When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
The number of A&E petition signatures is still hovering near 2350, as it has been doing since late April. In fact, it has been declining slowly

08/01: 2354
09/01: 2351
10/01: 2349
today: 2348

Now I am not going to speculate why the lose a few signatures now and then. It sometimes happened that a signature disappears, only to reappear some weeks or even months later. Perhaps they are resolving issues then.

Yesterday, I took the time to download all current 2347 signatures (one is a double) and checked the differences to a download from August 26. To my slight surprise
  • there were 22 signatures where the name or place had been changed (James became Jim, people move to a different city/country, or a spelling was corrected)
  • one signer, a Steven, not only moved from Panama to Florida, he/she also had their first name changed to Jeanne :D
  • one signature is genuinly new since late August: William Dumke of Green Bay.
I had slightly suspected that there is some technical problem with the database or its web server interface that prevented them from entering or displaying new A&E signatures, but that is disproven now. I am at a complete loss to explain why they don't add new architects and engineers. They claimed 150 paper signatures at the AIA Convention in May, and a couple dozend this past weekend in Vegas, but they apparently choose not to publish them electronocally.

I have not downloaded the 20,000+ other signers, but that number is growing ever so slightly:
05/01: 20214
06/01: 20250
07/01: 20261
08/01: 20327
09/01: 20309 <- this shows that they are both adding and subtracting
10/01: 20318
In fact, I have submitted an "other supporters" signature some weeks ago, and it was accepted and published within less than 24 hours (Laila Selk). So this unusually slow growth (1.0% annually since June 1st, compared to 11.1% in both 2014 and 2013) may be "real".


Web traffic / page hits

In contrast to this, the web traffic at ae911truth.org experienced its usual September peak (albeit 45% under the Sep 2014 peak):




Facebook Likes

Biiig September peak here: For the first time, they averaged more than 300 Likes/day. This was due to two factors: Apparently there is a base level of perhaps 250 "bought" likes/day, and the actual 9/11 peak:
9/10: 388
9/11: 1592
9/12: 679
9/13: 535
9/14: 447
9/15: 362




PR activity

I have no stats on this, but lately (since a month ago or so), they seem to have put out more articles both on the Facebook page and the homepage than they did all summer long.


Board of Directors

Oh, and they finally got around to adding an article on Kelly David as new (since Spring 2015) Chief Operating Officer and member of the Board of Directors, to join Gage (President), Robert McCoy (Board Chairman), Dan Barnum (Secretary), and Tom Spellman (Treaurer).
 
The number of A&E petition signatures is still hovering near 2350, as it has been doing since late April. In fact, it has been declining slowly

08/01: 2354
09/01: 2351
10/01: 2349
today: 2348

Now I am not going to speculate why the lose a few signatures now and then. It sometimes happened that a signature disappears, only to reappear some weeks or even months later. Perhaps they are resolving issues then.

Yesterday, I took the time to download all current 2347 signatures (one is a double) and checked the differences to a download from August 26. To my slight surprise
  • there were 22 signatures where the name or place had been changed (James became Jim, people move to a different city/country, or a spelling was corrected)
  • one signer, a Steven, not only moved from Panama to Florida, he/she also had their first name changed to Jeanne :D
  • one signature is genuinly new since late August: William Dumke of Green Bay.
I had slightly suspected that there is some technical problem with the database or its web server interface that prevented them from entering or displaying new A&E signatures, but that is disproven now. I am at a complete loss to explain why they don't add new architects and engineers. They claimed 150 paper signatures at the AIA Convention in May, and a couple dozend this past weekend in Vegas, but they apparently choose not to publish them electronocally.

Guess what: It lives!
But barely.

Since I posted the above on October 5th, they have grown to *gasp* 2360 displayed signature - that's +12!
I checked, and 5 of these are reappearances, 7 are genuinly new. So they are back to adding signatures!

But why only 7? There had been this structural engineering conference in Vegas in early October, where, so they claim, 24 visitors to their booth signed on - but I have so far only 2 new civil engineers, neither of whom mention Vegas in their personal statement.
 
Just went down to the 9/11 Memorial. Place was packed. I was really hoping to bait a truther but couldn't find one. I suppose that's good really
 
Just went down to the 9/11 Memorial. Place was packed. I was really hoping to bait a truther but couldn't find one. I suppose that's good really

The best spot to bait a truther around there is on Vesey Street adjacent to the Path Tubes station. Apparently, they are there every Saturday.
 
Update for November 2015


A) SIGNATURES

Since October they are confirming and adding signatures again. I have no way to tell if those they are adding now are fresh, or the backlog that must have piled up since they stopped appending the list in late April. Anyway, they are at A&E 2393 signatures at the end of November - that's +18 in October and +27 in November; or annual growth rates of 9,4% and 14.8%. 0.58 and 0.9 new signatures per day is somewhat better than the 2014 average and slightly worse that 2013 - but you can't really compare that, if they are taking signatures from a months old backlog. 2015 as a whole is definitely on track to becoming their worst year ever: They have +72 signatures (3.4% annually) since the beginning of the year, 37 less than 2012, their previous record low.

"Other Supporters" had
+48 | 1.6/day | +2.8% annually in October
+149 | 5.0/day | +9.3% annually in November
That's so far +497 | 1.5/day | +2.7% annually for 2015 - far far below the previous record low of +1781 in 2013.

Graphics to go with that:



HOMEPAGE HITS

Traffic to ae011truth.org has been rather steady all year long, between 3150 and 5150 page hits per day - October and November are smack in the middle of that range at 3829 and 4427/day. Since March, this has consistently been between 23% and 55% below the level one year prior.




FACEBOOK LIKES

Good times and bad times come in strange patterns:
  • Between early May and mid August, they had under 100 Likes/day on 98 of 100 days.
  • Then, for 19 days, they had more than 300 Likes/day every day exept one.
  • Then they had a week averaging under 100
  • Then, from early September to mid-October, more than 200 Likes/day every day for 39 days straight
  • Then under 200/day for 7 days straight
  • Then 200+ on 18 out of 20 days
  • Then under 150 for 12 straight days
  • Then they jumped to 350+ for the last 2 days I recorded so far.
I can never associate those trend changes to any events (with the sole exception of the 9/11 aniversary, which accounted for 1500 to 2000 extra Likes over that weekend). There are no marketing measures, no newsletters, no earth-shattering announcements, no stories running in the MSM that I can see.
Only explanation I have is their switching on and off payed Likes from black commercial providers of such dubious services.

My graphic, sampling on the 1st of each month, doesn't do justice to these pronounced spells of low and high activity:
 
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."

> Margaret Mead
 
http://www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/...WSDfumsdDhw9XFThirKJ/story.html?event=event25

Alex Beam’s portrayal of “architect truthers” is yet another disappointing example of a journalist resorting to ad hominem attacks and avoiding the facts when discussing the destruction of the three World Trade Center skyscrapers on Sept. 11, 2001 (“The ‘truthers’ and 9/11,” Opinion, Nov. 16).

Sadly, not one sentence of Beam’s column examines the evidence for or against the controlled demolition of the Twin Towers and WTC Building 7. Instead, he devotes 600 words to revealing his own ill-founded bias.

He cherry-picks the appearance of three nonexperts from the 15-minute video “Architects & Engineers — Solving the Mystery of Building 7,” but doesn’t highlight any of the film’s “various experts.” Noting that some Americans think that what happened that day hasn’t “been fully explained,” he declares, “I don’t agree,” but gives no evidence-based reason for disagreeing. His position rests on his revulsion at the idea that someone — “our own government,” he supposes — consciously demolished the World Trade Center.

As building professionals, we at Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth try not to let personal feelings interfere with investigating the three worst structural failures in modern history. Nearly 2,400 architects and engineers, not including the 109 who signed our petition at the recent annual trade show ABX, have joined us because we stick to science.

The physical evidence shows that scattered office fires could not have caused the 47-story WTC 7 to collapse symmetrically into its footprint. (Imagine Boston’s 52-story Prudential Tower completely collapsing in seven seconds from small fires — it’s hard to, isn’t it?) The evidence also shows that the twin towers were not leveled by the airplane impacts and ensuing fires.

The implications are indeed far-reaching, and that is why we urge people to study all the evidence before reaching a conclusion.

Richard Gage

Berkeley, Calif.

It seems he is upset his appeal to authority has been challenged.
 
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."

> Margaret Mead

Or misguided dolts, like NAZIs... got to love the committed part...

911 truth is will not change anything; 911 truth will expose failed education, and overwhelming gullibility.
 
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."

> Margaret Mead

Too bad twofers are neither thoughtful or committed.

14 years of failure and counting...
 
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."

> Margaret Mead

Yes, eventually the creationists, through their "commitment" and "thoughtfulness", will finally defeat the Darwinian official story.
 
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."

> Margaret Mead

The 9/11 Truth Movement has merely a few ten thousands of luke-warm adherents worldwide. Merely a few thousands of activists.

Let's be generous and grant that 100,000 people in the World would give more than $100 to that cause (far fewer actually stand up!).

If every group of 100,000 humans got their 15 minutes of fame, it would take more than 2 years for the 7.3 billion people in the world today to get their moment of glory.


But I spotted and highlighted the problem that the 9/11 TM faces. They can't think.
 
But I spotted and highlighted the problem that the 9/11 TM faces. They can't think.
:thumbsup: Agreed.

I suggest it is because they cannot think convergently - the process needed to sort, select, align and link the necessary multiple factors to establish a logical argument. Their processes of "thinking" - if they ever try it - are divergent. And most of them:
(a) cannot process more than one factor at a time;
(b) cannot put multiple factors in a coherent context;
(c) routinely present conflicting claims - and appear unaware that they have rebutted themselves.

It is part of the support for this pair of hypotheses:
Hypothesis #1 - Truthers cannot think. AND
Hypothesis #2 - That is why many of them became truthers.
 
Last edited:
:thumbsup: Agreed.

I suggest it is because they cannot think convergently - the process needed to sort, select, align and link the necessary multiple factors to establish a logical argument. Their processes of "thinking" - if they ever try it - are divergent. And most of them:
(a) cannot process more than one factor at a time;
(b) cannot put multiple factors in a coherent context;
(c) routinely present conflicting claims - and appear unaware that they have rebutted themselves.

It is part of the support for this pair of hypotheses:
Hypothesis #1 - Truthers cannot think. AND
Hypothesis #2 - That is why many of them became truthers.

This is not entirely accurate. They do think... they do use logic. I suspect the problem is that they more easily fall for poor logic and reasoning, such as trusting "experts" while reject everything the MSM reports in one fee swoop... Further most people including truthers are really not technically up tp speed to evaluate something like a building collapse and tend to have cartoon (simplified) conceptions of things... which toss out details... and maybe the important stuff in the process. And I don't think most people are skilled observers... and believe their own (untrained) eyes naturally.

So this is really not that they are incapable of thinking... but they are "handicapped" and too easily sign on to what someone else says who SEEMS to know more than they do about a subject. And what seems have occurred is that there are a lot of "false prophets" who are more than willing to (mis)lead others for whatever the reason... ego, power, money, 15 minutes of fame...

And of course they can't even tell that their thinking about these topics is flawed. THAT would require more critical thinking than they have. It's almost like asking someone to pull themselves up by their own boot straps.
 
Yes - but their thinking is divergent NOT convergent.

Ask one of them to decide if something is "A" or "B" they are likely to come back with "there are more than two letters in the alphabet". "Don't you know that there are 26?"

That may be one description... I was thinking about two "truth" guys (DD and PZ) I know a bit and both are intelligent and clearly think or can. I can't understand why they "fall" for the truth pitch. I think both are definitely disgusted with US policies and distrustful of official "anything". So perhaps their default is to reject the official story from the get go and turn to "critics" who stand up another tale which arguably is no more spin than the official spin. We've been flooded with spin and advertising and PR, infotainment as news and so on... it's not hard to believe we live in a Truman show of sorts.

I think one of the drivers in their thinking is a cui bono notion... that everything we see was done with intent to benefit someone... so when they look at how made out... it supports the notion of self interest, self preservation and advancing a "war" agenda sort of thing. Once they recognize the motive... (common one) they simply find the "evidence" that supports it and ignore that which doesn't... or claim that the "proofs" are bogus.
 
That may be one description....
Yes it is - not "may be" either - "is"

..and the rest of your post is partially an example of the process. Notice how you only partially accept the single point I made - then raised about a dozen others? :)

"I say the sky is blue"

"but the grass is green and the roses are pink and those cows are black and white."

"But my comment was about the sky being blue."

"Are you denying that the grass is green?"

BUT your example should be OK - your diversions are at least true - the truther version - as well as missing/avoiding the point would probably be untrue also.

But the structure is still divergent. :D
 
Little unimportant event:

The petition reached the 2400 A&Es mark today.
Congratulation. It took you only about 13 months since the last round hundred (2300 reached in early 11/2014). This was the first time they took more than a year to add 100.

Strange, given that they claimed (up to) 150 new signers at the AIA Convention in May and 24 new signers at the NCSEA's "Structural Engineering Summit" in early October.
 
Yes - but their thinking is divergent NOT convergent.



Ask one of them to decide if something is "A" or "B" they are likely to come back with "there are more than two letters in the alphabet". "Don't you know that there are 26?"


Rejecting your false dilemmas is illogical??


Sent from our shared looking glass platform
 
AE911Truth has finally finished their IRS Form 990 financial statement for 2014:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/g2195oxvp5olw1d/2014 AE911 FEDERAL TAX RETURN FORM 990.pdf?dl=0
(PDF, 197 KB)

Some highlights:
  • Total income is down 32% from 2013, now at $606,571
  • Particularly, "Contributions and grants" (read: donations) are down 37%; now at $470,000
  • Richard Gage's salary is down 17% to $70,835,
  • Other salaries, to now 5 instead of 3 employees, are up 55% to $120,567
  • Other expenses are down 38%, to $428,170 ($7,600 of these go to Justin Keogh's address, probably to support 911blogger.com)
I didn't think hard about what development I had expected. A couple of days before I recieved this form, I had stated to someone that I'd think income might be slightly (-10%) down. After all, 2013 had been exceptionally strong (+64%), much of that increase coming from the very focused and successful "ReThink911" campaign.
I did not see donations crashing by more than 1/3, and even less seen Gage having to cut his own salary.

The due date for the Form 990, after getting an extension, is Oct 31. In recent years, they submitted in the first half of November. Doing this only on Dec 09 is the largest delay so far.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom