I am addressing Tinyal specifically: He says that "AA is religious" and that "it doesn't work" (or very similar). He is two decades sober yet he is an atheist. How? How if it doesn't work? How if one has to be religious for it to work? And how did he get and stay sober for all those years. He is a walking contradiction yet refuses to explain these paradoxes.
It seems he also contuinues to attend AA even though he doesn't believe in it. Why? As an example of how it doesn't work!?! Or is it something I am yet to understand?
Normally, I ignore your posts AA Alfie - not because I dislike you personally, but because I believe you don't pay attention to what I am typing - my belief (which I believe I can justify, if needed & if I cared enough to) is that you have some kind of blinders on when you read posts critical of AA.
Be that as it may, I am choosing to respond to this one post of yours as I think you have raised a valid question - one that I shall attempt to answer for the benefit of any new readers. (yet again - for those who have been here since the beginning of this post, they will recall that I've repeated what I'm about to say elsewhere previously in this thread).
I will answer the second of your questions first, which I shall take the liberty of summarizing as 'why do I continue to attend AA if I think it doesn't work any better than not attending?'. Repeating myself,
I have been going to AA for the express purpose of demonstrating, through my speeches & 'sharing' my experiences at AA meetings & conferences all across the western US, that no God (the god of Bill W & AA as a whole), no higher power of any kind is necessary to get sober , to stay sober, nor to live a fulfilling, productive life as a sober individual..
Additionally, I point out the benefits of
people with problems meeting regularly with others who have similar problems to talk/share/hash out solutions, to get together for support (which happens to be the
only thing of value I believe AA provides - and it is very important, in my view perhaps even
critical to a healthy lifestyle).
In addition, I frequently speak on the great number of basically illformed, even inane statements found within the AA program (targeting the chapters 'We Agnostics' & 'To The Wives'). I also make myself available after nearly every meeting to give out information on alternatives to AA such as SOS & SMART, to those who express interest.
As for your first question, something I will summarize as 'how did I get sober as an atheist if AA doesn't work',
I got sober the same way everyone else does - by coming to a realization (some come to it quickly, others much more slowly - and many never do) that
I am in control of what I put in my body, that no one forced me to drink/drug, that I continued to use because I liked the effect even tho it was killing me and damaging many people around me. Upon this realization, action followed -
action to change my habits and behaviors using my own willpower (the only power I have, as no gods of any kind exist - and if they did,
they'd be the ones forcing me to drink in the first place). A realization that for one reason or another (possibly genetic, possibly not) my body cannot tolerate any amount of alcholol, and I need to avoid consuming it if I am to live a happy productive life.
I have personally consoled (AA might call it 'sponsorship')
hundreds of people who have a problem with the christian centered god of AA , who have a problem with AA's
insistence that one must turn one's life over to something else, that reason and logic needs to take a back seat to Faith (the faith of Bill W & Dr. Bob, specifically), and who have a legitimate problem with the demeaning, stupid talk of AA that says I'm both powerless and a sinner.
I certainly don't try to 'convert' to nontheism any AA members or potential members who are happy with the religious focus of AA. I will state the few facts we do have, from several studies, on the ineffectiveness of AA. I will state it's dismal success rate, it's focus on sins & the christian god, on
the fact that it's not a quit-drinking program but a faith & religion gaining program.
In a nutshell, this is why I continue to attend AA. This is how I got - and
stay - sober. And the roughly 10% of AA members who are nontheist (as well as those forced by the court to attend) my benefit from my experience - I have been told by many that they agree with me, including many with more sober time than I have. I - and they - try to be a
reasonable voice of hope without some silly,
untrue & unnecessary 'faith in a higher power'. (note the word '
reasonable')
I hope that answers your questions - do me and the other posters & readers here a favor and
try to read my posts this time, reading the actual black stuff between the white spaces -
I have said all of the above before in this very thread. Thanks.