Why are we ignoring the epidemic of white male suicides?

I think part of the problem is that so many people here live in a relatively diverse rational/liberal bubble (even if they don't like the terms). And yes, younger generations are getting better at this as the older one dies off, but again, this is not consistent from group to group.

Of course not. See, the point of my post was that perhaps your contention that your experience is the norm and ours isn't is not correct. Maybe it's your experiences that are marginal. Or maybe not. So maybe you have some sort of, I don't know, evidence, to demonstrate that this is still widespread?

Not anecdotes or individual groups or instances. I'm talking about hard numbers. Otherwise we're all speculating based on limited experience.

Aside from the extremists, it's easy enough to see more subtle variations of it throughout mainstream pop culture. And while yes, that has been changing, the constant outcry against those changes is blatant and loud. Gamergate being the most obvious example; but there's more to it than that. Look at the outcry any time a, for example, superhero character which has been traditionally male is replaced with a female version? Look at gender-swapped film characters like the Ghostbusters remake; and female actors hounded off social media with death and rape threats.

Wait a second, there. The backlash against that movie wasn't because it had female leads; after all plenty of female-led movies, even action movies, are beloved by the exact same community. The issue was that the trailer was terrible. As for the more general case of gender-flipping, we've been over this numerous times on this forum: it's more a case of people disliking major changes to established characters that they love. I'm sure you'll find that gender-flipping in the opposite direction would get the same reaction for that sort of character.

If this is only about scoring Internet points for you, then I don't see why I need to bother responding to anything else.

Calm down. I didn't say anything about "internet points." I'm saying that I disagree with one part of your post. And that sets you off? Geez.
 
Last edited:
Wait a second, there. The backlash against that movie wasn't because it had female leads; after all plenty of female-led movies, even action movies, are beloved by the exact same community. The issue was that the trailer was terrible.
I think there would have been less backlash if they had done it as a sequel rather than a reboot. They didn't actually gender-flip or even replace the original characters, they erased them.

Still, I was looking forward to it. I thought it was enjoyable, but not great. It just didn't have the same chemistry. There are reasons not to have liked the movie other than the casting choices.
 
I think part of the problem is that so many people here live in a relatively diverse rational/liberal bubble (even if they don't like the terms). And yes, younger generations are getting better at this as the older one dies off, but again, this is not consistent from group to group. I think the fact that so many of us exist somewhat outside mainstream culture has insulated us to a large degree from its more toxic aspects.
[/QUOTE]

I don't know that I'm particularly outside mainstream culture. More intersectional, maybe. I come from a medium sized town in the midwest. My parents were schoolteachers, but my friends' parents were a pretty even mix of working class and white collar with incomes ranging from poor to upper middle class. Some of my friends went to college, some didn't. Those that didn't last I saw were either working blue collar (construction, factory) or retail/service. They were pretty much all like that. My wife's family is completely blue collar and dedicated democrats some of whom for some reason support Trump.

There are a few people who act like you describe, but they are pretty much regarded as ********. Both male and female.

I have two daughters. My youngest tended to have more stable friendships with her male friends. The girls were much more cruel and seemed to latch onto any flaw or weakness. (Hell hath no fury like a teenage girl.) The guys were more supportive and understanding.
 
I think part of the problem is that so many people here live in a relatively diverse rational/liberal bubble (even if they don't like the terms). And yes, younger generations are getting better at this as the older one dies off, but again, this is not consistent from group to group. I think the fact that so many of us exist somewhat outside mainstream culture has insulated us to a large degree from its more toxic aspects.

I grew up in a very religious-right community, and this sort of thing was rife.
Still is. And it's not like it's difficult to find online either. The MRA community, for all its whinging about persecution by women, homosexuals, and "soy boys", continues to perpetuate this machismo culture. Extremists like MGTOW, Red Pill, Incels, RoK, and others of the anti-feminist "manosphere" are founded on it. Machismo culture permeates the alt.right and reactionary right.

Aside from the extremists, it's easy enough to see more subtle variations of it throughout mainstream pop culture. And while yes, that has been changing, the constant outcry against those changes is blatant and loud. Gamergate being the most obvious example; but there's more to it than that. Look at the outcry any time a, for example, superhero character which has been traditionally male is replaced with a female version? Look at gender-swapped film characters like the Ghostbusters remake; and female actors hounded off social media with death and rape threats.

It's all part and parcel of that same machismo culture, and the resistance against attempts to counteract and change it.

Claiming that it never existed, or ceased to exist, because it was never perfectly adhered to or expressed, or that there was a minority of people who didn't buy into the culture, is wrongheaded and little better than a handwave. It was always there as an ideal, an archetype by which men were measured, and a cudgel to bludgeon anyone who existed outside the mainstream culture with.




:rolleyes:

If this is only about scoring Internet points for you, then I don't see why I need to bother responding to anything else.

Do you mind posting some actual hard evidence for this anti-men rant, rather than a couple of anecdotal stories?, One of which (the Ghostbusters one) is just plain wrong.
 
Wait a second, there. The backlash against that movie wasn't because it had female leads; after all plenty of female-led movies, even action movies, are beloved by the exact same community. The issue was that the trailer was terrible.

It wasn't just the trailer that was terrible.

As for the more general case of gender-flipping, we've been over this numerous times on this forum: it's more a case of people disliking major changes to established characters that they love. I'm sure you'll find that gender-flipping in the opposite direction would get the same reaction for that sort of character.

The contrast in fan reception for Captain Marvel and Alita: Battle Angel pretty much disproved the notion that a strong female lead was the problem. It wasn't. The marketing and Bree Larson herself were the problem. Here's a nice analysis of how Larson managed to piss people off even in ways that have nothing to do with gender or politics:


And yes, if you tried to make a gender-swapped Allen: Battle Angel, you'd piss everybody off, including the male fans.
 
Now, on the other hand... I think men avoid showing vulnerability in front of women, generally. We know it's not attractive

That's a pretty good expression of toxic masculinity right there, and shows just how clueless some people can be about it.
The highlighted part in particular. For starters, its only men and maybe a tiny minority of women who think that men showing vulnerability is unattractive. In my experience, women do, in fact, appreciate it when men show vulnerability, and do find it attractive. And by that, I mean true, actual, vulnerability; not just whinging about how they've been so badly mistreated by the world (and women), and how it's everyone else's fault, like you strongly implied in the next bit.
This second highlighted bit is the most telling:




Because it is, in fact, mostly men who contribute to men not being able to be open about their feelings. And this is an old trick, trying to cast the majority for the blame for this on women, and minimize their own responsibility for toxic behaviour. But the fact is, it's predominantly men who have created and enforced this type of machismo culture.
Women have been saying that they want for men to be more open for longer than I've been alive. To the point it has become somewhat cliche. It dominates a lot of literature written by women (ignoring sociopaths like Ayn Rand). Some of the "Harlequin romance" genre of fiction does also tend to support the stoic, emotionless stereotypes, but a good deal of that is also written by men (under female pseudonyms); and more of it starts with that, but ends with the male lead becoming more open about his feelings due to the female lead's influence.

One really interesting thing is that it's actually fairly new to Anglosphere culture. One of the most popular figures of his day, Lord Byron, was very much the "rock star" of his time, and was very much a moody emotional sort of person (although a bit more extreme in his moods than was strictly healthy). The stereotype of the "sensitive artist" has always been one that a good deal of women swooned over. Even in traditionally machismo cultures like those that dominate in the Mediterranean and their offshoots, men being vulnerable and emotional was actually encouraged, albeit only in certain, limited contexts. It was the "frontier western" stereotype of the stoic loner that was really the birth of modern toxic masculine culture.

I don't want to jump around too far from the conversation, so I hope this is an appropriate question: What do you mean by "expression of toxic masculinity" and what is "toxic masculinity"? I've heard several different definitions and I'm not sure what you're using. Here are 2 common ones I've heard...
1) toxic masculinity is having some combination of extreme masculine traits (fitting a gender role)
2) toxic masculinity is the act of pushing those traits onto others (enforcing gender roles)

I hope those make sense. I'm not good at putting things like this into words

second/third highlight:
I disagree, and think you've reframed what I said to be more about blaming women than it is. We may disagree about what vulnerability is. Accepting that one is victim of society's standards (and I would argue gynocentrism/male disposability) doesn't make one not vulnerable. Pointing fingers at sources of suffering doesn't make the suffering - and acceptance of victimhood - no longer being vulnerable, imo
 
Men bully each other into drinking too much.
Men bully each other into eating too much meat.
Men bully each other by using "gay" as an insult.
Men bully each other about being crazy; veg*an; different.
Men fear being bullied.
Men bully each other into being bullies.

Drinking, eating, and arguing too much cause obesity, depression, and unhappy relationships.

It's easier for some men to chant, "Send them back" to female politicians than it is to not drink with their buddies who have the same social pressures as themselves.
It's easier for men to angrily argue the existence of climate change than it is to act differently and learn new ways of living, especially when you're afraid of appearing different to your family, buddies, workmates.

As with dieting, health, mental health, and political blame, men want a quick fix, being the hunter/action man in their minds, and ending it all can seem easier than gradual change.
 
Men bully each other into drinking too much.
Men bully each other into eating too much meat.
Men bully each other by using "gay" as an insult.
Men bully each other about being crazy; veg*an; different.
Men fear being bullied.
Men bully each other into being bullies.

Drinking, eating, and arguing too much cause obesity, depression, and unhappy relationships.

It's easier for some men to chant, "Send them back" to female politicians than it is to not drink with their buddies who have the same social pressures as themselves.
It's easier for men to angrily argue the existence of climate change than it is to act differently and learn new ways of living, especially when you're afraid of appearing different to your family, buddies, workmates.

As with dieting, health, mental health, and political blame, men want a quick fix, being the hunter/action man in their minds, and ending it all can seem easier than gradual change.

Maybe in your world.

It doesn't work that way in mine.

I should probably add it is quite humorous that you think all climate change deniers are male.
 
Maybe in your world.

It doesn't work that way in mine.

This forum is part of your world.


I should probably add it is quite humorous that you think all climate change deniers are male.

Don't shove your words in my mouth to make a convenient straw man, distraction and derail.

I've seen female climate change deniers, bullies, carnivores, alcoholics.

I said nothing about any of these being only male problems.

I described the pattern of what happens to men, sticking to the topic.

You could have thought a bit more before making your denials. Have you been drinking?
 
Last edited:
This forum is part of your world.

I haven't seen your following on the forum

Men bully each other into drinking too much.
Men bully each other into eating too much meat.
Men bully each other by using "gay" as an insult.
Men bully each other about being crazy; veg*an; different.
Men fear being bullied.
Men bully each other into being bullies.

Drinking, eating, and arguing too much cause obesity, depression, and unhappy relationships.

It's easier for some men to chant, "Send them back" to female politicians than it is to not drink with their buddies who have the same social pressures as themselves.
 
Actually that isn't entirely true

If it a bloke I have seen picking on a child as well.

And angry old white men
 
Sorry?

This is unintelligible.

Again I ask if you have been drinking.

It isn't that hard

And then there are the misogynistic attacks on Greta Thunberg.

Me in answer

The slightest criticism of Greta's methods is labelled misogynistic unless it is not a bloke

Actually that isn't entirely true

If it a bloke I have seen picking on a child as well.

And angry old white men
 
The slightest criticism of Greta's methods is labelled misogynistic unless it is not a bloke

Actually that isn't entirely true

If it a bloke I have seen picking on a child as well.

And angry old white men


Women can be misogynistic, too. It's not unusual at all. There is also toxic femininity, but this thread is mainly about an epidemic of white male suicides allegedly being ignored.
 
Women can be misogynistic, too. It's not unusual at all. There is also toxic femininity, but this thread is mainly about an epidemic of white male suicides allegedly being ignored.

Yes I know

Which is why I was wondering why you brought up Greta
 
I still don't understand why this is seen as an epidemic. I am not saying that it is not, it just seems there are perhaps conflicting statistics.

Again, having personal experience that led me to reviewing every thing I could find, it does not seem to point to the issue being "ignored". I have come across many, many sites, blogs, comments, that seem to indicate that this is being openly discussed.

As someone up-thread said, it is not the 1950's. Things have changed a lot. Most men I know talk about feelings with both women and other men. When my sons were in their teens, and I was a single mother, the oldest would call for "a family meeting", where we sat down and aired any issues or complaints we had. Now that they are grown, I see how open they are with their wives and children, and realize what a healthy habit they have developed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom