Why I despise the Truthers

Aflac

No. I claimed the opposite. The WTC had more steel thus should have conducted the heat better. It collapsed in less then an hour. The Windsor framed primarily in steel reinforced concrete shouldn't of conducted heat as well as the WTC but somehow only suffered partial collapse after four hours.
Do you understand your post is not making any sense about anything? I think this post mentality summarizes your failure to understand 9/11.
 
[sigh]

Zen

As you might have gathered, I'm an architect who actually works in this field. You should assume that I have a grasp of the pertinent structural, civil, and fire engineering issues.

I am familiar with the detail of the NIST report and have had the (enforced) opportunity over the last few months to go over the findings at leisure. I have also looked at all the so called innaccuraces, mistakes, and misrepresentations thus far made known to me by supporters of the Truth Movement.

To date I have seen nothing which would lead me to doubt the central findings of the NIST report.

Should you wish to debate these in an appropriate technical manner, then I am at your disposal. However we will be looking at the key points in considerable detail, not broad-brush assertions, and will be making reference to issues such as fire testing and performance, the Eurocode, progressive structural failure, and the like.

Now, are you interested?
 
Last edited:
Complete collapse of the only part of the structure which was steel frame.

COMPLETE COLLAPSE of the steel framed structure.

Now, you must, by now, know that the Windsor Tower had a substantial amount of reinforced concrete forming it's structure. You MUST know this.

And yet you post here as if you actually believe what you are writing.

You must be able to understand that the Windsor Tower is a very bad example to cite if you want to try to prove the invincibility of steel in fire. You have to know this by now. It's been gone over time and time again on this forum and elsewhere. You can't be that ignorant.

But if you're not stupid then there is only one other option: you must be prepared to lie in order to prop up your beliefs.

Which is it?

Are you truly ignorant of the construction of the Windsor Tower, though you chose to cite it in support of your claims?

Or, are you trying to deceive?
I gave multiple examples of steel structured high-rise fires and even one that involved a plane crash. The Windsor seems to be the one everyone here wants to respond to. We can go back to comparing the WTC to the Kador toy factory or some bridge somewhere which also didn't have a plane crash into it if that makes you feel any better.
 
more research, can you tell me where the building is today?

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/analysis/compare/windsor.html

The Windsor Building fire engulfed the upper third of the building, but also spread downward as low as the fourth floor. A report by two fire safety experts in Japan highlighted three causes for the very wide extent of the fire:

The lack of a sprinkler system
Incorrect installation of spandrels
The lack of fire prevention regulations in Spain

But still performed better then the WTC
The Windsor Building was destroyed by fire, it is gone. The WTC was destroyed by fire, it is gone. The fire in Spain was fought! WTC fire was not fought in 1/2 or 7. Now show me the 60,000 pounds of jet fuel and impact damage equal to 2200 pounds of TNT at the Windsor building so we can compare apples to apples. Fire destroys the strength of steel; this is why the Windsor building is gone. Stop using stupid examples to defend fantasy ideas of 9/11 truth, you have not doing a good job.

The world knows the Windsor building was destroyed with just fire, the WTC was destroyed by fire after impact and 20,000 gallons of fuel started the big fires. Where have you been for all those years?
 
There has. to date, been no massive fire in a high-rise building constructed at all like the towers or WTC 7, so your point is meaningless.

Steel-span roofs collapse regularly in fires. The WTC buildings that collapse more closely resembled a stack of steel-span roofs than they did any of the buildings around them. Yet the combination of fires and incredibly heavy debris falling on their roofs did not bring those more conventional buildings down. THe construction of the towers was not really as strong as one might expect.
 

yawn

As you might ahve gathered, I'm an architect who actually works in this field. You should assume that I have a grasp of the pertinent structural, civil, and fire engineering issues.[

I'm Napoleon. I own a mansion and a yacht.


[I am familiar with the detail of the NIST report and have had the (enforced) opportunity over the last few months to go over the findings at leisure.

Well goody for you. But I'm not assuming anything including that you are an architect with all kinds of liesure on your hands to read NIST and debate 9-11.


To date I have seen nothing which would lead me to doubt the central findings of the NIST report.


I'm know there are things in the NIST report that are correct. But in the end they only offer a theory of collapse initiation not a fact and nothing on the collapse itself.


[Should you wish to debate these in an appropriate technical manner, then I am at your disposal. However we will be looking at the key points in considerable detail, not broad-brush assertions, and will be making reference to issues such as fire testing and performance, the Eurocode, progressive structural failure, and the like.

Now, are you interested?

If you want to debate some architechs get in touch with these guys. www.ae911truth.org

If you have a question for me then ask it. I'm not going anywhere.
 
Those guys ban anyone who disagrees with them, and in fact Richard Gage is a liar. He is a coward also, and as such refuses to debate anyone. But he'll be glad to sell you some merch!
Really? When you were on there trying to start up a debate did you refer to him as a coward and a liar or did you get banned for your scary facts?
 
There has. to date, been no massive fire in a high-rise building constructed at all like the towers or WTC 7, so your point is meaningless.

Steel-span roofs collapse regularly in fires. The WTC buildings that collapse more closely resembled a stack of steel-span roofs than they did any of the buildings around them. Yet the combination of fires and incredibly heavy debris falling on their roofs did not bring those more conventional buildings down. THe construction of the towers was not really as strong as one might expect.
Really? Am I the only one going down the road of comparing the Windsor to the WTC?
 
Well goody for you. But I'm not assuming anything including that you are an architect with all kinds of liesure on your hands to read NIST and debate 9-11.

You truly are ignorant.

The NIST report was not written for the benefit of 'truthers'.

It wasn't even intended to be a fun read for the mildly curious.

It was written to answer fundamental questions which have a bearing on how steel framed structures are built today.

An Architect reads the NIST report because his profession requires it, not for leisure.
 
no he banned us prior to even posting. That is the "people" you associate your self with. Open to debate to them means =- only people who agree with us.
 
Really? Am I the only one going down the road of comparing the Windsor to the WTC?

And it's a bad comparison if you want to pretend that steel structures are unaffected by fire.

You claim that the windsor tower didn't collapse, but the steel framed part of it did. The only part which was relatively undamaged was the reinforced concrete. But you believe, or would have others erroneously believe, that the Windsor tower was a steel framed structure which withstood a fire. It didn't!

That you pretend to be unaware of the reinforced concrete construction leads one to believe that you're uninformed and need to get better informed before forming an opinion on these matters, or that you're willfully obtuse.
 
No. I claimed the opposite. The WTC had more steel thus should have conducted the heat better. It collapsed in less then an hour. The Windsor framed primarily in steel reinforced concrete shouldn't of conducted heat as well as the WTC but somehow only suffered partial collapse after four hours.


And I showed how anyone can easily calculate the fact that heat transfer through structural steel is an irrelevant factor in any building fire. So why do you continue to refer to "better" conduction of heat as if it were significant in predicting the differences in outcome of different fires?

The Windsor Building fire engulfed the upper third of the building, but also spread downward as low as the fourth floor. A report by two fire safety experts in Japan highlighted three causes for the very wide extent of the fire:

The lack of a sprinkler system
Incorrect installation of spandrels
The lack of fire prevention regulations in Spain

But still performed better then the WTC


Yes, for the following reasons:

1. The building was smaller.

2. The fire was smaller.

3. The building had more concrete structural elements.

4. The building had not been structurally damaged prior to the fire.

5. The fireproofing on the steel was intact.

6. The fire was fought, primarily with "containment" efforts (suppression by water streams from outside) whose effect is to cool the outer framework.

7. The larger windows failed at a lower temperature, ventilating the fire. (Though ventilation increases the combustion rate and the visible flame, it also reduces the interior heat accumulation in a fire.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
I'm Napoleon. I own a mansion and a yacht.

Well goody for you. But I'm not assuming anything including that you are an architect with all kinds of liesure on your hands to read NIST and debate 9-11.

There are at least 3 people on this site with my full RIBA/ARB registration details, and several others who have knowledge of my work. Whether you believe me or not is of no great interest to me, other than ensuring that you are aware that you should not expect bluffing and hand-waving to work in any detailed technical discussion.


I'm know there are things in the NIST report that are correct. But in the end they only offer a theory of collapse initiation not a fact and nothing on the collapse itself.

Well why don't you tell us what bits you believe are wrong, and we'll have a proper technical analysis of your concerns?


If you want to debate some architechs get in touch with these guys. www.ae911truth.org

We challenged them. And they refused. Something to hide from honest debate, I shouldn't think.
 
There are at least 3 people on this site with my full RIBA/ARB registration details, and several others who have knowledge of my work. Whether you believe me or not is of no great interest to me, other than ensuring that you are aware that you should not expect bluffing and hand-waving to work in any detailed technical discussion.




Well why don't you tell us what bits you believe are wrong, and we'll have a proper technical analysis of your concerns?




We challenged them. And they refused. Something to hide from honest debate, I shouldn't think.

Zen-

Can I ask why you won't discuss anything with Architect? He gave you his credentials so you know he has an idea of what he's talking about. Why the defensive attitude? He hasn't been abusive toward you and has offered to discuss.

Also, keep in mind, I'm curious, and I'm not trying to taunt you or anything, I just find it odd that you come at Architect, answer sarcastically, and refuse to discuss things with him.
 
Zen-

Can I ask why you won't discuss anything with Architect? He gave you his credentials so you know he has an idea of what he's talking about. Why the defensive attitude? He hasn't been abusive toward you and has offered to discuss.

Also, keep in mind, I'm curious, and I'm not trying to taunt you or anything, I just find it odd that you come at Architect, answer sarcastically, and refuse to discuss things with him.
Yaters,

Since I've started I've put no one on ignore nor have I reported anyone for anything. I try to reply to everyone who addresses me. Go back and look at this thread it's not always easy.

If he has a question for me he can ask me. Like I said I'm not going anywhere. But if it's a debate he's looking for why me? Why not go debate his fellow architects? There's certainly enough of them if that's what he's looking for.
 
Yaters,


If he has a question for me he can ask me. Like I said I'm not going anywhere. But if it's a debate he's looking for why me? Why not go debate his fellow architects? There's certainly enough of them if that's what he's looking for.

he has asked you, you ignored.
you are making statements as if they are fact and you are not backing them up with your proof. he's an architect, asking you to provide that proof.

you are ignoring him.

he doesn't have to debate with his fellow architects, because his fellow architects agree with the findings in the NIST report.

surely youre not suggesting that he debate the "architects" found on Richard Gage's fraud site?

Signing your name to a site, doesnt mean that they agree with the ONLY statement found on that site. If I was an architect, I would put it into MY OWN words of what i believe, not just sign blinding to something stated on a website, without even a glance at what its claiming (which is what it looks like from the ae911 truth site).
 
There are at least 3 people on this site with my full RIBA/ARB registration details, and several others who have knowledge of my work. Whether you believe me or not is of no great interest to me, other than ensuring that you are aware that you should not expect bluffing and hand-waving to work in any detailed technical discussion.

What you claim to be on an anonomus forum is of no interest to me.


Well why don't you tell us what bits you believe are wrong, and we'll have a proper technical analysis of your concerns?


I believe it was post #617 that I didn't get one response to. Why don't you start there?

We challenged them. And they refused. Something to hide from honest debate, I shouldn't think

You mean I wasn't your first choice?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom