Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joey, ... big snip of yawn...

HEY TINYAL?

I will ask this again. Each time you don't respond you look sillier and sillier.

Tinyal. Did AA help you get sober and stay sober even though you are an atheist?
If you are an atheist in this supposedly religious organisation, how did you get to such dizzying heights of the heirarchy (of which you were only a trusted servant btw)? Did you perhaps lie for all those years about your religious convictions? Or maybe it's simply because no-one gives a toss about religion or otherwise as the primary purpose is to simply get people sober?

You are a true paradox mate.

Waiting.....

They have been pointed out to you on numerous occasions and yet you still can't fing the posts. A newcomer would think you are not being honest. Of course, I'm not a newcomer and so I know you aren't.

No they have not been shown and they are not there. These claims were made earlier in the thread and were never responded to in any manner that proved what is being said. I recall a link to an AA website (whoopdedoo) which gave us nothing and a reference to "half measures availed us nothing". There are no claims made by AA along the lines that have been suggested. If they were it woiuld be a simple matter of producing them wouldn't it?

I can't find what is non existent.

I would think that someone claiming to be a professional counsellor would know that but that claim has never been verified although you stated you would provide the evidence at the very beginning of the thread.

Whether you believe that I am a counsellor or not matters not to me. In the meantime, I will do my job with hundreds of people each year, trying to assist with their problems in areas of AOD, relationships, anger, domestic violence etc. Whether you belive me or not is not my problem.

For a number of reasons that may or may not be obvious, I prefer to remain anonymous. Whilst I do not recall actually saying I would provide evidence to what my vocation is (and I'm not saying I didn't), if I did, I have changed my mind. Get over it.

You wouldn't know the truth if it bit you in your donkey.

I would know the truth if you produced it.
It's so simple: Put up or shut up.

And leave my donkey out of it.

Read the thread for once.

I have, and guess what IT'S NOT THERE, it is impossible to find what is not there. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
No they have not been shown and they are not there. These claims were made earlier in the thread and were never responded to in any manner that proved what is being said. I recall a link to an AA website (whoopdedoo) which gave us nothing and a reference to "half measures availed us nothing". There are no claims made by AA along the lines that have been suggested. If they were it woiuld be a simple matter of producing them wouldn't it?


What specifically are you wanting evidence for again?
 
Whether you believe that I am a counsellor or not matters not to me. In the meantime, I will do my job with hundreds of people each year, trying to assist with their problems in areas of AOD, relationships, anger, domestic violence etc. Whether you belive me or not is not my problem.

Actually, I don't care what you do. If you are a counsellor all I can say is "pity your clients."

For a number of reasons that may or may not be obvious, I prefer to remain anonymous. Whilst I do not recall actually saying I would provide evidence to what my vocation is (and I'm not saying I didn't), if I did, I have changed my mind. Get over it.

You can't remember that just like you can't remember anything else from the post. Your behaviour is quite pathetic and very unbecoming a profession af your great stature. :rolleyes:

I can see why you don't want to admit who you are. You would be quite embarassed if any of your clients or co-workers were to know it's you. :p

I would know the truth if you produced it.
It's so simple: Put up or shut up.

Another lie by you as evidence by all your other lies in this thread.

And leave my donkey out of it.

It's the best, most intelligent, part of you. :D


I have, and guess what IT'S NOT THERE, it is impossible to find what is not there. :rolleyes:

Too late for that lie. You've already admitted you don't remember what has been posted in this thread. Read.

Ahhhhhh, Alfie. 'Tis like shooting fish in a barrel. But, even that gets boring after a time. :p
 
What specifically are you wanting evidence for again?

See 3383, 3389, 3395 and 3393 for the claims and requests.

In the meantime I notice that Q has nothing but abuse and insults. Most rational people would simply find the posts in question as I have here.
 
Actually, I don't care what you do. If you are a counsellor all I can say is "pity your clients."

Meh. They keep coming back.

You can't remember that just like you can't remember anything else from the post.

That's right, my memory isn't infallible and anyone claiming there's is is a liar.
Interestingly you can't remember not posting the evidence.

I can see why you don't want to admit who you are. You would be quite embarassed if any of your clients or co-workers were to know it's you.

Not even close. But keep guessing, I am more than happy to play this game.

Another lie by you as evidence by all your other lies in this thread.

Prove the lie. Show me the evidence! :)

It's the best, most intelligent, part of you.

Perrhaps, but it produces a power greater than you. :D


Put up or shut up.
 
Last edited:
It's common knowledge that members are threatened with jails, institution or death if they leave. They say "If you can get sober on your own, you're not an alcoholic". Every meeting someone says if they stopped going to meetings they would die. This is a cult. It's very easy for some idiot to claim that "you can take what you want and you're not forced to stay." But really, how honest is that in such a climate? I already showed how they used mind control.

There are horror stories after horror stories that never seem to happen in hospital environments managed by real professionals. 13th stepping, coaching people off their meds because that's not in the program, "disconnection" all your friends are suddenly in A.A., you're being coached to disconnect from your disapproving family because they are "getting in the way of your sobriety. It goes on and on, this stuff is happening because it's a whacked out cult, go ahead apologize for it.

And it looks like Tinyal was talking about Vaillant

Not only had we failed to alter the natural history of alcoholism, but our death rate of three percent a year was appalling.

Don't listen to the cult apologists or pay attention to this immature conversation. This isn't some conspiracy theory or hidden secret, this debate has been over for decades. Ignore the issues at the peril of those who will suffer from more quack treatment in the future.

http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-effectiveness.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effectiveness_of_Alcoholics_Anonymous

A 2006 Cochrane systematic review by Ferri et al on studies of alcohol treatment conducted between 1966 and 2005 that investigated the efficacy of both AA and non-AA twelve-step program attendance, concluded that "no experimental studies unequivocally demonstrated the effectiveness of AA" in treating alcoholism

Quacks.
 
Last edited:
See 3383, 3389, 3395 and 3393 for the claims and requests.

In the meantime I notice that Q has nothing but abuse and insults. Most rational people would simply find the posts in question as I have here.


Ah. I would have appreciated just a few words telling me again rather than providing some unlinked post numbers for me.

All you had to do was say: evidence of harm

and

evidence of "AA is the only way"


Anyway... I'd like to know first what you consider to be harm in this context then. I, for one, am not going to do a whole lot of research to provide evidence and then have you try and discount them by claiming it's not harm.

I may not do the research anyway, but if you're sincere, then I'd appreciate an honest, councilor-like response to what you consider harm to be.


As far as AA saying it's the only way...


"...you may be suffering from an illness which only a spiritual experience will conquer..."

"At first some of us tried to avoid the issue, hoping against hope we were not true alcoholics. But after a while we had to face the fact that we must find a spiritual basis of life — or else."
The Big Book, 3rd Edition, page 44.

"...he was insisting that he had found the only cure."
The Big Book, 3rd Edition, page 257.

"...they had found the only remedy..."
The Big Book, 3rd Edition, page 259.

"Any willing newcomer feels sure A.A. is the only safe harbor for the foundering vessel he has become."
Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, Bill Wilson, page 35.

"Unless each A.A. member follows to the best of his ability our suggested Twelve Steps to recovery, he almost certainly signs his own death warrant."
Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, Bill Wilson, page 174.

"If you don't Work The Program, then your fate will be "Jails, Institutions, Or Death".

The last is a slogan that I've personally heard at nearly every meeting I've been to and is a well-known slogan in the program.
 
Have I somehow contradicted myself? I said your turd could be your HP (or PGTY) and it can, I just personally don't see how.
Edited by LashL: 
Removed quote of moderated content.


In the meantime, have you dropped the pretense that you have evidence that AA "does harm" and that it (AA) says it is "the only way".

Edited by LashL: 
Removed quote of moderated content.

I have basically decided not to pay much attention to your arguments, as I've heard them all before, and it's not really productive for me to continue beating a dead horse... :deadhorse ...with you while I have thread newbies to argue with.

Please don't take offense; :) it's just that we've been over so much old ground together, I doubt it's worth your time too.

However, I thought your point regarding "harm" was worth responding to, for the sake of the Thread Newbies.

Harm, on an individual level, is really difficult to quantify, so I don't bother with that end of things on this thread (especially as Tinyal, and DD, are likely more qualified than me to do so), despite my interests in psychology.

The biggest, and most quantifiable Harm, is the Harm to the Culture and to Politics, and in that respect it is no different from any religious movement's effects on Society in any given geopolitical arena. As a sociologist and as an historian of comparative theology, mythology, and philosophy; it is the effects of religious ideologies on society as a whole that interests me the most.

Of course whether these effects are viewed as harmful or beneficial depends on whether one accepts and embraces the dominant ideologies, or not.

Coming out of the Protestant Puritanism that fueled the Temperance Movements leading up to Prohibition; AA bears all the hallmarks of those religious ideologies, even in its modern semi-(pseudo)-Universal version. And AA, through active proselytizing over several generations, became the de-facto model (particularly in the US) for what I call Addiction Ideology. Numerous films and TV programmes have promoted AA, and continue to do so today. AA's Addiction Ideology helped fuel the Drug War and Reagan's "Just say No" initiative.

Many of the AA laity will argue that this is not so; that AA does not proselytize. Despite the fact that the 12th step promotes proselytizing, and the fact that AA's official website has a number of outreach programmes (aka, propaganda) directed towards the Media, the Judiciary, and the Employer.

So if you love the Drug War, and Cultural Puritanism, you will no doubt see the effects of AA's religious propaganda as beneficial to society. I, for one, do not.


GB
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ah. I would have appreciated just a few words telling me again rather than providing some unlinked post numbers for me.

All you had to do was say: evidence of harm

and

evidence of "AA is the only way"

I felt you would have a better feel by reading the posts in their entirety.

Anyway... I'd like to know first what you consider to be harm in this context then. I, for one, am not going to do a whole lot of research to provide evidence and then have you try and discount them by claiming it's not harm.

Actually that was my question too. The claim of "harm" was made by others, I wanted to know in what context they thought harm was. I still do.
 
As far as AA saying it's the only way...
Dude you forgot "Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path" (especially hilarious in light of the Cochrane review) I mean they drill that lie into your head every night with no evidence? Atrocious.
 
I felt you would have a better feel by reading the posts in their entirety.

Alright, thank you! :)



Actually that was my question too. The claim of "harm" was made by others, I wanted to know in what context they thought harm was. I still do.

Would you be satisfied by a definition by myself or another "on my side" as it were?



Dude you forgot "Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path" (especially hilarious in light of the Cochrane review) I mean they drill that lie into your head every night with no evidence? Atrocious.


Yes, that's another. I had forgotten it, as a matter of fact. It seems to be a sort-of reverse of the "AA is the only way" mantra.
 
Have I somehow contradicted myself? I said your turd could be your HP (or PGTY) and it can, I just personally don't see how. It wouldn't work for me, but I can certainly see it working for you; like attracting like and all that :p

In the meantime, have you dropped the pretense that you have evidence that AA "does harm" and that it (AA) says it is "the only way".

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for Rule 0.

Your post is evidence that an emotional attachment to AA can harm your membership status here.
 
Alright, thank you! :)

Would you be satisfied by a definition by myself or another "on my side" as it were?

I would be interested to have a look at where it was coming from, that was my question all along. What is meant by harm?

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/harm

Definition of HARM
1: physical or mental damage : injury
2: mischief, hurt

Examples of HARM
They threatened him with bodily harm.
The scandal has done irreparable harm to his reputation.
She'll do anything to protect her children from harm.
They have suffered serious physical harm.
These new regulations could cause lasting harm to small businesses.


I would have imagined harm would be along these lines, so I would be interested to see something around same.
 
Yes, that's another. I had forgotten it, as a matter of fact. It seems to be a sort-of reverse of the "AA is the only way" mantra.
There's just too many of them dude, I'll quote from that article on "Why A.A. Is A Cult"

Almost everyone who has interacted with AA has been impressed by the way that these sayings manage to replace original thought, which is no-doubt why Lifton referred to their ilk as “the thought-terminating cliché

It's super creepy. There are replacement terms for almost everything important you can imagine.
 
I would be interested to have a look at where it was coming from, that was my question all along. What is meant by harm?

The bolded portions are the ones that apply to AA.

Definition of HARM

1: physical or mental damage : injury 2: mischief, hurt



Injury

1a : an act that damages or hurts : wrongb : violation of another's rights for which the law allows an action to recover damages
2: hurt, damage, or loss sustained


Wrong

a : an injurious, unfair, or unjust act : action or conduct inflicting harm without due provocation or just cause b : a violation or invasion of the legal rights of another; especially : tort
2: something wrong, immoral, or unethical; especially : principles, practices, or conduct contrary to justice, goodness, equity, or law
3: the state, position, or fact of being or doing wrong: as a : the state of being mistaken or incorrect b : the state of being guilty
 
Last edited:
Wrong

a : an injurious, unfair, or unjust act : action or conduct inflicting harm without due provocation or just cause b : a violation or invasion of the legal rights of another; especially : tort
2: something wrong, immoral, or unethical; especially : principles, practices, or conduct contrary to justice, goodness, equity, or law
3: the state, position, or fact of being or doing wrong: as a : the state of being mistaken or incorrect b : the state of being guilty



Now you need to explain why. :rolleyes:
 
Wrong

a : an injurious, unfair, or unjust act : action or conduct inflicting harm without due provocation or just cause b : a violation or invasion of the legal rights of another; especially : tort
2: something wrong, immoral, or unethical; especially : principles, practices, or conduct contrary to justice, goodness, equity, or law
3: the state, position, or fact of being or doing wrong: as a : the state of being mistaken or incorrect b : the state of being guilty



Now you need to explain why. :rolleyes:


Oooooooh!...must...stop....typing....can't....resist....irony.....aaaaargh!

:id: :id:



GB
 
Last edited:
In the previous post, which I was replying to, you said you weren't in control of your life when it came to using the drug of your choice. Now, apparently, you're saying you are in control of it, and can simply choose not to use it.

Don't know which is true, but when you change the statement like that, yes, of course, it does make what I wrote before irrelevant.

I did not change a single thing and you went off on a tangent, what you assume is is not what I intend. You can always ask. I can not control my use of my drug of choice. So i choose not to use, there is a difference. If I use, and do not abstain as soon as possible, it is very likely that old habits will re-establish them selves, they may not. I don't want to find out.

ETA: This si what I said
"Not to control my use of my drug of choice, no. I am not."

I am not trying to control my use, I am avoid use period. Not collecting stamps is not a hobby, avoiding use is not controlling use.

I did not change a single thing, avoiding sex is not having sex. Avoiding use, is not regulating use. Not setting fires is not the same as controlling fires.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom