Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

gumboot asks:

No, that information is still in dispute.
Several other threads discussing this point have been running on JREF ---

As of Wednesday's reports, I estimate that around 75 kids have lost their lives. That certainly isn't a tragedy of genocidal proportions.
Actually, it is fair to say that the number of civilians killed is ridiculously small in comparison to what the IAF and IDF are capable of inflicting if they weren't being so very cautious.

(In fact, the IDF ground troops who suffered severe fatalities yesterday, are complaining that their superiors didn't just level the entire village with air power before they went in. The statements I saw were to the effect: "We told the civilians to leave, as far as we know they did depart, and we should have just carpet-bombed the whole place into rubble at that point."

Not doing so cost them 9 fatalities in close-quarters combat.
I doubt that will be repeated...
why don't you use the term "rediculously small" to describe Israeli casualties from rocket attacks?

please feel free to have a stab at the question I asked "skeptic"...what level of lebanese deaths would cause you to say stop?
 
gumboot asks:

No, that information is still in dispute.
Several other threads discussing this point have been running on JREF ---

As of Wednesday's reports, I estimate that around 75 kids have lost their lives. That certainly isn't a tragedy of genocidal proportions.
Actually, it is fair to say that the number of civilians killed is ridiculously small in comparison to what the IAF and IDF are capable of inflicting if they weren't being so very cautious.

(In fact, the IDF ground troops who suffered severe fatalities yesterday, are complaining that their superiors didn't just level the entire village with air power before they went in. The statements I saw were to the effect: "We told the civilians to leave, as far as we know they did depart, and we should have just turned the whole place into rubble at that point."

Not doing so cost them 9 fatalities in close-quarters combat.
I doubt that will be repeated...
  • IDF officers in the Golani and Paratroops Brigades charged that the IDF employed insufficient force before the soldiers were deployed to search the homes. They said that once the civilians had been told to leave the town, the army should have regarded Bint Jbail as a battlefield and destroyed all homes where Hezbollah guerrillas were suspected of hiding.

    They also charged that not enough aircraft were used to attack targets.

    The IDF's modus operandi in southern Lebanon in recent days has sparked great debate among all ranks of the army. Many field officers argue that insufficient forces are being deployed in the fighting.
---- reported by Amos Harel and Eli Ashkenazi, Haaretz Correspondents 7-26-06

Except that when civilians try to leave, they are assumed to be guerillas, and attacked.
 
Except that when civilians try to leave, they are assumed to be guerillas, and attacked.

Untrue.
As they leave,the guerillas use the vehicles to transport their weapons, and they are hiding and escaping among the convoys of refugees.

You knew that, of course? It is the modus-operandi of Hezbollah. No secret.


Here's the link to the source article for my previous post about the IDF complaints about insufficient air bombardment.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/743027.html

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

TF urges me:please feel free to have a stab at the question I asked "skeptic"...what level of lebanese deaths would cause you to say stop?

48,217.
(For good measure, I'll go ahead and make that to include Palestinians in Gaza)


The combat action against Hezbollah and HAMAS will continue until the release of Goldwasser, Regev and Shalit.
This is a simple equation. At some point it will be comprehended by the Palestinian and the Hezbollah jihadists.

Until then, tally ho.....
 
Strange bedfellows:

From the J-Post:
'"For China and for others, we condemn this because I think any attack on the United Nations positions and the United Nations personnel is inexcusable and unacceptable," China's UN Ambassador Wang Guangya said.'

He seems to be forgetting a certain peninsula not a million miles from China.
 
Untrue.
As they leave,the guerillas use the vehicles to transport their weapons, and they are hiding and escaping among the convoys of refugees.

You knew that, of course? It is the modus-operandi of Hezbollah. No secret.


Here's the link to the source article for my previous post about the IDF complaints about insufficient air bombardment.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/743027.html

\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\



48,217.
(For good measure, I'll go ahead and make that to include Palestinians in Gaza)


The combat action against Hezbollah and HAMAS will continue until the release of Goldwasser, Regev and Shalit.
This is a simple equation. At some point it will be comprehended by the Palestinian and the Hezbollah jihadists.

Until then, tally ho.....
It didn't seem like a hard question web....maybe you can just blow it off and get back to chest beating but just because you don't care how many bystanders you kill please don't expect the rest of the world to do the same.
 
Is there any level of lebanese deaths you would condemn? If so....what level would that be?....no answer?


I know you didn't ask me this, but I hope I aren't stepping out of line for offering my own view.

Were I shown evidence of a single Lebanese civilian being injured as a result of being specifically targetted as a civilian by the IDF, I would condemn it.

However, accidental killing of civilians by the IDF is not an accumulative figure for condemnation.

Were the war to wage on, and thousands, in ones and twos, were killed accidentally by the IDF I would not condemn it. However at any point, were the IDF to accidentally kill large numbers of civilians AT ONE TIME I would look very closely at the circumstances because such a large casualty level would suggest to me - upon first glance - that the IDF had been negligent to the extreme.

-Andrew
 
But do you think Hezzbollah (and Hamas and Fatah for that matter) might think twice before kidnapping more soldiers?


No.

They are currently attempting to do just that, as evidenced by their actions in Bint Jbail. The Hezbollah tried to capture the bodies of the fallen IDF soldiers there, and were kept from doing so by a valiant effort of their comrades in the field.
  • During the next three hours after the initial ambush and the casualties, other platoons entered the area in an attempt to extricate the force that was pinned down. Hezbollah forces fired antitank missiles and threw grenades at the force it had caught in its ambush, and it also used mortars to attack the supporting IDF units.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/743027.html

and

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/743473.html
"It was hell on earth," Corporal Lior Sharabi said. "People risked their lives not only for the wounded but also for the dead bodies."
 
Last edited:
It didn't seem like a hard question web....maybe you can just blow it off and get back to chest beating but just because you don't care how many bystanders you kill please don't expect the rest of the world to do the same.

I expect you to call for the release of Goldwasser, Regev and Shalit.
No strings attached.

I have not seen you do so.

Why is that?
 
*snip*
However, accidental killing of civilians by the IDF is not an accumulative figure for condemnation.

Were the war to wage on, and thousands, in ones and twos, were killed accidentally by the IDF I would not condemn it.

-Andrew

Like these persons, for instance:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/742784.html
Israel Defense Forces troops killed 23 Palestinians in fighting across the Gaza Strip on Wednesday, including at least nine militants, three children and a disabled man,
and a 75-year old woman.


Ed knows, I'm trying to keep these reports straight, with links, but there is a lot of ***** happening all at once!

(in gaza)
There is a two-front war underway. This fact is being blurred out.
Samson's Pillars in the Gaza Strip is also a very hot combat operation.
The Palestinians are even feeling "left out" of the limelight ---

  • Saeb Erekat, a top aide to Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, called on the world to remember the plight of the Palestinians despite the conflict in Lebanon.
    "This is the forgotten war," he told Reuters. "We urge the international community to intervene."
 
Hizbullah attacks Israel supposedly in support of their comrades in Palestine, now Erekat is complaining that Palestine is being ignored because of the conflict in Lebanon.

:hypnotize Damn those zionists and their fiendish plans to attack Lebanon to distract the world from the evil zionist plot to attack Palestine. :hypnotize
 
However, accidental killing of civilians by the IDF is not an accumulative figure for condemnation.

There's a difference between accidental killings and incidental killings -- so called "collateral damage" is the latter.

So far in this operation the IDF has killed many more civilians than Hezbollah fighters. Is that really acceptable as a response to a military attack on Israeli soldiers? What ratio of civilians to Hezbollah fighters is unacceptable?
 
Ralph said:
I can't imagine the level of reality-distorting mental gymnastics required to sit there with a straight face & suggest Israel is deliberately killing civilians.

Well take your pick, Ralph.
It's either because Hezbollah controls the media. Or it's becuase Israel sends messages like these to Lebanese civilians:

Residents of Besieged City Feel 'Just Left Here to Die'

The warning came in the morning Thursday, a recorded message dialed to phone numbers in southern Lebanon. In flawless Arabic, it instructed: Leave now, beyond the Litani River that bisects the rock-studded wadis of the south. Don't flee on motorcycles or in vans or trucks. Otherwise, you will be a target. The message signed off simply: the state of Israel.

Civilians in vans or trucks or motorcycles are targets. Israel's own words. From what has been seen, that also extends to cars and minibuses and even ambulances.

Ralph said:
The IAF owns the airspace over Lebanon. They can bomb the snot out of population centers at will if they choose to do so.

You are seriously argueing that because they are not killing everybody, they can't be intending to kill some of the civilians they are blowing up on roads as they flee the areas they are told to flee?

Fleeing civilian vehicles hit by Israeli missiles
 
Firegarden,

Its not quite the same thing at all. It is in fact proof that Israel is not targetting civillians and you should actually be thanking Israel that they delivered that message.

Israel believes Hezbollah will be using those kinds of vehicles.

Hezbollah fighters in vehicles like that are legitimate targets.

But Israel can't tell the difference between a civillian and a Hezbollah fighter in one of those vehicles.

Israel doesn't want to hurt civillians.

Israel realises that Hezbollah needs vans for transportation, but civillians can just as easily be transported in cars.

So Israel warns civillians not to use those vehicles.

Its just the same as telling a civillian not to wear a military uniform in a war zone or else they will be targetted.

You really can't get anywhere with your argument. Because we know Hezbollah are deliberately targetting Israelis, the very most you could do is to convince people that Israel was as bad as Hezbollah.

If only Hezbollah showed as much concern for Israeli civillians as Israel showed, then innocent Israelis would still be alive.
 
If only Hezbollah showed as much concern for Israeli civillians as Israel showed, then innocent Israelis would still be alive.

So far in this conflict, Hezbollah has actually killed fewer civilians per enemy soldier than IDF has. Now, admittedly, that's at least partly because the majority of combat is occuring on Lebanese soil, but it's still a fact that's worth some thought.
 
So far in this conflict, Hezbollah has actually killed fewer civilians per enemy soldier than IDF has. Now, admittedly, that's at least partly because the majority of combat is occuring on Lebanese soil, but it's still a fact that's worth some thought.

Not very much thought, though. If you consider the effort Hezbollah has put into killing Israeli civilians - i.e. thousands of shrapnel-filled rockets aimed at residential areas - compared to Israel's efforts, you'd realize that the only reason Israel's casualty toll is less than Lebanon's is the disparity in weapons technology. If Israel put anywhere near as much effort as Hezbollah into trying to harm civilians, the death toll in Beirut alone would be in the tens of thousands by now.
 
So far in this conflict, Hezbollah has actually killed fewer civilians per enemy soldier than IDF has. Now, admittedly, that's at least partly because the majority of combat is occuring on Lebanese soil, but it's still a fact that's worth some thought.

I have thought about that and I have concluded that it is because Hezbollah is too weak to have killed more and Israel has better civillian defence (i.e. shelters). Its not for want of trying, on the other hand, no one has shown how Israel is actually trying to kill civillians or even why they would want to.

I am wondering whether it would serve Israel's interests more to attempt to limit this war and see if Lebanon can grow (economically and maybe in other ways) out of this phase. On the other hand, I wonder how far they will need to go.

I don't really think Lebanon is capable of being a good neighbour to Israel at the moment, when you see the sorts of things that are shown on Lebanese TV by Hezbollah's station

And what the Lebanes President has to say at
der Spiegel.

What do you think?
 
What do you think?

What I think is that the Israeli operation in Lebanon is disproportionate to the Hezbollah attack that triggered it, and that Israel is not taking taking enough precautions to prevent civilian casualties.

What I do not think is that unacceptable actions by Hezbollah or Lebanese excuses unacceptable actions by the IDF.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom