WTC the floors pulverized in midair as they fell and hit the next floor. What did this falling mass of overpass pulverize when fell?

A highway overpass is designed to hold more weight than the floor of an office building, and the support structure was completely different, so after one floor collapses, the similarities end.

Don't they equate? One mass design with a certain strength falling on one of equal strength. No? In fact I believe the floors of the WTC were lighter at the top. They also they weren’t as far apart as the overpass.

On that highway, the tanker was the ONLY source of fuel. In the WTC...fuel sources were EVERYWHERE... Offices, furniture, doors, desks, computers, carpet, jet fuel, etc.

The tanker was a full tank of fuel though I don't know how many gallons that is. NIST estimated the tanks in the planes were about half full with most of it burning up in the fireball. All other Jet fuel 10-15 minutes later. Office content fires burned up in any give area in about 20-25 minutes. I also saw something once where Jet fuel doesn't burn as hot as gasoline but I'll have to see if I can confirm this.

http://digg.com/offbeat_news/Tanker_Fire_Literally_Melts_Freeway_Pics?t=6406121
by nakedtruth on 04/30/2007
Gasoline burns at a much higher temperature than does jet fuel. Even the "9/11 debunkers" at Popular Mechanics admit that jet fuel only burns between 800 and 1500 degrees C. Gasoline burns at over 2000 degrees C putting it MUCH higher than temperature of jet fuel.


Again, bottom line, fire causes steel to lose strength. Lose enough strength, and it fails to support its designed load. This will happen regardless of whether or not a global collapse is initiated.

Fire does weaken steel. But the question is how hot and for how long to cause Global collapse of multiple supports at the same time.
 
Fire does weaken steel. But the question is how hot and for how long to cause Global collapse of multiple supports at the same time.

Then this would be the part where you tell us how long the WTC buildings should have burned before they collapsed and how NIST got it wrong. Please provide your calculations to support these claims.
 
So, steel structure collapsed through fire alone? Yes? You get it now?

OK

How long do you think the wtc towers should have survived the fires there?

1. 30 minutes?
2. 60 minutes?
3. 120 minutes?
4. 480 minutes?
5. Indefinately

Go on, give it your best guess. Trust me, it is possible to estimate this. (unless you go for (5) in which case you need a check up from the neck up)
How about the top of the WTC should last at least as long as the top of the Windsor. I think NIST found only 3 inches of sag after 2 hours but needed 42 inches in an hour to just initiate collapse in the computer model. Still then when it collapses how does it do it evenly enough to evenly smash the intact floors below all the way down? And how much weight and load is left after these supposedly intense fires burned everything up? Did you see the top of the Windsor? It looked like a house of sticks. And what are you claiming? A dynamic broken up unsecured mass broke through a static mass of still intact floors all the way down to the ground level? What is this pile driver made of and where is any significant part of it at the end of the collapse? What pulverizes first? The falling floor when it hits the next floor or the floor that gets hit? Why didn’t NIST model this?
 
Are you Steven Jones?
Again, my qualifications are of no importance. It is you who are asserting things counter to the status quo. If you wish to remain coy about your background and education, don't be surprised when your thoughts are given less weight than those who sign their names to their work.

What you "bring to the table" is little more than oft-addressed points that have been refuted time and time again. You're welcome to try something new. But those pesky extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Why bother? Good question. When I first joined these discussions I was under the impression that those "asking questions" about 9/11 were sincerely interested in having them answered. It has become clear that the great majority are either ignorant and unwilling to do the work necessary to elevate themselves from their stupor, or agenda-driven liars. I "bother" because both types upset me just a bit.

Oh, and Architect has provided his credentials to several people on the forum, only choosing to refrain from making them fully public. You can do the same (say, PMing them to a moderator) if you like.
So now there's a pre-requisite for posting on JREF? Stop dodging. If you're going to claim someone unworthy to debate the official version of 9-11 then present your own worthiness and stop hiding behind Architect. What are you his agent?

He asked me to debate not the other way around.

Why is that?
 
How about the top of the WTC should last at least as long as the top of the Windsor. I think NIST found only 3 inches of sag after 2 hours but needed 42 inches in an hour to just initiate collapse in the computer model.
If you would please read page 141 of NCSTAR 1 as I suggested to you in another thread, you would learn the context of NIST's scale load test. The tests were done to establish a baseline performance for the structure of the floors, not to validate the computer model.
Still then when it collapses how does it do it evenly enough to evenly smash the intact floors below all the way down? And how much weight and load is left after these supposedly intense fires burned everything up?
NCSTAR 1-6 has most of the answers to these questions. Specifically, I would suggest reading the section on collapse initiation. It should make it very clear why the floors failed the way they did.
Did you see the top of the Windsor? It looked like a house of sticks. And what are you claiming? A dynamic broken up unsecured mass broke through a static mass of still intact floors all the way down to the ground level?
The video evidence, along with they eyewitness testimonies of thousands of witnesses saw this exact thing happen. Why do you deny it?
What is this pile driver made of and where is any significant part of it at the end of the collapse? What pulverizes first? The falling floor when it hits the next floor or the floor that gets hit? Why didn’t NIST model this?
At the end of the NCSTAR 1, there is a reproduction of the National Construction Safety Team Act. Congress did not direct NIST to model the entirety of the collapse.

Beyond that, the computation power and complexity involved in modeling the entire collapse is not feasible. There are millions of elements, thousands of equations and thousands of variables. I'd also like to mention that there's not scientific basis for modeling a collapse in a computer to see if it simulates real life.
 
How about the top of the WTC should last at least as long as the top of the Windsor. I think NIST found only 3 inches of sag after 2 hours but needed 42 inches in an hour to just initiate collapse in the computer model. Still then when it collapses how does it do it evenly enough to evenly smash the intact floors below all the way down? And how much weight and load is left after these supposedly intense fires burned everything up? Did you see the top of the Windsor? It looked like a house of sticks. And what are you claiming? A dynamic broken up unsecured mass broke through a static mass of still intact floors all the way down to the ground level? What is this pile driver made of and where is any significant part of it at the end of the collapse? What pulverizes first? The falling floor when it hits the next floor or the floor that gets hit? Why didn’t NIST model this?

No, what I'm saying is that, depending on the building codes in force at the time of construction, the wtc tower steel would have be given fire protection designed to resist the effects of fire for a given period of time.

Fire proofing isn't a matter of just applying any old inert material at any old thickness. It is DESIGNED to protect for as long as it is deemed necessary to evacuate the building and to give the firefighters a chance to control the blaze.

The windsor tower had fireproofing. It did it's job. But the steel eventually failed.

The WTC towers had impact from large commercial aircraft. The structures were damaged. It is not unreasonable to speculate that the fireproofing was also damaged. This means that some areas of the towers were effectively unprotected against fire.

You now jump to the matter of how the structure above the damage zone managed to destroy the structure below it. I will assume, therefore, that you now understand that steel will fail in fire and that fireproofing is applied in order to delay this failure. Perhaps we're making progress with you.

Now, once again you argue from ignorance on the subject of the global collapse.

Let's say you have a suspension bridge and you cause a large number of the supporting cables to break. What happens? Well, if you break enough then the bridge deck will fail because it is no longer supported. But you never broke the bridge deck, you broke the cables. Amazing, huh?

This goes to show that structures are interdependent upon their various elements. The bridge deck may be sound and undamaged, but remove the support it requires and it fails.

The WTC towers were engineered structures. They were Dependant on the various structural elements in order to remain standing. Remove the perimeter columns and the fall down. Remove the floors and they fall down.

When the wtc towers failed it was because the floor trusses were no longer able to withstand the fires. Did they lose fireproofing during the plane impacts? It would be amazing if they had not.

Once the flor trusses started to fail they pulled at the perimeter columns. These columns were not designed to take this amount of lateral load. They failed.

We then had a fall of material from the point of failure, down onto the sound structure below.

But this structure was designed to accept normal live and dead loads calculated upon normal usage and environmental conditions.

The failure of the upper structure overloaded the lower structure. Floors below the initiation point failed. As the floors failed, so did the lateral restraint to the perimeter columns. These columns, unrestrained but still transferring a load from above, moved out of upright, something they were not designed to do. The columns then failed.

Get it now?
 
How about the top of the WTC should last at least as long as the top of the Windsor. I think NIST found only 3 inches of sag after 2 hours but needed 42 inches in an hour to just initiate collapse in the computer model. Still then when it collapses how does it do it evenly enough to evenly smash the intact floors below all the way down? And how much weight and load is left after these supposedly intense fires burned everything up? Did you see the top of the Windsor? It looked like a house of sticks. And what are you claiming? A dynamic broken up unsecured mass broke through a static mass of still intact floors all the way down to the ground level? What is this pile driver made of and where is any significant part of it at the end of the collapse? What pulverizes first? The falling floor when it hits the next floor or the floor that gets hit? Why didn’t NIST model this?
NIST was using fire protected steel. Do you even understand this stuff? No facts still?

The WTC fires were started all at once, not in one small place. I have never seen, until 9/11, a fire started in an office building with 20,000 gallons of accelerant.

You have lost this one, and this is a reason why.
 
If you would please read page 141 of NCSTAR 1 as I suggested to you in another thread, you would learn the context of NIST's scale load test. The tests were done to establish a baseline performance for the structure of the floors, not to validate the computer model.

Good so what's invalid the computer model or the physical fire test? What’s more likely?

NCSTAR 1-6 has most of the answers to these questions. Specifically, I would suggest reading the section on collapse initiation. It should make it very clear why the floors failed the way they did

Actually I sited NCSTAR 1-6 on the very thread you speak of before you ever replied to me. I know all about the NIST theory of collapse initiation. I suggest you go back and read their own disclaimers before you go reciting NIST as Gospel on the collapse of the towers.

The video evidence, along with they eyewitness testimonies of thousands of witnesses saw this exact thing happen. Why do you deny it?

Because there is no video evidence of the inside of the towers or things like 42 inches of sag.

At the end of the NCSTAR 1, there is a reproduction of the National Construction Safety Team Act. Congress did not direct NIST to model the entirety of the collapse.

Lucky for them.

Beyond that, the computation power and complexity involved in modeling the entire collapse is not feasible. There are millions of elements, thousands of equations and thousands of variables. I'd also like to mention that there's not scientific basis for modeling a collapse in a computer to see if it simulates real life.

Yes I know all about the problems NIST had with the complexity of their own computer modeling. Maybe that’s why they needed to tweak the numbers? I agree it would be hard to marry real life and the official version of the WTC collapse. Maybe Hollywood should try.
 
In addition to reading, as The Almond suggests, how about you show your analysis which leads you to that conclusions?
I already did as far as my observations. Beyond that I have no access to any physical evidence and as you probably well know even NIST had limited access in that area.

How about you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom