Why I despise the Truthers

Okay let's:

Size, concrete core, no plane, fire was fought, heavy beam supported concrete and steel floors that stopped the collaspe.

Doesn't matter because it doesn't explain how different parts of a building would collapse from pockets of fire on a few floors at the same time after less then an hour.



Only relatively. Steel is a very poor conductor of heat compared to most metals, almost as bad vs aluminium as concrete is to it. Steel makes a lousy heat sink or conductor, hence why heat conductors and sinks are make from Aluminium or copper, not steel, and why we can use steel for pots and pans that sit on top of a fire or element, but still have a cool handle.

We need not talk about what kind of other metals conduct heat better when we are comparing two building that used steel. We need only to access which building conducted the heat better. The general concensus seems to be that the towers would have conducted the heat better thus making the global collapse of the WTC in less then an hour very strange compared to the Windsor which burned longer and didn't suffer global collapse.

Had no plane or structural damage. Not a truss and tube in tube structure. Far smaller foot print area. The fire was fought.

No two fires are going to be exactly the same and your only excuse for all of them seems to be that they weren't hit by a plane. Then I give you one that was hit by a plane and you hand wave that one also. Yes there is a pattern. No steel structure has ever suffered global collapse from fire, plane, or anything for that matter except explosives. Now if you want to believe that three buildings on 9-11 suffered global collapse for TWO different reason when it's never happened before and will never happen again then go ahead. Just don't tell me it's been proven as to why in any official version to date.

It hasn't.
 
Outcry? How about some proof?

How about you find some proof that a investigative body found or that a foreign media outlet has that proves the official versions correct? If you know of this proof I suggest you forward it to the FBI so that they may update their most page to include 9-11 in UBL's profile.

Period

Oh look... it's the old "Prove a Negative" canard being used as the last refuge of a cornered Truther. What a surprise. Our delusioned little friend actually expects me to prove that there has been no outcry from any foreign media outlet or investigative body regarding the supposed 9/11 conspiracy. Apparently, his knowledge of scientific method is on par with his knowledge of the criminal justice system. You're just embarassing yourself now, ZEN.

I'll say it again: There has been no outcry, and if you can prove otherwise, why don't you do it? Why don't you make me eat my words? Because you can't, and you know it.

As to the question as to why there has been no outcry, I'll help you out there. There has been no outcry, because aside from a handful of loons and over-imaginative teenagers NO ONE BELIEVES THIS NONSENSE.

This information you Truthers claim to have is not a secret. Lots of other people have looked at it and examined it. Journalists. Investigators. Scientists. People smarter than you. And they all came to the same conclusion: It's bunk.

That's why there has been no outcry. And no matter how many questions Truthers dodge, no matter how many Truthers come here and paste and link the same old tired crap, that will not change.
 
Only relatively. Steel is a very poor conductor of heat compared to most metals, almost as bad vs aluminium as concrete is to it.

You're completely wrong about thermal conduction of steel vs.concrete being similar to steel vs. aluminium.

steel conducts heat approx 60 times better than concrete
whereas, aluminum conducts only 4 times better than steel.
So your wrong by a factor of about x15



so fine let's cut to the chase shall we. All known examples of a Tube in Tube entirely steel structural skyscrapper to have suffered massive trauma followed by mulit-floor, unfought fires, has collapsed...

" All known examples" meaning those on 9/11 , right?

I think you're trying to make it seem like there were other such collapses.
 
Last edited:
Doesn't matter because it doesn't explain how different parts of a building would collapse from pockets of fire on a few floors at the same time after less then an hour.

NIST has a good explaination for why it occured, they even have pictures.

We need not talk about what kind of other metals conduct heat better when we are comparing two building that used steel. We need only to access which building conducted the heat better. The general concensus seems to be that the towers would have conducted the heat better thus making the global collapse of the WTC in less then an hour very strange compared to the Windsor which burned longer and didn't suffer global collapse.

And steel is a terrible conductor of heat. You suggestion seems to be that the WTC building should have conducted the heat away from the fire because steel is a better conductor of heat than concrete. This is an invaild argument. Just because it is better that concrete doesn't mean that it can conduct the heat away faster that the fire can input the heat. Steel is a poor conductor of heat and so it takes a long time to transfer it it away from a fire, longer than it takes for the area in the flame to get red hot. You can bet a bar of steel and heat up one end to red hot while holding the other end in your bare hands, a trick that I wouldn't attempt with Alumimiun. The question shouldn't be, was it a better conductor of heat than the Winsor Building, it is was it a good enough conductor to get rid of the excess heat, the answer is no.

No two fires are going to be exactly the same and your only excuse for all of them seems to be that they weren't hit by a plane. Then I give you one that was hit by a plane and you hand wave that one also. Yes there is a pattern.

It is true that no two fires are going to be the same, but it is also true that no two buildings are built exactly the same. The Twin Towers were probably the closest to that. The question therefore is, if no two fires are the same and no two buildings are built the same, why do you expect that they should have the same results? Your whole argument is that the same thing didn't happened to the other buildings as it did to the WTC, but here you are conceeding that they were not the same as the WTC. Therefore why should the end result be the same? You then try and introduce a building hit by a plane as it that is a cure for your inability to present cases that resemble the WTC, but in doing so you have a different plane, going a different speed, hitting a building that is a totally different structure right down to its building materials. Why should such a building react in the same way as the WTC?

No steel structure has ever suffered global collapse from fire, plane, or anything for that matter except explosives.

You mean no steel structure other than those that have collasped due to fire, like the Kadar Toy factory and others.

Now if you want to believe that three buildings on 9-11 suffered global collapse for TWO different reason when it's never happened before and will never happen again then go ahead. Just don't tell me it's been proven as to why in any official version to date.

No, the evidence points towards a natural collaspe, NIST's report shows that evidence and video and photos of the building back up their conculsions. There is ZERO evidence for a CD. As to the reasons, other than with WTC where it seems at least one vital column gave out underneath an overloaded and poorly restructured part of the building, the main causes of all three are similar. Serious trauma to the building's structure followed by concontrolled multi-story fires. So far you haven't shown any buildings that have suffered both the trauma and the uncontrolled multi-story fires that have not actually collasped, you simply claim that since Building A had a fire and didn't collapse then Building B shouldn't have, totally ignoring any differences in situation A and B. Who is it that is really the one waving their hands heres?
 
You're completely wrong about thermal conduction of steel vs.concrete being similar to steel vs. aluminium.

steel conducts heat approx 60 times better than concrete
whereas, aluminum conducts only 4 times better than steel.
So your wrong by a factor of about x15

Yes, it's called an exageration to make a point, I have on this board quoted the actual values themselves.

" All known examples" meaning those on 9/11 , right?

I think you're trying to make it seem like there were other such collapses.

No, I'm trying to point out that claiming that the result was "The first time in history" is stupid because the action was also "the first time in history." Why the huge surprise that a unique action causes in a unique result? And until you finally acknowledge that you can't use other cases as an example to try and judge what happened in this case because they aren't similar, I'm going to keep pointing it out.
 
Theory? They would have failed miserably and they know it. That's why they refused to even try. Like I said... chicken.

That is your speculation.

That was asked of me and what you cut out was the beginning of my answer. I replied it took them 5 years to pay out and they were threatened by a politician with fines.

And that still doesn't mean anything.

Do you just cut things out of context or do you also read out of context?

Miscommunication, in this case. Why would I make a habit out of quoting out of context. You're doing a fine job at demolishing context, yourself.

Is Johnny karate your hero? How cute.

See what I mean ? You try to transform the conversation into something different because you don't like what's being said, and you say _I_ quote out of context ?

Glad I could give a little meaning and purpose to your pathetic life.

Really, Zen. How old are you ?

You don't really need another person for this conversation you're doing fine on your own.

Proceed. And let me know how it turns out.

And AGAIN you dodge and refuse to state your own opinions.

I think you're here just for the attention.
 
The investigation comes first. Then comes the separate testimony under oath. They slip up. Then we get some rope. Then we find a tree.

So you need an investigation but you already know the outcome ?

My, what a fine investigator you'll make.

So you finally did graduate? congratulations

Insults. The truther's first and last line of defense.

Unless I tell you something personally don't jump to conclusions about what I believe. A major flaw in your thought processes and belief system.

But you DO jump to conclusions, Zen. You think that Bush's lack of willingness to testify under oath means something, while it really doesn't.

What is perjury?

Not much to someone who just murdered 3000 people.

Exactly why he tried to first prevent an investigation in the first place and then hindered what little of an investigation that was attempted. So nothing incriminating would be found. Chicken.

Again, that's YOUR speculation.

Here's a clue. cluck cluck

SERIOUSLY, how old are you ?

Now if we could just get some of this crap under oath and ask about 9-11 the possibilities are endless. I think Dubya's dumb enough to unwittingly become the White House's new deep throat.

"Under oath" is not a magic spell that compels the truth out of someone, Zen.

What's obvious to me is there has been no real investigation into 9-11 that would uncover the evidence that would warrant the lawsuits you speak of.

And you see that as proof that something evil's afoot ?

(ii) Taunt the CTist with “where’s your evidence?”

Yes, you see, in the real world, evidence is important. Speculation seldom does.
 
Maybe they don't want to lose their job for something that's just going to be dismissed because of lack of evidence because ... here we go yet once again... lack of a complete investigation that would uncover such evidence to warrant such a lawsuit. Maybe...

Maybe you should stop speculating and actually digging up some evidence to warrant this vaunted investigation of yours.

Sounds like NIST to me.

:id:

As I've pointed out before you believe 19 hijackers did it. Was all of Al Queda in on the details? Why didn't we see Al Queda's evidence dripping from the trees enough to stop it from happening?

Because they were operating in SECRET, Zen. Something that's no longer required once the attack is completed.

Michael Moore went on record this week to tell Infowars.com and WeAreChange.org reporters that three years after the release of his film Fahrenheit 9/11 he now has many more questions about 9/11 and does not believe the public have been told "half the truth" about what really happened.

Yeah, but Moore's an idiot.

So you are high.

Zen, your reply to Myriad's fine post indicates one of two things:

1) You didn't read his post
2) You are an idiot.

Please choose carefully.

No. You brought it up. Or did you make it up?

Make up what ? He asked you a question.

If you really have any cold, hard facts and logic why don't you pack them up and mail them to NIST.

You might have missed this: because we don't need to prove something that's already been shown.

So everyone's coming out for their daily dose huh? Good. If it wasn't for me I think this thread would have died on page two. Glad to keep you all occupied.

You're welcome.

Now I already stated I hoping corsair accepts the nomination to head up the new investigation.

I see you have no intention of answering questions, participating in a civil, adult discussion, or stating your opinions and beliefs or presenting your evidence.

Troll.
 
Doesn't matter because it doesn't explain how different parts of a building would collapse from pockets of fire on a few floors at the same time after less then an hour.

Did you miss the 767 that crashed into the building ??

We need not talk about what kind of other metals conduct heat better when we are comparing two building that used steel. We need only to access which building conducted the heat better. The general concensus seems to be that the towers would have conducted the heat better thus making the global collapse of the WTC in less then an hour very strange compared to the Windsor which burned longer and didn't suffer global collapse.

So... because metal conducts heat... it doesn't heat up ?

No two fires are going to be exactly the same and your only excuse for all of them seems to be that they weren't hit by a plane.

That's a very good difference, don't you think ?

No steel structure has ever suffered global collapse from fire, plane, or anything for that matter except explosives.

That is a complete and utter lie.

Now if you want to believe that three buildings on 9-11 suffered global collapse for TWO different reason when it's never happened before and will never happen again then go ahead.

Argument from incredulity, which pretty much summarises everything you've said so far.
 
Oh look... it's the old "Prove a Negative" canard being used as the last refuge of a cornered Truther. What a surprise. Our delusioned little friend actually expects me to prove that there has been no outcry from any foreign media outlet or investigative body regarding the supposed 9/11 conspiracy. Apparently, his knowledge of scientific method is on par with his knowledge of the criminal justice system. You're just embarassing yourself now, ZEN.

I'll say it again: There has been no outcry, and if you can prove otherwise, why don't you do it? Why don't you make me eat my words? Because you can't, and you know it.

As to the question as to why there has been no outcry, I'll help you out there. There has been no outcry, because aside from a handful of loons and over-imaginative teenagers NO ONE BELIEVES THIS NONSENSE.

This information you Truthers claim to have is not a secret. Lots of other people have looked at it and examined it. Journalists. Investigators. Scientists. People smarter than you. And they all came to the same conclusion: It's bunk.

That's why there has been no outcry. And no matter how many questions Truthers dodge, no matter how many Truthers come here and paste and link the same old tired crap, that will not change.
Oh look... The Government and the Administration have been assertin UBL behind 9-11 although there is no hard evidence to support this claim. Credibility lost. What else are they asserting with no hard evidence?

There's been no outcry? Where's the outcry from the otherside? Don't dish it out if you can't eat it.
 
NIST has a good explaination for why it occured, they even have pictures.

NIST has a theory of collapse initiation not even supported by their own testing.

And steel is a terrible conductor of heat. You suggestion seems to be that the WTC building should have conducted the heat away from the fire because steel is a better conductor of heat than concrete. This is an invaild argument. Just because it is better that concrete doesn't mean that it can conduct the heat away faster that the fire can input the heat. Steel is a poor conductor of heat and so it takes a long time to transfer it it away from a fire, longer than it takes for the area in the flame to get red hot. You can bet a bar of steel and heat up one end to red hot while holding the other end in your bare hands, a trick that I wouldn't attempt with Alumimiun. The question shouldn't be, was it a better conductor of heat than the Winsor Building, it is was it a good enough conductor to get rid of the excess heat, the answer is no.

We’re only talking about two building fires here. Which should have conducted the heat better Windsor or WTC?

It is true that no two fires are going to be the same, but it is also true that no two buildings are built exactly the same. The Twin Towers were probably the closest to that. The question therefore is, if no two fires are the same and no two buildings are built the same, why do you expect that they should have the same results? Your whole argument is that the same thing didn't happened to the other buildings as it did to the WTC, but here you are conceeding that they were not the same as the WTC. Therefore why should the end result be the same? You then try and introduce a building hit by a plane as it that is a cure for your inability to present cases that resemble the WTC, but in doing so you have a different plane, going a different speed, hitting a building that is a totally different structure right down to its building materials. Why should such a building react in the same way as the WTC?

You mean no steel structure other than those that have collasped due to fire, like the Kadar Toy factory and others.

Kadar Toy factory and others.

Yeah the Kadar toy factory is a better example the building that was actually hit by a plane. Ok?

4 story Kadar toy factory(hardly a high-rise) in a third world country that was still damaged from a previous and did not suffer global symmetrical collapse at the same time.

Is this the best you have or are you going to bring up some bridges next?


No, the evidence points towards a natural collaspe, NIST's report shows that evidence and video and photos of the building back up their conculsions. There is ZERO evidence for a CD. As to the reasons, other than with WTC where it seems at least one vital column gave out underneath an overloaded and poorly restructured part of the building, the main causes of all three are similar. Serious trauma to the building's structure followed by concontrolled multi-story fires. So far you haven't shown any buildings that have suffered both the trauma and the uncontrolled multi-story fires that have not actually collasped, you simply claim that since Building A had a fire and didn't collapse then Building B shouldn't have, totally ignoring any differences in situation A and B. Who is it that is really the one waving their hands heres?

Dismissing CD doesn’t prove the NIST theory correct.
 
That's right. But besides the NIST theory on the WTC how fast has it ever done it before and has it ever caused global collapse at the same time?

It doesn't matter how fast it was done before. The main thing is fire weakens steel, it's only a matter of how much time the steel has been in a fire and the weight on it to cause it to collapse.

Collapse of structures has been and will forever be a part of our lives. Things aren't meant to "last forever". People destroy structures everyday, whether in a war or just removing the old and constructing the new.
 
ZENSMACK89 said:
Sounds like you have a narrative for a complicated inside job conspiracy. Let's have it.
Any "inside job" would require, at a minimum:
  • Two instigators at a sufficiently high level with the desire and ability to conceive and develop a master plan
  • One thoroughly trustworthy underling who would be instructed by the instigator/overseers to research and draw up the master plan. This to include, but not be limited to:
    • Human resource recruitment for all contingencies, including pre-event operations, event enactment, and post-event follow-up. This to include managers responsible for each aspect of the plan, including security, procurement, demolition, finance, etc.
    • Personnel (unknown number) technically qualified and able to install all manner of hardware and systems for each aspect of the plan.
    • Materials procurement for multiple methods and sites. This to include explosives, wiring, detonators and all manner of related items
    • Transportation of workmen and materials (including housing and temporary storage)
    • Installation of materials and equipment at each site
  • Method(s) for masking and/or eliminating any and all physical evidence in case of discovery
  • Remote-control systems for four passenger jet aircraft
  • Real-time "voice morphing" equipment* and personnel for use during faked hijacking (not to mention advance script-writing for several not-yet-known passengers) (not to mention advance research on who each of those passengers might call in an emergency, along with their phone numbers)
  • Source of sufficient funds to pay for all materials as well as all manpower (including ongoing hush-money)
Security
  • "Official" cover story creation, with all aspects of back story, including 19 "terrorist" biographies and their recent histories, etc. all put in place within the relevant departments of the CIA and FBI
  • Secure communications from point of inception through culmination of the event(s) and into the post-event cleanup
  • Personnel placed at a high level within each team responsible for post-event analysis, including medical recovery and analysis, structural analysis, air traffic, etc.
  • Numerous contingency plans for each aspect of the plan at each site
  • Ongoing (to present day and beyond) cover-up
  • Post-event cleanup, including the destruction of all evidence of conspiracy
And on and on.

Such a thing would be, as I've said, one of the most complex undertakings of its kind in the history of man. Compare it to:
  • A small number of a group of enemies of the state with a demonstrated desire and willingness to engage in terrorist activity
  • Access to the open borders of a free society
  • An ability to recruit and train 19 or 20 soldiers and place them in the U.S.
  • Sufficient funds to support the 19 or 20 with rent, food, tuition, transportation, and miscellaneous small expenses during their limited time in the U.S.
  • Basic flight training for only a handful of the men
  • Limited need for communications once the plan is first initiated
  • Use of the element of surprise during the operation in order to take control
  • Simple, easy-to-conceal, though dangerous hand weapons to be used against unarmed opponents in close-quarters
  • Use of intimidation and fakery during the operation as well as the suggestion that cooperation will result in a safe outcome
  • Extreme ease of crashing each airplane into some portion of a heavily-populated area (be it a specific building or simply a city center), thereby achieving a result of a terrorized populace
  • No need for subsequent secrecy
Your “inside job,” by definition, would require the involvement of hundreds, if not thousands of people. None of who would be able to slip up or have a crisis of conscience for the rest of their lives. Never mind their master work, complex in and of itself, would have to reach its goals in broad daylight, in front of countless millions of people, live and around the world.

Any questions?
ZENSMACK89 said:
Jerome Hauers advice to the White House on 9-11. Jerome Hauers ex co-worker Steven Hatfill the one time Anthrax mailer prime suspect.
That's a cryptic response that in no way proves the anthrax scare was an inside job, much less links it to your alleged inside job 9/11 perps. Please start a new thread and we'll discuss the issue there.
Makes no sense to you? How ironic.
Spare me. The sentence is awkwardly composed, preventing me from ascertaining your meaning. Try again, if you like.



*There is no evidence proving that "voice morphing" tech, with the ability to make someone sound like someone else, exists.
 
Last edited:
We’re only talking about two building fires here. Which should have conducted the heat better Windsor or WTC?

The rate of heat transfer by conduction, all other things being equal, depends inversely on the distance the heat is transfered.

The WTC towers were much larger than the Windsor, and the fires in them were much larger. Therefore heat had much farther to travel to be conducted away from the fire areas. So the Windsor should have "conducted the heat better."

But conduction of heat from the fire zone via the steel framing is actually a trivial factor in fire dynamics, in any case. Assume a very hefty beam .1 square meter in cross section, and a portion of that beam one cubicle away from the boundary of the fire area (about 3m), heated by a fire to 800 degrees C above ambient. The rate of heat conduction to a point along the beam 3 meters away is:

Heat transfer rate (W) = delta T (degrees K) * conductivity (W/m-K) * area (m^2) / distance (m)

= 800 * 0.1 * 46 / 3
= 1250 Watts

How many Watts of heat does your blow dryer put out?

This is insiginficant in an uncontrolled fire, even allowing for all the beams intersecting the fire zone (most of which are much thinner than .1 square meter).

If the beam is thinner, or gets less hot, or doesn't heat evenly all the way through, or has farther to run to reach a cooler zone, or when the cooler zone itself starts heating up, the rate of heat transfer out of the fire zone decreases.

So, the assertion that "steel buildings don't collapse in fire because the steel conducts the heat" is not supported by the laws of physics.

Is this the best you have or are you going to bring up some bridges next?


Do steel bridges collapse as a result of fire?

How about steel oil platforms?

When a piece of steel is heated by fire, do its properties change differently if it's part of a bridge or part of an oil platform than if it's part of a building? (How does it know?)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Last edited:
Any "inside job" would require, at a minimum

Any "inside job" would require, at a minimum

Cherry picking and attempting to discredit different conspiracy theories doesn't prove or make the official conspiracy theory anymore credible nor does it negate the need for a real investigation into 9-11. This includes facts on "voice morphing" or anything else you seem to think proves the official version truthful somehow.
 
Oh look... The Government and the Administration have been assertin UBL behind 9-11 although there is no hard evidence to support this claim. Credibility lost. What else are they asserting with no hard evidence?

You mean, aside from his confession ?

NIST has a theory of collapse initiation not even supported by their own testing.

I think you've missed a bit.

Which should have conducted the heat better Windsor or WTC?

I'd wager the one with structural damage will have several problems going its way.

Dismissing CD doesn’t prove the NIST theory correct.

No, but proving the NIST theory correct does. AND it also dismisses CD.

But besides the NIST theory on the WTC how fast has it ever done it before and has it ever caused global collapse at the same time?

Irrelevant.

"Your honour. NO ONE has EVER been shot through the left nostril in the history of forensic pathology. Therefore the accusation's claim that the victim was shot through thr left nostril is patently RIDICULOUS! I rest my case."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom