When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
I was getting at their penchant for trying to make simple numbers look impressive. For instance "2000 A & E", as if that is a significant number.
250K seems like a lot of people when in fact it's miniscule if the pool is the world's internet community.
Even if it were limited to just Mexico, USA and Canada it would be well under ten percent of the population of teens plus adults.
 
Statistics-wise, the first half of June has been an absolute desaster:

|A&E signers|other signers|FB likes|Page hits
Period|per month|per month|per day|per day
3-year avg. |+18.2|+154|+173|+5679
Jun 2014|+13|+219||
Mar 2015|+10|+75|+106|+3731
Apr 2015|+14|+57|+127|+3760
May 2015|+0|+36|+59|+3904
1-16 Jun '15| -0,5 |+1,5|+30|+3388

They've been below long-term averages for months in all categories, but June is so far setting new record lows everywhere.

They have not added even one signature to the A&E list since late April. I am sure there are signatures to be verified (a month ago, they claimed, they gor 150 signatures at the AIA Convention), but it becomes more and more obvious that no one is doing the verifying any longer, at least for the A&E! That is not to say that they do nothing - occasionally they let a handful of other supporters in; those do not require a background check of academic degrees and licenses. The +3 "other" supporters so far in June were actually at least 14 signatures added minus 11 signatures taken off.
For a few years now, the leader of the Verification Team has been Laura Nieboer. She also attended the AIA Conventions in recent years, but I did not see her this year. Perhaps she's gone?

I have been looking closely at the development of Facebook likes, since this past week the daily average dropped to only +10, and there have now been two days with even a net loss. Sampling at 5-minutes intervals at different times of the day, I found that they actually lose something like 50-100 likes every day (people either unliking, or terminating their accounts, I suppose), while gaing slightly more than that new likes. This means that roughly 10% of their current likers are leaving per year, while they gain perhaps 15% new likers. It stands to reason that, all else being equal, the proportion of unlikes will remain constant. If their total likes increase by 50%, so will the daily/annual unlikes. At the same time, the rate of new likes has not been climbing. It follows that a dynamic equilibrium isn't so far ahead in terms of numbers (but it would take a long time to get there).
AE911T's Facebook page will never reach the juggernaut strength of 1 million likes! (even at the average rate of the last 3 years, this would take 12 years; but that rate will decline asymptotically towards 0).
 
Oystein, does AE911T use the Facebook feature of "boosting" their posts or site?
I don't doubt they do employ something for this, but the objective traffic data for the site rankings would indicate that it doesn't work in upping their publicity by a long shot... that is after all the entire point of such exercises. That would in turn indicate that their media skills in good publicity just patently suck. ;)
 
Oystein, does AE911T use the Facebook feature of "boosting" their posts or site?

Not really.
Some of their articles link to YouTube, some link nothing. Sometimes they copy the beginning of a longer article that they also send via email newsletter and then link to the full newsletter text - but those are not hosted on their own domain ae911truth.org.
 
So far, 11 days later, not a single signature verified and appended to the petition. I guess office is closed.

While searching for something else (recent information about the Verification Team), I stumbled across this article from last years's Convention in Chicago:
CHICAGO AIA CONVENTION ACTIVISTS NET OVER 120 MORE A/E PETITION SIGNERS
That Convention was held in June 26-28, 2014. AE911Truth claims:
ae911truth said:
AE911Truth had surpassed even its own expectations, eclipsing the Denver results by amassing more than 120 new petition signers — 100 of them architects or engineers, including four new FAIA members
... between 2013/12/29 and 2014/11/03 (6 months prior to and 4 months after the Convention), they added
  • 21 licensed architects (2 identified as FAIA, 4 more as AIA)
  • 9 unlicensed architects (1 identified as Associate AIA)
  • ...
I call ******** on the "120 new petition signers" during the 2014 Convention ...

The article I cited with 120 Chicago signers was written and published in July 2014.

I just saw that their current page on Membership and the 2015 Agenda, first published in January 2015, now even claims 200 new signatures:
ae911truth said:
2014 HIGHLIGHTS

...
AIA Convention
6. Educated thousands of architects at the June 2014 AIA Convention in Chicago, adding 200 new petition signers while there and bringing the total number of architect and engineer petition signers to more than 2,300.
(You have to click on "With you... Read More >>" )

Note that there they explicitly claim that these 200 are included in the "more than 2,300" signers!

This is now a clear and blatant lie. On June 25, 2014 - a day before the Chicago AIA Convention began - the petition had 2207 signers. At the end of 2014, they had reached 2323 signatures - that's only +116 signers! The vast majority of those must have been unlicensed engineers and signers from outside the USA - not architects!
 
The article I cited with 120 Chicago signers was written and published in July 2014.

I just saw that their current page on Membership and the 2015 Agenda, first published in January 2015, now even claims 200 new signatures:

(You have to click on "With you... Read More >>" )

Note that there they explicitly claim that these 200 are included in the "more than 2,300" signers!

This is now a clear and blatant lie. On June 25, 2014 - a day before the Chicago AIA Convention began - the petition had 2207 signers. At the end of 2014, they had reached 2323 signatures - that's only +116 signers! The vast majority of those must have been unlicensed engineers and signers from outside the USA - not architects!

Truthers doing what they do best....lying.
 
June is history, 2015 is half a year old. What has AE911Truth achieved in that time?

Short answer: NOTHING.

First, the boring statistics:

A) THE PETITION

Jan-Jun 2015 has been the worst half year ever for them:



They got the most signatures per day in late 2009/early 2010 (for A&E/Others, respectively) - that was 5 years ago and more.

Part of the reason that those numbers are so bad is of course, as I already mentioned, that Gage's office fails to verify signatures:
  • Not a single Architect or Engineer verified and added to the list since April
  • A handful of Other Supporters are occasiolly added - and sometimes subtracted, but, for example, a signature that I submitted about 2 weeks ago still doesn't appear on the list or in the count

And thus, the number of signatures per day, averaged month to month, has developed like this:



They actually lost one A&E in June!

And for the sixth time in a row, the Quarter was was worse than the same quater a year before:



B) FACEBOOK LIKES

There was a period of 2 weeks in June, from the 13th to the 27th, when the number of likes didn't increase (in fact, it very slightly declined). During most of the rest of the month, they gained around 30 likes/per day, so the average for the month came out at +18 per day - only a tenth of the longterm average they had (+191) before Facebook cracked down on them and removed more than 10,000 likes in mid-March.






C) PAGE HITS

Traffic to their homepage has this downward trend, too:



April, May and June all had less traffic than any month since October 2011. The average for the half year since january has been the slowest half year since early 2010.



D) MONEY

Unfortunately, I have zero information on incoming money. I already made the mistake in 2012 to predict from declining interest in the petition, the homepage or their Facebook presence a decrease in money income. Gage's focus had successfully shifted towards milking the followers he already had.
 
Other achievement January - June 2015:


A) The "Ambitious 2015 Agenda"

When they relaunched their homepage in early January, they posted an agenda for 2015 under "What you can do - Membership":
AE911Truth said:
1. New Research Initiatives
• Conduct sophisticated computer modeling of World Trade Center Building 7 to demonstrate, first, the impossibility of the collapse initiation mechanism put forth by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and, second, that a controlled demolition more readily replicates the observed destruction.
• Research, write, and publish monthly technical briefs.
• Publish and market a book based on psychologist Frances Shure’s groundbreaking series, “Why Do Good People Become Silent—Or Worse—About 9/11?”

2. Expanded Outreach Initiatives
• Train and coordinate a team of ten or more presenters around the U.S., who will give, in total, at least five presentations each week, with an emphasis on reaching audiences at colleges and universities.
• Renew outreach to the academic engineering community with quarterly mailings and phone calls from AE911Truth’s engineers to their local university’s engineering faculty.
• Systematically correspond with professional associations and other institutions to gain allies.
• Attend and speak at the annual conference of the American Institute of Architects (AIA) and similar events.
• Retool our national grassroots organizing apparatus and establish a permanent presence at the National September 11 Memorial & Museum.

3. Legal Strategies
• Sue NIST and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) under the Freedom of Information Act for refusal to release data.
• Submit a Request for Correction under the Information Quality Act, using the results of the computer modeling of WTC 7 to prove NIST’s errors.
I marked in red the activities on which no progress has been reported yet
In SandyBrown those that had at least some progress reported - I was generous here.
In SeaGreen the lone agenda issue which so far has been fullfilled (well, ignoring the "and similar events" caveat).

SandyBrown items:
  • "Research, write, and publish monthly technical briefs." Simon Falkner (business student) and Chris Sarns (carpenter) have published parts 3 to 6 of their series "NIST's WTC 7 Reports: Filled with Fantasy, Fiction, and Fraud". It is generous for me to count this - presumably, this was already written or at least drafted in 2014, and it is doubtful if this digest of truther talking points written by two technical non-experts counts as "technical briefs". But it's all they have!
  • "Renew outreach to the academic engineering community with quarterly mailings and phone calls from AE911Truth’s engineers to their local university’s engineering faculty." I really don't know if this has been done in any systematic fashion, but at least the did report: Architecture and Engineering Faculties of Five Major Universities Receive Explosive 9/11 Evidence
  • "Systematically correspond with professional associations and other institutions to gain allies." Again I can't speak of any "systematical" effort, and generously count the above unsolicited mailing of stuff to some university departments towards this goal.
Finally, the lone "green" activity:
  • "Attend and speak at the annual conference of the American Institute of Architects (AIA)" - Yep, they did go there, burned money, spoke - and got their arses handed back to them in a crushing 4:96 voting defeat.


Other than this list of failures and non-achievements, Gage toured Europe for a month. In some sites, I understand, he drew nice crowds (around 1,000 in Delft!), elsewhere the usual few dozens to couple of hundred. Mostly already committed truthers.

Also, they burned money on Harrit's silly lost appeal in a Danish court house.


I may be missing some activities, but Gage's staff doesn't do a good job publishing success, if there is any. Work on the homepage has stalled, I see no development other than the occasional (3 per month) news article. For example, Kelly David has been a member of their Board since approximately March 25 (I have an email from Gage's office saying so), but the homepage still only lists Gage, Barnum, McCoy and Spellman.
 
Last edited:
There are no real successes other than more funding... They are not going to research and publish a rational technical book, or paper showing CD was how it happened.

Keep hope alive... so people can fork over money so AE can continue to ask for more money based on fantasy projects.... which the naive believe are for real.

It's funny and it's sad.
 
There are no real successes other than more funding... They are not going to research and publish a rational technical book, or paper showing CD was how it happened.

Keep hope alive... so people can fork over money so AE can continue to ask for more money based on fantasy projects.... which the naive believe are for real.

It's funny and it's sad.

Its almost as if the organization is hypothyroid as a whole.

I was dx'd with hypothyroidism about 12 years ago. I had gone to the Dr. because I was seemingly stuck in perpetual planning mode. Could plan out in detail what I would do, and plan, and plan ,and plan , and only by extreme force of will actually 'do' anything. Sound familiar? Maybe a daily does of thyroxine to all the 2K A&E is in order.:)
 
Prompted by something cantonear1968 posted in another thread today, I need to dump so dirty laundry here, as part of my documenting every spicy info on AE:

It starts with this April 2012 rant by Sarah and Thomas Corriher who had set up and run AE911Truth's servers until shortly before that, before being mobbed out (with then-Board member Justin Keogh apparently leading the mob):
The Shaky Moral Foundation that AE911Truth is Built Upon
(Note that the Corrihers probably believe in even nuttier stuff than Gage. Still, their criticism of the organisation is solid).

Make sure to read the comments, and follow links there!
Oh what the heck, here they are:

Mark Graham, September 2013: A PDF proposing improvements to Gage's bad management
Mark Graham, December 2013: a follow-up blog post
(perhaps I should check out what else there is on davis911truth.org)


And while I am at it: Here's my conversation with Mark from two years ago - I don't think I ever posted it (me in blue, Mark in black):

June 23, 2013
Hi Mark,

I just read your comment at 911Blogger on AE's "ReThink" campaign from 4 days ago. Sounds pretty bitter! I remember having seen you featured in several articles at the ae homepage as one of their team leaders. Just curious: You still active there in that capacity, or some other, despite your apparent frustration?

I could try to reply at 911Blogger, but somehow moderation there seems to be inactive, and I have, ever since I signed up, been on a status that doesn't allow me to post without moderator approval.

Cheers
Oy

---------------------------

June 24 2013 07:37
Hi Oy,

Although we now know that NSA saves our emails, if you want to correspond by email mine is [email protected]

I'm glad to see that Gage has not had my comment removed! It was quite hard to find on blogger though.

http://911blogger.com/news/2013-05-25/here-it-final-ad-911-global-campaign

My intention was to put out the facts so that people considering donating time and money to AE could make an informed decision and avoid wasting their time and money. Despite a rosy appearance Gage is not really interested in doing what it would take for AE to succeed in its stated mission. Thus he is wasting everybody's time while making off like a bandit. Remember his $85,000 a year salary from AE911Truth plus his rent, cell phone, car, etc. are ALL paid.

My hope was that my message would be evaluated based on the facts. Not on emotions. Same way I want people (and Gage wants people) to evaluate 9/11 Truth and the government's story about 19 Arab hijackers.

Did you agree with my analysis of this $600,000 billboard campaign? Do you think it can succeed? How much money do you think has already been raised? (raised, not pledged).

There is nothing I can do about whether you perceived my message as bitter.

There is nothing wrong with being bitter after investing 3 years, thousands of hours of work in AE and finding out what a phony Richard Gage is. If you went through that experience (and I don't think you would have stuck it out that long) you would be a combination of disappointed, angry at Gage, bitter, and very well informed by the whole experience. And grateful for the good people you were able to meet and work with along the way. As I am.

As of late November last year I am no longer affiliated with AE. I am working on a letter to my friends and former colleagues there telling what I think is wrong with AE and what would have to be done to fix it.

Cordially,
Mark

-------------------------------------------------

June 24 2013
Wow, Mark, that's heavy!

Looking at the donors:
http://fundly.com/otp/donors?page=0&limit=1000
It seems rather obvious that 176,000+60,000+50,000 = 286,000 of the total of $315,176 total haven't actually been raised, that leaves $29,176 actual donations - less than 10%. Of those, the biggest single donation is $5,000 - could be phony as well.
I believe though that the 50,000 are left over from the "Building What" campaign and represent actual money in AE's purse. So they have about 80K to spend right now.
As far as pledges go, I think it is unclear if pledges will be payed out when cities don't reach their targets, and find it possible that no pledges actually will be payed at all.
I also agree that it is unclear what happens to money donated by city teams when the fall far short of targets. Most cities are under $300, you won't buy any effective advertising with such peanuts. (Most cities of course have raised 0).
So no, I don't think the billboard campaign will have measurable success. Few cities will see little advertising, and little will come of it.

Just a few days ago, Gage posted this at his website:
http://www1.ae911truth.org/en/news-section/41-articles/770-ae911truth-summer-membership-drive.html
Note: "The worldwide ReThink911 ad campaign is off to an incredible start, with $100,000 raised already"
100K? Not 300K? :D


I saw another bitter comment by another former AE team leader, Joe d'Angelo, on the AE911Truth Facebook page:
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?...omment_id=8441990&offset=0&total_comments=111
Seems you're not the only one disappointed by Gage's leadership.


So what does it take to achieve the AE goals, i.e. a new investigation? I think two things are paramount:
1. Shed dubious claims of facts from the presentation. For example, "WTC7 dropped into footprint" is so obviously false, it should be dropped. I am certain that the "red-gray chips = thermite" claim is false, and a major liability to the credibility. "Multi-ton steel sections ejected laterally" are a nonsense argument - I know Tony Szamboti, one of the very few serious engineers doing serious engineering calcs for AE, thinks this is not a proper argument for CD.
2. Change strategy and move towards actually defining and organising a new investigation, i.e. tap human resources (1900+ A&E) and start serious research! Do your own FEAs, or whatever it takes. Support publishing in actual engineering journals - that's what decision makers would take serious.


Cheers
Oy


Mark then dropped the ball, I think (unless we continued via email; I lost my mails from that time, and don't remember)
 
Perhaps I have too much time... I am currently listening to the latest, June 24, recording of the TruthTeleconference (hosted by Craig McKee and Ken Freeland).

At 7:00, a Barton Bruce has something technical about Richard Gage not wanting to be on the mailing list (I can't understand all of the mumbling).
At 8:00, someone (I believe McKee) interrupts and has some interesting remarks:
I assume you all know that Dave Slesinger's got nothing to do with AE911Truth anymore. And Wayne Coste, who was on Board no longer's on the Board and no longer's doing anything with them.
The latter is a strange remark - as just 2 weeks ago, Wayne Coste was scheduled to present a paper in Orleans, France - trip sponsored by AE Travels!
McKee goes on:
...and Richard Gage doesn't really run the show. There's a really prosperous, prominent, rich California architect who's the first one to speak on some of the videos and not on others, who really runs the Board meetings.
No name given, and ae911truth.org doesn't have a current list of Board members, but let's see, besides Gage, they have Dan Barnum of Houston, Texas; Tom Spellman of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin; and Robert McCoy of La Canada, California. His bio:
ae911truth.org said:
Robert McCoy, AIA, Architect, Board Chairman

Robert McCoy received a Bachelor of Architecture degree from the University of California at Berkeley in 1963. He has been a licensed California architect since 1964. For the next 20 years, most of his experience was in multi-story, high-rise, steel-frame buildings, including the 34-story headquarters for Pacific Gas and Electric in San Francisco. McCoy also participated in the design of 575 Market Street, a 44-story building for Standard Oil's headquarters, and 100 Pine Street, a 34-story office building.
Would that make him prominent and rich? Maybe. He's the owner of his architecture firm, McCoy Associates (here's a letter with leterhead - seems he's moved up from board secretary to board chairman).
Anyway, McKee continues:
And so I don't know who is calling what shots or what the ground rules are. The current lady, Kelly David, who's the replaced [? Conya ??] there, has been difficult from my point of view at least to get to tick things on, you know, whatever, your access to this and that things on the website or whatever, or mail access, when they've changed something and things don't work anymore, getting her to do anything may take several calls to Richard. There's things going on behind the scenes there. Why Slesinger left, he did some rather outrageous threats, which he basically deserved what he got, but it's hard to know [..?..]. And, you know, Wayne Coste is, you know, whatever, I think just left. He's been muscled out of the position he was doing, he was their "Congressional Outreach"... So they are doing just their own thing their own way. But there's things going on behind the scences at ae911truth that I don't in anyway pretend to understand. But someone like Barbara Honegger is very [? up to now? apt to know ?], and Wayne is [? up to now? apt to know ?] a lot, too, so would Dave Slesinger know, but Wayne is someone you might prefer to ask of the two. They're both good guys.
Oh and then I get what the technicality was: Gage wants to be included in the distribution list, but not be listed anywhere :D
 
Perhaps Gage is ok keeping his cash cow salary + expenses and letting another prominent architect run things for him. It's hard to know. They MO is people join with good intentions, try to help in various ways.... run into many road blocks from Gage, the volunteers, the "culture" and leave or are tossed out. Gage remains and a few loyal yes men henchmen. The illusion is always preserved and usually the departed make a few parting shots and don't bother waging a battle to expose the BS. By default that takes on the appearance more of sour grapes than of being a truth teller exposing the corruption... as the organization still manages to hold a veneer of "respectability", being a legitimate 501c(3) and battle for truth, justice and the American way. Opposing that makes you look terribly creepy... So the illusion goes on. It's funny and tragic.
 
Perhaps I have too much time... I am currently listening to the latest, June 24, recording of the TruthTeleconference (hosted by Craig McKee and Ken Freeland).

At 7:00, a Barton Bruce has something technical about Richard Gage not wanting to be on the mailing list (I can't understand all of the mumbling).
At 8:00, someone (I believe McKee) interrupts and has some interesting remarks:

The latter is a strange remark - as just 2 weeks ago, Wayne Coste was scheduled to present a paper in Orleans, France - trip sponsored by AE Travels!
McKee goes on:

No name given, and ae911truth.org doesn't have a current list of Board members, but let's see, besides Gage, they have Dan Barnum of Houston, Texas; Tom Spellman of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin; and Robert McCoy of La Canada, California. His bio:

Would that make him prominent and rich? Maybe. He's the owner of his architecture firm, McCoy Associates (here's a letter with leterhead - seems he's moved up from board secretary to board chairman).
Anyway, McKee continues:

Oh and then I get what the technicality was: Gage wants to be included in the distribution list, but not be listed anywhere :D

I see what you are saying in the other thread, Oystein. AE911T does seem to have quite the turnover within their ranks.
 
Another ae911truth FAIL:
...just 2 weeks ago, Wayne Coste was scheduled to present a paper in Orleans, France - trip sponsored by AE Travels! ...

Now look what I found:
https://www.facebook.com/ae911truth....164274.59185411268/10152885448121269/?type=1
ae911t said:
Free Fall host Andy Steele will give an update on the European Society for Engineering Education's censorship of an ethics-in-engineering paper that was to be presented at its 2015 conference earlier this month. The paper, which had been accepted but was banned a few days before SEFI's annual conference in France, argues that the integrity of the engineering profession has been undermined by the failure of engineering professional associations and faculties at universities to critically examine NIST's World Trade Center reports.
Whut? Europe is not supporting da Twoof? Eeeeenterresteeng! :p
 
Haha this is fun!
On this conference paper that the ae911truthers didn't get to present in Orleans, France:

The Procedings of the SEFI 2015 Annual Conference are available online now:
Full papers (listed by author) - Wayne Coste and Mike Smith are missing.
Book of abstracts - do a text search for "Coste" and "Smith" and you DO find them listed in the Index at the end - their paper, number 54759 (which has a third author, Korol R. M.) was supposed to be on page 105 but - the book has no page 105: Page 106 follows page 104. And it appears that this is the only page that was removed!

So there we have circumstantial evidence that indeed their paper was initially accepted but later busted.

2015 is a terrible, terrible, embarrassing year for ae911truth...
 
Haha this is fun!
On this conference paper that the ae911truthers didn't get to present in Orleans, France:

The Procedings of the SEFI 2015 Annual Conference are available online now:
Full papers (listed by author) - Wayne Coste and Mike Smith are missing.
Book of abstracts - do a text search for "Coste" and "Smith" and you DO find them listed in the Index at the end - their paper, number 54759 (which has a third author, Korol R. M.) was supposed to be on page 105 but - the book has no page 105: Page 106 follows page 104. And it appears that this is the only page that was removed!

So there we have circumstantial evidence that indeed their paper was initially accepted but later busted.

2015 is a terrible, terrible, embarrassing year for ae911truth...
Is the submitted "paper" sourced by AE/911? Please forgive my laziness in searching, at this point, it's really hard to give a crap what any of them say. :)

ETA: That said, We're having a great time here at NHMS. Rebel flags and all, it's a great time with good friends.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom