Why I despise the Truthers

Cherry picking and attempting to discredit different conspiracy theories doesn't prove or make the official conspiracy theory anymore credible nor does it negate the need for a real investigation into 9-11. This includes facts on "voice morphing" or anything else you seem to think proves the official version truthful somehow.

Roses are red.

That's about as good a rebuttal as you just gave.
 
The rate of heat transfer by conduction, all other things being equal, depends inversely on the distance the heat is transfered.

The WTC towers were much larger than the Windsor, and the fires in them were much larger. Therefore heat had much farther to travel to be conducted away from the fire areas. So the Windsor should have "conducted the heat better."

But conduction of heat from the fire zone via the steel framing is actually a trivial factor in fire dynamics, in any case. Assume a very hefty beam .1 square meter in cross section, and a portion of that beam one cubicle away from the boundary of the fire area (about 3m), heated by a fire to 800 degrees C above ambient. The rate of heat conduction to a point along the beam 3 meters away is:

Heat transfer rate (W) = delta T (degrees K) * conductivity (W/m-K) * area (m^2) / distance (m)

= 800 * 0.1 * 46 / 3
= 1250 Watts

How many Watts of heat does your blow dryer put out?

This is insiginficant in an uncontrolled fire, even allowing for all the beams intersecting the fire zone (most of which are much thinner than .1 square meter).

If the beam is thinner, or gets less hot, or doesn't heat evenly all the way through, or has farther to run to reach a cooler zone, or when the cooler zone itself starts heating up, the rate of heat transfer out of the fire zone decreases.

So, the assertion that "steel buildings don't collapse in fire because the steel conducts the heat" is not supported by the laws of physics.




Do steel bridges collapse as a result of fire?

How about steel oil platforms?

When a piece of steel is heated by fire, do its properties change differently if it's part of a bridge or part of an oil platform than if it's part of a building? (How does it know?)

Respectfully,
Myriad
None of this proves anything of the NIST theory on collapse initiation nor does it explain why the Windsor withstood the fire better and longer then the WTC.
 
It doesn't matter how fast it was done before. The main thing is fire weakens steel, it's only a matter of how much time the steel has been in a fire and the weight on it to cause it to collapse.

Collapse of structures has been and will forever be a part of our lives. Things aren't meant to "last forever". People destroy structures everyday, whether in a war or just removing the old and constructing the new.
How much of the WTC was on fire and for how long? What happen or better yet didn't happen in the NIST fire tests after two hours?

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-6.pdf

Figure 3-11 (p 49) PDF page 131
Figure 3-15 (p 52) PDF page 134
Figure 9-6 (p 297) PDF page 297
 
Oh look... The Government and the Administration have been assertin UBL behind 9-11 although there is no hard evidence to support this claim. Credibility lost. What else are they asserting with no hard evidence?
Assuming that what you are saying is true, that there is no hard evidence to implicate Bin Laden for the 9/11 attacks, how does this in any way prove any of your ridiculous theories? (Here's a clue: It doesn't.)

And with whom is credibility supposedly lost? A bunch of delusional paranoids from some conspiracy theory forum? Big loss. Because there certainly has been no loss of credibility from any media outlet or investigative body on the planet, all of whom unanimously reject your movement's crackpot ideas. (Remember when this was the original issue? You know, the one you keep side-stepping?)

There's been no outcry?
That's correct.

Where's the outcry from the otherside?
I have no idea what you are talking about. Who is "the otherside" and over what should there be an outcry, but supposedly isn't?

Don't dish it out if you can't eat it.
Not only is your sad little playground taunt a non-sequitur, but it belies your lack of intelligence and maturity.
 
None of this proves anything of the NIST theory on collapse initiation nor does it explain why the Windsor withstood the fire better and longer then the WTC.

Simple. The Windsor had a reinforced concrete core, WTC had a steel core. Though the Windsor have steel core on the upper floors...guess what happened, they collapsed.

1:29 East face of the 21st floor collapsed

1:37 South middle section of several floors above the 21st floor gradually
collapsed

1:50 Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:02 Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:11 Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:13 Floors above about 25th floor collapsed
Large collapse of middle section at about 20th floor

2:17 Parts of floor slab with curtain walls collapsed

2:47 Southwest corner of 1 ~ 2 floors below about 20th floor collapsed

2:51 Southeast corner of about 18th ~ 20th floors collapsed

3:35 South middle section of about 17th ~ 20th floors collapsed
Fire broke through the Upper Technical Floor

3:48 Fire flame spurted out below the Upper Technical Floor

4:17 Debris on the Upper Technical Floor fell down


http://www.mace.manchester.ac.uk/pr...Study/HistoricFires/BuildingFires/default.htm
 
You're completely wrong about thermal conduction of steel vs.concrete being similar to steel vs. aluminium.

steel conducts heat approx 60 times better than concrete
whereas, aluminum conducts only 4 times better than steel.
So your wrong by a factor of about x15

" All known examples" meaning those on 9/11 , right?

I think you're trying to make it seem like there were other such collapses.
Okay, please take your computer apart and put in a steel heat sink. At least the steel will not melt when your CPU burns up.

Where is that building in Madrid today, and why were the steel only sections falling apart shortly after they were fully involved in fire? Early in the Madrid fire the steel parts of the building fell explosively to the ground. Poor research results in poor conclusions.

Show me the building. How is your CPU with that steel heat sink?
 
None of this proves anything of the NIST theory on collapse initiation nor does it explain why the Windsor withstood the fire better and longer then the WTC.


No, it only refutes your assertion that the Windsor withstood the fire because its steel conducted the heat, and that the WTC should have done so also.

The explanation of why the Windsor withstood the fire better and longer than the WTC is all of the following:

1. The building was smaller.

2. The fire was smaller.

3. The building had more concrete structural elements.

4. The building had not been structurally damaged prior to the fire.

5. The fireproofing on the steel was intact.

6. The fire was fought, primarily with "containment" efforts (suppression by water streams from outside) whose effect is to cool the outer framework.

7. The larger windows failed at a lower temperature, ventilating the fire. (Though ventilation increases the combustion rate and the visible flame, it also reduces the interior heat accumulation in a fire.)

I'll also point out that though much of the Windsor did indeed remain standing, it was deemed too dangerous for anyone to enter afterward, due to the risk of further collapse. In other words, inspectors feared that the additional weight of a few people could have collapsed it. Suppose it had been one storey taller, what might that additional weight have done?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Cherry picking and attempting to discredit different conspiracy theories doesn't prove or make the official conspiracy theory anymore credible nor does it negate the need for a real investigation into 9-11.
Er, ooookay.

Where have I "cherry pick[ed]?" Furthermore, it is not up to anyone to discredit any conspiracy theory (especially those which, as I demonstrated in post #1517, discredit themselves); it is up to challengers of the generally accepted consensus to present their evidence to the contrary. This is something that you or any truther cannot do, or you would've already.

This includes facts on "voice morphing" or anything else you seem to think proves the official version truthful somehow.
Any time you'd like to present your evidence for an "inside job" -- not speculation, not questions, not fallacies of personal incredulity -- you're plenty welcome. Perhaps some day, when you at last come to grips with the reality that you can't, you might realize the reason is that the way it happened is the way it happened.
 
Last edited:
No, it only refutes your assertion that the Windsor withstood the fire because its steel conducted the heat, and that the WTC should have done so also.


No. I claimed the opposite. The WTC had more steel thus should have conducted the heat better. It collapsed in less then an hour. The Windsor framed primarily in steel reinforced concrete shouldn't of conducted heat as well as the WTC but somehow only suffered partial collapse after four hours.
 
No. I claimed the opposite. The WTC had more steel thus should have conducted the heat better. It collapsed in less then an hour. The Windsor framed primarily in steel reinforced concrete shouldn't of conducted heat as well as the WTC but somehow only suffered partial collapse after four hours.

Complete collapse of the only part of the structure which was steel frame.

COMPLETE COLLAPSE of the steel framed structure.

Now, you must, by now, know that the Windsor Tower had a substantial amount of reinforced concrete forming it's structure. You MUST know this.

And yet you post here as if you actually believe what you are writing.

You must be able to understand that the Windsor Tower is a very bad example to cite if you want to try to prove the invincibility of steel in fire. You have to know this by now. It's been gone over time and time again on this forum and elsewhere. You can't be that ignorant.

But if you're not stupid then there is only one other option: you must be prepared to lie in order to prop up your beliefs.

Which is it?

Are you truly ignorant of the construction of the Windsor Tower, though you chose to cite it in support of your claims?

Or, are you trying to deceive?
 
No, it only refutes your assertion that the Windsor withstood the fire because its steel conducted the heat, and that the WTC should have done so also.

The explanation of why the Windsor withstood the fire better and longer than the WTC is all of the following:

1. The building was smaller.

2. The fire was smaller.

3. The building had more concrete structural elements.

4. The building had not been structurally damaged prior to the fire.

5. The fireproofing on the steel was intact.

6. The fire was fought, primarily with "containment" efforts (suppression by water streams from outside) whose effect is to cool the outer framework.

7. The larger windows failed at a lower temperature, ventilating the fire. (Though ventilation increases the combustion rate and the visible flame, it also reduces the interior heat accumulation in a fire.)

I'll also point out that though much of the Windsor did indeed remain standing, it was deemed too dangerous for anyone to enter afterward, due to the risk of further collapse. In other words, inspectors feared that the additional weight of a few people could have collapsed it. Suppose it had been one storey taller, what might that additional weight have done?

Respectfully,
Myriad
http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/analysis/compare/windsor.html

The Windsor Building fire engulfed the upper third of the building, but also spread downward as low as the fourth floor. A report by two fire safety experts in Japan highlighted three causes for the very wide extent of the fire:

The lack of a sprinkler system
Incorrect installation of spandrels
The lack of fire prevention regulations in Spain

But still performed better then the WTC
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom