Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

How do you think Israel should have responded to Hezbollah?

I think that's pretty obvious from my previous reply -- they should have responded in a way more proportionate to the Hezbollah actions, and with more concern for civilian casualties. I'm not so much opposed to the type of the Israeli response as I am to its degree and the lack of accuracy in their application of force.
 
Sorry,

That you were talking about a proportionate response was clear, but I was hoping for a suggestion of a type of response. I am not trying to bait you, I just want to know how Israel could have responded better and still achieved its goals (which it hasn't yet).
 
There's a difference between accidental killings and incidental killings -- so called "collateral damage" is the latter.


The words are synonymous, according to the dictionary. The only distinction between them, far as I can tell, is "incidental" indicates "minor" whereas an "accident" can be major.

So by saying the killing of civilians is incidental, you're actually making it less significant.


So far in this operation the IDF has killed many more civilians than Hezbollah fighters. Is that really acceptable as a response to a military attack on Israeli soldiers? What ratio of civilians to Hezbollah fighters is unacceptable?


You're making it sound like there's a quota. Ratio's are irrelevant. Numbers killed are irrelevant. Whether they are pregnant women or disabled children with wooden eyes is irrelevant. That is purely emotive rhetoric designed to influence a person's opinion by blinding them to reason.

As long as Israel complies with the laws of International Armed Conflict I will find no reason to condemn their actions. The moment they fail to comply, they deserve condemnation. It is as simple as that.

I can see only two ways in which someone looking at this conflict rationally and objectively could condemn Israel's actions. One is as described above - if they fail to comply with the laws of international armed conflict. The second would be if you do not consider they have grounds for invoking Article 51 of the UN Charter, in which case the actions carried out by Israel would be considered aggression.

I, personally, believe there is grounds for invoking Article 51, however I am open to hearing arguments to the contrary.

-Andrew
 
From the BBC

Lebanese Americans flee conflict zone

Setting off at an agreed time from Rmeich, fleets of dozens of taxis have been taking people down to the coast at Naqqoura and north to Tyre.

The US embassy had to tell the Israelis the exact number of vehicles in the convoy - otherwise they could have been hit anyway, like so many other civilians between Tyre and the border.



gtc said:
Its not quite the same thing at all. It is in fact proof that Israel is not targetting civillians and you should actually be thanking Israel that they delivered that message.

I should be thanking the Israelis?
Yes, thanks for only being raving mad instead total lunatics.

Israel believes Hezbollah will be using those kinds of vehicles.

So owning a van instead of a car is grounds for execution? I imagine it is not easy to gain access to fuel or a vehicle at the moment. Civilians have the right to use minibuses and vans. Not to mention ambulances.

but civillians can just as easily be transported in cars.

BBC reports following the aid convoy to Tyre have shown vehicles along the side of the road, vehicles in craters. I saw many cars. In fact, mainly cars.

Its just the same as telling a civillian not to wear a military uniform in a war zone or else they will be targetted.

Shameful apologetics.
Vehicles moving away from a warzone are being hit. Why doesn't Israel limit itself (atleast until the exodus of refugees is complete) to hitting vehicles moving towards the warzone?

Answer: They don't give a damn about civilians lives.
 
At least you are not saying that Israel is deliberately targetting civillians anymore.
 
what I was curious about is if there is any level of civilian casualties in lebanon that would make you sufficiently revolted to turn into a hezbollah sympathiser by condemning it or calling on it to be stopped....is there any level of deaths you would draw the line at?

On the flip side, is there a low number of civilian casualties you would find acceptable?

That should be pretty easy, shouldn't it? How small would the number have to be before you agreed Israel was doing everything it could to minimize civilian casualties?
 
So far in this conflict, Hezbollah has actually killed fewer civilians per enemy soldier than IDF has. Now, admittedly, that's at least partly because the majority of combat is occuring on Lebanese soil, but it's still a fact that's worth some thought.

It’s not worth much thought when you consider that Israel puts their soldiers in harms way in taking the fight to Hezbollah while Hezbollah purposefully maximizes Lebanese civilian casualties by hiding amongst them.
 
gtc said:
At least you are not saying that Israel is deliberately targetting civillians anymore.

Israel doesn't give a damn who they kill in Lebanon. And you're happy because they haven't started an intentional program of genocide?
 
The words are synonymous, according to the dictionary. The only distinction between them, far as I can tell, is "incidental" indicates "minor" whereas an "accident" can be major.

So by saying the killing of civilians is incidental, you're actually making it less significant.

While they words can be synonyms, there is a difference in their typical useage. "Incidental" suggests that something occurs (or is likely to occur) as an un-intended side-effect to something[1], where "accidental" suggests it a freak occurence[2].

The CPU of a computer produces heat when it operates. Nobody wants it to produce heat, and nobody intends for it do so, but it does, and we know it does. The heat is incidental to the operation of the CPU, but it's not accidental. We know there will be heat produced.

("Accidental" can be used in a meaning very close to incidental, but that's not the common useage. Nobody would talk about "accidental heat" from a CPU)


Webster's Encyclopedic Unabridged Dictionary of the English Language, 1996 edition. Both definitions shortened to the relevant passaged:

[1] Incidental. 1. Happening or likely to happen in fortuitous or subordinate conjunction with something else. 2. likely to happen or naturally appertaining (usually followed by to). 3. incurred casually and in addition to the regular or main account.

[2] Accidental 1. Happening by chance or accident; unexpected. 2. nonessential; incidental; subsidiary





You're making it sound like there's a quota. Ratio's are irrelevant. Numbers killed are irrelevant. Whether they are pregnant women or disabled children with wooden eyes is irrelevant. That is purely emotive rhetoric designed to influence a person's opinion by blinding them to reason.

As long as Israel complies with the laws of International Armed Conflict I will find no reason to condemn their actions. The moment they fail to comply, they deserve condemnation. It is as simple as that.

No, numbers killed are not irrelevant. There is a difference between killing one innocent civilian and hundred armed fighters, and killing hundered civilians and only one armed fighter. It's not the same thing to blow up an army barrack although there's a civilian washerwoman inside and blowing up an apartment complex filled with civilians and one solitary militiaman guarding the lobby.

Secondly, the question is if the IDF is complying with the laws of war. The laws of war explicitly protectes the civilian population and explicitly states that the civilian losses from an attack must not be excessive to the military gains. ("Indiscriminate attacks are prohibited. [...] Among others, the following types of attacks are to be considered as indiscriminate:[...] an attack which may be expected to cause incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects, or a combination thereof, which would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated.") My opinion is that the IDF's current actions in Lebanon causes civilian losses that are "excessive in relations to the ... military advantage," and thereby are in violation of the laws of war. (Note that that's my opinion as a layman only.)
 
Last edited:
What's annoying is the insinuation. "the bombing of Japan was done to terrorize the population!". Well, so? Was that a war crime? Should those still surviving of the pilots be put on trial? No answer.

Within a few months after Pearl Harbor, the US launched the aptly-named Doolittle Raid, where a bunch of US bombers made a 1-way trip past Japan into China. The purpose was to let the Japanese government and civilians know it wasn't gonna be business as usual shortly.
 
I, personally, believe there is grounds for invoking Article 51, however I am open to hearing arguments to the contrary.
-Andrew

I wish to respond to Lief Roar's comment (post #54):
"Is that really acceptable as a response to a military attack on Israeli soldiers? "

I had this same exchange with Dustin last week ---- the opening salvo on July 12th was an unprovoked missile assault on Israeli civilians several kilometers from the ambush on the IDF patrol. Hezbollah chose to engage the Israelis by firing at the people living in SHLOMI. Not at any soldiers or military post --- they targeted rockets at innocent jews.
This is the same thing that palestinians are doing from gaza.
It has all been coordinated and planned from Damascus and Tehran.


Now, the terrorists are being dismembered as a result of a two-front war they brought down upon the populations they live among ----- and if it requires the total destruction of Lebanon or Gaza, and tens of thousands of casualties, and hundreds of thousands of refugees, so be it.

I just don't care anymore.

Leave -- Us -- Alone.
 
No I don't believe [WWII Allied Command] should be charged with warcrimes because the great majority of the people on thier side who would decide what is right and what is not did not care a hoot what happened to "japs"...bit like you and the current Lebanese casualties.

And inevitably, the people who complain about this type of thing are sitting safely a long, long way from the battlefield and battle time. Why don't you (over there, in harm's way) fight the enemy in a suboptimal manner so I don't feel bad about civilians you might accidentally kill. I frown in your general direction.
 
I'm not there , so I don't know, but from what little I've seen on BBC news it appears there are quite different situations regarding reporters on the ground in Israel and Lebanon.
While foreign TV teams are essentially safe in Israel, or as safe as in any war zone, they may be more tightly controlled in legitimate access to information. I suspect the Israeli government and army use the same methods of control of journalists as the allied forces in Iraq and the earlier Gulf War- ie there is an attempt at central control of what gets out, via formal press meetings etc. This is not necessarily censorship. It's just what happens in a state at war. An approved version is presented to the media through approved channels.

In south Lebanon, the reporters seem to be in areas controlled by Hisbollah or Hamas, which means what they say and do may be interfered with by patrols on the ground, but such patrols are unlikely to have a centralised policy and may have nobody fluent in English, or any of the other languages broadcasters may be using.

Even if both sides were using identical ordnance and identical targeting methods and policies, the difference in press controls might be enough on its own to create diferent messages emerging from either side.
 
I wish to respond to Lief Roar's comment (post #54):
"Is that really acceptable as a response to a military attack on Israeli soldiers? "

I had this same exchange with Dustin last week ---- the opening salvo on July 12th was an unprovoked missile assault on Israeli civilians several kilometers from the ambush on the IDF patrol. Hezbollah chose to engage the Israelis by firing at the people living in SHLOMI. Not at any soldiers or military post --- they targeted rockets at innocent jews.
This is the same thing that palestinians are doing from gaza.
It has all been coordinated and planned from Damascus and Tehran.


Now, the terrorists are being dismembered as a result of a two-front war they brought down upon the populations they live among ----- and if it requires the total destruction of Lebanon or Gaza, and tens of thousands of casualties, and hundreds of thousands of refugees, so be it.

I just don't care anymore.

Leave -- Us -- Alone.


Well put, and I agree. Those criticising Israel's response can't merely look at the unprovoked attacks in a vacuum. There is a tremendous cumulative effect from the Arab world (and Iran) which has sought to dismantle Israel from the moment of its official declaration of existence. Several wars have been fought over the issue, and many, many less formal yet vicious attacks on innocent Israelis have occurred throughout Israel's young life as a modern nation. There is a reason founded on incontrovertible facts that Middle Eastern Muslims are so often caricatured as suicide bombers. The Muslim world, and in particular the Arab world (and Iran), spreads hatred towards Jews like a virus that infects vasts swaths of the Muslim populations. Their children are taught to hate Jews as soon as they can speak.

I said it a couple of weeks ago, and I'll say it again. In a very real sense, Israel is fighting for its life. It cannot afford to let its enemies see it fail to defend itself. It must be steadfast and relentless in chasing out the armed Hezbollah fighters.

I wholeheartedly support Israel's efforts. All of the blood of civilian casualties is on the hands of Hezbollah and its supporters. All of it.

Also, strategically, when one looks at the bigger picture, those of us in the Western world simply must grasp that we're in the jihadists' gunsights as well. Therefore, in a very real sense, Israel's current two-front war is our war. In the long run, what is good for Israel in this regard is good for the West. I wish more Westerners would understand that.

AS
 
Within a few months after Pearl Harbor, the US launched the aptly-named Doolittle Raid, where a bunch of US bombers made a 1-way trip past Japan into China. The purpose was to let the Japanese government and civilians know it wasn't gonna be business as usual shortly.

(sarcasm) So Jimmy Doolittle was a war criminal. (sarcasm)
 
do you want an answer in between you tying the two lines you impatient little man?


No I don't believe they should be charged with warcrimes because the great majority of the people on thier side who would decide what is right and what is not did not care a hoot what happened to "japs"...bit like you and the current Lebanese casualties.

OK, so let get this straight. Whomever--if anybody--should have been actually blamed for it, you DO think that the USA bombing of Japanese cities is a war crime. Correct?
 
OK, so let get this straight. Whomever--if anybody--should have been actually blamed for it, you DO think that the USA bombing of Japanese cities is a war crime. Correct?

If they happened today, some of the bombing raids by the USA on the Japanese mainland might have considered war crimes, but at the time the laws of war was different and didn't contain the same protections of the civilian population, so judging by the standards of the day, they weren't.
 
If they happened today, some of the bombing raids by the USA on the Japanese mainland might have considered war crimes, but at the time the laws of war was different and didn't contain the same protections of the civilian population, so judging by the standards of the day, they weren't.

I appreciate that you include both the legal and cultural standards in that reply. It shows that it wasn't the sucker punch it would be if done today, law or no law.

Misapplication of contemporary standards to historical events is a common source of hand-wringing and general angst. Particularly for Hezbollah, which has "historically" paid no significant price for their crimes.

The times, they are a-changin'. Hopefully for the better, in the long run.
 
Secondly, the question is if the IDF is complying with the laws of war. The laws of war explicitly protectes the civilian population and explicitly states that the civilian losses from an attack must not be excessive to the military gains. ("Indiscriminate attacks are prohibited. [...] Among others, the following types of attacks are to be considered as indiscriminate:[...] an attack which may be expected to cause incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects, or a combination thereof, which would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated.") My opinion is that the IDF's current actions in Lebanon causes civilian losses that are "excessive in relations to the ... military advantage," and thereby are in violation of the laws of war. (Note that that's my opinion as a layman only.)

Let's try to remember to be skeptical of those "civilian deaths" numbers. They are give to us by the Hezbolla/Lebanese. There have been almost no BDA from the IDF, for security purposes. How many of those bombed cars had AK-47's in them? How many of the bomb craters in villages have rocket launchers in the bottom? How many Hizbollah "civilians" bodies were found at the UN out post? (11, form one Izzy site) How many "civilians" were killed at the big site in South Beruit, vs the secondary explosions from the munitions stored under the building?

And those UN 'observers' in a war zone being killed- just like war correspondents, or medics, they are at risk. Why did Kofi allow them to stay? As shields for the Hezbollah?


Likewise, I've not heard any discussion of how the IDF chooses it's targets. But I do know of the existence of radar to track incoming missiles, and use counter-battery fire within seconds to throw artillary shells at the launch point, regardless of it's location re: civilians. All legal, within the quote above.

Sorry, I've got to back the IDF so far. Until an after-action report shows an audit of how each site was chosen for action, which ain't gonna happen.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom