Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

That's because they are only targeting children.
And pregnant women.
with disabilities.
Israeli child molesting squads
With imbedded catholic priests...

Cute. :D

Seriously--how can anybody who's not mentally retarded (and doesn't belong to Hezbollah) make this claim?
I think by civilians we mean non-combatants.

On a serious note, the reason you are hearing about non-combatant casualties is the fact that - like Gaza and the West Bank - the combatants are intermingled with the civilian population. They are in residential neighborhoods. Hamas, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad, etc, deliberately intermingle as to be indistinguishable from the non-combatants. You don't know if that truck racing down the street towards you is combatants heading into battle or non-combatants fleeing the fighting. The lines are blurred.

Hezbollah's stronghold is in south Beirut. This suburb is called the Haret Hreik district, (picture here). Their HQ is there, their leaders are there, their radio and TV stations are there, and a huge cache of intel and munitions is there. The rest of Hezbollah's "party supplies" are spread throughout southern Lebanon - villages in the Bekaa, etc. - in a similar fashion.

Ergo if one is going to engage Hezbollah you run into the nightmare of having to strike villages, towns and suburbs... such as south Beirut. To complicate this mission even further you have Hezbollah fighters who do not have "a fixed distinctive sign recognizable at a distance" on their clothing or vehicles, they don't "conduct their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war" and they are not "members of regular armed forces". Sadly this translates into non-combatant casualties. You can't avoid it.
 
Cute. :D




On a serious note, the reason you are hearing about non-combatant casualties is the fact that - like Gaza and the West Bank - the combatants are intermingled with the civilian population. They are in residential neighborhoods. Hamas, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad, etc, deliberately intermingle as to be indistinguishable from the non-combatants. You don't know if that truck racing down the street towards you is combatants heading into battle or non-combatants fleeing the fighting. The lines are blurred.

Hezbollah's stronghold is in south Beirut. This suburb is called the Haret Hreik district, (picture here). Their HQ is there, their leaders are there, their radio and TV stations are there, and a huge cache of intel and munitions is there. The rest of Hezbollah's "party supplies" are spread throughout southern Lebanon - villages in the Bekaa, etc. - in a similar fashion.

Ergo if one is going to engage Hezbollah you run into the nightmare of having to strike villages, towns and suburbs... such as south Beirut. To complicate this mission even further you have Hezbollah fighters who do not have "a fixed distinctive sign recognizable at a distance" on their clothing or vehicles, they don't "conduct their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war" and they are not "members of regular armed forces". Sadly this translates into non-combatant casualties. You can't avoid it.

That may be true, but you can avoid looking like you don't highly value each and every individual non-combatant Lebanese citizen that is killed by the IDF while targeting terrorists, and you can avoid looking like you aren't acknowledging, memorializing, and deeply regretting the death of each inidividual non-combatant Lebanese citizen that is inadvertantly killed during IDF operations. For among other reasons, it's just good PR and I think indisputably the right thing to do. And it's pretty much cost-free.
 
That may be true, but you can avoid looking like you don't highly value each and every individual non-combatant Lebanese citizen that is killed by the IDF while targeting terrorists, and you can avoid looking like you aren't acknowledging, memorializing, and deeply regretting the death of each inidividual non-combatant Lebanese citizen that is inadvertantly killed during IDF operations. For among other reasons, it's just good PR and I think indisputably the right thing to do. And it's pretty much cost-free.
Could it be because in a couple of days, Israel will formally declare war on Lebanon, and then the civilian casualties and evacuations will begin in earnest? I believe Israel has already stated that they've given civilians plenty of time to evacuate south Lebanon and that anyone killed there from this point on will have only himself to blame (so to speak). When Israel starts laying waste to everything within two miles of its border with Lebanon, and dozens, or even hundreds of people not wearing uniforms turn up dead every day, previous claims of regret for civilian casualties will ring pretty hollow.

Just my guess.
 
Could it be because in a couple of days, Israel will formally declare war on Lebanon, and then the civilian casualties and evacuations will begin in earnest? I believe Israel has already stated that they've given civilians plenty of time to evacuate south Lebanon and that anyone killed there from this point on will have only himself to blame (so to speak). When Israel starts laying waste to everything within two miles of its border with Lebanon, and dozens, or even hundreds of people not wearing uniforms turn up dead every day, previous claims of regret for civilian casualties will ring pretty hollow.

Just my guess.

Well, I'm assuming here that Israel actually means what it says when it says that these civilian casualties were inevitable and unintentional in their efforts to thwart the type of terrorism that would lead to even more deaths. As for civilians have only themselves to blame, I think that the world's a little more complicated than that. There are probably elderly and infirm people that are unable to evacuate, that have or will end up as civilian casualties but are still worth being publicly mourned, acknowledged, and remembered by Israeli leadership. I think that would apply even to the eccentric, the stubborn, and the foolish: it's still good PR and good policy, in the most cost-free of ways, to mourn their inadvertant deaths in the course of fighting terrorism.
 
Plenty of Arabs are claiming it who aren't affiliated with Hamas. Anan claimed Israeli apparantly deliberatly targeted the UN peace keepers as well.


Anecdotal of course...

But the NZDF peace keepers in Lebanon (who were waiting to move up to the base that was hit at the time) do not believe the attack was intentional.

Incidentally... do we have confirmed numbers of civilians killed?

And by that I mean, how many of the "civilians" are adult men with balaclavas over their faces and AK-47's or RPG-7s still gripped tight in their dead cold fingers?

-Andrew
 
I can't imagine the level of reality-distorting mental gymnastics required to sit there with a straight face & suggest Israel is deliberately killing civilians.

The US killed over 100,000 Japanese in a single raid with piston-engined aircraft and simple low-tech incendiary bombs in 1945.

Even when both sides were evenly matched---such as during the Iran/Iraq war....MILLIONS died--mostly civilians---when there was no genuine concern for loss of civilan life.

The IAF owns the airspace over Lebanon. They can bomb the snot out of population centers at will if they choose to do so.

The death toll should be in the tens or even hundreds of thousands by now if that were the case. Instead--we hear about 200-300 "civilians" killed and presented as examples of Israels lack of concern for civilian life.

Seriously--how can anybody who's not mentally retarded (and doesn't belong to Hezbollah) make this claim?

The bombers were targetting civilians, it was part of the strategic bombing aim, to destroy morale and the ability of Japan to sustain a war.
 
The bombers were targetting civilians

Indeed they were....which is why I'm suggesting that when a country with clear military superiority over another country decides to kill it's citizens--you will see massive numbers of deaths. Tens or hundreds of thousands---not the numbers we're seeing in Lebanon.

I think the relatively low # of deaths argues that Israel is -as it always has--trying as best it can (under very difficult circumstances) to limit civilian casualties.
 
I was listening to the radio here in Calgary tonight and they had a retired General on who said he exchanged an email with (who he thought was) the Canadian soldier who was killed. The solder basically said their position was surrounded by Hezbollah using them as a shield.

The station is QR77 and they store show audio to listen to, so you can register on the site to hear it. It was between 7:30pm and 8:00pm
 
I was listening to the radio here in Calgary tonight and they had a retired General on who said he exchanged an email with (who he thought was) the Canadian soldier who was killed. The solder basically said their position was surrounded by Hezbollah using them as a shield.

The station is QR77 and they store show audio to listen to, so you can register on the site to hear it. It was between 7:30pm and 8:00pm
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1796835&postcount=93
 
I doubt Israel is deliberately killing civilians or Peacekeepers. However I might be wrong.
So then why do you bother to make this comment, except perhaps to illustrate how you admire Kerry's style?



I believe the most likely case is incompetent military leadership and unskilled soldiers.
And the skilled soliers who fight wars without civilian casualties are which? What's the name of that doll that looks kind of like your avatar?



Afterall they made the mistake of re-invading lebanon.
Instead of sucking in those abs and taking it like He Man?

(:chuckle: have you no idea how silly that picture colors anything you say, now or in the future?)
 
with disabilities.

With wooden legs.

Which they set on fire.

Still, we should listen carefully to Hizbullah when they say israel is waging a campaign of terror on innocent civilians.

That is, after all, expert opinion.
 
The bombers were targetting civilians, it was part of the strategic bombing aim, to destroy morale and the ability of Japan to sustain a war.

There surely are a few old men, in their 80s, still alive of the pilots who flew those missions.

Do you suggest putting them on trial for war crimes?
 
There surely are a few old men, in their 80s, still alive of the pilots who flew those missions.

Do you suggest putting them on trial for war crimes?



Incidentally, I recall seeing an interview with Capt. Paul Tibbets (Pilot of the Enola Gay) not long after I read his book "Ruin From The Air". He was asked by the interviewer if, knowing now the impact of an Atomic Weapon, did he approve of his mission.

His rather blunt answer was, yes he still approved, and if given the same situation again he wouldn't hesitate to do exactly the same thing again.

For clarity, from his book and the interview Tibbets is a very well educated, intelligent, compassionate person.

Was interesting.

-Andrew
 
What's annoying is the insinuation. "the bombing of Japan was done to terrorize the population!". Well, so? Was that a war crime? Should those still surviving of the pilots be put on trial? No answer.
 
What's annoying is the insinuation. "the bombing of Japan was done to terrorize the population!". Well, so? Was that a war crime? Should those still surviving of the pilots be put on trial? No answer.
Why do you twist this on to the pilots? Did they all get together and decide to firebomb cities? Instead of simply misrepresenting the opposing position you should consider occasionally addressing it.


what I was curious about is if there is any level of civilian casualties in lebanon that would make you sufficiently revolted to turn into a hezbollah sympathiser by condemning it or calling on it to be stopped....is there any level of deaths you would draw the line at?
 
Why do you twist this on to the pilots? Did they all get together and decide to firebomb cities? Instead of simply misrepresenting the opposing position you should consider occasionally addressing it.

Fine, then. So, should the USAF Pacific command--or General McArthur--or Roosevelt--or whoever was "in charge" in your view--have been prosecuted for being war criminals, for their decision to bomb the Japanese cities?

Again, no answer.
 
gumboot asks:
Incidentally... do we have confirmed numbers of (Lebanese) civilians killed? And by that I mean, how many of the "civilians" are adult men with balaclavas over their faces and AK-47's or RPG-7s still gripped tight in their dead cold fingers?

No, that information is still in dispute.
Several other threads discussing this point have been running on JREF ---

As of Wednesday's reports, I estimate that around 75 kids have lost their lives. That certainly isn't a tragedy of genocidal proportions.
Actually, it is fair to say that the number of civilians killed is ridiculously small in comparison to what the IAF and IDF are capable of inflicting if they weren't being so very cautious.

(In fact, the IDF ground troops who suffered severe fatalities yesterday, are complaining that their superiors didn't just level the entire village with air power before they went in. The statements I saw were to the effect: "We told the civilians to leave, as far as we know they did depart, and we should have just turned the whole place into rubble at that point."

Not doing so cost them 9 fatalities in close-quarters combat.
I doubt that will be repeated...

  • IDF officers in the Golani and Paratroops Brigades charged that the IDF used insufficient force before the soldiers were deployed to search the homes. They said that once the civilians had been told to leave the town, the army should have regarded Bint Jbail as a battlefield and destroyed all homes where Hezbollah guerrillas were suspected of hiding.

    They also charged that not enough aircraft were used to attack targets.

    The IDF's modus operandi in southern Lebanon in recent days has sparked great debate among all ranks of the army. Many field officers argue that too low a level of troop strengths are being deployed in the fighting.
---- reported by Amos Harel and Eli Ashkenazi, Haaretz Correspondents 7-26-06
 
Last edited:
Fine, then. So, should the USAF Pacific command--or General McArthur--or Roosevelt--or whoever was "in charge" in your view--have been prosecuted for being war criminals, for their decision to bomb the Japanese cities?

Again, no answer.
do you want an answer in between you tying the two lines you impatient little man?


No I don't believe they should be charged with warcrimes because the great majority of the people on thier side who would decide what is right and what is not did not care a hoot what happened to "japs"...bit like you and the current Lebanese casualties.

You have to judge people's actions in the context of the times they were done in....


Is there any level of lebanese deaths you would condemn? If so....what level would that be?....no answer?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom