Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

webfusion,

That slide show of kids in the Middle East dressed as suicide bombers and brandishing AK-47s and M-16s and RPGs was one of the most disturbing things I've ever seen. I've seen pics before, but all of them put together in a 2 minutes slide show was scary.

AS


But, remember, it's not evidence for dustin.
I'm just wasting his valuable time...

and photos of Hezbollah military marches with youngsters in uniform, that's not evidence either.

(people have short memories, really ----- see: RPG kids in Lebanon 1980's)
http://www.me-ontarget.com/2004/march/the_value_of_a_child.html
 
Webfusion, I've asked this question on the "Why people hate Jews" thread, but since it is off topic, I'll ask it again here, because you haven't answered it.

Are three lives worth killing 500 ?

It's not just three lives. It's Hezbollah continueing to shoot at Israeli civilians even though Israel withdrew from Lebanon more than a half a decade ago. It's Lebanon continuing to allow an armed militia on Israel's border even years after the UN has called for its disarmament. It's Iran and Syria continuing to fund Hezbollah with 20 million dollars a month to keep the conflict going. The soldiers are merely the last straw, this conflict needs to end.
 
Webfusion, I've asked this question on the "Why people hate Jews" thread, but since it is off topic, I'll ask it again here, because you haven't answered it.

Are three lives worth killing 500 ?

It's a loaded question, but inevitable and perfectly acceptable to ask.

Although I'm certainly no expert, and I'm not nearly as versed in the motivations as webfusion, let me suggest that perhaps two important principles are at work motivating the Israeli military at the moment.

1) The proud and honorable dedication to their own troops that they will never leave their servicemembers behind, and the commitment and promise to do what is necessary to rescue them, even if it's their dead bodies (many other military forces follow the same tradition and promise, and still others at least ostensibly do so).

2) The commitment to standing up to and defending itself against any threats or force used against Israel's sovereignty. This can also be regarded as a solidarity among the people -- at least the Jewish Israelis -- and the government to maintaining their state at all costs. They waited thousands of years for it, and suffered immensely during that time as refugees all over the world, but they finally got it, and they want more than anything to keep it. This is far more important to the Israeli people than you seem to be allowing for. This is why they will fight to the death if necessary. They mean business.

Now, one must ask are principles ever worth fighting for? If you value human life at all costs at the expense of principles that might be very important, even vital, to you and your people, then you are among those Benjamin Franklin intended to address with his remark, "Those who would trade liberty for security deserve neither."

Millions died in the first world war because of one man's assassination (Ok, Europe was already a powderkeg, and much of the rest of the world was eager to join in to settle scores). Was it worth it?

Tens of millions died in the second world war because England and France declared war on Germany to save face after their promise just one month earlier that they would protect Poland from German aggression at all costs. Were those tens of millions of lives, probably more of them civilians than military personnel, worth sacrificing for the cause?

War is ugly business, but goddammit sometimes it's necessary. This is one of those times.

AS
 
Thanks for taking the time to explain to me your point of view, Webfusion.

I understand it, but I do not share it. I personnally don't think even more violence will make this conflict end. Violence is what they (Hizbollah/Syria/Iran) want, that's what they need to justify even more hatred against Israel. It's an unending circle.
 
Pardalis offers;
Violence is what they (Hizbollah/Syria/Iran) want

Again, you disconnected the second front of the same war, in Gaza (HAMASTAN).
Why do you keep doing that?

I do appreciate being thanked for my taking the effort to provide details, links and evidence (such as it is) about what is going on.
It's a thankless task, and the condemnation and invective will roar along out there in the world, regardless of what I contribute here in this small corner of cyberspace, hosted by James Randi, whose method and whose philosophy I do indeed consider to be appropriate when looking at issues such as this.
 
The local paper had a photo of Israeli children writing messages on shells that were about to be fired at Lebanon.

That's been thoroughly debunked. I suggest you have another look at the picture and see what was ACTUALLY written on the shell.
 
To say that they had time to leave is a wrong argument. That's just a poor excuse to dismiss responsability. As Lief said, it's not enough to give them warnings, you have to give them support and structure for evacuation.




Correct me if I'm wrong, but you appear to be talking about full scale ground invasion of Southern Lebanon...

Yes?

-Andrew
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but you appear to be talking about full scale ground invasion of Southern Lebanon...

Yes?

-Andrew

Hi Gumboot :)

No, I wasn't talking about a full invasion. What I meant, from what I know of the situation, is this:

first of all, Israel started to bomb Lebanese villages without warning, they attacked strategic points and infrastuctures (airports, roads, bridges) which disabled the innocent civilians' ability to actually successfully evacuate.

Then, the remaining people are warned to leave these towns because of impending attacks. Yet, the Israeli give them no time to do so, and start bombing these villages. Even if they have had more time to evacuate, these people are poor and afraid, have no means of escape (remember the roads and bridges are off, or too dangerous). An evacuation of this magnitude takes alot of resources and preparation, you cant' just tell them to leave and eexpect them to.

So, to finish my thought, what I meant to say is that the "the civilians were told to leave, therefore it's not our fault if they die" argument is to me, totally bogus. It's an extremely weak excuse to dismiss the Israeli responsability for the civilian casualties, regardless of if there were Hizbollah in these villages.
 
Hi Gumboot :)

No, I wasn't talking about a full invasion. What I meant, from what I know of the situation, is this:

first of all, Israel started to bomb Lebanese villages without warning, they attacked strategic points and infrastuctures (airports, roads, bridges) which disabled the innocent civilians' ability to actually successfully evacuate.

It's an extremely weak excuse to dismiss the Israeli responsability for the civilian casualties, regardless of if there were Hizbollah in these villages.


I totally agree. :)

Now here is where we may differ... I don't believe Israel needs to be excused. Regardless of how the PR dance around it, Israel is at war with Lebanon. In such a scenario civilians will get killed. As long as Israel is not targetting civilians, their actions do not need to be excused.

However...

Though it wasn't what you meant, your post did get me thinking. I actually think a full scale invasion is the best solution.

The warnings are pointless. The civilians can't realistically evacuate anyway, and all they do is give Hizbollah warning. The problem is relying on airstrikes at all.

The Israeli reliance on air power is misplaced. The US did the same thing during Clinton's administration, after Somalia. Unwilling to commit US soldiers, they figured they could win every conflict by airpower alone.

Airstrikes mean civilian casualties. It means great PR for the enemy. If you want to get rid of something like Hizbollah you have to go in and go door to door. It is dirty, nasty fighting. But it also means less civilian casualties. Look at the Iraq War. The vast majority of civilians killed by the coalition were killed in the opening stages - the invasion itself. Those killed by the coalition since are virtually all from air strikes.

If Lebanon will not get rid of Hizbollah, if the rest of the world will not get rid of them, and if Israel considers them a threat to their security, under Article 51 of the UN Charter Israel has the right to take measures into its own hands to get rid of Hizbollah.

But continual airstrikes won't get rid of Hizbollah. It will kill a lot of civilians. The only way Israel can get rid of them on their own is to flood Southern Lebanon with ground troops, hunt down every Hizbollah member, and kill them. Destroy every bunker. Destroy every weapons cache. And then leave.

-Andrew
 
I totally agree. :)

Now here is where we may differ... I don't believe Israel needs to be excused. Regardless of how the PR dance around it, Israel is at war with Lebanon. In such a scenario civilians will get killed. As long as Israel is not targetting civilians, their actions do not need to be excused.

I somewhat disagree here. Israel is not at war with Lebannon, but with Hizbollah. And to me, to justify their actions, Israel should have waited for an international consensus. But I do agree that Israel is not targeting civilians purposefully, I think this is where Dustin is wrong.

BTW, what is PR?

If Lebanon will not get rid of Hizbollah, if the rest of the world will not get rid of them, and if Israel considers them a threat to their security, under Article 51 of the UN Charter Israel has the right to take measures into its own hands to get rid of Hizbollah.

But continual airstrikes won't get rid of Hizbollah. It will kill a lot of civilians. The only way Israel can get rid of them on their own is to flood Southern Lebanon with ground troops, hunt down every Hizbollah member, and kill them. Destroy every bunker. Destroy every weapons cache. And then leave.

That's a good militaristic approach, but they can't do all that alone. Again, they would need international help. Instead of that, they probably alienated alot of countries, like the US did when they went ahead in Iraq. Even then, military invasion of a country should be the very last option to a conflict, and certainly too extreme measures for a few kidnappings.
 
That's been thoroughly debunked. I suggest you have another look at the picture and see what was ACTUALLY written on the shell.
I think the only thing that could have been "debunked" was various claims about what was written...messages to lebanese children etc....I personally don't care what was written because all I am interested in is who gave the children the marker pens and suggested to them it may be a good Idea to doodle on shells. Its a very old and faithfull propaganda photo idea.....The use of the children makes it particularly obnoxious. The photographer is said to have claimed the parents gave them the markers.....not him.

http://www.cjrdaily.org/behind_the_news/about_those_photos_of_little_g.php
 
But continual airstrikes won't get rid of Hizbollah. It will kill a lot of civilians. The only way Israel can get rid of them on their own is to flood Southern Lebanon with ground troops, hunt down every Hizbollah member, and kill them. Destroy every bunker. Destroy every weapons cache. And then leave.

-Andrew

That was what happened when Sharon invaded Southern Lebanon before, and Hezbollah was created as a response to that invasion.
 
See what they are actually doing is doodling pictures of the Israeli flag. Either they or someone else had written to Nasrallah whit love from Israel on the side.
and then given the children a go?

The level of apologist behavior is getting silly. This is an obnoxious picture and should be condemned....just the same as would happen if it were a picture of Lebanese children doodling on rockets.

Thier parents deserve to have thier arses kicked.
 
I think the only thing that could have been "debunked" was various claims about what was written...messages to lebanese children etc....I personally don't care what was written because all I am interested in is who gave the children the marker pens and suggested to them it may be a good Idea to doodle on shells. Its a very old and faithfull propaganda photo idea.....The use of the children makes it particularly obnoxious. The photographer is said to have claimed the parents gave them the markers.....not him.

http://www.cjrdaily.org/behind_the_news/about_those_photos_of_little_g.php

If it was their parents, then at least it is a kind of genetic stupidity that will be self correcting in the long run.

Convenient how the photographer appears to be wiping his hands of any involvement.

If it was the parents doing, then I wonder if the photographer feels any moral guilt over not stopping those kids. My first thought on seeing a parent doing that would not be to grab my camera (although my first thought would not be to try and stop the kids either, it would be to turn and run).

Edited to add: If its not clear, I agree with what you are saying about the parents. My only comment was about what was written. It was child abuse, but it doesn't seem to have been aimed at Lebanese children.
 
Last edited:
That was what happened when Sharon invaded Southern Lebanon before, and Hezbollah was created as a response to that invasion.


So Israel invaded Lebanon before to get rid of Hizbollah, and it was this invasion (where they came in, got rid of Hizbollah, and left) that CREATED Hizbollah?

Um...

-Andrew
 
If it was the parents doing, then I wonder if the photographer feels any moral guilt over not stopping those kids.



How do you feel about journalists taking photos of victims of war for the use of propaganda?

-Andrew
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom