Why I despise the Truthers

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/analysis/compare/windsor.html

The Windsor Building fire engulfed the upper third of the building, but also spread downward as low as the fourth floor. A report by two fire safety experts in Japan highlighted three causes for the very wide extent of the fire:

The lack of a sprinkler system
Incorrect installation of spandrels
The lack of fire prevention regulations in Spain

But still performed better then the WTC
WTC 1 & 2 were hit by planes, WTC7 was hit by the collapse of WTC1 & 2...that could be why they didn't perform as well as the Windsor Building.
 
This is quite amusing. You're doing everything which you can to avoid getting involved in a technical discussion. Let's have a wee look at the latest:

What you claim to be on an anonomus forum is of no interest to me.

I'm quite happy to be judged on the technical content of my posts. Are you?



I believe it was post #617 that I didn't get one response to. Why don't you start there?

That's not so much a cogent argument as a bit of a meander. Which particular technical point would you like to discuss.



You mean I wasn't your first choice?

Gage was given the opportunity to debate with a peer, and refused. What does that tell us?
 
Last edited:
You truly are ignorant.

Well since we’ve already established you have trouble deciphering what’s true I’ll let that pass.

The NIST report was not written for the benefit of 'truthers'.

Well that's an understatement

It wasn't even intended to be a fun read for the mildly curious.

Well you got me there except maybe that cool shotgun test. I bet that was fun.

QUOTE=uk_dave;2887500]It was written to answer fundamental questions which have a bearing on how steel framed structures are built today.[/QUOTE]

So what happened?

QUOTE=uk_dave;2887500]An Architect reads the NIST report because his profession requires it, not for leisure..[/QUOTE]

I thought he claimed to read it in his leisure?
 
This is quite amusing. You're doing everything which you can to avoid getting involved in a technical discussion. Let's have a wee look at the lates:

A wee look of the what?


I'm quite happy to be judged on the technical content of my posts. Are you?

And?


That's not so much a cogent argument as a bit of a meander. Which particular technical point would you like to discuss.

All of them. You did ask me.


Gage was given the opportunity to debate with a peer, and refused. What does that tell us?

You mean it wasn't you?
 
I thought he claimed to read it in his leisure?


I fear that nearly all the regulars here will know why I had the enforced opportunity to read it at my leisure, but not you.

Tell you what, instead of flinging poorly aimed rocks why don't you tell me exactly where you think NIST made technical errors?
 
Really, is that the best you can do?

Come on, make a real, bona fide technical point! You can do it!!!
Come on! Address post #617

Someone with all of your degrees and capabilities and leisure time should have no problem with it. You did want to do this no? When you're done with your homework assignment I'll have something else for you but first things first.

chop chop

get to it

point by point
 
I think you should perhaps re-read post 617 and consider which point on your leisurely wander you wish to focus upon. Looking up "cogent" in the dictionary may help.

But let's look at this a different way. Let me pose you a question.

Do you, or do you not, accept that structural steelwork is susceptible to failure under normal fire loadings?
 
I think you should perhaps re-read post 617 and consider which point on your leisurely wander you wish to focus upon. Looking up "cogent" in the dictionary may help.

But let's look at this a different way. Let me pose you a question.

Do you, or do you not, accept that structural steelwork is susceptible to failure under normal fire loadings?
Here we go.

Whatever

Yes I accept that steel can be compromised by fire.
 
I think you should perhaps re-read post 617 and consider which point on your leisurely wander you wish to focus upon. Looking up "cogent" in the dictionary may help.

But let's look at this a different way. Let me pose you a question.

Do you, or do you not, accept that structural steelwork is susceptible to failure under normal fire loadings?
I got to go. I'll try to catch up with you later.
 
And do you dispute that the fire within the towers was of sufficient intensity to cause such failure in this particular instance?
 
Even if one were to lend credence to any of the "points" made in post #617, credit could not be given to ZEN for making them. All he did was cut and paste that text from another source (the source in question being Steven Jones' widely ridiculed paper).

Coupled with his refusal to engage in a technical discussion now, this just goes to demonstrate ZEN's skills for intelligent debate don't extend any further than his ability to right-click his mouse.
 
Even if one were to lend credence to any of the "points" made in post #617, credit could not be given to ZEN for making them. All he did was cut and paste that text from another source (the source in question being Steven Jones' widely ridiculed paper).

Coupled with his refusal to engage in a technical discussion now, this just goes to demonstrate ZEN's skills for intelligent debate don't extend any further than his ability to right-click his mouse.
I linked the source.
 
I linked the source.

Whether or not you linked the source is irrelevant. Architect has requested a debate with you, wherein you would express your thoughts and opinions. All you did was direct him to a block of text you cut and pasted from someone else's work.

You have proven yourself incapable of independent thought, most glaringly in relation to the technical aspects of this discussion. And yet you still muster the hubris to question documents that you have never read and would most likely be unable to understand.

So the question remains: What is your basis for questioning data that has been proven to be beyond your comprehension?
 
Whether or not you linked the source is irrelevant. Architect has requested a debate with you, wherein you would express your thoughts and opinions. All you did was direct him to a block of text you cut and pasted from someone else's work.

You have proven yourself incapable of independent thought, most glaringly in relation to the technical aspects of this discussion. And yet you still muster the hubris to question documents that you have never read and would most likely be unable to understand.

So the question remains: What is your basis for questioning data that has been proven to be beyond your comprehension?
He asked what about the NIST report I had a problem with. Those are quotes from NIST.

Can you read?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom