Why I despise the Truthers

I'll never understand why an inside job theory would have to include first responders in on it. Especially on WTC7. I mean we are talking about a building that housed the offices for the FBI, CIA, NSA, and Giuliani.

Like I said you can go through every first responder who heard explosions or first instinct was secondary devices and wave your hand and explain them away. So what?

Someone here asked me to show where someone has changed their story. Thanks for posting just that kook. Wasn't Paul Issac the one who claimed gag order also? Are you cherry picking his statements and throwing out the rest?

How about this change of story from an explosives expert that I’m also sure has been dismissed here long ago.

The collapse of the buildings appears "too methodical" to be a chance result of airplanes colliding with the structures, said Van Romero, vice president for research at New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology. "My opinion is, based on the videotapes, that after the airplanes hit the World Trade Center there were some explosive devices inside the buildings that caused the towers to collapse," Romero said.

Then a few days later without any further investigation...

"Certainly the fire is what caused the building to fail," said Van Romero, a vice president at the New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology.

Then a little while later..

WASHINGTON -- U.S. Senator Pete Domenici today reported that Van Romero of Socorro has been appointed by President Bush to serve on a White House commission aimed at closing the educational achievement gap for Hispanic American youth.

There has been no real investigation. All versions are theory at this point. The official conspiracy theory of 19 hijackers is one of the wackiest of all.



Yeah, and how inconvenient is it to your fantasy that those wacky jihadists are so maddeningly proud of their accomplishment? If only they'd stop bragging and making new threats, you liars could do a decent job of conning the suckers.

You're not telling the truth about the "official" theory, as you know. It doesn't exist--just like your imaginary conspiracy.
 
I'll never understand why an inside job theory would have to include first responders in on it..

I'll try to explain this in simple terms:

You cannot have a building demolition without leaving evidence.

These are examples, these are things that cannot be hidden:

1) Demolition explosions are very, very, very loud. Such charges would be heard blocks and blocks away. Which means that first responders as well as much of lower Manhatten would need to be 'in on it'.

2) Columns cut by charges have very distinct marks. They look nothing like cuts made by blowtorches. That means the crews on the scene were overlooking these marks rather conveniently, IF THEY WERE THERE.

3) Demolition is done with detcord. Despite silly and naive clams that it could be done with 'remote control' the simple fact is that there would have needed to be miles of detcord. This cord can be found everywhere on a small demolition site. Yet somehow the responders managed to overlook it IF IT WERE THERE!

4) Demolition charges are not like you see in the movies. You do not roll a Soda Machine or Van filled with explosives into a building and have it come down unless you are very lucky and the building has weak points, such as critical columns (like at the OK City bombing) which the Towers did not have. Properly done demolition charges have copper metal bands (which get burned into a interesting purplish color) as well as carpet and plywood. These remnants can be found all over even a small CD site. Yet somehow the responders managed to overlook it IF IT WERE THERE!

You can't hide this stuff. It would be there. Period. The firefighters and other city workers were first on the scene and nobody would have had a chance to scoop the evidence up. They would have seen it.

The only conclusions? 1) There was no demolition. or 2) there was demolition and the firefighters actively covered it up, despite the demoltion killing many of their brothers in arms.

Troofers invariably conclude that it was demoltion, which leads to the firefighters (and others) covering up the evidence, even if they are not saying it. Hence the reason that Bermas and other troofers try to 'rationalize' by saying they firefighers took payments or are too scared for their pensions to come forward.

The only way troofers have found around these two conclusions is to invent something very silly. The thermate/thermite arguements are one of the bigger moments in troofer silliness attempting to get around the above conclusions.

Don't like it? Then stop saying the towers were brought down with bombs. You are effectively claiming the firefighters are corrupt or are cowards when you say that, even if you don't say it out loud.
 
I'll never understand why an inside job theory would have to include first responders in on it.

Please then explain how an "inside job" could have been pulled off without at least the complicity of the Port Authority Police Department?

Wasn't Paul Issac the one who claimed gag order also?

Who would have been issuing this supposed gag order? Paul Issac was never a member of the FDNY. Use the search feature and you'll find the thread on him.
 
How about this change of story from an explosives expert that I’m also sure has been dismissed here long ago.

The collapse of the buildings appears "too methodical" to be a chance result of airplanes colliding with the structures, said Van Romero, vice president for research at New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology. "My opinion is, based on the videotapes, that after the airplanes hit the World Trade Center there were some explosive devices inside the buildings that caused the towers to collapse," Romero said.

Then a few days later without any further investigation...

"Certainly the fire is what caused the building to fail," said Van Romero, a vice president at the New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology.


We have gone through Van Romero before on YouTube.


As I explained to you before, he first believed that it was brought down by CD, which was only presented to him in video form. He did further investigation (which is still a strange concept to the googlevideologists)


Here is part of the second Albuquerque Journal article.
"Subsequent conversations with structural engineers and more detailed looks at the tape have led Romero to a different conclusion.
Romero supports other experts, who have said the intense heat of the jet fuel fires weakened the skyscrapers' steel structural beams to the point that they gave way under the weight of the floors above. That set off a chain reaction, as upper floors pancaked onto lower ones."


I know what you are going to say next....but he was appointed to a government position.

So here is my response to that, HE IS THE MOST QUALIFIED PERSON FOR THE JOB!

Here is his Qualifications
 
You can't hide this stuff. It would be there. Period. The firefighters and other city workers were first on the scene and nobody would have had a chance to scoop the evidence up. They would have seen it.

And that's after the fact. Just how did all these explosives and det cord get into the buildings in the first place? The Port Authority Police Department would have to have known.
 
LMAO

Boy oh boy, you guys are too precious.

Let me ask it again.

Can somebody go through the testimonies in the following video, and state why you think they are false, since this is what you all believe.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2179339594842383954&q=wtc7+smoking+gun

In particular, with reference to Singh, Mcpadden, and the 3 1st responders saying ~"we got a building about to be blown up"

Did I not say before, "Get ready for silence"? You dudes are like clockwork mice!
 
LMAO

Boy oh boy, you guys are too precious.

Let me ask it again.

Can somebody go through the testimonies in the following video, and state why you think they are false, since this is what you all believe.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2179339594842383954&q=wtc7+smoking+gun

In particular, with reference to Singh, Mcpadden, and the 3 1st responders saying ~"we got a building about to be blown up"

Did I not say before, "Get ready for silence"? You dudes are like clockwork mice!

Posts 109 and 110. You're welcome.
 
Yeah that makes sense.

Yeah I've heard all about how many teams of people it would have taken for how many months with miles of detonator cord to take down the buildings the way it did but then in the next sentence I'm told an airplane did it in less then an hour all on its own.

Yeah that makes sense.

Why can an airplane do it all on it's own but an airplane coupled with explosive devices is impossible? Is it not a known terrorist tactic to wait until emergency responders show up to set off another device? We are talking about a place that was the target of a car bomb before but now that’s impossible and not worthy of investigation.

Yeah ok.
 
How about this change of story from an explosives expert that I’m also sure has been dismissed here long ago.

The collapse of the buildings appears "too methodical" to be a chance result of airplanes colliding with the structures, said Van Romero, vice president for research at New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology. "My opinion is, based on the videotapes, that after the airplanes hit the World Trade Center there were some explosive devices inside the buildings that caused the towers to collapse," Romero said.

Then a few days later without any further investigation...

First, Van Romero was NOT an explosives expert ... at least not the sort of expert qualified to say by looking that the buildings were brought down via CD. Here's his resume. http://infohost.nmt.edu/~red/van.html Study it and you will learn that at the time of 9/11 he wasn't even working in the field of explosives. You will learn that for only 2 or 3 years he ran a group that focused on ordnance, explosives and energetic materials ... and not so much the effects of them on structures but the characteristics of the explosives themselves. Certainly there is no mention of him or any organization he belong to working on explosive demolition of structures or buildings. And you will learn that prior to 1995, he conducted Environmental Impact Assessments, implemented radiation protection policies and investigated thermodynamic limits for the nuclear reactors. That's hardly the resume of the explosives, demolition and structures *expert* that the bombs-did-it CT community makes him out to have.

Second, Romero stated quite clearly why he retracted his first impression that the destruction was a demolition. He said he changed his story after looking at more detailed videos and the rest of the information that was gathered. So your claim that he changed his story without further investigation is false.
 
Why can an airplane do it all on it's own but an airplane coupled with explosive devices is impossible? Is it not a known terrorist tactic to wait until emergency responders show up to set off another device? We are talking about a place that was the target of a car bomb before but now that’s impossible and not worthy of investigation.

Yeah ok.

Several things wrong here, and an example of how you guys don't think things through.

1) Any bomb in the plane would have to be brought on board the plane. This is a massive risk for the terrorists with very little reward. It was easy to bring knives on boards, much harder to bring a bomb (not that this stopped some of the terrorists from claiming there was a bomb).

2) Any such bomb would be pretty small. You can't really pack that much into a suitcase.

3) Said bomb would need to survive the impact. A very unlikely case.

4) In order for a secondary device to be effective as a terrorist weapon, it must be timed so that it explodes when the crews arrive. (As an aside, are there instances of Islamic terrorists using secondary bombs prior to 2001? I know that some X-tian abortion bombers used the tactic, but that's it). This involves timing that is very speculative.

5) Assuming said bomb surivived the impact in point 3, it would then need to surivive the fire. Most explosives don't like heat, but they rarely explode. Any timing mechanism would be subject to the fore as well. A heat based detonator could be used, but what is the point?

6) Any such secondary device would do nothing to the structure of the building beyond cosmetic damage in an area already devastated by plane impact. Meaning if it survived it would be detonating in an area already cleared by the fire an do nothing important, structurally speaking.
 
Posts 109 and 110. You're welcome.
Apparently you're not familiar with the Twoofer mindset. "Addressing these issues" does not mean "responding to the things you were asked." It means jumping to a completely unrelated topic and using that to prove your earlier point.

Please try to keep up in the future. ;)
 
Not the least bit likely. The fire department was right on the scene. Standard opoerating procedure is not to let anyone return to a building once the fire has started. You get out, you stay out. They can't have untrained civilians getting in their way. In an emergency situation, a trained responder is looking for additional threats to his well-being. Certainly, someone carrying a box or rucksack full of something into a burning building is going top trip a few alarms.
Eh, I partially disagree. Yes, SOP is to gain control of the scene - in my jurisdiction, the 5th-due engine company is assigned to lobby control on high-rises - but FDNY wasn't there instantly after the 1st plane struck, which would have left a little time when security attention at both buildings would have been diverted to some degree. And even after the first firefighters started responding, the lobbies would have been pretty chaotic with people milling around. The ability to effect assess for such threats is going to be compromised in such a situation, especially given the novel situation - which was initally presumed to be an accident for the first strike.

But in any case, my whole secondary bomb scenario is just a thought exercise. I don't know really know how easy it would have been to get bombs into those buildings either before or immediately after the impacts; I'm just looking for conceivable ways it could have been done. And again, there is no evidence for any of it (unless you count explosion-like sounds recalled by some people, which has many non-bomb interpretations).

ZENSMACK89 said:
Why can an airplane do it all on it's own but an airplane coupled with explosive devices is impossible? Is it not a known terrorist tactic to wait until emergency responders show up to set off another device? We are talking about a place that was the target of a car bomb before but now that’s impossible and not worthy of investigation.
Two different scenarios. What I'm talking about is an antipersonnel tactic designed to cause injury and panic, not a charge designed to somehow work in concert with an impact to actually destroy the building.

And, again, AFAIK there is no evidence for either.
 
Several things wrong here, and an example of how you guys don't think things through.

1) Any bomb in the plane would have to be brought on board the plane. This is a massive risk for the terrorists with very little reward. It was easy to bring knives on boards, much harder to bring a bomb (not that this stopped some of the terrorists from claiming there was a bomb).

2) Any such bomb would be pretty small. You can't really pack that much into a suitcase.

3) Said bomb would need to survive the impact. A very unlikely case....
Eh, I don't think ZENSMACK89 meant a bomb on the airplane. I think he meant one brought in some other way. Yes, using a timer would be iffy, but hypothetically such a device could simply be detonated at the right time by yet another suicidal terrorist.
 
Truthers question the official story becauses it has so many things that don't add up.
No, truther question the official story because they think it doesn't add up. Important difference.

In reality, the assertion that things don't add up is either not substantiated by the actual evidence or is inconsequential to the events of the day.
 
Did I say a bomb on the plane?

Did I say a bomb on the plane? Wow YOU really thought that one through.

And why would the bomb have to be in the impact zone? Didn't the plane take care of the impact zone?

Ok real slow now.

How about a plane crash into the towers and then a little later an explosive device somewhere else in the building, like lower down?

Oh yeah…

How much detonator cord, teams of experts, and months of access to the building were needed in Oklahoma City? The bomb in OK city wasn't even IN the building. It did a pretty good job though didn’t it? Just imagine one of those bombs in the WTC parking garage or in an out of service elevator. How long would it take to set that up? How many teams of people? How much detonator cord? It could be done by a delivery guy who doesn’t even know what’s in the box or the van.

I’m not saying that’s what happened I’m just saying teams of people and detonator cord aren’t the only way to go.
 
Truck Bomb? Wasn't already done before and failed?

Did you forget about the security in the Loading Docks and Parking Garage? That still implicates the Security Guards and the PAPD to allow that to enter the building.
 
Did I say a bomb on the plane? Wow YOU really thought that one through.

And why would the bomb have to be in the impact zone? Didn't the plane take care of the impact zone?

Ok real slow now.

How about a plane crash into the towers and then a little later an explosive device somewhere else in the building, like lower down?


Let's go much slower. How about a plane crash and then a collapse from the impact zone?

How about ABSOLUTELY NO--ZERO--EVIDENCE OF EXPLOSIONS LOWER THAN THE IMPACT ZONE?


Oh yeah…

How much detonator cord, teams of experts, and months of access to the building were needed in Oklahoma City? The bomb in OK city wasn't even IN the building. It did a pretty good job though didn’t it? Just imagine one of those bombs in the WTC parking garage or in an out of service elevator. How long would it take to set that up? How many teams of people? How much detonator cord? It could be done by a delivery guy who doesn’t even know what’s in the box or the van.

I’m not saying that’s what happened I’m just saying teams of people and detonator cord aren’t the only way to go.


You haven't the faintest idea of what you're talking about. Could you ask someone to read Brent Blanchard's Protec paper to you?
 
Eh, I don't think ZENSMACK89 meant a bomb on the airplane. I think he meant one brought in some other way. Yes, using a timer would be iffy, but hypothetically such a device could simply be detonated at the right time by yet another suicidal terrorist.

OK, I see what you mean, but again you have expanded the plan to add more terrorists and that means more things that can go wrong. Again, its added risk with little reward.

I mean, you would have to get the bomb into the building before the planes arrived (you couldn't really time this and if you were late, you were not getting into that area with anything more than a backpack.

Let's assume you managed to get the bomb inside somehow. What if the airplane crews had to abort for that day for some reason? Now you've got to get to bomb out, because if you set it off there's a good chance you spoil the plan for the flight crews.

Sorry, I still don't see enough risk/reward ratio being high enough to add this in.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom