ProBonoShill
Master Poster
- Joined
- May 17, 2010
- Messages
- 2,329
When's the funeral for AE/911 Truth?


The number of A&E petition signatures is still hovering near 2350, as it has been doing since late April. In fact, it has been declining slowly
08/01: 2354
09/01: 2351
10/01: 2349
today: 2348
Now I am not going to speculate why the lose a few signatures now and then. It sometimes happened that a signature disappears, only to reappear some weeks or even months later. Perhaps they are resolving issues then.
Yesterday, I took the time to download all current 2347 signatures (one is a double) and checked the differences to a download from August 26. To my slight surprise
I had slightly suspected that there is some technical problem with the database or its web server interface that prevented them from entering or displaying new A&E signatures, but that is disproven now. I am at a complete loss to explain why they don't add new architects and engineers. They claimed 150 paper signatures at the AIA Convention in May, and a couple dozend this past weekend in Vegas, but they apparently choose not to publish them electronocally.
- there were 22 signatures where the name or place had been changed (James became Jim, people move to a different city/country, or a spelling was corrected)
- one signer, a Steven, not only moved from Panama to Florida, he/she also had their first name changed to Jeanne
- one signature is genuinly new since late August: William Dumke of Green Bay.
Just went down to the 9/11 Memorial. Place was packed. I was really hoping to bait a truther but couldn't find one. I suppose that's good really



Alex Beam’s portrayal of “architect truthers” is yet another disappointing example of a journalist resorting to ad hominem attacks and avoiding the facts when discussing the destruction of the three World Trade Center skyscrapers on Sept. 11, 2001 (“The ‘truthers’ and 9/11,” Opinion, Nov. 16).
Sadly, not one sentence of Beam’s column examines the evidence for or against the controlled demolition of the Twin Towers and WTC Building 7. Instead, he devotes 600 words to revealing his own ill-founded bias.
He cherry-picks the appearance of three nonexperts from the 15-minute video “Architects & Engineers — Solving the Mystery of Building 7,” but doesn’t highlight any of the film’s “various experts.” Noting that some Americans think that what happened that day hasn’t “been fully explained,” he declares, “I don’t agree,” but gives no evidence-based reason for disagreeing. His position rests on his revulsion at the idea that someone — “our own government,” he supposes — consciously demolished the World Trade Center.
As building professionals, we at Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth try not to let personal feelings interfere with investigating the three worst structural failures in modern history. Nearly 2,400 architects and engineers, not including the 109 who signed our petition at the recent annual trade show ABX, have joined us because we stick to science.
The physical evidence shows that scattered office fires could not have caused the 47-story WTC 7 to collapse symmetrically into its footprint. (Imagine Boston’s 52-story Prudential Tower completely collapsing in seven seconds from small fires — it’s hard to, isn’t it?) The evidence also shows that the twin towers were not leveled by the airplane impacts and ensuing fires.
The implications are indeed far-reaching, and that is why we urge people to study all the evidence before reaching a conclusion.
Richard Gage
Berkeley, Calif.
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."
> Margaret Mead
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."
> Margaret Mead
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."
> Margaret Mead
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has."
> Margaret Mead
But I spotted and highlighted the problem that the 9/11 TM faces. They can't think.
Agreed.
I suggest it is because they cannot think convergently - the process needed to sort, select, align and link the necessary multiple factors to establish a logical argument. Their processes of "thinking" - if they ever try it - are divergent. And most of them:
(a) cannot process more than one factor at a time;
(b) cannot put multiple factors in a coherent context;
(c) routinely present conflicting claims - and appear unaware that they have rebutted themselves.
It is part of the support for this pair of hypotheses:
Hypothesis #1 - Truthers cannot think. AND
Hypothesis #2 - That is why many of them became truthers.
Yes - but their thinking is divergent NOT convergent.This is not entirely accurate. They do think..
Yes - but their thinking is divergent NOT convergent.
Ask one of them to decide if something is "A" or "B" they are likely to come back with "there are more than two letters in the alphabet". "Don't you know that there are 26?"
Yes it is - not "may be" either - "is"That may be one description....
Yes - but their thinking is divergent NOT convergent.
Ask one of them to decide if something is "A" or "B" they are likely to come back with "there are more than two letters in the alphabet". "Don't you know that there are 26?"