Why are we ignoring the epidemic of white male suicides?


Interesting and all, but no bearing on the OP which says men's mental health is being ignored, and my point that men are actually talking about mental health. It is being drummed into children in recent years, where I got through 12 years of school and tertiary education without hearing it mentioned.

This thread is not about the obvious fact that more women than men seek help for mental health. It is about it being ignored because white, middle class men are suffering. A theory which belongs in the CT section in my view.
 
Interesting and all, but no bearing on the OP which says men's mental health is being ignored, and my point that men are actually talking about mental health. It is being drummed into children in recent years, where I got through 12 years of school and tertiary education without hearing it mentioned.

This thread is not about the obvious fact that more women than men seek help for mental health. It is about it being ignored because white, middle class men are suffering. A theory which belongs in the CT section in my view.

Nice try

But this time you can't pretend other people have said things they haven't, cos it is your posts.

I’d like to see evidence that men don’t talk about their problems. I’ve read reports that mental health has overtaken the flu as the biggest cause of people visiting GPs in Australia. My doctor told me that a third of his patients are seeing him over their mental health, evenly split between men and women.

I see no mention of "white" or "middle class"

What I see is someone avoiding addressing males kill themselves more than females due to less help (be it self or institutional)
 
Nice try



I see no mention of "white" or "middle class"

The OP mentions white men, it also uses the word “privileged” so it’s not a stretch to presume middle class, but ignore that if you wish. My point is that men are talking about their mental health, young men in particular. Your own links (which I doubt you read given how quickly you posted them) make this point.
 
The OP mentions white men, it also uses the word “privileged” so it’s not a stretch to presume middle class, but ignore that if you wish. My point is that men are talking about their mental health, young men in particular. Your own links (which I doubt you read given how quickly you posted them) make this point.

I am a fast reader.

I have said this before.


Your own request for evidence did not say "privileged"

Whatever this actually means

Care to give me a definition?
 
Or white

You just can't help making things up in posts and it has reached your own
 
Or white

You just can't help making things up in posts and it has reached your own

You are just looking silly now. From the OP
in which men in general and white men in particular
.

This is what I was addressing. See I read the OP and try to stay on topic. I don’t repeat the entire OP when I comment about it.

So, again to the OP, do you believe that the mental health of white males is being ignored? Because your own links say it isn’t, while still making the obvious point that men don’t seek help as often as women.
 
You are just looking silly now. From the OP .

This is what I was addressing. See I read the OP and try to stay on topic. I don’t repeat the entire OP when I comment about it.

So, again to the OP, do you believe that the mental health of white males is being ignored? Because your own links say it isn’t, while still making the obvious point that men don’t seek help as often as women.

I think public attention to male suicide is lacking recognition massively in general.

From the figures it also seems to be low socio-economic males in a large proportion.

It isn't rocket science to work out in most countries they make up more of this category.

Only you seem to want to seem obsessed about race of the males doing it, rather than seeing it is males in general doing more.

I have already said here the highest rate is Maori males.

There is a trend here you seem to be avoiding and every country I have seen and it starts with "M" and ends in "ales"

And your own request for proof had nothing to do with privilege or white.

Again as much as you like to pretend other people have said something, it doesn't work for yourself
 
I think public attention to male suicide is lacking recognition massively in general.

From the figures it also seems to be low socio-economic males in a large proportion.

It isn't rocket science to work out in most countries they make up more of this category.

Only you seem to want to seem obsessed about race of the males doing it, rather than seeing it is males in general doing more.

I have already said here the highest rate is Maori males.

There is a trend here you seem to be avoiding and every country I have seen and it starts with "M" and ends in "ales"

And your own request for proof had nothing to do with privilege or white.

Again as much as you like to pretend other people have said something, it doesn't work for yourself

For Christ’s sake, read the OP.
 
I have already said here the highest rate is Maori males.


In Greenland, too!

Suicide in Greenland is a significant national social issue. Greenland has the highest suicide rate in the world: reports between 1985 and 2012 showed that an average of 83 people in 100,000 committed suicide, more than twice the rate of the second placed country, Lithuania.
Suicide in Greenland (Wikipedia)


(And that was before Trump tried to buy Greenland!)

Incidence and variance
An article published in the journal, BMC Psychiatry, in 2009 reported that a total of 1,351 suicides took place in Greenland during a study period of 35 years, from 1968 to 2002. The study noted a significant variation of the suicide rate in relation to the season, characterized by peaks in June and troughs in the winter. The clustering of suicides in summer months was most pronounced in areas north of the Arctic Circle. Regional variations were also observed with suicide rates in northern parts of west Greenland being higher than in southern parts.
Suicide rates are higher for men than women. Among those who are committing suicide, the greater part are young men between the ages of 15 and 24. Unlike in other Western countries, the suicide rate in Greenland decreases with age.
Suicide in Greenland: Incidence and variance (Wikipedia)
 
Only you seem to want to seem obsessed about race of the males doing it, rather than seeing it is males in general doing more.

If only Lionking is "obsessed about race of the males doing it", why is the OP titled "Why are we ignoring the epidemic of white male suicides?"?
 
If only Lionking is "obsessed about race of the males doing it", why is the OP titled "Why are we ignoring the epidemic of white male suicides?"?

Fair point

Bit dumb saying he is making stuff up while exaggerating his posts
 
I would say that this is being ignored.

Yes, and rightly so. Trying to introduce black children into a thread about white males is off topic and deserves it's own thread.

Me ? I'm still trying to work through this topic while watching season 1 of Yellowstone. What a strange coincidence.
 
Is that a "white" thing?


One more:

TED Talk: A Call to Men


”The Man Box”
Don’t cry or openly express emotions with the exception of anger
Do not show weakness or fear
Demonstrate power control especially over women
Aggression-Dominance
Protector
Do not be ”like a woman”
Heterosexual
Do not be ”like a gay man”
Tough-Athletic-Strength-Courage
Makes decisions – Does not need help
Views women as property/objects


When you consider that this speaker is also black, viewing women as property is so much more damning.
Toxic masculinity is probably more toxic for black men (and women) than for whites.
 
Yes, and rightly so. Trying to introduce the ignored suicide epidemic in black children into a thread about the ignored suicide epidemic in white males is not off topic and deserves it's own thread.

Me ? I'm still trying to work through this topic while watching season 1 of Yellowstone. What a strange coincidence.

FTFY. :)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom