Why I despise the Truthers

So your scientific poll has a sample size of 1 person. I'm impressed. In the general population, more than 1/100 is severely psychiatrically disturbed, which could account for any number of opinions on either side.

I am convinced that most truthers have all the repect in the world for the people of the NYPD, NYFD and PAPD. Personally, I am in awe.

There may be alternative interpretations of someone believing that WTC7 was pulled without implicating the NYPD, NYFD and PAPD. The FD could have agreed with Silverstein to let it burn out and not risk any more lives. Then Silverstein could have sent his boom boys to do the dirty work.

Not my personal belief, but not an uncommon truther suspicion.
No, you truthers are the most disrespectful people in the world. You make up false conclusion based on no facts and pass it along. You have signed up with others to push this agenda of ignorance.

Even more disturbing is so called engineers and scientist claiming the standard lies of 9/11 truth. Those people should have the ability to solve 9/11 with facts, but like you they pass on the lies of 9/11. Yes they are lies now that you persist without facts to support even one of your ideas on 9/11. At least you engineers who support 9/11 are only 0.00067 percent or less of all engineers. So I have to get over the facts a few idiots are in my profession, both of my professions.
 
What's my narrative? There's been no real complete investigation into 9-11 and anyone who thinks there shouldn't be further investigation is wrong.

That's not a narrative. That's not even decent criticism. Next.

GT'ers claim truthers are calling first responders murderers but it doesn't work the other way around when those same first responders talk of secondary explosions, molten metal, pressure to keep quiet, and anything else that doesn’t fit into the official version? Who's doing the twisting of words?

We've already covered this. The FRs made comments and the troothers twisted them. Repeating your claim is not a counterarguement. Next.

Whitman was appointed by Dubya as Administrator of the United States Environmental Protection Agency. But I'm mixing up two different reports? How's that?

There were two reports (at a minimum) issued from the EPA. One concerned the immediate section of ground zero and the other was for the immediate area. The one in ground zero stated some very well known problems and told people to wear their masks!

The other one, often cited by troofers, concerned the area around Ground Zero, where the EPA was much too optimistic about the air quality. They did this probably due to pressure from Bush, but also from the Wall Street folks and much of Manhattan wanting part of its city back. Either way, bad EPA.

But the EPA did warn workers at Ground Zero about the air quality they were facing and told them to wear their masks. Some say they should have put more pressure on the supervisors, but in either case the warnings were there.

But look at any photo of ground zero workers. You will see they are rarely wearing their masks. Very often, many of them have their masks off so they could smoke.

You tossed up this issueissue because you claimed that GZ workers were having problems. That is true. But you implied Bush told them it was OK via the EPA. That is where you are mixing up the EPA studies. In essence, what you end up doing is blaming Bush for not coming down the Ground Zero and shoving a mask on every worker.

As my friend put it, 'You'd think when they see that the EPA agent never takes his mask off while in the pit, they'd get the message no matter what anyone said'.

Its a tragedy, yes. Bush's fault? That's a stretch.

'Inevitable conclusion' only if you're short sighted. Which isn't hard to imagine.

Why does everyone necessarily have to be "in on it" in a CT theory? Was every single terrorist in al-Queda in on the hijackings with first hand knowledge according to the official Gov CT?

I have no idea what you are referencing here. You should learn to use the 'quote' feature. I doubt your response is anything effective, however.

I find the bare assertions and claims of some here hilarious. Got anything else?

Look who's talking.
 
GT'ers claim truthers are calling first responders murderers but it doesn't work the other way around when those same first responders talk of secondary explosions, molten metal, pressure to keep quiet, and anything else that doesn’t fit into the official version? Who's doing the twisting of words?

Let's check shall we?

secondary explosions

Loud explosion like sounds in a raging fire? nah, why would there be those, I mean itr's not like there could be everyday office and buildings things that might go boom in a fire, you know, aerosol cans, transformers, capacitors, fire-extinushers, steel plates and beams, even smoke itself. Show me were any Debuker has said that there were no explosion like sounds in the WTC towers? The only thing I have seen is the pointing out that explosion like sounds do not equal explosives. Next...

molten metal

Show me were any debunker has denied the presence of motel metal? Show me where any person has been able to prove the existance of molten Steel. Two totally different things here. Not all metal is steel. Molten Aluminium, Lead, Copper, Tin, Zinc, all of these are metals that become molten before Steel does. All of those could have been present in the WTC buildings, some in very large amounts. Next...

pressure to keep quiet

Evidence of this happening? Seems to me that the FR's have done a huge amount of discussing what they saw and did on that day. Who exactly is being told to keep quiet? Certainly not the FDYN, NYPD, or PAPD. What else do you have?
 
<snip>It was only in April when I started researching more into the truth movement to better understand what their "evidence" is. As most of you have come to the same conclusion as I have, they are full of [rule8].

Nice post. Nomination worthy, even. :)

But since I'm late to this thread, I will address only the latter parts of your post and the subsequent posts in this thread, as the early parts have already been addressed most eloquently by others.

The current anklebiters are just children with too much time on their hands and too little parental supervision, during their summer break from school.

It appears that, unlike most of their peers, the current crop of troofers do not have the advantages that most kids have, and they have defaulted into becoming tinhatters in order to "belong" somewhere - anywhere - and the twoof movement is the only place they were welcomed.

It is sad, really.

But it is also understandable how such vulnerable kids get sucked into cults such as the twoof movement.
 
Last edited:
I don't have a problem with the general notion that there could have been explosives planted in WTC buildings. The idea that they were actually prepared for explosive demolition is ludicrous, but the use of secondary devices to cause panic, impede evacuation, and harm first responders is a well-known terrorist tactic. [ AFAIK, there's no evidence for such secondary devices, but it wouldn't shock me if such evidence was uncovered. That would also mean there were other accomplices, still unaccounted-for. ]

As for truthers on record with claims about first responders, I've already mentioned one on apollohoax who claimed all the cops and firefighters at the Pentagon were in on it.
 
I don't have a problem with the general notion that there could have been explosives planted in WTC buildings. The idea that they were actually prepared for explosive demolition is ludicrous, but the use of secondary devices to cause panic, impede evacuation, and harm first responders is a well-known terrorist tactic. [ AFAIK, there's no evidence for such secondary devices, but it wouldn't shock me if such evidence was uncovered. That would also mean there were other accomplices, still unaccounted-for. ]

As for truthers on record with claims about first responders, I've already mentioned one on apollohoax who claimed all the cops and firefighters at the Pentagon were in on it.

Sts60:

What is your rationale, that allows you to accept the notion of PREPLANTED explosives in the WTCs? I can see an arguement to be made that explosive materials may have been stored in the building, but I would like to hear your explanation behind why you feel there might have been PREPLANTED explosives in the buildings, and their purpose there.

Thanks

TAM:)
 
Shame on you.

I rest my case on bare assertions with use of the word “NEXT” from some people. As if they can assert when a debate is over when they haven’t even responded with any legitimate points. The jump to protect Bush from any responsibility is really telling considering it was never implied in the first place. Who implied that Whitman and the EPA were two different things…. me?

Sts60 makes a very good point about secondary devices a known terrorist tactic. No one has ever wanted to investigate that though. Opening that can of worms will serve no one involved. Bombs are exactly what the building security was supposed to prevent after 93. I’m sure there were even security measures that had to be met to re-insure the buildings after 93. The plane only theory makes it no fault. This not only frees those involved with security of accountability but it also makes for an easier insurance payout which turned out not to be easy anyway even with the plane only theory.

I’m not experienced on JREF or any other forum for that matter. No I don’t know how to use the quote feature or many of the other features other then to post but I’ll figure it out when I have time. Besides I’m really responding to ALL GT’ist here. What’s the difference between any of you?

When Thomas Kean head of the 9-11 commission claims they were stonewalled, under funded, and the report they handed in was incomplete at best then how is that good enough for anyone?

When FEMA finds rapid corrosion of steel from the WTC caused by intense heat and calls it an unknown phenomenon that needs further investigation but no one ever performs that investigation how is that good enough for anyone?

When the NIST hands in a 20,000 page report on everything from Emergency response and evacuation procedures but stop short of the collapse itself only offering up a computer model theory of “collapse initiation” how is that an explanation?

Now for people here who have proclaimed to be the protectors of the first responders I’m curious to know did the FR’s know their job and were they experienced or not? What about the explosions they heard in the towers were different then hundreds of other fires they’ve been involved with before? How about a firefighter who claims the fire in the impact zone can be put out with two lines but then that fire triggers the entire building to fall down? Are you claiming he didn’t know what he was talking about? Did he not suspect the possibility of a collapse? Was the hero mistaken or worse yet lying?

Shame on you.
 
I am convinced that most truthers have absolutely NO concept that their allegations have any implications whatsoever. According to them, they are accusing 'The Government' of the deed.

To them it is a single, monolithic entity. The fact it is made up of individuals just like them is lost on them.

Truthers question the official story becauses it has so many things that don't add up. Yes there are some who think there was a big conspiracy involving the government. Some times innocent people are accused of crimes when the evidence is not clear. That does not in any way remove the responsibility of the government for investigating fully.

You paint a black and white picture of people who are all shades of gray. Most truthers, poppy-cock! We haven't even heard what most truthers think or believe, which was the point of my post.
 
ZENSMACK89, you seem to have a penchant for avoiding questions with rhetoric and more questions. I posted this previously, perhaps you missed it:

You seem incredulous to the idea that a CD theory, or any "inside job" theory for that matter, doesn't automatically imply the involvement of the NYPD, NYFD, and PAPD.

Please provide a detailed explanation how any inside job could have been pulled off without the involvement or knowledge (either before, during, or after the fact) of members of these three organizations.

I anxiously await your reply.

Edit: GregoryUrich, please feel free to respond as well.
 
Last edited:
When FEMA finds rapid corrosion of steel from the WTC caused by intense heat and calls it an unknown phenomenon that needs further investigation but no one ever performs that investigation how is that good enough for anyone?

Here are a few links to the results of the investigation that no one ever performed.

http://www.abmbrasil.com.br/cim/download/Vander_Voort.pps#256,1,Microstructural Analysis of Steel from the World Trade Center Buildings 7, & 1 or 2

http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=165759

http://www.me.wpi.edu/MTE/News/seminars3.html

Dave
 
Truthers question the official story becauses it has so many things that don't add up. Yes there are some who think there was a big conspiracy involving the government. Some times innocent people are accused of crimes when the evidence is not clear. That does not in any way remove the responsibility of the government for investigating fully.

You paint a black and white picture of people who are all shades of gray. Most truthers, poppy-cock! We haven't even heard what most truthers think or believe, which was the point of my post.

Well, perhaps I generalize, but frankly it can go both ways. Personally, I'm sick and tired of implications that we are all non-thinking US government drones because we don't think there is enough evidence for a 'new investigation'.

It is as if it is totally impossible for somebody to intelligently look at ALL the evidence and still think the 'official story', while not perfect, makes the most sense, and until a better theory comes along (hint: I don't consider CD a better theory) is 'the truth' as much as the truth can be known.
 
I never claimed first responder were murderers. That was put out on this post by a GT’ist as a straw man argument. It’s like you make up your own argument and then debate it. What good is it?

Just reading and listening to the eyewitness accounts the morning of 9-11 and then to see how those accounts stopped or changed later speaks volumes as to people being shut-up. Being told not to talk about something by people who hold your job and your pension in their hand is a powerful tool. I don’t think it’s unrealistic.

It also seems to be the claim that the reason CT’ist are calling first responders murderers is because the first responders would have had before hand knowledge of WTC7 if it was demoed. Did people die when WTC7 came down at around 5:00 pm on 9-11? Was there really murder in regards to WTC7?

Again these were not my claims.

Now how about answering some of my questions. How is any official version to date good enough for anyone? How does anyone who endorses incomplete investigations supporting the truth, the first responders, or the families of 9-11 victims?
 
The current anklebiters are just children with too much time on their hands and too little parental supervision, during their summer break from school.

It appears that, unlike most of their peers, the current crop of troofers do not have the advantages that most kids have, and they have defaulted into becoming tinhatters in order to "belong" somewhere - anywhere - and the twoof movement is the only place they were welcomed.

It is sad, really.

But it is also understandable how such vulnerable kids get sucked into cults such as the twoof movement.

It's creepy too. On the Loose Change forum one of the teens who regularly posts there mentioned that a "prominent truther" gave him his phone number and asked him to call. Thankfully, his parents wouldn't allow it.
 
Sts60:

What is your rationale, that allows you to accept the notion of PREPLANTED explosives in the WTCs? I can see an arguement to be made that explosive materials may have been stored in the building, but I would like to hear your explanation behind why you feel there might have been PREPLANTED explosives in the buildings, and their purpose there.

Thanks

TAM:)
Simply that the use of secondary explosives, timed or otherwise triggered to go off when first responders, evacuees, bystanders, and impromptu civilian rescuers are jamming the scene, is a well-known terrorist tactic. I find it plausible that terrorists might have added such devices to their planes-as-weapons plan. They would have a pretty large time window to set the devices off, since the evacuation and firefighting efforts would take a long time. They could have taken advantage of the chaos to bring such devices in after the impacts, thus avoiding normal building security.

I'm not sure on what you mean by "preplanted" vs. "stored". I sort of envision the former as a timed device, and the latter as a device left for someone else to come in later and use, but you'll have to clue me in on your meaning. Either way, though, I can imagine that explosives were somehow brought in before the event, if a good way to get them through security was found, or after the impacts as mentioned above. Terrorists smart enough to plan and execute the plane hijackings would have been smart enough to figure out an approximate impact time to use timers, or could have set them off directly. (Of course, the longer such devices were in place, the greater the possibility they would have been discovered ahead of time.)

Now, I accept this notion in the abstract. AFAIK, there is no good evidence for such devices, nor the extra terrorists that would have been involved. And there are lots of plausible explanations for other, non-bomb, sources of explosions and events that sounded like explosions. In the absence of any evidence for such bombs, I'm not claiming they exist. I'm merely pointing out they would be consistent with the terrorists' aims and tactics. I would also stress that such devices are antipersonnel in nature and have nothing to do with alleged "demolitions".
 
Just reading and listening to the eyewitness accounts the morning of 9-11 and then to see how those accounts stopped or changed later speaks volumes as to people being shut-up. Being told not to talk about something by people who hold your job and your pension in their hand is a powerful tool. I don’t think it’s unrealistic.

You are disgraceful. How dare you say that ANY employee of The City of New York would put his or her lousy pension ahead of the investigation of the murder of their co-workers, friends and/or loved ones.
 
Just reading and listening to the eyewitness accounts the morning of 9-11 and then to see how those accounts stopped or changed later speaks volumes as to people being shut-up. Being told not to talk about something by people who hold your job and your pension in their hand is a powerful tool. I don’t think it’s unrealistic.

First off, give some examples of eyewitness accounts changing in such a manner to make somebody suspect they were 'talked to', because I think that's BS. Also, it IS totally unrealistic to think that there is nobody who will risk their livelihood or even their lives to bring mass murderers to justice.

The world's history is FULL of people who have done just that. How many mob witnesses have come forward even though they are target number 1? And this isn't a Mafia Don we are talking about. This is murder on a massive scale by ones own government.

At the very least it is simply a cynical outlook, at worst you are insulting a whole lot of people.
 
You are disgraceful. How dare you say that ANY employee of The City of New York would put his or her lousy pension ahead of the investigation of the murder of their co-workers, friends and/or loved ones.
Not just "any," but EVERY ONE of them except for the scattered very few who can offer nothing more than their opinion on what they think might have happened.
 
I never claimed first responder were murderers. That was put out on this post by a GT’ist as a straw man argument. It’s like you make up your own argument and then debate it. What good is it?

Just reading and listening to the eyewitness accounts the morning of 9-11 and then to see how those accounts stopped or changed later speaks volumes as to people being shut-up. Being told not to talk about something by people who hold your job and your pension in their hand is a powerful tool. I don’t think it’s unrealistic.

It also seems to be the claim that the reason CT’ist are calling first responders murderers is because the first responders would have had before hand knowledge of WTC7 if it was demoed. Did people die when WTC7 came down at around 5:00 pm on 9-11? Was there really murder in regards to WTC7?

Again these were not my claims.

Now how about answering some of my questions. How is any official version to date good enough for anyone? How does anyone who endorses incomplete investigations supporting the truth, the first responders, or the families of 9-11 victims?

I don't think you're thinking this through. We're saying no controlled demolition theory makes sense unless there is compliance from the first responders. For instance, who put all the plane wreackage and dna evidence at the pentagon? Who put the dna evidence at the WTC and flight 93 crash site? How did none of the first responders (NYPD, NYFD, ect.) notice?

And you seem to be saying that they were in on WTC7 but since no one died in WTC7, no one is calling them murderers. But how can you be "in on" WTC7 and not the rest? or at least not be suspicious of the rest? Conspiracy theorists always say if WTC was controlled demo, then WTC1&2 must have also, so doesn't it follow if NYFD and PD were in on WTC7, they were in on WTC1&2?

We're asking conspiracy theorists to explain how FD was no in on it, given their claims. Especially how Alex Jones have called them murderers and liars as pointed out here with direct links.
 
Well then… So now people who think there should be a real investigation into 9-11 think that first responders are murderers?

Accessories, at best.

I guess I can make the claim that the reason I hate GT’ers is because they claim there were no explosions, molten metal, or gag orders, thus labeling first responders who claim these things liars.

There's simply no evidence for those.

How dare those CT'ers

Indeed, how dare ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom