Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

"27, you believe that? I have some magic beans I'd like to sell you sucker, I mean sir... "

LOL...if you are selling the beans then no thanks.

Are you still selling the "Afghanistan is doing just great these days" line by the way? I`ve been away for a while but would just love to take up where we left off...or if I remember correctly...where I left off...you didn`t seem to reply to the installation of former regime members, war criminals and tortureres back into the newly installed "democracy" .
And I was so waiting for you to defend the intsallation of war criminals in the new regime there...that never came did it?... Hopefully I have that pleasure to come...any time.

Go for it Wildcat...as I say, I`m still waiting to hear how it`s all better there...knock your self out.
Jeeze, sometimes I wonder why I bother.
 
"27, you believe that? I have some magic beans I'd like to sell you sucker, I mean sir... "

LOL...if you are selling the beans then no thanks.

Are you still selling the "Afghanistan is doing just great these days" line by the way? I`ve been away for a while but would just love to take up where we left off...or if I remember correctly...where I left off...you didn`t seem to reply to the installation of former regime members, war criminals and tortureres back into the newly installed "democracy" .
And I was so waiting for you to defend the intsallation of war criminals in the new regime there...that never came did it?... Hopefully I have that pleasure to come...any time.

Go for it Wildcat...as I say, I`m still waiting to hear how it`s all better there...knock your self out.
Jeeze, sometimes I wonder why I bother.
Why don't you start an Afghanistan thread then, and not derail this one?

Do you really believe Hezbollah when they say they only lost 27 fighters so far?
 
"Where is the part where Gur claims Israel dropped brochures to warn Lebanese civilians of an impending attack?
Surely that was also a standard Israeli way of war in '78?"

Well, seems like you are making the claim that they did this, so you supply the evidence.

I do believe he was excersizing the art of irony, to which you were supposed to go "Ah! The good general of the time said no such thing! Therefore, what my good fellow poster must be doing is illustrating the great difference between what happened in the past and Israel's approach to the current war. Thank you, good sir, for bringing this to my attention."

Not to you in particular, but I think someone needs to start putting in a reply every few hours in these threads where the distinction is made between targetting civilians and killing civilians while thinking that Hezbollah is being targetted. There's quite a difference. While Israel has killed more civilians in this conflict, Hezbollah is the only one targetting civilians for death specifically with no other objective in mind.
 
"Ah! The good general of the time said no such thing! Therefore, what my good fellow poster must be doing is illustrating the great difference between what happened in the past and Israel's approach to the current war. Thank you, good sir, for bringing this to my attention."

Oh for chrissakes, I missed it...someone fill this guy in somewhere along the road please?
Goodnight gracie....

"Hezbollah is the only one targetting civilians for death specifically with no other objective in mind"
I`m working with a documentary film maker as you speak...collating film...this is exactly what we are looking for...I`m asking you for your terrorist film footage...got any?

And where is Mephisto these days?
 
Come on Webbie...(why do I always think I`m talking to Spiderman when we cross swords? lol...hope all is well with you)

FYi, the 'webfusion' is a name I swiped from a computer program which I used in Israel that creates WYSIWYG websites.

I'm OK, demon, thanks for asking. How are you? What kept you away?

I got called-up to my IDF unit during Operation Summer Rains, but since I'm in the middle of a project here for Hamilton Sundstrand for my Israeli employer, my commanders allowed me a temporary release from coming back onto active duty. I doubt that the current battle operations will expand to a point requiring a total draft. The three divisions that just got orders should cover it.

We assume.

Meanwhile, my cousin's home went up in smoke (that was his house in Haifa that took a hit at the outset of the war). He is pretty mad. For him, the IAF is not doing nearly enough damage against Lebanon!

As for the Lebanese, they are in deep trouble and it's getting deeper.
Nasrallah might need to cut his losses, and ignore those polls and return the Israeli hostages Goldwasser and Regev as soon as he can, especially if the HAMAS blinks and does the same with Cpl Shalit.

The Hezbollah leader knows that time is not on his side, and his own life isn't worth a plugged nickel with the Mossad dogging his every move. Nasrallah just returned from Syria, and you can be sure he was given detailed instructions by their mutual masters in Tehran as to how far he can press things from this point forward.
  • Naim Qassem, the deputy of Hezbollah Secretary General Hassan Nasrallah, said in an article published in Al-Nahar on Thursday that the group will consider it a victory if Lebanon does not become an American bridgehead in the Middle East. This does not reflect merely an ideological aspiration, but a real opposition to the deployment of a NATO force controlled by the United States in southern Lebanon. --- Zvi Bar'El, Ha'aretz



In reply to Pardalis (concealed behind a burka?) ----
AFAIK, The poll was conducted by telepathy.

(really, I have no clue, Zvi Bar'el who reported the information, did not offer the source). He mentioned Lebanon's LBC station, maybe they comissioned the survey? Anyway, like demon notes, those results are not surprising, under the circumstances.
 
No, numbers killed are not irrelevant. There is a difference between killing one innocent civilian and hundred armed fighters, and killing hundered civilians and only one armed fighter. It's not the same thing to blow up an army barrack although there's a civilian washerwoman inside and blowing up an apartment complex filled with civilians and one solitary militiaman guarding the lobby.


Sorry for a late reply, time zones and all...

You are making the same mistake again above...

In the above examples you are talking about destruction relative to single events. In the second example, you are talking about the act of targetting civilians compared to the act of targetting the military.

The distinction is in the intent, not in the numbers.



Secondly, the question is if the IDF is complying with the laws of war. The laws of war explicitly protectes the civilian population and explicitly states that the civilian losses from an attack must not be excessive to the military gains.

My opinion is that the IDF's current actions in Lebanon causes civilian losses that are "excessive in relations to the ... military advantage," and thereby are in violation of the laws of war. (Note that that's my opinion as a layman only.)


This is just my opinion, correct me if I am wrong, but you're looking at this the wrong way, and as a result I feel this results in an incorrect conclusion (however I do not believe it is your "layman" interpretation of the law that is wrong).

What you seem to be looking at is the accumulative total. Which, as I have said, is irrelevant. In the case of assessing compliance with the laws of war, one must assess each incident independently.

A thousand non-war crimes do not equal a single large war crime.

Now, for each incident, there are four basic things:

1) What the IDF believed to be the situation
2) The actual situation
3) What the IDF intended to do/believed would happen
4) What actually happened

What is a little different about war crimes is only 1) and 3) are relevant. It is a little odd for people only familiar with civil law. But the actual situation, and what actually happened are irrelevant in assessing if a warcrime has taken place.

Okay. Let's run through a hypothetical example shall we? The israelis bomb a house in Lebanon and kill three children and a woman.

Going to our list:

1) What the IDF believed to be the situation (Hizbollah are operating from a house in Lebanon)
2) The actual situation (Hizbollah are not in the area, only civilians)
3) What the IDF intend to do/believe will happen (The house is to be targetted and an aircraft will drop a laser guided bomb on it, killing the Hizbollah fighters and possibly injuring surrounding civilians)
4) What actually happens (something goes wrong, the wrong house is hit, and four civilians (three children and a woman) are killed. The reports of Hizbollah were in error and there are no fighters nearby).

Now. Is this a warcrime? No, it's not. According to what the IDF believed to the be the scenario, Hizbollah were identified at a specific location and that specific location was targetted. Perfectly legal.

Now, this could happen 100 times, resulting in 400 civilian casualties. War crime yet? No. It could happen 1000 times, with 4,000 civilian casualties. War crime? No.

Hence no war crime. Hence numbers are irrelevant.

The only way a warcrime could be established would be if the following was revealed:
1) At the time the IDF knew the target was only civilian
2) At the time the IDF knew the actions would result only in civilian deaths

This would have to be done for EVERY SINGLE incident.

Let's take another example:

The IDF bomb a village in Lebanon and kill one hundred Hizbollah fighters.

1) What the IDF believed the situation was (it was a civilian village with no enemy in sight)
2) What the actual situation was (Hizbollah had chased all the civilians out and made the village their own base)
3) What the IDF believed/intended would happen (a fighter would drop a bomb on the village killing lots of innocent civilians)
4) What actually happened (the bombing kills all the Hizbollah fighters)

The strange thing is the above situation IS a warcrime. Hence, as we can see, the end result of their actions are actually irrelevant when assessing if a warcrime has been committed.

-Andrew
 
"I'm OK, demon, thanks for asking. How are you? What kept you away?"

I`m ok thanks, let`s talk sometime about other stuff...what keeps us both away from this sort of place....I`ve been doing a little more activism these days...you know I`ve had/have dialogue with Dana? I`m not scoring points here, I`m just talking commuinication
 
In reply to Pardalis (concealed behind a burka?) ----

LOL

No it's not a burka, silly, it's a ninja hood! I'm a JREF Ninja Ocelot! :D

(really, I have no clue, Zvi Bar'el who reported the information, did not offer the source). He mentioned Lebanon's LBC station, maybe they comissioned the survey? Anyway, like demon notes, those results are not surprising, under the circumstances.

So, respectfully, this poll is irrelevant, and unscientific.
 
So, respectfully, this poll is irrelevant, and unscientific.


No. All you know right now is that the poll results were published, and those results were reported by Zvi Bar'el, a journalist from Israel working for Ha'Aretz.

The problem is that you cannot track the source, at this point, which means you'll need to dig a little deeper to investigate and determine the sample size, the questions asked, the demographics and methodology of the survey (phone calls, man-in-the-street interviews, internet clicks, what?)

That's the skeptical method; to get the facts.
You cannot dismiss the poll as 'irrelevant' or 'unscientific' just because I haven't offered those details which you're lacking to make a reasoned and logical judgement.

I do wish I could help you further, but it's after 2am on the East Coast of the United States, and I'll respectfully let the matter drop. If the MSM picks up on that poll and gives it some coverage (don't hold your breath) then we'll have more to go on. But, as of now, I'll go to bed and hope for the safe return of our soldiers Goldwasser, Regev and Shalit.

More than that, you couldn't ask for.
 
I expect you to call for the release of Goldwasser, Regev and Shalit.
No strings attached.

I have not seen you do so.

Why is that?
because its self evident. For what its worth of course I call on Hezbolla to release all people they hold. Right now...without conditions. so are you interested on commenting on if you think there is any level of death among Lebanese civilians that you would find unacceptable?
 
The problem is that you cannot track the source, at this point, which means you'll need to dig a little deeper to investigate and determine the sample size, the questions asked, the demographics and methodology of the survey (phone calls, man-in-the-street interviews, internet clicks, what?)

That's the skeptical method; to get the facts.
You cannot dismiss the poll as 'irrelevant' or 'unscientific' just because I haven't offered those details which you're lacking to make a reasoned and logical judgement.

I do wish I could help you further, but it's after 2am on the East Coast of the United States, and I'll respectfully let the matter drop.

First of all, you're the one who grought up that poll to make somekind of a point, so you're the one who should have searched it through. Don't turn the burden of proof on me.

Secondly, how can you expect me to believe this poll to be valid and scientific when the country's population and infrastructures are being bombarded?
 
Its because terrorists are not soldiers, they are citizens who take arms and commit acts of violence. Therefore civilians are going to be killed in the process of trying to kill the terrorists. I wish people would just let the middle east fight, I mean its been going on for 1000’s of years. What makes anyone think the U.S. or EU can stop it now?
 
so are you interested on commenting on if you think there is any level of death among Lebanese civilians that you would find unacceptable?

I really wish you would stop asking this silly, rhetorical question. No reasonable person finds death caused by war to be "acceptable." Indeed, we can all safely conclude that the deaths are mostly tragic, on a personal scale to the very real persons and their family, friends, coworkers, neighbors, and associates.

Modern guerilla warfare is tough to fight, especially in an urban setting. It is tremendously dangerous for the attacking force, who usually suffer casualties that seem to come out of nowhere. It's hard to fight that.

Not only that, but we have some fairly recent history to compare to. The US involvement in the Vietnamese War in the 60s and early 70s was fought on unconventional battlefields. Much of it was during patrols in dense jungle, and some of it took place in small villages, and some in urban settings. The US not only had the Northern Vietnamese Army (NVA) to fight, but it also struggled against a highly organized but disguised Viet Cong (VC) made up of civilian combatants and supporters.

I have friends who were US soldiers who fought in Vietnam. One of them I remember telling me very vividly how small Vietnamese children would bring the American soldiers water from the village while they were maintaining their tanks and armored vehicles. The soldiers would gratefully accept the water. Meanwhile, the young VC supporter was carefully counting the tanks, the soldiers, and noting their positions. He ran back to the village and told the VC combatants the important intelligence about the nearby American forces. Thus, the VC actually deliberately used children as spies against the Americans.

The law of war and human decency get awfully muddy in such circumstances. Once you find out what he is doing, do you allow the boy to return to the village, knowing that he is bringing it information the village inhabitants and surrounding VC and NVA will use to conduct a surprise attack on you? If you take any action against the boy, who bears moral responsibility for your doing so? Surely the village people who relied on him are responsible for placing him in harm's way and making him a combatant or supporter.

The Americans fought the Vietnamese War as a war of attrition. The American generals and the Presidents and their administrations were concerned with body counts. More NVA and VC killed meant American success. The US intended to win the hearts and minds of the South Vietnamese people by convincing them that it was in their best interests to give up and recognize that the US was the superior force, and the one destined to win.

We were wrong to fight the war the way the US did. It should have either stayed out of the Vietnamese conflict altogether, or it should have fought it relentlessly, without restrictions other than those in the law of war, to win. Are the hundreds of thousands of Vietnamese people, soldiers, VC, and other civilians killed during the conflict "acceptable?" What about the 58,000 American servicemen who died there? "Acceptable" or not?

Basically, you are asking a rhetorical question that implies military force is never "acceptable" because it necessarily involves deaths. You are wrong. Death is an inevitable result of warfare. Warfare is unfortunately part of the human condition. Sorry you don't like it, but it's true.

AS
 
"Where is the part where Gur claims Israel dropped brochures to warn Lebanese civilians of an impending attack?
Surely that was also a standard Israeli way of war in '78?"

Well, seems like you are making the claim that they did this, so you supply the evidence.
Actually, I believe the onus is on you to back up your statement. You made the observation of "...the Israeli way of war which does not seem to have changed very much."

I have pointed out one glaring difference that does demonstrate change from the past - the use of flyers dropped in the area to warn civilians of impending attack. Doing that would also imply that Israel is not merely giving lip service about avoiding innocent civilian deaths, but are proactively making the effort.

So do you still stand by the claim that it's business as usual for Israel as per the statements you cited by Gur?
 
This pretty well sums up what I feel about this conflict (Applicable to both sides BTW):

Surgeon Maj. Reynolds: Damn you, Chard! Damn all you butchers!

No excuses acceptable end the buthcery now.
 
This pretty well sums up what I feel about this conflict (Applicable to both sides BTW):

Surgeon Maj. Reynolds: Damn you, Chard! Damn all you butchers!

No excuses acceptable end the buthcery now.

BS. This is part of a much bigger problem than just ending the "butchery." This is an attempt by Israel to mortally wound the military capability of Hezbollah and Hamas, and in the bigger scheme, to continue to demonstrate to its neighbors that it will not succumb to attacks to destoy it.

Israel is not engaged in butchery. It is striking back at forces trying to wipe if off the map.

Damn the empty-headed nonsense spouted by peaceniks.

AS
 
I agree with AUP, the entire Lebanese people are not responsible for the actions of this group of extremists.
:confused: What have you been reading? What is "a group of extremists" to you? They constitute 40% of the LEBANESE people and as such are the LARGEST single group of people in Lebanon, and by all accounts 100% of them support Hizbullah. Add in a few more supporters and you can probably argue they are the absolute majority. Resonsibility ends with who, in your opinion?

I take my own people as an example: Quebecers were not responsible for the actions of the terrorist group FLQ, back in 1970, but yet the Canadian government sent in the armed forces in the streets of Montréal and arrested hundreds of people for no reason.
Are you saying the majority of peoples in Quebec were supporters of the FLQ, but as a minority in Canada they were nevertheless not responsible? I'm sure you don't, but I fail to understand how you think this is a valid analogy. As to "no reason"; what you really mean is that you didn't agree with the "reason". Others probably thought they had one.

But I do agree that the Lebanese government is responsible for letting Hizbollah get away with murder, yet alone become a 'legitimate' political entity. There should have been long ago better efforts to curb them. What is happening right now was IMO inevitable because of that, even though I tend to believe Israel's response was way too extreme. But as I said, it was bound to happen...
Now I'm really confused.:boggled:

Do you or do you not think that peoples, just like individuals, have to live with the consequences of their actions, or inactions?

ETA Particularly when their stated objective is war to the end?
 
Last edited:
:confused: What have you been reading? What is "a group of extremists" to you? They constitute 40% of the LEBANESE people and as such are the LARGEST single group of people in Lebanon, and by all accounts 100% of them support Hizbullah. Add in a few more supporters and you can probably argue they are the absolute majority. Resonsibility ends with who, in your opinion?

Where do you get this 100 % approval? I'd be glad to read where you get your figures. From what I know of Lebanese people where I live, they are very peaceful people, I doubt they all approve of this terrorist organization (at least before the Israeli attacks).

Are you saying the majority of peoples in Quebec were supporters of the FLQ, but as a minority in Canada they were nevertheless not responsible? I'm sure you don't, but I fail to understand how you think this is a valid analogy. As to "no reason"; what you really mean is that you didn't agree with the "reason". Others probably thought they had one.

No, I was saying the majority of Quebecers didn't approve of the FLQ but yet 497 people were arrested, and only 62 were charged. I call that excessive measures. My point of this analogy was that you can't blame an entire people for one group of extremists.

But you're right, it was a clumsy analogy.

Now I'm really confused.:boggled:

Do you or do you not think that peoples, just like individuals, have to live with the consequences of their actions, or inactions?

ETA Particularly when their stated objective is war to the end?

I guess you're right, the Lebanese and their government are responsible for letting Hizbollah remain influent, or even exist. But I still think you can't blame all Lebanese, there's a limit of what innocent civilians can do to change things.

Other reasons explain why the Hizbollah remained influent, you can't blame the Libanese people for everything.

Even Bush said so in his 'talk' with Blair: "We are not blaming the Lebanese government."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom