No, numbers killed are not irrelevant. There is a difference between killing one innocent civilian and hundred armed fighters, and killing hundered civilians and only one armed fighter. It's not the same thing to blow up an army barrack although there's a civilian washerwoman inside and blowing up an apartment complex filled with civilians and one solitary militiaman guarding the lobby.
Sorry for a late reply, time zones and all...
You are making the same mistake again above...
In the above examples you are talking about destruction relative to single events. In the second example, you are talking about the act of targetting civilians compared to the act of targetting the military.
The distinction is in the intent, not in the numbers.
Secondly, the question is if the IDF is complying with the laws of war. The laws of war explicitly protectes the civilian population and explicitly states that the civilian losses from an attack must not be excessive to the military gains.
My opinion is that the IDF's current actions in Lebanon causes civilian losses that are "excessive in relations to the ... military advantage," and thereby are in violation of the laws of war. (Note that that's my opinion as a layman only.)
This is just my opinion, correct me if I am wrong, but you're looking at this the wrong way, and as a result I feel this results in an incorrect conclusion (however I do not believe it is your "layman" interpretation of the law that is wrong).
What you seem to be looking at is the accumulative total. Which, as I have said, is irrelevant. In the case of assessing compliance with the laws of war, one must assess each incident independently.
A thousand non-war crimes do not equal a single large war crime.
Now, for each incident, there are four basic things:
1) What the IDF believed to be the situation
2) The actual situation
3) What the IDF intended to do/believed would happen
4) What actually happened
What is a little different about war crimes is only 1) and 3) are relevant. It is a little odd for people only familiar with civil law. But the actual situation, and what actually happened are irrelevant in assessing if a warcrime has taken place.
Okay. Let's run through a hypothetical example shall we? The israelis bomb a house in Lebanon and kill three children and a woman.
Going to our list:
1) What the IDF believed to be the situation (Hizbollah are operating from a house in Lebanon)
2) The actual situation (Hizbollah are not in the area, only civilians)
3) What the IDF intend to do/believe will happen (The house is to be targetted and an aircraft will drop a laser guided bomb on it, killing the Hizbollah fighters and possibly injuring surrounding civilians)
4) What actually happens (something goes wrong, the wrong house is hit, and four civilians (three children and a woman) are killed. The reports of Hizbollah were in error and there are no fighters nearby).
Now. Is this a warcrime? No, it's not. According to what the IDF believed to the be the scenario, Hizbollah were identified at a specific location and that specific location was targetted. Perfectly legal.
Now, this could happen 100 times, resulting in 400 civilian casualties. War crime yet? No. It could happen 1000 times, with 4,000 civilian casualties. War crime? No.
Hence no war crime. Hence numbers are irrelevant.
The only way a warcrime could be established would be if the following was revealed:
1) At the time the IDF knew the target was only civilian
2) At the time the IDF knew the actions would result only in civilian deaths
This would have to be done for EVERY SINGLE incident.
Let's take another example:
The IDF bomb a village in Lebanon and kill one hundred Hizbollah fighters.
1) What the IDF believed the situation was (it was a civilian village with no enemy in sight)
2) What the actual situation was (Hizbollah had chased all the civilians out and made the village their own base)
3) What the IDF believed/intended would happen (a fighter would drop a bomb on the village killing lots of innocent civilians)
4) What actually happened (the bombing kills all the Hizbollah fighters)
The strange thing is the above situation IS a warcrime. Hence, as we can see, the end result of their actions are actually irrelevant when assessing if a warcrime has been committed.
-Andrew