Why are we ignoring the epidemic of white male suicides?

I do think the younger generations will be better than those of mine in dealing with mental health. So hopefully we will see a reduction just through being brought up to treat health issues as a health issue regardless of it being a mental health issue.

I've been trying to make a small change in how I view mental health and try now to not actually say "mental health issue" but rather " a health issue". The "mental " just isn't needed if you are talking about the state of someone's health.
 

The OP literally says white male suicides in the title(s) and as a bonus, the article even stats out with an attempt to deflect away from the claims made into a "what about this group ? ". Much like you're trying to do with you're article.
 
The OP literally says white male suicides in the title(s) and as a bonus, the article even stats out with an attempt to deflect away from the claims made into a "what about this group ? ". Much like you're trying to do with you're article.

It also uses the word "ignoring" in the title, and asks why that's happening.

What's the evidence that it's being ignored, and what do you think is the reason for it being ignored?
 
Yes, and rightly so. Trying to introduce black children into a thread about white males is off topic and deserves it's own thread.

I dunno. Ignoring white male suicide in a thread about ignoring white male suicide has a certain poetry to it.

And in a sense, kellyb is even addressing the question raised in the OP: She's ignoring white male suicide because she believes that suicide rates among black children are more a more important topic - overwhelmingly so.
 
It also uses the word "ignoring" in the title, and asks why that's happening.

What's the evidence that it's being ignored,
Happy to help:

I would say that this is being ignored.
That's you, ignoring the topic of the thread.

and what do you think is the reason for it being ignored?
Here's my best guess:

And in a sense, kellyb is even addressing the question raised in the OP: She's ignoring white male suicide because she believes that suicide rates among black children are more a more important topic - overwhelmingly so.
 
And in a sense, kellyb is even addressing the question raised in the OP: She's ignoring white male suicide because she believes that suicide rates among black children are more a more important topic - overwhelmingly so.

LOL!

I'm showing that it's probably not being ignored any more than other suicide epidemics are ignored, which can also be called "not necessarily ignored."
 
This is interesting, though.

me said:
and what do you think is the reason for it being ignored?
theprestige said:
Here's my best guess:

Originally Posted by theprestige View Post
And in a sense, kellyb is even addressing the question raised in the OP: She's ignoring white male suicide because she believes that suicide rates among black children are more a more important topic - overwhelmingly so.

You think society in general is ignoring the suicide epidemic in white men because people think the suicide epidemic in black children is overwhelmingly more important?

If not, can you fill in the blank here, in plain language?

"I think the suicide epidemic in white men is being ignored because ________."
 
We don't even know if the white male suicide epidemic actually is being ignored. I've found material on it ( one source cited places like Montana for having a high rate, hence my Yellowstone comment ) in what would be considered popular culture.

What I was looking for is something like suicide hotlines playing identity politics.

Welcome to The Suicide Prevention Hotline
If you're white press 1
If you're male press 2
If you're middle aged press 3
If you're straight......
We will place you in the appropriate queue.

Haven't found anything like that.
 
Why are they doing this? Do they lose their job? Did the wife leave them? Are they trying to escape a painful fatal disease? I'm old and ailing myself and before I get worse a few years in the future I'm going to apply for assisted suicide in Oregon.
 
Why are they doing this? Do they lose their job? Did the wife leave them? Are they trying to escape a painful fatal disease? I'm old and ailing myself and before I get worse a few years in the future I'm going to apply for assisted suicide in Oregon.


Do you consider the first two to be sensible reasons for committing suicide? Because you lose your job or your spouse?
Consider the attitude to having a wife or a job that is required in order for you to consider offing yourself if you lose them. (i.e. ever heard of the American Dream?)
Psychology of the Private Individual - Critique of Bourgeois Consciousness
Part III. From failure to self-destruction — The realm of psychology
Chapter 12: The enforcement of psychological self-criticism: suicide
 
Last edited:
To me, "ignored" doesn't mean "no studies or research or anything like that at all". Rather, it means "of all the things that get regular mention in the mainstream media, and get brought up in public conversation in places like this forum's SI&CE section, this isn't one of them."

We get regular surges of "... while black" threads, and people can't stop pushing Donald Trump into every thread they can find, but when was the last time we actually talked about white male suicide? Why?

Resolving this question at a national level, according to science, is probably not going to happen here. But as far as our own small, relatively tight-knit community goes, we can certainly talk about why we ignore it here.
 
We don't even know if the white male suicide epidemic actually is being ignored. I've found material on it ( one source cited places like Montana for having a high rate, hence my Yellowstone comment ) in what would be considered popular culture.

What I was looking for is something like suicide hotlines playing identity politics.

Welcome to The Suicide Prevention Hotline
If you're white press 1
If you're male press 2
If you're middle aged press 3
If you're straight......
We will place you in the appropriate queue.

Haven't found anything like that.


Sorry for the OT aside, but the post above reminded me how much I love this song :



As to the topic of the thread, the general deplorable approach to mental health in general already mentioned in this thread combined with the sort of mindset embodied by "Jessica Valenti+male tears" probably has quite a bit to do with it.
 
To me, "ignored" doesn't mean "no studies or research or anything like that at all". Rather, it means "of all the things that get regular mention in the mainstream media, and get brought up in public conversation in places like this forum's SI&CE section, this isn't one of them."

We get regular surges of "... while black" threads, and people can't stop pushing Donald Trump into every thread they can find, but when was the last time we actually talked about white male suicide? Why?

Resolving this question at a national level, according to science, is probably not going to happen here. But as far as our own small, relatively tight-knit community goes, we can certainly talk about why we ignore it here.

Can you fill in the blank here, in plain language?

"I think the suicide epidemic in white men is being ignored because ________."
 
Has it been established that first there actually is a suicide epidemic among white males, and second that such an epidemic is being ignored? Because this thread seemed to jump straight to speculation on secondary, tertiary, and bickeratory matters.
 
Because it's White men. Who gives a **** about them? It's their way of owning up to the privilege lives they've enjoyed throughout history. They realize they are a malevolent force of nature and are creating a better world by ceasing to exist.

I can't tell, is this serious?
 
Can you fill in the blank here, in plain language?

"I think the suicide epidemic in white men is being ignored because ________."
As far as I'm concerned, that's an open question for which we don't yet have a good answer (we don't even agree on whether it's actually a question).

Can we at least discuss the issue for a while, before you start pressing everyone for their answers?
 
As far as I'm concerned, that's an open question for which we don't yet have a good answer (we don't even agree on whether it's actually a question).

Can we at least discuss the issue for a while, before you start pressing everyone for their answers?

So, you no longer answer "what do you think is the reason for it being ignored?" with "And in a sense, kellyb is even addressing the question raised in the OP: She's ignoring white male suicide because she believes that suicide rates among black children are more a more important topic - overwhelmingly so"?

:confused:

eta: and I wasn't asking what "we" think. I was asking what you think.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't discount access to handguns.

85% of non-handgun suicide attempts fail. And almost all of those people go on to die of other causes, showing that suicide isn't an irrevocable choice.

When it comes to handgun suicides, though, the numbers flip. 85% of handgun suicide attempts succeed.

I think that it may be easier for white men to gain access to handguns. I haven't seen a statistic on that, though.

I am not saying that this is the only factor. It may be one of them, and we may be able to lower the suicide rate by addressing the health risks that handguns pose to their owners.
Roughly 60% of gun deaths in the US are suicide, almost all by hand gun, the vast majority of gun murders are with hand guns. For some reason, control conversations are all(mostly) about rifles?

Has it been established that first there actually is a suicide epidemic among white males, and second that such an epidemic is being ignored? Because this thread seemed to jump straight to speculation on secondary, tertiary, and bickeratory matters.

1, yes there does seem to be a recent increase in suicide among adult white males.
https://afsp.org/about-suicide/suicide-statistics/
2. It definitely isn't being ignored but it usually gets covered with the opoid crisis and called "deaths of dispair."
 
According to this, females are more likely to attempt suicide than males: https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/statistics/suicide.shtml#part_154973 (.7% of adult females vs .5% of adult males)

Of course, that's really hard to pin down. Does getting the gun but deciding not to pull the trigger count as an attempt? Does taking the pills, having second thoughts and calling 911? I'm not convinced there is a difference in the rate of attempt.

Either way, I'm not sure that statistic supports the "not allowed to talk about it" meme. I'm actually not convinced that men don't express feelings anyway. At least not to the extent that it's played up to be. That's just not my experience. They group of guys I talked to did talk and listen to each other. I never heard a peer tell someone to "be a man." (Though that might have been said to little boys to get them to stop crying. The equivalent for girls was "Be a big girl.") These conversations probably didn't look the same as when girls talked, though. Not a lot of hugging or crying on shoulders (physically). More listening, pats on the back and supportive advice. ("You'll get through this.") But maybe my group wasn't typical. (Whose is?)

Anyway, there seems to be two issues: attempts and success. If you are going to address attempts, it's not as much of a gendered issue. If you are going to address success, you are talking about methodology. It's possible that men use guns simply because men are more likely to be interested in or own guns independently of suicide or depression. In other words the correlation may be less with sex and more with gun ownership or awareness of access.

The suicide rates in elementary age black children don't get a lot of attention probably because the suicide rate of children in general is low in comparison to adolescents and adults. (That was taken from the article kellyb linked.)

My daughter has had at least two people she has known commit suicide. An ex-boyfriend and a friend's ex-girlfriend. Both hit her pretty hard. I think there may be someone she knew in the Air Force as well. She's become kind of a Facebook suicide awareness activist, so I see a lot of posts about it. But I think she sees it as a gender-neutral issue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom