Why I despise the Truthers

What's my narrative? There's been no real complete investigation into 9-11 that agrees with me

Corrected that for you.


What the hell's a GT'er ?

'Inevitable conclusion' only if you're short sighted. Which isn't hard to imagine.

Sweet. Insults are arguments.

Why does everyone necessarily have to be "in on it" in a CT theory?

Think about it. Really.

Was every single terrorist in al-Queda in on the hijackings with first hand knowledge according to the official Gov CT?

Not every single terrorist in al-Quaeda needed that information in order for the attacks to occur.
 
The jump to protect Bush from any responsibility is really telling considering it was never implied in the first place.

Protect ? Why is the world so black and white to you ?

Sts60 makes a very good point about secondary devices a known terrorist tactic. No one has ever wanted to investigate that though.

Might have something to do with the fact that there were no explosions.

The plane only theory makes it no fault.

Why would terrorists place explosives in 7 WTC ? They were aiming for 1 and 2.

Besides I’m really responding to ALL GT’ist here. What’s the difference between any of you?

Again, the truther is simplifying reality in order to wrap his brain around it. Typical.

Again these were not my claims.

Well, isn't that convenient ? You're "just asking questions", right ?
 
You are disgraceful. How dare you say that ANY employee of The City of New York would put his or her lousy pension ahead of the investigation of the murder of their co-workers, friends and/or loved ones.

Agreed


This whole following orders as Alt+F4 has posted before is a bunch of ****. Its about the love of the job, not the money...not the pension.


Side Note:
There are better words than lousy to describe the pension...but it works for now :D
 
I make a point of reminding various loons that theirs is an "evil" movement. The sheer rock-headed stupidity is the first twoofer characteristic most observers notice, but all the irrationality and dishonesty is in the service of pure evil.
Sorry, how do I get that dog laughing emoticon?
 
Don’t be despicable

I never even implied First Responders were murderers that was the job of the person who put up this thread. I also didn’t imply they were inexperienced or stupid for not wearing their masks at ground zero or not realizing the buildings might collapse from structural damage to a few floors and pockets of fire. This is all done by Government Theory holders who seem to know better then everyone on everything by simply asserting that they know better. I also never claimed that NO ONE has come forward. There just seems to be some GT excuse for every account that doesn’t support the official version.

Here are a few emergency responders who spoke of explosions at least once. Although I’m sure they've all been covered before. Now you great defenders of the First Responder can tell me how they are lying, inexperienced and mistaken, or have since changed their story.

Craig Bartmer
Paul Isaac Jr
Louie Cacchioli
Albert Turi
Frank Cruthers
Karin Deshore
Brian Dixon
Neil Sweeting

Now careful how you respond about 9-11 hero’s. That is what this thread is supposed to be about… right? You wouldn’t want anyone to despise you now.
 
Just on the point of "twisting" (or ignoring) testimony, wondered if any OTers would like to comment on the 6/7 testimonies in this vid?

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2179339594842383954&q=wtc7+smoking+gun

Get ready for silence...

There was one who claimed "I know an explosion when I hear it" but who didn't actually see it either. And one woman who thought she might have heard something about the buildings being "brought" down. Then lots of old canards like the out-of-context Silverstein quote. Oh and the Russian guy on TV who at first didn't know it was about 9/11 and thus wasn't aware that the building was badly damaged by debris from the Twin Towers.

So... all you have are carefully hand-selected quotes of witnesses and experts which are utterly vague and are contradicted by the statements of myriads of other witnesses and experts. And that's assuming the video didn't deliberately misconstrue their statements. Oh, and the argument from incredulity, false claims and inappropriate music thrown in for good measure. Good luck with your revolution.
 
Just on the point of "twisting" (or ignoring) testimony, wondered if any OTers would like to comment on the 6/7 testimonies in this vid?

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2179339594842383954&q=wtc7+smoking+gun

Get ready for silence...


The above shows just how deluded you are about people who don't subscribe to your interpretation of The TruthTM mjd.

Bartmer's story has already been dealt with in the following thread and elsewhere:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=67361
 
Now careful how you respond about 9-11 hero’s. That is what this thread is supposed to be about… right? You wouldn’t want anyone to despise you now.

There are probably 10 times, or more, as many people who reported hearing NO explosions at all. Real investigators understand that not all witnesses remember things properly, some forget, some were stressed out, in ANY investigation of a large event with many witnesses there are ALWAYS a minority of witnesses who misinterpret what they hear or see, or frankly just remember it wrong.

I repeat. Real investigators understand that. Real investigators use the preponderance of eye witness accounts coupled with corroborating physical evidence if possible to come to a conclusion.

That's not calling people liars. It's conducting a through and professional investigation.

Since the preponderance of physical evidence and eye witness accounts actually support the official story, the only way to reconcile that if you are a conspiracy theorist is to imply that the evidence is planted, or the witnesses are lying. At the very least the witnesses have to be discredited.

We need do no such thing; it's normal, and expected as a matter of fact, to have a small amount of conflicting eye witnesses testimony.

It's two different ways to conduct an investigation.
 
Simply that the use of secondary explosives, timed or otherwise triggered to go off when first responders, evacuees, bystanders, and impromptu civilian rescuers are jamming the scene, is a well-known terrorist tactic. I find it plausible that terrorists might have added such devices to their planes-as-weapons plan. They would have a pretty large time window to set the devices off, since the evacuation and firefighting efforts would take a long time. They could have taken advantage of the chaos to bring such devices in after the impacts, thus avoiding normal building security.

Not the least bit likely. The fire department was right on the scene. Standard opoerating procedure is not to let anyone return to a building once the fire has started. You get out, you stay out. They can't have untrained civilians getting in their way. In an emergency situation, a trained responder is looking for additional threats to his well-being. Certainly, someone carrying a box or rucksack full of something into a burning building is going top trip a few alarms.
 
“New York firemen were very upset by what they considered a cover-up in the WTC destruction. Many other firemen knew there were bombs in the buildings,’ he said, ‘but they are afraid for their jobs to admit it because the higher-ups forbid discussion of this fact.’ - Paul Isaac Jr

That brings up my OP, people claim that the FDNY is involved and a murder by association. Again as Alt-F4, as NYC Employees, if I knew that there were bombs in the building I would speak out. The union protects you against any discrimination for thinking it was an inside job.


Louie Cacchioli was upset that People Magazine misquoted him, saying "there were bombs" in the building when all he said was he heard "what sounded like bombs" without having definitive proof bombs were actually detonated.


I can't find much on Albert Turi, I am reading his interview now.


I can't find anything about Frank Cruthers saying there was a bomb in the WTC or Inside Job.


I am continuing to read Karin Deshore's interview with the post. Other than that I can't see where she is spoke out about an inside job or bombs


Brian Dixon, "I looked up and you could actually see everything blew out on the one floor. I thought, geez, this looks like an explosion up there, it blew out. Then I guess in some sense of time we looked at it and realized, no, actually it just collapsed. That ís what blew out the windows, not that there was an explosion there but that windows blew out."


Neil Sweeting, "You heard a big boom, it was quiet for about ten seconds. Then you could hear another one. Now I realize it was the floors starting to stack on top of each other as they were falling. It was spaced apart in the beginning, but then it got to just a tremendous roar and a rumble that I will never forget."


After all the EMTs, Paramedics, and Firefighters I have talked to and personally know. Still none of them believe there were bombs or it was an inside job.
 
I never even implied First Responders were murderers that was the job of the person who put up this thread.

Look, I'm trying to explain this to you. We know you didn't imply that, many truthers don't (though Alex Jones and at least one member of NY 911 Truth did). It's just that it's the inevitable conclusion when you follow their theories and reasoning. We're asking you to somehow reconcile what you believe, your theory, with the NYPD, FDNY somehow not being in on it. We don't understand how it can be reconciled, please educate us; elucidate it for us.

Cause either the build 7 had a lot of damage and was about to collapse as the many firefighters said, or they were lying. If they were lying then they were in on it. If they're not, then building 7 really was damaged and about to collapse.
 
The only EMT testimony that would indicate something wrong would be the Ondrovic interview. But I am not the least inclined to give it much weight, because it seems clear to me that some of what she describes defies physical laws. I strongly suspect PTSD may have something to do with that. She may even be confabulating some of it. She was running AWAY from her triage location, even though there were wounded there. I think she lost it.

If they have offered her what she considers "hush money" I would suspect that it is actually just a pension for a line-of-duty disability.
 
"Certainly..."

I'll never understand why an inside job theory would have to include first responders in on it. Especially on WTC7. I mean we are talking about a building that housed the offices for the FBI, CIA, NSA, and Giuliani.

Like I said you can go through every first responder who heard explosions or first instinct was secondary devices and wave your hand and explain them away. So what?

Someone here asked me to show where someone has changed their story. Thanks for posting just that kook. Wasn't Paul Issac the one who claimed gag order also? Are you cherry picking his statements and throwing out the rest?

How about this change of story from an explosives expert that I’m also sure has been dismissed here long ago.

The collapse of the buildings appears "too methodical" to be a chance result of airplanes colliding with the structures, said Van Romero, vice president for research at New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology. "My opinion is, based on the videotapes, that after the airplanes hit the World Trade Center there were some explosive devices inside the buildings that caused the towers to collapse," Romero said.

Then a few days later without any further investigation...

"Certainly the fire is what caused the building to fail," said Van Romero, a vice president at the New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology.

Then a little while later..

WASHINGTON -- U.S. Senator Pete Domenici today reported that Van Romero of Socorro has been appointed by President Bush to serve on a White House commission aimed at closing the educational achievement gap for Hispanic American youth.

There has been no real investigation. All versions are theory at this point. The official conspiracy theory of 19 hijackers is one of the wackiest of all.
 
Someone here asked me to show where someone has changed their story. Thanks for posting just that kook. Wasn't Paul Issac the one who claimed gag order also? Are you cherry picking his statements and throwing out the rest?

This is What Paul Issac's letter to Mark Roberts has to say.

Hello Mark,

If its the wingtv article its ********. They slandered me last year when I read them the riot act about their behavior.

The article" Fireman admits again 9-11 was an inside job" is slander.

The article written by randy lavello is also slander as he has me saying that woolsey former CIA Director Woolsey was passing a gag order down the rank and file of the FDNY. That statement was never made in that context, It was said in humor ,and as a matter of fact that so-called reporter was fired by Alex Jones for making **** up on alot of people. The only reason I didn't go through the legal channels is because lawyers cost to damn much.

So the true statement was the that I heard Explosions not bombs as I couldn't tell what the sounds were as I was blocks away and can not confirm what the noise was. As I was aproaching City Hall the North Tower began the collapse I heard what sounded like thunder just prior to the collapse then the Popping as the tower fell. I had my radio scanner and there were reports of explsions within the conplex over the PD and PAPD frequencies. As I made my way closer I could pick up on the FD Handie Talkie frequencies and it sounded like hell. No one new what the was going to happen next but when the second tower began its fall there were what sounded like loud popping coming from the tower as well as a sucking sound like reveres air pressure.

Its seems the people at 911Truth have some problems with credibility as I had approached them on this issue for clarification. No need to say they never returned my messages.

They are tools of the trade.

Take care
Paul
 
The reason you see NEXT, is usually because you are bringing up the same, tired, extremely well debated issues AGAIN!!!

I'll never understand why an inside job theory would have to include first responders in on it. Especially on WTC7. I mean we are talking about a building that housed the offices for the FBI, CIA, NSA, and Giuliani.

Please explain how those you feel are responsible for the collapse of WTC7 carried out this demolition. I don't want quotes, or links to others words, I want to hear it from you, in your own words, how you think it went down.


Like I said you can go through every first responder who heard explosions or first instinct was secondary devices and wave your hand and explain them away. So what?

how many can you quote that "on instinct" thought the explosions were "secondary devices?? one, two, three, a half-dozen?

how many first responders have said they think there were preplanted explosives in the WTCs that day?


Someone here asked me to show where someone has changed their story. Thanks for posting just that kook. Wasn't Paul Issac the one who claimed gag order also? Are you cherry picking his statements and throwing out the rest?

How about this change of story from an explosives expert that I’m also sure has been dismissed here long ago.

I must have missed this part of the thread, as it makes no sense to me.


The collapse of the buildings appears "too methodical" to be a chance result of airplanes colliding with the structures, said Van Romero, vice president for research at New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology. "My opinion is, based on the videotapes, that after the airplanes hit the World Trade Center there were some explosive devices inside the buildings that caused the towers to collapse," Romero said.

Then a few days later without any further investigation...

"Certainly the fire is what caused the building to fail," said Van Romero, a vice president at the New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology.

It is called time to reflect, think, look the evidence over....


Then a little while later..

WASHINGTON -- U.S. Senator Pete Domenici today reported that Van Romero of Socorro has been appointed by President Bush to serve on a White House commission aimed at closing the educational achievement gap for Hispanic American youth.

Please be direct...spit it out, what are you implying here?


There has been no real investigation. All versions are theory at this point. The official conspiracy theory of 19 hijackers is one of the wackiest of all.

Love the opinion, too bad it is worth dirt!

TAM:)
 
There has been no real investigation. All versions are theory at this point. The official conspiracy theory of 19 hijackers is one of the wackiest of all.

Really ?

Maybe you should tell these guys they are looking in the wrong place.

INTERPOL's 181 member countries and its 80+ year history have given us much experience about the importance of fighting terrorism wherever it might occur. Whether it be what has happened in Afghanistan, Algeria, Colombia, France, Germany, Greece, India, Indonesia, Iraq, Israel, Italy, Kenya, Morocco, Pakistan, the Philippines, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Sri Lanka, Tanzania, Tunisia, Turkey, the UK, the US, Uzbekistan or Yemen just to name some of the many countries that have suffered terrorist attacks, INTERPOL knows that terrorism must be fought wherever it appears.
Despite already having a long history of reminders of the danger of terrorism, just a few days ago we were once again brutally reminded that the type of attacks that Al Qaeda-like terrorist groups use are among the most troubling to us as law enforcement officials and to us as a world community.

Each successfully carried out terrorist attack that links itself to Al Qaeda or September 11th undermines public confidence that governments' can shield their citizens from harm. Groups have claimed responsibility for the March 11th attacks and have linked them to the September 11th 2001 attacks on New York and Washington and the war in Iraq. Some people have pointed to the fact that March 11th 2004 was exactly 911 days following September 11th 2001 also known as 911 in the US.

http://www.interpol.int/Public/ICPO/speeches/SG20040316.asp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom