Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Marcus, do you mind clarifying for me precisely what I said - anywhere in this thread - that gave you the impression (wholly mistaken, in my view), that I advocated avoiding personal responsibility???
For the life of me, I cannot see how you came to that conclusion from anything I've said - does anyone else see that I have done so, anywhere??

I was very puzzled by that claim too. I re-read the post he was responding to several times looking for evidence of his assertion., but I didn't find any.

GB
 
Marcus, do you mind clarifying for me precisely what I said - anywhere in this thread - that gave you the impression (wholly mistaken, in my view), that I advocated avoiding personal responsibility???
For the life of me, I cannot see how you came to that conclusion from anything I've said - does anyone else see that I have done so, anywhere??

No I don't.
Personal responsibility is one of the cornerstones for recovery.

But on another topic Tinya;

Did AA - a supposedly religious organisation" get an atheist sober? It seems not to make sense to me unless.....
as I have said all along, that it (religion) isn't a prerequisite for recovery, but it is just one of the options on offer within the framework that is AA?

Do you think I am correct here?
 
No I don't.
Personal responsibility is one of the cornerstones for recovery.

But on another topic Tinya;

Did AA - a supposedly religious organisation" get an atheist sober? It seems not to make sense to me unless.....
as I have said all along, that it (religion) isn't a prerequisite for recovery, but it is just one of the options on offer within the framework that is AA?

Do you think I am correct here?

I think you aren't addressing the point, really. Or you're missing it, or something.

That an atheist can utilize AA to get and stay sober hasn't really anything to do with it being an organization with a religious bent.

If it (religion) is seen by some as a "prerequisite for recovery," it's probably because the notion is in the Twelve Steps. But even if religion is not a prerequisite, it's still a heavy influence.

The thread title asks "Why do people not see AA as religious?"
I'd ask that also. It appears religious to me.
 
I think you aren't addressing the point, really. Or you're missing it, or something.

That an atheist can utilize AA to get and stay sober hasn't really anything to do with it being an organization with a religious bent.

If it (religion) is seen by some as a "prerequisite for recovery," it's probably because the notion is in the Twelve Steps. But even if religion is not a prerequisite, it's still a heavy influence.

The thread title asks "Why do people not see AA as religious?"
I'd ask that also. It appears religious to me.

I am addressing Tinyal specifically: He says that "AA is religious" and that "it doesn't work" (or very similar). He is two decades sober yet he is an atheist. How? How if it doesn't work? How if one has to be religious for it to work? And how did he get and stay sober for all those years. He is a walking contradiction yet refuses to explain these paradoxes.
It seems he also contuinues to attend AA even though he doesn't believe in it. Why? As an example of how it doesn't work!?! Or is it something I am yet to understand?
 
I am addressing Tinyal specifically: He says that "AA is religious" and that "it doesn't work" (or very similar). He is two decades sober yet he is an atheist. How? How if it doesn't work? How if one has to be religious for it to work? And how did he get and stay sober for all those years. He is a walking contradiction yet refuses to explain these paradoxes.
It seems he also contuinues to attend AA even though he doesn't believe in it. Why? As an example of how it doesn't work!?! Or is it something I am yet to understand?

Normally, I ignore your posts AA Alfie - not because I dislike you personally, but because I believe you don't pay attention to what I am typing - my belief (which I believe I can justify, if needed & if I cared enough to) is that you have some kind of blinders on when you read posts critical of AA.
Be that as it may, I am choosing to respond to this one post of yours as I think you have raised a valid question - one that I shall attempt to answer for the benefit of any new readers. (yet again - for those who have been here since the beginning of this post, they will recall that I've repeated what I'm about to say elsewhere previously in this thread).

I will answer the second of your questions first, which I shall take the liberty of summarizing as 'why do I continue to attend AA if I think it doesn't work any better than not attending?'. Repeating myself, I have been going to AA for the express purpose of demonstrating, through my speeches & 'sharing' my experiences at AA meetings & conferences all across the western US, that no God (the god of Bill W & AA as a whole), no higher power of any kind is necessary to get sober , to stay sober, nor to live a fulfilling, productive life as a sober individual..
Additionally, I point out the benefits of people with problems meeting regularly with others who have similar problems to talk/share/hash out solutions, to get together for support (which happens to be the only thing of value I believe AA provides - and it is very important, in my view perhaps even critical to a healthy lifestyle).
In addition, I frequently speak on the great number of basically illformed, even inane statements found within the AA program (targeting the chapters 'We Agnostics' & 'To The Wives'). I also make myself available after nearly every meeting to give out information on alternatives to AA such as SOS & SMART, to those who express interest.

As for your first question, something I will summarize as 'how did I get sober as an atheist if AA doesn't work', I got sober the same way everyone else does - by coming to a realization (some come to it quickly, others much more slowly - and many never do) that I am in control of what I put in my body, that no one forced me to drink/drug, that I continued to use because I liked the effect even tho it was killing me and damaging many people around me. Upon this realization, action followed - action to change my habits and behaviors using my own willpower (the only power I have, as no gods of any kind exist - and if they did, they'd be the ones forcing me to drink in the first place). A realization that for one reason or another (possibly genetic, possibly not) my body cannot tolerate any amount of alcholol, and I need to avoid consuming it if I am to live a happy productive life.

I have personally consoled (AA might call it 'sponsorship') hundreds of people who have a problem with the christian centered god of AA , who have a problem with AA's insistence that one must turn one's life over to something else, that reason and logic needs to take a back seat to Faith (the faith of Bill W & Dr. Bob, specifically), and who have a legitimate problem with the demeaning, stupid talk of AA that says I'm both powerless and a sinner.

I certainly don't try to 'convert' to nontheism any AA members or potential members who are happy with the religious focus of AA. I will state the few facts we do have, from several studies, on the ineffectiveness of AA. I will state it's dismal success rate, it's focus on sins & the christian god, on the fact that it's not a quit-drinking program but a faith & religion gaining program.

In a nutshell, this is why I continue to attend AA. This is how I got - and stay - sober. And the roughly 10% of AA members who are nontheist (as well as those forced by the court to attend) my benefit from my experience - I have been told by many that they agree with me, including many with more sober time than I have. I - and they - try to be a reasonable voice of hope without some silly, untrue & unnecessary 'faith in a higher power'. (note the word 'reasonable')

I hope that answers your questions - do me and the other posters & readers here a favor and try to read my posts this time, reading the actual black stuff between the white spaces - I have said all of the above before in this very thread. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
I will answer the second of your questions first, which I shall take the liberty of summarizing as 'why do I continue to attend AA if I think it doesn't work any better than not attending?'. Repeating myself, I have been going to AA for the express purpose of demonstrating, through my speeches & 'sharing' my experiences at AA meetings & conferences all across the western US, that no God (the god of Bill W & AA as a whole), no higher power of any kind is necessary to get sober , to stay sober, nor to live a fulfilling, productive life as a sober individual..

.. snip ..

Thanks.

And I agree with you. No God is required which therefore seems to confirm that AA is not religious but spiritual.

You seem to be saying (like I do) that the religious aspect of AA can be ignored. Yes?
That seems to fly in the face of some other things you say.

I also say to people they can let go of the god stuff if they like, their hp (or pgtm) can be something else; as AA itself seems to be with you.

This also seems to fly in the face of your arguments that AA doesn't work - and I agree in part; it doesn't work for everyone and it never will. Those that don't like AA can go elsewhere, there are other programs that have equally bad (or worse) recovery rates than AA.

In spite of what some say, AA has never said it has the market cornered on recovery. Nor has it said it is "the only" way. Individual members might, but they do not represent AA (nor does Bill W btw).

On the big book and other literature, I also agree: There is a lot in there that is outdated, even silly. But by and large they are one man's opinions; he is not (dare I say it?) God, and never professed to be. Nor is he is our "leader"; simply another member sharing his experience strength and hope, just as you do.

So while I can agree with much of what you have said above, I cannot understand why you try and tear AA down when:
- it clearly does help people.
- it helped get you and me sober.
- it does help others get sober.
- it gives people hope
- it is not a religious organisation (you are proof) yet it can be religious if you want it to be. It can also be a place to make friends if you want it to be. A place to learn lifeskills, if you want it to be. A place for community service, if you want it to be.
- etc etc.

I do not agree with you when you say that it a recruiting place for a Christian religion when there are huge percentages that are neither religious nor Christian (you and me as examples, both with long term sobriety). AA is not affiliated with any church and in practice everyone is welcomed. That said, there are some zealots on the Christian/religious side. There are other zealots on the other side to; I see you as one of the atheist zealots on the other extreme. Am I right? What would your friends say?

My bottom line has been and always will be "take what you need and leave the rest"; many "leave" the religion and still get sober with AA, with or without the steps. Neither is a prerequisite.

All that aside, your explanation still makes little sense when one considers you think AA is religious, yet you are an atheist, and AA helped get you sober.

Take what you need, and leave the rest.
 
Last edited:
I'm getting one of those funny feelings again that some evidence needs to be reposted. Oddly enough it's a repost of a repost. But people tend to forget that their argument has clearly been refuted if the evidence isn't posted on a regular basis.

I've posted this before, but I think it's worth posting again to illustrate a point.

The Secular 12 Steps

1. We admitted we were powerless over addiction--that our lives had become unmanageable.

2. Came to believe that The Program, as a power greater than ourselves, could help us toward normal living.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care this program and to the loving care of this group.

4. Made a searching and fearless inventory of our character for ourselves.

5. Admitted to our group, to ourselves and to another human being the exact nature of our faults and misdeeds.

6. Were entirely ready to practice the program in order to remove our defects of character.

7. Humbly asked the help of others in the removal of our short comings and resolved to work to remove these faults ourselves.

8. Made a list of all persons we harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people whenever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly admitted it.

11. Sought through study and meditation to improve our awareness of law and of the natural forces that govern life hoping only for knowledge of right and wrong and the strength to follow that knowledge.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to addicts and to practice these principles in all our affairs.

Alrighty then, now I think there are a host of problematic issues with the above is it simply substitutes The Programme, or The Group, for God, without actually changing the Doctrines (see Qayaks Group-Think post for details).

But I would concede that the above Secular 12 Steps are "Spiritual but not Religious."

Now compare it with AA's (almost) original 12 Steps that continues to be the core document (along with the Big Book) of AA.

Service Material from the General Service Office
THE TWELVE STEPS OF ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS

1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become
unmanageable.

2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to
sanity.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.

4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make
amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do
so would injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly
admitted it.

11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to
carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our
affairs.

It's very obvious when they are side by side. AA's 12 Steps include a Deity. By definition the Steps are Religious. AA is a Religious programme BY DEFINITION. It is thus "Spiritual AND Religious.

So pretend all you like that it's not a Religious Programme, but until AA adopts the Secular 12 Steps (and relegates the Big Book as it currently stands to an Historical Archive) it will remain a Religious Programme.

There really is no legitimate argument you guys can possibly come up with to demonstrate otherwise.

However, as I have ALSO stated previously, there is nothing wrong with AA being a Religious Programme (as long as the judicial system doesn't force people to attend). What is wrong, is pretending it's not Religious.

In fact, the Pretense is a Violation of the Step that calls for a "searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves."

GB
 
Marcus, do you mind clarifying for me precisely what I said - anywhere in this thread - that gave you the impression (wholly mistaken, in my view), that I advocated avoiding personal responsibility???
For the life of me, I cannot see how you came to that conclusion from anything I've said - does anyone else see that I have done so, anywhere??
I'm sorry, I misspoke, what I meant to say was that you were advocating personal responsibility by making the statements that you did.

The ones avoiding personal responsibility are those who insist on a higher power.
 
Wiki? Please!

Source aside, what information in there troubles you the most?

The only people who have a problem with me sourcing wikipedia these days are the twoofers I talk to on youtube. Those little blue numbers? You can click on them, and they take you to links to reliable references, like the Cochrane study. Where did the Cochrane analysis go wrong in your scientific opinion?

What troubles me is A.A. is a cult that is uninterested in using science to better themselves or criticize themselves.
 
The only people who have a problem with me sourcing wikipedia these days are the twoofers I talk to on youtube. Those little blue numbers? You can click on them, and they take you to links to reliable references, like the Cochrane study. Where did the Cochrane analysis go wrong in your scientific opinion?

What troubles me is A.A. is a cult that is uninterested in using science to better themselves or criticize themselves.

I don't know about "twoofers" (whatever they are :confused:), but I think Wikipedia is one of the most reliable information sources devised. They are well moderated, and regularly updated.

GB
 
Another very reliable site is urban dictionary! ;) for other reasons tho...

Really they were asking for it, calling themselves the "truth movement" when it's all woo! Magical thermite and spacebeams...
 
The only people who have a problem with me sourcing wikipedia these days are the twoofers I talk to on youtube.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed personal comments


Those little blue numbers? You can click on them, and they take you to links to reliable references, like the Cochrane study. Where did the Cochrane analysis go wrong in your scientific opinion?

They say...

"no experimental studies unequivocally demonstrated the effectiveness of AA" in treating alcoholism

Presumably that means they also found that: no experimental studies unequivocally demonstrated the non-effectiveness of AA" in treating alcoholism, either.
It does sound rather inconclusive and one or two other statements suggest that also:

further efficacy studies are needed,

Perhaps you can direct me to their studies on other forms of treatment so we can compare success (or otherwise). I am happy to wait.

It seems to me this proves not a thing one way or another. And I remain confused as to what your actual point is.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Another very reliable site is urban dictionary! ;) for other reasons tho...

Really they were asking for it, calling themselves the "truth movement" when it's all woo! Magical thermite and spacebeams...

Ah! I see. I tend to stay away from large groups of people that self-identify with silly names (like AA, Truthers, Birthers etc). But I also tend not to conflate Magic and Space Beams with Thermite. ;)

GB
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed previously moderated content and response to same

They say...

"no experimental studies unequivocally demonstrated the effectiveness of AA" in treating alcoholism

Presumably that means they also found that: no experimental studies unequivocally demonstrated the non-effectiveness of AA" in treating alcoholism, either.
This is a meta analysis of randomized controlled studies.
It does sound rather inconclusive and one or two other statements suggest that also:

further efficacy studies are needed,
All Cochrane reviews say stuff like this, it's akin to legalese, for evidence of this you will find many skeptical doctors complaining about this type of language in their blogposts about Cochrane reviews on CAM.

Perhaps you can direct me to their studies on other forms of treatment so we can compare success (or otherwise). I am happy to wait.
How about you read and attempt to comprehend the entire review and get back to me on this (it's quite long) I'm happy to wait.

It seems to me this proves not a thing one way or another. And I remain confused as to what your actual point is.
AA is a cult and it doesn't work, doesn't care to improve, and science-based medicine pwns j00.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed previously moderated content and response to same


The reason I talk to twoofers on youtube is I'm interested in understanding them so I can maybe help them change. I've actually been successful at this. I'm trying to help them, I'm not talking to them for perverse pleasure if that's your assumption...

How noble.

:rolleyes:

This is a meta analysis of randomized controlled studies.
All Cochrane reviews say stuff like this, it's akin to legalese, for evidence of this you will find many skeptical doctors complaining about this type of language in their blogposts about Cochrane reviews on CAM.

Sure, but the author actually confirms my initial point with this:

Although one small study reported AA had better abstinence outcomes than a comparison treatment, there is no conclusive evidence to show that AA can help patients to achieve abstinence, nor is there any conclusive evidence to show that it cannot.

Did you say something about scientific?

But just what do you actually think the study concludes? What is your point exactly. For the life of me I have no idea.

How about you read and attempt to comprehend

Right back at you.
Like I said, what do you think it says? Given the author says:

It should also be underlined that in the available studies all the interventions appeared to improve at least some of the outcomes considered.

"Improve some of the outcomes", that sounds a lot to me like there is er... some improvement (i assume that means the treatment helps?) :D

So what's your point exactly? :)

I am happy to wait, I am also happy to wait on the results of the efficacy of other therapies apart from the very small sample they have used in this study. :boggled:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
How noble.

:rolleyes:
Oh isn't that what they all say. It's quite sad and funny that you think my interest in cult deprogramming is somehow not respectable seeing as A.A. is a cult
Sure, legalese for they are pretty much inconclusive and can't stand behind their findings one way or another. Did you say something about scientific?
They stand behind what it says in their results, you can twist their words, that's not science. I know, it's beyond your understanding.
But just what do you actually think the study concludes? What is your point exactly. For the life of me I have no idea.
I think it concludes what is says it concludes. I guess you don't like reading scientific documents very much. I do.
Like I said, what do you think it says? What's your point?
Unlike you I prefer to look at data and make the reasonable inferrences and I don't try to poke holes in things I don't understand. You're criticizing the study from reading a few lines on wikipedia. That was huge news 5 years ago the fact you are just hearing about it from me now is hilarious to me, you have absolutely no idea what's going on. Read the entire pdf file and then complain about what it says in it or don't comment.
I am happy to wait, I am also happy to wait on the results of the efficacy of other therapies apart from the very small sample they have used.
8 trials combined and 3417 patients. Like others have said you aren't much worth responding to.
 
Last edited:
LOL

So you either haven't read it or haven’t understood it yourself. I don’t think it says what you think it does (not that anyone could possibly understand your point yet given you haven't told us). :rolleyes:

What do you think it says?

The author says:

It should also be underlined that in the available studies all the interventions appeared to improve at least some of the outcomes considered.

"Improve some of the outcomes" for “all the interventions”, that sounds a lot to me like there is er... some improvement (I assume that means the treatment helps in AA too? Hmm?:rolleyes:)

So. What is your point exactly? :boggled:

What was that you said about a sore loser. Ha!

See ya. Thanks for playing. :)
 
Last edited:
Usually when I say something stupid and someone corrects me I say, Oh whoops, thanks you're right! A small sample Alfie?
WHAT DO YOU THINK IT SAYS?
What I think doesn't matter Alfie, are you trying to get me to say something you can attack because you can't refute the study. Author's conclusions: Implications for practice:
People considering attending AA or TSF programmes should be
made aware that there is a lack of experimental evidence on the
effectiveness of such programmes.
That's fair enough for me.
Given the author says:

It should also be underlined that in the available studies all the interventions appeared to improve at least some of the outcomes considered.

"Improve some of the outcomes", that sounds a lot to me like there is er... some improvement (i assume that means the treatment helps?
What are those outcomes that are improved? You'd know and would mention them if you read the study. It's not that long. I'll give you a hint: they are not the most important ones, thus the conclusion...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom