When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
AE911T has had very little research or papers authored by an engineer or architect. Even fewer authored by such who have relevant qualification and/or experience in large steel structures.

A kid's book author,,,,,,,,:rolleyes:

Which is ironic given how much some of the people Beeeeeeeeeeeeee and moan about internet aliases and whether the person has a professional title in the latest crop of threads that have been active. They certainly have no qualms about those same people writing major articles on behalf of their namesake
 
I consider them far worse than a scamming group. Their use of their professional titles and the expected standard of knowledge just plain makes incompetent, and exasperates the deception they pull with their audience. I just still find it ironic - even though I've seen this for years - they carry out a huge double standard with the format they demand
 
Not forgetting the dubious "Petition Signers" == "Members"

Their actual membership limited to what - about a dozen.

And of those - excepting Gage - how many are game to appear in public discussion?

Whilst Gage only presents in tightly controlled dog and pony shows.
 
April was a bit better than January-March, but still below the 8-year average in every way. Nothing really interesting.

Whily watching the numbers of signatures from day to day, I frequently note that they have decreases, especially on the "general population" number. So I spent some time checking, and found:

From January 01 till May 03, the number of Other Supporters increased from 20022 to 20209, that's a net plus of +187.
However, this really is +225 new signers -38 deletions. For every 6 new signers, 1 other signer is deleted.

A&E increased from 2322 to 2353 (net + 31), that's +36 -5. For every 7 new signers, 1 other signer is deleted.


I can't know why they delete signatures - death, change of mind, ... . I'd kinda expect it though after 8 years.
 
A&E increased from 2322 to 2353 (net + 31), that's +36 -5. For every 7 new signers, 1 other signer is deleted.


I can't know why they delete signatures - death, change of mind, ... . I'd kinda expect it though after 8 years.

It's a funny bit of ethical conduct in an unethical organisation.

Makes you doubt the reasoning skill of those involved - if they are trying to keep their "roll" accurate - whilst forgetting that they are not "members" plus all the other dishonesty inherent in AE91.

Funny mindsets - I'm sort of convinced that the operator slaves are limited intellects trying to do an honest job. Quite sad really - Gage manipulating even his volunteer staff...
 
In this newsletter, sent on May 16 after the AIA Convention in Atlanta, they claim:

AE911Truth said:
We are pleased to have gained the signatures of another 150 AIA members, seven of whom are fellows of the Institute.

150 new signatures to the petition by (mostly) licensed architects? That's almost 50% of the number they have today (338, of whom 86 include "AIA" in their title).

I very much doubt this. I shall monitor! They historically took 2-3 weeks to verify the majority of new signatures, so by June 7th, half of the 150 should actually appear on the signature list.

I hold a personal prediction against that: 5 at most by the end of June 7th.
 
April was a bit better than January-March, but still below the 8-year average in every way. Nothing really interesting.

Whily watching the numbers of signatures from day to day, I frequently note that they have decreases, especially on the "general population" number. So I spent some time checking, and found:

From January 01 till May 03, the number of Other Supporters increased from 20022 to 20209, that's a net plus of +187.
However, this really is +225 new signers -38 deletions. For every 6 new signers, 1 other signer is deleted.

A&E increased from 2322 to 2353 (net + 31), that's +36 -5. For every 7 new signers, 1 other signer is deleted.


I can't know why they delete signatures - death, change of mind, ... . I'd kinda expect it though after 8 years.

It does seem signatures are eliminated frequently. For supporters it's less and members increased by one more?

Shucks - I read till the end, and now I hunger for some potato chips :(

:D

Why don't you run up the block to the corner store and get a bag?
 
It does seem signatures are eliminated frequently. For supporters it's less and members increased by one more?
One of us has a too sleepy brain - I don't get your question :o
You mean there's a difference of 1 between 6 and 7 in 6:1 and 7:1? Too small a sample to mean anything significant. Both groups are losing members in roughly the same proportion to new members is how I would read it, but that is really just a temporary snapshot. Had I looked at the last, say, 6 instead of 4 months, I might have gotten a somewhat different result.


Why don't you run up the block to the corner store and get a bag?
Trying to kick the habit :o
 
One of us has a too sleepy brain - I don't get your question :o
You mean there's a difference of 1 between 6 and 7 in 6:1 and 7:1? Too small a sample to mean anything significant. Both groups are losing members in roughly the same proportion to new members is how I would read it, but that is really just a temporary snapshot. Had I looked at the last, say, 6 instead of 4 months, I might have gotten a somewhat different result.



Trying to kick the habit :o

A combination of a sleepy brain and unable to reason with numbers logically. They appear jumbled to me if it makes any sense to you. In other words, I'm learning disabled in math. Ok, you got it. I asked the difference, but you simplified for me by breaking it down. I get the equal proportion. :D Thank you!

That can be rough.
 
In this newsletter, sent on May 16 after the AIA Convention in Atlanta, they claim:



150 new signatures to the petition by (mostly) licensed architects? That's almost 50% of the number they have today (338, of whom 86 include "AIA" in their title).

I very much doubt this. I shall monitor! They historically took 2-3 weeks to verify the majority of new signatures, so by June 7th, half of the 150 should actually appear on the signature list.

I hold a personal prediction against that: 5 at most by the end of June 7th.

So far, 11 days later, not a single signature verified and appended to the petition. I guess office is closed.

While searching for something else (recent information about the Verification Team), I stumbled across this article from last years's Convention in Chicago:
CHICAGO AIA CONVENTION ACTIVISTS NET OVER 120 MORE A/E PETITION SIGNERS
That Convention was held in June 26-28, 2014. AE911Truth claims:
ae911truth said:
AE911Truth had surpassed even its own expectations, eclipsing the Denver results by amassing more than 120 new petition signers — 100 of them architects or engineers, including four new FAIA members
Unfortunately I don't have snapshots of the petition for summer 2014, but between 2013/12/29 and 2014/11/03 (6 months prior to and 4 months after the Convention), they added
  • 21 licensed architects (2 identified as FAIA, 4 more as AIA)
  • 9 unlicensed architects (1 identified as Associate AIA)
  • 29 licensed engineers
  • 54 unlicensed engineers
  • 73 A&E from abroad
I call ******** on the "120 new petition signers" during the 2014 Convention, and ******** on the 150 new petition signers in 2015.
 
Interesting... at the AIA Convention in Denver a few years ago, they SHOWED me their petition, and it had several pages of hand-written signatures (mostly architects, a few engineers) with names, addresses, emails, whatever. They also told me it would be a few months before their names would all appear. After being at an AIA Convention myself, I give a lot of credence to their numbers. I just don't get why those numbers don't result in a big upwards jolt to the numbers over the following weeks!
 
Interesting... at the AIA Convention in Denver a few years ago, they SHOWED me their petition, and it had several pages of hand-written signatures (mostly architects, a few engineers) with names, addresses, emails, whatever. They also told me it would be a few months before their names would all appear. After being at an AIA Convention myself, I give a lot of credence to their numbers. I just don't get why those numbers don't result in a big upwards jolt to the numbers over the following weeks!

My guess is that in their verification process... they likely call the professional who in the interim has had time to study their materials and reflect on them and may have decided... that they eitherno longer agree with the full trust of the AE claims... or enough of them to have their name associated with their petition.

Gage can make a slick presentation especially to non technically savvy people. We all tend to give the "truth" benefit of doubt to people we speak with thinking they are honest. How could we go through life thinking everyone is a snake oil salesman? Gage "hides" behind AIA in attached to his name... and so he gets even more credibility points at the get go.

But as Ronald Regan (who I am no fan of) said ()to Gorbachev)...

trust but verify

People who verify learn that the pitch is mostly BS... significantly flawed. I personally bought the pitch and only when I began to drill into the whole thing did I see it was smoke and mirrors, shock and awe and unsubstantiated claims... based on misreading of the record and attributing "anomalies" to nefarious causes.

I left that in the dust. I don't care to prove anything... I think 9/11 proofs are silly to begin with. I learned a lot about mechanics and these structures in the intervening years and nothing showed me CD or what likely happened. The ROOSD explanation for the collapse phase is spot on. I don't care what you call it.

If you don't look, you can't see. If you don't study you can't understand.
 
Interesting... at the AIA Convention in Denver a few years ago, they SHOWED me their petition, and it had several pages of hand-written signatures (mostly architects, a few engineers) with names, addresses, emails, whatever.

Were any of them Hugh Jass or I. P. Freely?
 
8 years AE911T Petition - the Statistics


The Petition has been online since May 2007 - at least that is the month for which archive.org has snapshots of the signatures. By the beginning of June 2008 (actually, 05/30/2007) they had 83 A&E and 38 "other supporters". Since June 2007 was the first full month that I have stats for, I have no 8 full years of comparable numbers.

A) Architects & Engineers

In May, Gage's office failed to verify any new signatures. We are told that they got 150 signatures at the AIA convention, now over 2 weeks ago, but none have surfaced thus far! I kinda suspect that Gage lost a staff member or two. Laura Nieboer has been the Verification Team leader for a while now, with Elaine French responsible for the verification of domestic AEs. Helping them are Dave Fura who focuses on Oregon, and Mark Peterson, who "the National Student Clearinghouse to confirm the degrees of any signers who are unable to provide their credentials". Finally, Laila Selk "verifies the identity of members of the general public". All that information is more than a year old. Perhaps Laura and/or Elaine are unavailable now...

Anyway, the charts: First signatures per day every month:



May was already the second month this year when they had zero growth. 2015 so far is as bas as their worst year yet, 2012.

Then the averages for my "business years" going from june through May:



After hitting a low point in 2011/12 with only 0.54 additional signatures per day, they had recovered somewhat in the two years that folled, to 0.63/day and 0.74/day, respectively. But this last, 8th year, they cam crashing down to a new all-time low of 0.43/day, that's -20% from the previous low, and 58% down from last year. (Absolut growth was 158 per year, after 240/yr).

The annual growth rate of 7.2% is equivalent to each signer talking one new A or E into signing once every 13.9 years. That's the old story: There is no organic growth.


B) Other Supporters



Numbers have been steadily declining since the heydays of 2009/10, for the 5th straight year. 3.50/day (1277/yr) is 28% down from the year before.
Annual growth rate of 6.7% is equivalent to 14.9 years per signer and year. Those other "Supporters" aren't supporting the Petition at all, they are not active recruiting new folks.


C) Facebook "Likes"

Rememeber the story back in mid-March: The Facebook page had lost more than 10,000 of its then almost 267,000 "Likes", and after that new likes/day had dropped from more than 270/day in January and February to less than 130/day in March and April. Quite possible a crack-down on the part of Facebook on artificial "likes".
And boy did it get worse!



Only 59/day now, down by a factor of 4.7 from Jan/Feb! And just over 1/3 of the long-term average for 1.5 years prior to that.

(Variation within the month is striking, too: In the first week of may, they had >90 likes every single day. After that until yesterday, they had <80 every single day, with never more than 54 between May 12 and May 30. Then today, up to 93 again. I predict they will stay at a level around 85 for several days, and then - who knows. This is not a random walk of people worldwide browsing the internet. I also see no overt marketing or communication effort by Gage that could explain these ups and downs. Quite the contrary: The down came at the tail of a much-publicized European tour and centered around a much-publicized Convention)


D) Homepage Hits

This last statistics is getting less and less relevant, but I am keeping it anyway: The "Content View Hits" counter that still being updated at the bottom of their old page layout. This still seems to count all the activity, includung the new layout.



After losing traffic for 8 straight months after September (the aniversary month traditionally having the most page hits), they have now been rather steady for three months at a level that's near the low end of what they ever had since 2010. In the internet-centered world of today, that's clearly a significant loss. But homepages aren't what counts anymore - traffic has move to social media. Also, I have no idea if and how mobile hits are counted.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom