Why I despise the Truthers

The truther dogma, by definition, has to involve complicity of the FDNY, PAPD, and NYPD, whether it be extensive, at all ranks, or simply the higher ups. In order for the CD theory to work, At least someone within each of those institutions had to be "in the know".

TAM:)
 
Wrong. He did not call them murderers, he said they were paid to keep silent. He later retracted it.

Yeah, some retraction:

http://loosechange911.blogspot.com/2006/12/message-from-jason-bermas.html

I hold them as heroes in the highest regard, and I truly believe that they were threatened in the aftermath of the event that not only traumatized a country, but still affect their lives deeply to this very day. Many of these men have families, and would do anything to keep them safe. I also believe many of them do not, and can not think the worst of their country. I know it was very difficult for me.

Including cover up the murder of their comrades, eh Bermas? All Bermas did was change 'payoff' to 'threats' to make himself look better. The FDNY are still covering up things in his book.
 
Incidently, it took Bermas three months to issue that 'retraction'. He thought everything was hunky-dory up until then.

Then, when a debate where this comment might loom over him cmoes up, he decides that he didn't mean what he said on a video his group put up and makes a lame 'apology', blaming 'jedi tricks' for expressing what he really thinks.
 
Not directly, no. That's not what troofers do. They never accuse anyone specific except the most public of targets (President and V.P). Everyone else is merely 'in on it' to some unspecified level, or is 'covering up', or some other nonsense. Its carefully chosen weasel-wording.

Take for example, WTC7. I've been told straight up by troofers that WTC7 is the keystone for ther arguements. If WTC7 can be proven to be done by CD, then by extension we have to suspect the collapses of WTC1 & 2*. Troofers then give me their (false) arguements as to why WTC7 'had to be' done by CD: The fires were small, a team of demolition ninjas could have gotten in, the damage wasn't too bad.

Over and over the counterarguements to these claims are the comments from firefighters. Dozens of them saying that WTC7 did not have small fires but was blazing away. It was not 'slightly damaged', it had a huge hole in its side. A team of demolitionists would have to sneak past the firefighters and other officials to get into the burning WTC7 to plant their charges (!).In addition, there are videos and written accounts of regular firefighters saying that WTC7 was going to be coming down.

The troofer reaction to this? Its usually avoidance and a return to 'It looks like CD!! WAAH!' or some kind of handwaving saying that the firefighters were wrong. One or two accounts of the fire I could see possibly wrong or overstated, but all of them?

These accounts should at least turn people away from their claims about WTC7, but they keep on making them!

So, how do they rationalize that? The only way a mind can 'rationalize' these contradicitons is to say that the Firefighters are all completely wrong and are willing to remain wrong, or they were all paid off in some fashion.

And if the firefighters were willing to lie about WTC7, by extension they have been lying about 1 & 2. Where many of their comrades died. That means that the firefighters, at a minimum, were willing to lie to cover up the deaths of their comrades. That is aiding and abetting murder.

Even if the troofers never outright say it, they are accusing the officials of murder. No matter who tries to 'shell game', that is the way things are in the troof movement.

And that sucks.













* The exception to this is P'doh's extremely lame and inexplicable 'Noble demolition theory, where the Firefighers quickly rigged the building for demolition to get it out of the way so they could search for their comrades. In addition to a complete lack of evidence, this idea requires that for some reason, the firefighters then decided they weren't going to tell anyone what they were doing.

Touche. That sums it up perfectly.

Btw, I had never heard that particular loon theory of P'duh's before. Why does it not surprise me?
 
2 problems:

Building 7 had no people die in the collapse so it doesn't involve murder.



First Degree Felony Murder - A killing that happens during the course of the commission of a felony, even if the death is accidental, will be considered "felony murder" by most states. However, if the killing happens during certain felonies, again determined by state, it will be considered "first degree felony murder". The felonies most often included in this category are arson, robbery, burglary, rape, mayhem and kidnapping.



They would have been involved in a conspiracy that caused the deaths of thousands in WTC1 and 2, even if they were not directly responsible for those deaths. That's exactly the sort of thing "Felony Murder" was intended for.

Therefore, if any members of the FDNY had any knowing role in causing, or covering up, the events of 9/11, they would be guilty of felony murder.

Denying the obvious consequences of your pet theories is disingeneous at best. At least have the guts to stand up for what you allegedly believe in.
 
How dare those CT'ers

Well then… So now people who think there should be a real investigation into 9-11 think that first responders are murderers? Where is there evidence that this is a general consensus among anyone? Would these people include the first responders themselves who claim explosions, molten metal, and pressure to keep their mouths shut?

I guess I can make the claim that the reason I hate GT’ers is because they claim there were no explosions, molten metal, or gag orders, thus labeling first responders who claim these things liars.

Should we have an investigation into what’s causing the sickness that’s killing many of them or is that just a CT also? How about the fact that the EPA and Whitman claimed the air was safe to breath? I guess that’s just a CT also?

How dare those CT'ers
 
Now? This has been the consensus among many Twoofers. I see you still don't read anything that has been previously posted, maybe you should read the links that have been posted previously in this thread. Where Alex Jones and others have claimed that they are involved with a cover up and are guilty of at least manslaughter.
 
Well then… So now people who think there should be a real investigation into 9-11 think that first responders are murderers? Where is there evidence that this is a general consensus among anyone? Would these people include the first responders themselves who claim explosions, molten metal, and pressure to keep their mouths shut?

OK, let's hear your narrative - outline a fully self-consistent scenario in which 9/11 was an inside job, WTC1 and 2 were brought down by explosives, and the PAPD, NYPD and FDNY are not at least accessories after the fact.

Dave
 
Well then… So now people who think there should be a real investigation into 9-11 think that first responders are murderers? Where is there evidence that this is a general consensus among anyone? Would these people include the first responders themselves who claim explosions, molten metal, and pressure to keep their mouths shut?

I guess I can make the claim that the reason I hate GT’ers is because they claim there were no explosions, molten metal, or gag orders, thus labeling first responders who claim these things liars.

Should we have an investigation into what’s causing the sickness that’s killing many of them or is that just a CT also? How about the fact that the EPA and Whitman claimed the air was safe to breath? I guess that’s just a CT also?

How dare those CT'ers


Glad you could make it here Zen.

"I guess I can make the claim that the reason I hate GT’ers is because they claim there were no explosions, molten metal, or gag orders, thus labeling first responders who claim these things liars."

There's no evidence to support what you just said. So what you said to me on YouTube is in fact true when I asked you if you were calling the FDNY, NYPD & PAP liars.
 
Well then… So now people who think there should be a real investigation into 9-11 think that first responders are murderers? Where is there evidence that this is a general consensus among anyone? Would these people include the first responders themselves who claim explosions, molten metal, and pressure to keep their mouths shut?

I guess I can make the claim that the reason I hate GT’ers is because they claim there were no explosions, molten metal, or gag orders, thus labeling first responders who claim these things liars.

Should we have an investigation into what’s causing the sickness that’s killing many of them or is that just a CT also? How about the fact that the EPA and Whitman claimed the air was safe to breath? I guess that’s just a CT also?

How dare those CT'ers


So much silliness, so little time.

Of course not every truther believes this, but several have stated, and many many more have implied it. Plus, if you understand who would have to been knowledgable of the "coverup" and allowed it, for the truther allegations to be true, than you realize most truthers imply, through their theories that some people at some level, within all of the NYFD, NYPD, and PAPD had to be involved.

Explosions....sure, please do a youtube search on "transformer explosions" and "aeresol explosions" and "Oxygen canister explosions" for examples of non-explosives that go "boom".

Molten metal - yes a rescuer said they saw molten metal. I would be amazed if some molten aluminum wasnt seen, or even molten copper...

Pressure to keep quiet...please show a source or I will assume this is a baseless lie.

I do not say gag orders didnt exist, I say I have had noone present me with solid proof in the form of written statements of such.

I have just stated a rescuer saw MOLTEN METAL.

I have no doubt that many, many people heard explosions...but not a single bit of evidence of EXPLOSIVES!!!!

Take your air quality stuff elsewhere, as noone here has claimed that the air quality issue is a CT, and this is a CT subforum. Nice try though.

TAM:)
 
I guess I can make the claim that the reason I hate GT’ers is because they claim there were no explosions, molten metal, or gag orders, thus labeling first responders who claim these things liars.

Who's claiming the bit I highlighted?
 
Well then… So now people who think there should be a real investigation into 9-11 think that first responders are murderers? Where is there evidence that this is a general consensus among anyone?

Consensus? Try 'inevitable conclusion'. The most basic of claims by MIHOP CTers require complicity by most of the agencies mentioned here.

Would these people include the first responders themselves who claim explosions, molten metal, and pressure to keep their mouths shut?

I would say they are not lying, but that the CTers have twisted their words beyond the breaking point in order to 'make a case'.

I guess I can make the claim that the reason I hate GT’ers is because they claim there were no explosions, molten metal, or gag orders, thus labeling first responders who claim these things liars.

See above. When a firefighter says there were explosions, that does not mean 'bombs', when someone on the cleanup crew says 'molten metal' that does not mean 'molten steel'. As for the gag order, that is a lie, but not one I have heard from first responders.

Should we have an investigation into what’s causing the sickness that’s killing many of them or is that just a CT also?

Nothing CT about it. Sadly, most of the responders did not wear their masks as they should have. An investigation would tell us little more than we already know.

Read my post here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2434862&postcount=77

How about the fact that the EPA and Whitman claimed the air was safe to breath? I guess that’s just a CT also?

You are mixing two reports. No surprise.

How dare those CT'ers

Yes, they are quite scummy.
 
It's not a matter of specific examples. There's simply no way that any of the CTs about 9/11 could possibly hold an ounce of water without at least implied complicity either before the demolition, during the critical time period after the blast, or both.

No one has to say "the firemen were involved" when they present boatloads of "evidence" that even in their loopy heads couldn't be possible without law enforcement being accessories to the crime.
 
Easiest thing to throw at them, when they claim WTC7 is demolition, is really Daniel Nigro. It's actually good to keep it very simple.

If they claim he was lying, they would have someone to blame. This person, Chief of Operations FDNY would be lying. But they never say he is lying, they don't dare. They always say, he didn't lie.

Well, if he didn't lie, here is the main point of what he said:

"the collapse had damaged 7 World Trade Center, which is about a 50 story building, at Vesey between West Broadway and Washington Street. It had very heavy fire on many floors and I ordered the evacuation of an area sufficient around to protect our members"

They say Nigro didn't lie, so this statement of his must be true. 7 had been damaged by the collapse, it had very heavy fires on many floors, and evacuation was ordered by HIM. This means pull it is not demolition and demolition didn't happen. Try to get them speak their way though that maze. They never can.

 
Jason Bermas has stated as much. On camera.

So your scientific poll has a sample size of 1 person. I'm impressed. In the general population, more than 1/100 is severely psychiatrically disturbed, which could account for any number of opinions on either side.

I am convinced that most truthers have all the repect in the world for the people of the NYPD, NYFD and PAPD. Personally, I am in awe.

There may be alternative interpretations of someone believing that WTC7 was pulled without implicating the NYPD, NYFD and PAPD. The FD could have agreed with Silverstein to let it burn out and not risk any more lives. Then Silverstein could have sent his boom boys to do the dirty work.

Not my personal belief, but not an uncommon truther suspicion.
 
I am convinced that most truthers have all the repect in the world for the people of the NYPD, NYFD and PAPD. Personally, I am in awe.
They might, but there's simply no conspiracy theory which rectifies that respect with their interpretation of the events of 9/11. Even if that's not the case on the surface, at some point in any theory they had to either be complicit beforehand or willfully ignorant of evidence in front of their faces once they became involved.

As you mentioned, there COULD be a theory that involves them not further risking their own lives. But since that isn't a part of the official story, even then they'd all have to be operating under a code of silence that keeps those orders from becoming public knowledge. Hence, they're still liars who are covering things up for their NWO puppetmasters.
 
The FD could have agreed with Silverstein to let it burn out and not risk any more lives. Then Silverstein could have sent his boom boys to do the dirty work.

So the NYFD is part of a failed insurance scandal now?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom