That's interesting. So for you, turning over your life and will to the care of a higher power actually means being more in control of your life than anyone else because you are not in control? I'm not sure what the "etc etc" could possibly refer to. Usually, "etc" is used when what comes next is obvious, but I can't even imagine what that would be here, unless you went on to assert that up is down and black is white, etc.
I will give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that you are not being deliberately obtuse here.
The point I am making is that very often in life I have no control over certain outcomes; my expectations can be such that when they are not met my disappointment is acute. I often drank on disappointment (eg. ego, self pity and resentments - those old favorites).
For me, handing over my life and my will (in many ways) is to hand over outcomes. eg. If I apply for a job, is it my will that will give it to me? No, I can do my best but I cannot guarantee or be certain of anything.
I might want to live to be 100 years old; do I have control over that? Hardly.
As I said, for me it is about managing expectations, not relinquishing control of my life, but 'handing over' (or letting go) of the things I can't. See also the serenity prayer/affirmation.
Worst story I ever heard was board meeting or something where many veterans with +5 years got into a huge argument over management and
everybody went out and got drunk!
And of course you have evidence for this.
Amazing, thank you!
http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm
A picture perfect view of some of the things AA fails to pay attention to or willfully ignores.
Can you tell me what the success measure is here?
What I mean is how long are people sober after the action is taken. Are we saying that people who do a detox have 'x' success because they stayed there for a week and AA doesn't because someone left after a solitary meeting and drank.
Seriously, what are the measures?
Wow, if by stubbies you mean beer or other alcohol, wow. that is a very tolerant meeting. I think most groups will not tolerate you drinking, I know some groups ask people to leave who are intoxicated.
If they are being disruptive to the meeting they would (probably) be guided out for a quiet discussion outside, but that has happened with sober people too.
I have seen drunk people in meetings many times: "the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking".
Stubby = beer.
375ml. 4.9% alcohol/vol
That is why a new tradition would be a good remedy.
I think this would be a great idea.
The idea that someone can't quit drinking on their own is just fiction. Most people do.
And many people don't. Go figure.
I thought you guys might be interested in this story, about a couple of secular AA groups who were purged from the local AA schedules, because if you take the God out, it's not AA anymore. I posted about it here:
stinkin-thinkin.com/2011/06/04/clowns-to-the-left-of-me/
Correct me if I am wrong, but if you take the God (of your understanding) out, you basically have the SMART program or something along similar lines.
Because all men want a nice BJ, and the 13th step is just a way to get there.
Don't get me wrong, I think the deliberate predators that are about are awful. Moreover, I take an active role in educating the women I meet that are new to AA as well as in my work about the occasional danger that can pop up (er... so to speak) when they are early in and confused.
There are also predatory women and men who chase money or other symbols - being slightly famous can also be a drawback. These too are dangerous in any community setting and AA often warns against these perils in circulars etc.
That said, if there was anything illegal that happened I would hope that things were reported to the authorities immediately. For example, a rape case.
Now, would AA be drawn in and charged, or just the individual that perpetrated the crime?
Does AA support rape and 13th stepping - of course not.
Was Bill a pants man - by best estimates, sure.
Was it illegal? No
Was it reprehensible? Quite probably.
In a 13th step situation: Did AA support or facilitate this behavior or were there two individuals (adults by the way) that acted of their own volition. And was it a situation where both are responsible for their actions.
Again, I do not apologise for 13th steppers, the predators are reprehensible.
I have warned women (and men) of the perils of being 13th stepped, however that advice has often been ignored, sometimes and sadly with catastrophic results.