Why are we ignoring the epidemic of white male suicides?

I don't know that it is an epidemic, but after my partner, the love of my life, committed suicide, two years ago Christmas, I have read a great deal. It turned a statistic into a forever heart break. I will never get over it.

Though 62, white, educated, he didn't fit the pattern of - men don't talk or express their feelings. He had good, close male friends who all shared their problems. He was in a men's group, saw a shrink, took meds, and spoke to me openly, intimately, rawly about all of his pain.

And, no guns involved. He choose helium. A gentle end to a gentle man.
 
I don't know that it is an epidemic, but after my partner, the love of my life, committed suicide, two years ago Christmas, I have read a great deal. It turned a statistic into a forever heart break. I will never get over it.

Though 62, white, educated, he didn't fit the pattern of - men don't talk or express their feelings. He had good, close male friends who all shared their problems. He was in a men's group, saw a shrink, took meds, and spoke to me openly, intimately, rawly about all of his pain.

And, no guns involved. He choose helium. A gentle end to a gentle man.

I am so, so sorry.
 
Either way, I'm not sure that statistic supports the "not allowed to talk about it" meme. I'm actually not convinced that men don't express feelings anyway. At least not to the extent that it's played up to be. That's just not my experience. They group of guys I talked to did talk and listen to each other. I never heard a peer tell someone to "be a man." (Though that might have been said to little boys to get them to stop crying. The equivalent for girls was "Be a big girl.") These conversations probably didn't look the same as when girls talked, though. Not a lot of hugging or crying on shoulders (physically). More listening, pats on the back and supportive advice. ("You'll get through this.") But maybe my group wasn't typical. (Whose is?)


You've been very lucky with your peer group, then. Outside of a few small subcultures I've been involved with, the responses from men that I've gotten, and that I've witnessed when another man tried to talk about problems like this, is general ridicule and questioning the person's manhood. "Shrinks are for women and queers." Sneering responses of "faggot", "pansy", and "pussy". "Grow a pair and stop whining like a little girl."

The worst place I ever encountered it was in the military, where the standard response at nearly all levels was "Suck it up and drive on." Those who did end up seeing a mental health professional were looked down on.

Anyone who seriously contemplated suicide openly, were generally told they were "just trying to get attention", and needed to "grow a pair". Those who actually attempted suicide, especially if they were successful, were loudly taken to task for being "selfish" and "not caring about anyone else" (comments I have seen repeatedly in this very forum), and that they needed to "think about how this will affect others, how they'll react you you killing yourself".

The closest thing to sympathy I've seen generally involved having cliches spouted at them, "suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem", as if that would somehow fix their problems. At no point is any attempt at real empathy made, or real effective help offered. The closest the latter gets is orders to "Promise me that if you feel like that, you'll call me/someone"; as if calling the person who has been doing nothing but ridiculing and denigrating suicidal people is going to sound at all useful to a suicidal person (and completely ignoring the fact that "reaching out" is something that is often insurmountably difficult for people in that state; not to mention that they're often in that state because their attempts to reach out have been rebuffed or ignored or not treated seriously).

Ridicule and denigration, or platitudes and useless advice, are the best that most men can reasonably expect from their peers.
 
Last edited:
Re: Faster growth rate for female suicides...

I'd guess that as women move into occupations previously mostly or always held by men, they are starting to experience the same problems that the men who held those jobs had.

That's an interesting guess. I think it would be pretty easy to prove or disprove. My first impulse is to blame social media.

I especially wonder about the suicide rate for pre-teens. I occasionally hear reports about kids under ten hanging themselves. As a child, I had no concept of hanging myself. Swallowing nine-millimeter aspirin, sure. It used to be your window for getting bullied was shortly before school until shortly after. Now kids have to live in fear 24/7, the audience to watch the humiliation doesn't need to witness the original event in real-time since it can be recorded, and there's no expiration date.
 
Can you fill in the blank here, in plain language?



"I think the suicide epidemic in white men is being ignored because ________."
Because of an absence of government action due to a lack of political will to address the problem and possibly due to a lack of effective advocacy groups for mental health.
 
Re: Faster growth rate for female suicides...



That's an interesting guess. I think it would be pretty easy to prove or disprove. My first impulse is to blame social media.

I especially wonder about the suicide rate for pre-teens. I occasionally hear reports about kids under ten hanging themselves. As a child, I had no concept of hanging myself. Swallowing nine-millimeter aspirin, sure. It used to be your window for getting bullied was shortly before school until shortly after. Now kids have to live in fear 24/7, the audience to watch the humiliation doesn't need to witness the original event in real-time since it can be recorded, and there's no expiration date.

Three times now, I have come into this thread, typed "I'm inclined to blame social media, honestly," and then left without hitting "post." I don't want to get into a massive debate about it, and I'm sure there are many other factors at play. But I agree with everything you've said here.

Social media and the internet may not even be creating the problem, but they're surely worsening it (especially where young people are concerned).
 
You've been very lucky with your peer group, then. Outside of a few small subcultures I've been involved with, the responses from men that I've gotten, and that I've witnessed when another man tried to talk about problems like this, is general ridicule and questioning the person's manhood. "Shrinks are for women and queers." Sneering responses of "faggot", "pansy", and "pussy". "Grow a pair and stop whining like a little girl."

The worst place I ever encountered it was in the military, where the standard response at nearly all levels was "Suck it up and drive on." Those who did end up seeing a mental health professional were looked down on.

Anyone who seriously contemplated suicide openly, were generally told they were "just trying to get attention", and needed to "grow a pair". Those who actually attempted suicide, especially if they were successful, were loudly taken to task for being "selfish" and "not caring about anyone else" (comments I have seen repeatedly in this very forum), and that they needed to "think about how this will affect others, how they'll react you you killing yourself".

The closest thing to sympathy I've seen generally involved having cliches spouted at them, "suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem", as if that would somehow fix their problems. At no point is any attempt at real empathy made, or real effective help offered. The closest the latter gets is orders to "Promise me that if you feel like that, you'll call me/someone"; as if calling the person who has been doing nothing but ridiculing and denigrating suicidal people is going to sound at all useful to a suicidal person (and completely ignoring the fact that "reaching out" is something that is often insurmountably difficult for people in that state; not to mention that they're often in that state because their attempts to reach out have been rebuffed or ignored or not treated seriously).

Ridicule and denigration, or platitudes and useless advice, are the best that most men can reasonably expect from their peers.

I haven't seen these attitudes, either, fwiw. My experience is similar to TomB's. I've spent many many hours talking with my friends about my personal life, relationships, and theirs as well... almost all of it while playing video games, going for walks, throwing footballs (yes, literally) and more. My understanding is that this is generally the kind of "emotional displays" you get from men around each other, as well. We don't talk as much and we like to be physically doing something when we do. I've heard similar from psychologists and social workers, though I probably couldn't name them.

See: http://menssheds.ca/about-mens-sheds/ for one group of organizations that tries to emulate this experience (and more). I haven't looked too closely myself, though that's what I've heard about it.

Now, on the other hand... I think men avoid showing vulnerability in front of women, generally. We know it's not attractive. I think to some extent we give boys the "stop crying" treatment and provide less sympathy when they do cry. I don't just blame women for this, but I think there tends to be a habit of saying that it is specifically (or mostly?) men who contribute to this feeling of other men not being able to be open about their feelings.

Anyway, those are my 2 cents. I hope what I said makes sense even if you and others disagree.

As a final thought I would not be at all surprised if the military was the extreme you are suggesting; it's an entire world away from everyday life in terms of "toughness", or at least what's expected of personnel. Who knows how much of it is ironic/sarcastic "endearing" language that a close-knit group uses, though.
 
Now, on the other hand... I think men avoid showing vulnerability in front of women, generally. We know it's not attractive

That's a pretty good expression of toxic masculinity right there, and shows just how clueless some people can be about it.

The highlighted part in particular. For starters, its only men and maybe a tiny minority of women who think that men showing vulnerability is unattractive. In my experience, women do, in fact, appreciate it when men show vulnerability, and do find it attractive. And by that, I mean true, actual, vulnerability; not just whinging about how they've been so badly mistreated by the world (and women), and how it's everyone else's fault, like you strongly implied in the next bit.

This second highlighted bit is the most telling:

I think to some extent we give boys the "stop crying" treatment and provide less sympathy when they do cry. I don't just blame women for this, but I think there tends to be a habit of saying that it is specifically (or mostly?) men who contribute to this feeling of other men not being able to be open about their feelings..


Because it is, in fact, mostly men who contribute to men not being able to be open about their feelings. And this is an old trick, trying to cast the majority for the blame for this on women, and minimize their own responsibility for toxic behaviour. But the fact is, it's predominantly men who have created and enforced this type of machismo culture.

Women have been saying that they want for men to be more open for longer than I've been alive. To the point it has become somewhat cliche. It dominates a lot of literature written by women (ignoring sociopaths like Ayn Rand). Some of the "Harlequin romance" genre of fiction does also tend to support the stoic, emotionless stereotypes, but a good deal of that is also written by men (under female pseudonyms); and more of it starts with that, but ends with the male lead becoming more open about his feelings due to the female lead's influence.

One really interesting thing is that it's actually fairly new to Anglosphere culture. One of the most popular figures of his day, Lord Byron, was very much the "rock star" of his time, and was very much a moody emotional sort of person (although a bit more extreme in his moods than was strictly healthy). The stereotype of the "sensitive artist" has always been one that a good deal of women swooned over. Even in traditionally machismo cultures like those that dominate in the Mediterranean and their offshoots, men being vulnerable and emotional was actually encouraged, albeit only in certain, limited contexts. It was the "frontier western" stereotype of the stoic loner that was really the birth of modern toxic masculine culture.
 
To me, "ignored" doesn't mean "no studies or research or anything like that at all". Rather, it means "of all the things that get regular mention in the mainstream media, and get brought up in public conversation in places like this forum's SI&CE section, this isn't one of them."

We get regular surges of "... while black" threads, and people can't stop pushing Donald Trump into every thread they can find, but when was the last time we actually talked about white male suicide? Why?

Resolving this question at a national level, according to science, is probably not going to happen here. But as far as our own small, relatively tight-knit community goes, we can certainly talk about why we ignore it here.

We do talk about suicide in general, though. We don't specifically talk about 50-something ginger suicides, but that doesn't mean they are being ignored, they're part of the general discussion of suicide. It's only if there's something special about the white male suicides that makes their issues different from the general issue that I'd consider not talking about that specific case to be ignoring it.

So, is there something special about the "epidemic of white male suicides" or is it just part of a general trend in which the same issues are at play? I haven't seen anything in this thread that suggests there's anything particularly white about this issue.
 
I don't know that it is an epidemic, but after my partner, the love of my life, committed suicide, two years ago Christmas, I have read a great deal. It turned a statistic into a forever heart break. I will never get over it.

Though 62, white, educated, he didn't fit the pattern of - men don't talk or express their feelings. He had good, close male friends who all shared their problems. He was in a men's group, saw a shrink, took meds, and spoke to me openly, intimately, rawly about all of his pain.

And, no guns involved. He choose helium. A gentle end to a gentle man.

My dad, 57 last year, I think did the same. Fentanyl.
I'm not torn up about it though. He'd been sick, quality of life wasn't good, and chose to go out on his terms. Honestly I think it was a fair move on his part.
 
My experience as a man is that my friends and I share our feelings and struggles with each other and that we are not only there for each other when asked, but also as a group look out for each other. One friend of mine has been struggling after a breakup and then loss of his job and not only do I talk about it with him, but when I see other friends they ask about him and try to think of ways to help, even just to cheer him up. When I have a hard time in my life I go to these friends to share my feelings. Sometimes I'll get a call at 2am (or make one) and no one ever gets called a pussy for this sort of thing. When one friend's father died he called me immediately on finding out and we met and talked for a few hours and cried.

What actually does seem to bother us is friends who don't share their problems and end up in self-destructive behaviour. One friend in our group is in a very toxic relationship but doesn't really feel comfortable talking about the way he is being treated or how he feels. Rather than being impressed by his stoicism the general consensus is that he's being a coward for not talking about or dealing with his problems. While one friend of mine is angered by this, I said to him that all we can do is be there for and try to support this friend of ours.

It's possible that there's something uniquely non-masculine about this group of friends, but they are people I met through martial arts who pride themselves on their masculinity and stoicism. Being willing and able to face your problems and deal with them is different from not talking about them to close friends.
 
My experience as a man is that my friends and I share our feelings and struggles with each other and that we are not only there for each other when asked, but also as a group look out for each other. One friend of mine has been struggling after a breakup and then loss of his job and not only do I talk about it with him, but when I see other friends they ask about him and try to think of ways to help, even just to cheer him up. When I have a hard time in my life I go to these friends to share my feelings. Sometimes I'll get a call at 2am (or make one) and no one ever gets called a pussy for this sort of thing. When one friend's father died he called me immediately on finding out and we met and talked for a few hours and cried.

What actually does seem to bother us is friends who don't share their problems and end up in self-destructive behaviour. One friend in our group is in a very toxic relationship but doesn't really feel comfortable talking about the way he is being treated or how he feels. Rather than being impressed by his stoicism the general consensus is that he's being a coward for not talking about or dealing with his problems. While one friend of mine is angered by this, I said to him that all we can do is be there for and try to support this friend of ours.

It's possible that there's something uniquely non-masculine about this group of friends, but they are people I met through martial arts who pride themselves on their masculinity and stoicism. Being willing and able to face your problems and deal with them is different from not talking about them to close friends.

I think the term for this might be "male bonding." I think this is how guys normally act within their group of male friends. Not so much with strangers.
 
I think the term for this might be "male bonding." I think this is how guys normally act within their group of male friends. Not so much with strangers.

Yes. I was thinking after posting that about how I hadn't noted that point, thanks for pointing it out. :)
 
To me, "ignored" doesn't mean "no studies or research or anything like that at all". Rather, it means "of all the things that get regular mention in the mainstream media, and get brought up in public conversation in places like this forum's SI&CE section, this isn't one of them."

We get regular surges of "... while black" threads, and people can't stop pushing Donald Trump into every thread they can find, but when was the last time we actually talked about white male suicide? Why?

Resolving this question at a national level, according to science, is probably not going to happen here. But as far as our own small, relatively tight-knit community goes, we can certainly talk about why we ignore it here.
It's not ignored here, it's mentioned in other threads, usually to demonstrate that males face problems as well as females.
 
Re: Faster growth rate for female suicides...







That's an interesting guess. I think it would be pretty easy to prove or disprove. My first impulse is to blame social media.



I especially wonder about the suicide rate for pre-teens. I occasionally hear reports about kids under ten hanging themselves. As a child, I had no concept of hanging myself. Swallowing nine-millimeter aspirin, sure. It used to be your window for getting bullied was shortly before school until shortly after. Now kids have to live in fear 24/7, the audience to watch the humiliation doesn't need to witness the original event in real-time since it can be recorded, and there's no expiration date.
I agree.

In the UK we've had media uptake of the death of a teenager which is being blamed on Instagram, she viewed suicide and self harm images and videos. Instagram have been changing their policies and how they moderate their content as a direct result of a campaign started by her father.

Latest story
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/amp/tech...errer=https://www.google.com&amp_tf=From %1$s
 
Because of an absence of government action due to a lack of political will to address the problem and possibly due to a lack of effective advocacy groups for mental health.

Something like that is almost definitely the case, to whatever extent the problem is being ignored.

Kind of on topic, but there is one place that's been able to reverse the trend.

This article isn't about "white male" suicides in particular by name, but it's about an area that's overwhelmingly white, and so the prevented suicides will be in that demographic.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/...ion-spots-such-as-motels-and-animal-shelters/

Repp, however, is not a medical examiner; she is a microbiologist. She is also an epidemiologist for Oregon’s Washington County, where she had been accustomed to studying infectious diseases such as flu or norovirus outbreaks among the living.

But in 2012 she was asked by county officials to look at suicide. The request introduced her to the world of death investigations and also appears to have led to something remarkable: in this suburban county of 600,000, just west of Portland, the suicide rate now is going down. That result is remarkable because national suicide rates have risen, despite decades-long efforts to reverse the deadly trend.

While many factors contribute to suicide, officials here believe they have chipped away at this problem through Repp’s initiative to use data—very localized data that any jurisdiction could collect. Now her mission is to help others learn how to gather and use them.

New York State has just begun testing a system like Repp’s. Humboldt County in California is implementing it. She has gotten inquiries from Utah and Kentucky. Colorado, meanwhile, is using its own brand of data collection to try to achieve the same kind of turnaround.


For example, data revealed a surprising number of suicides at hotels and motels. They also showed a number of those who killed themselves had experienced eviction or foreclosure or had a medical visit within weeks or days of their death. And the information revealed that people in crisis regularly turn their pets over to an animal shelter.

But what to do with that information? Experts have long believed that suicide is preventable, and there are evidence-based programs to train people in how to identify and respond to folks in crisis and direct them to help. That is where Debra Darmata, Washington County’s suicide-prevention coordinator, comes in. Part of Darmata’s job involves running these training programs, which she described as like CPR for mental health.

The training is typically offered to people such as counselors, educators or pastors. But with the new data, the county realized it was missing people who may have been the last to see the decedents alive. It began offering the training to motel clerks and housekeepers, animal shelter workers, pain clinic staffers, and more.

From 2012 to 2018, Washington County’s suicide rate decreased by 40 percent, preliminary data show.

Repp cautions that the findings cannot be generalized. What is true in suburban Portland may not be true in rural Nebraska or in San Francisco—or even in suburban New Jersey, for that matter. Every community needs to look at its own data.
 
And that's it in a nutshell, really. Men aren't allowed to talk about their feelings, to admit to being anything but strong, self-sufficient, and... well... "manly".

I don't know; this isn't the 50s anymore. I've met very few people under 50 who think they have to suppress their feelings. At least in my experience, just as it was a myth in earlier ages that men had to be 'manly' as you describe, I think it's a myth that the myth endures today.

So while I agree with the rest of your post, I'm not sure about that first paragraph. Also minus points for bringing up the patriarchy.
 
You've been very lucky with your peer group, then. Outside of a few small subcultures I've been involved with, the responses from men that I've gotten, and that I've witnessed when another man tried to talk about problems like this, is general ridicule and questioning the person's manhood. "Shrinks are for women and queers." Sneering responses of "faggot", "pansy", and "pussy". "Grow a pair and stop whining like a little girl."
Screw responses from men, my wife routinely says things like this!
 
I don't know; this isn't the 50s anymore. I've met very few people under 50 who think they have to suppress their feelings. At least in my experience, just as it was a myth in earlier ages that men had to be 'manly' as you describe, I think it's a myth that the myth endures today.


I think part of the problem is that so many people here live in a relatively diverse rational/liberal bubble (even if they don't like the terms). And yes, younger generations are getting better at this as the older one dies off, but again, this is not consistent from group to group. I think the fact that so many of us exist somewhat outside mainstream culture has insulated us to a large degree from its more toxic aspects.

I grew up in a very religious-right community, and this sort of thing was rife.
Still is. And it's not like it's difficult to find online either. The MRA community, for all its whinging about persecution by women, homosexuals, and "soy boys", continues to perpetuate this machismo culture. Extremists like MGTOW, Red Pill, Incels, RoK, and others of the anti-feminist "manosphere" are founded on it. Machismo culture permeates the alt.right and reactionary right.

Aside from the extremists, it's easy enough to see more subtle variations of it throughout mainstream pop culture. And while yes, that has been changing, the constant outcry against those changes is blatant and loud. Gamergate being the most obvious example; but there's more to it than that. Look at the outcry any time a, for example, superhero character which has been traditionally male is replaced with a female version? Look at gender-swapped film characters like the Ghostbusters remake; and female actors hounded off social media with death and rape threats.

It's all part and parcel of that same machismo culture, and the resistance against attempts to counteract and change it.

Claiming that it never existed, or ceased to exist, because it was never perfectly adhered to or expressed, or that there was a minority of people who didn't buy into the culture, is wrongheaded and little better than a handwave. It was always there as an ideal, an archetype by which men were measured, and a cudgel to bludgeon anyone who existed outside the mainstream culture with.

So while I agree with the rest of your post, I'm not sure about that first paragraph. Also minus points for bringing up the patriarchy.


:rolleyes:

If this is only about scoring Internet points for you, then I don't see why I need to bother responding to anything else.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom