When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
Is the submitted "paper" sourced by AE/911? Please forgive my laziness in searching, at this point, it's really hard to give a crap what any of them say. :)

ETA: That said, We're having a great time here at NHMS. Rebel flags and all, it's a great time with good friends.

What do you mean by "sourced"? Do you mean "Coste et al used AE911T as sources for the claims in the paper" or "AE provided resources (money, advice...)" or "the paper can be downloaded from ae911truth.org" or...?? :confused:
And what is NHMS??? :confused::confused:
 
What do you mean by "sourced"? Do you mean "Coste et al used AE911T as sources for the claims in the paper" or "AE provided resources (money, advice...)" or "the paper can be downloaded from ae911truth.org" or...?? :confused:
And what is NHMS??? :confused::confused:
Is the "paper" available to read on-line?

This is NHMS:

http://www.nhms.com/

Search the site for "camping at". :D

Sorry for being confusing, The party started last night and runs through Monday.
 
Last edited:
Is the "paper" available to read on-line?
Not that I know of.
This may be just an updated version of a paper by ... I forgot who, doesn't matter, that made the rounds last year. But I can't be bothered to search now.

This is NHMS:

http://www.nhms.com/

Search the site for "camping at". :D

Sorry for being confusing, The party started last night and runs through Monday.
Cheers!
 
Not that I know of.
This may be just an updated version of a paper by ... I forgot who, doesn't matter, that made the rounds last year. But I can't be bothered to search now.
It seems to me that this is their (failed) attempt at taking their contentions with NIST to Europe, as per Pepper's letter.

Maybe someone else in Europe will listen to them?
 
Last edited:
Thanks. I did read that paper.

I love this comment on his site:

Finding no technical faults or errors, the paper passed SEFI 2015’s peer review steps and was accepted for presentation.

Talk about ethics, what orifice did he pull this out of? :eek:
 
What's wrong with the claim?
The "Finding no technical faults or errors". This implies the paper was reviewed on technical merit. Last time I checked, presenting a paper at a conference is not reviewed for technical accuracy.

This acceptance would be based on if it was thought it could be a topic of discussion. I suspect it got tossed after members read it and decided they had no intention of attending the presentation. No interest from the members will get your talk canceled.
 
Well, I don't know exactly what their standards and criteria are for accepting papers, but whatever they are, that particular paper did initially pass those criteria.
They did not publish the papers ahead of time, afaics. The list of authors and topics did not appear on the SETI conference website until more than ten days after the conference, so no one could have shown no interest...
I am fairly certain that they do in fact have "political" motives to uninvite the AE nutjobs. Perhaps people who were made aware of AE's advertising of the event (and call for donations) contacted them and made them aware of what fruitcakes they had invited there.
 
I am fairly certain that they do in fact have "political" motives to uninvite the AE nutjobs. Perhaps people who were made aware of AE's advertising of the event (and call for donations) contacted them and made them aware of what fruitcakes they had invited there.

Could be.

The point is, where does he get the idea that the paper was peer reviewed for accuracy? Being accepted as a conference discussion does not mean it was peer reviewed for technical accuracy, he pulled that out of thin air.
 
Could be.

The point is, where does he get the idea that the paper was peer reviewed for accuracy? Being accepted as a conference discussion does not mean it was peer reviewed for technical accuracy, he pulled that out of thin air.

To some extent, that's even true for proper journal papers that get full peer-review: The referees won't hardly ever try to verify the new technical claims - called "data" - presented in a paper. They may check for plausibility, they should catch when arguments are illogical or conclusions don't follow from the data, but they usually can't "review for accuracy".
 
To some extent, that's even true for proper journal papers that get full peer-review: The referees won't hardly ever try to verify the new technical claims - called "data" - presented in a paper. They may check for plausibility, they should catch when arguments are illogical or conclusions don't follow from the data, but they usually can't "review for accuracy".
True.

I'd like to see him show the technical aspects he claims they checked. As far as I can remember, none were actually made. There are claims about what they perceive as important and relevant but, nothing technical.
 
True.

I'd like to see him show the technical aspects he claims they checked. As far as I can remember, none were actually made. There are claims about what they perceive as important and relevant but, nothing technical.

Somehow the paper is supposedly about how the peer-review process in today's engineering journals is flawed such that it allowed some wrong things through and disallowed debate on such errors.

How ironic.

Take for example Section 3 of the paper "EVIDENCE OF HIGH TEMPERATURE INCENDIARIES / EXPLOSIVES". This section makes approving reference to 3 publications that, apparently, the authors accept as true and relevant. However:
The first - the RJ Lee Report - was never peer-reviewed or published by any journal. It was a commercial report for a paying customer with vested interests.
The second - SE Jones, K Ryan et al's "Extremely High Temperatures" - was "peer"-reviewed at JoNES - by actual peers, with Jones and Ryan being editors of the journal
The third - Harrit et al - was published at Bentham, we know how that went peer-review-wise.

Hypocrites!
 
Last edited:
Somehow the paper is supposedly about how the peer-review process in today's engineering journals is flawed such that it allowed some wrong things through and disallowed debate on such errors.

How ironic.

Take for example Section 3 of the paper "EVIDENCE OF HIGH TEMPERATURE INCENDIARIES / EXPLOSIVES". This section makes approving reference to 3 publications that, apparently, the authors accept as true and relevant. However:
The first - the RJ Lee Report - was never peer-reviewed or published by any journal. It was a commercial report for a paying customer with vested interests.
The second - SE Jones, K Ryan et al's "Extremely High Temperatures" - was "peer"-reviewed at JoNES - by actual peers, with Jones and Ryan being editors of the journal
The third - Harrit et al - was published at Bentham, we know how that went peer-review-wise.

Hypocrites!
Yep..............

I still love how they think mentioning that WTC7 wasn't hit by a aircraft is somehow important.

I guess you have to play to your audience.....

They talk about Government propaganda................:rolleyes:
 
Back their - Wayne Coste mainly, on behalf of AE - holy outrage about their being unvited (outvited?) from this SEFI conference in France:

AE had this article last week: SEFI APPROVES 9/11 SCIENCE AND ETHICS PAPER—THEN CENSORS IT ON DUBIOUS GROUNDS
Towards the bottom, they link to Wayne's latest, current activism - he wants engineer a social media ********* on Facebook and Twitter! Whoa!

The Facebook-event had just under 1,100 invitees, and 69 "guests" had responded accepting the invitation when I first saw this last weekend. Now, with 2 days to go to the big day, Saturday, 1,128 invitations, 71 accepted.

Somehow they want to blitzkrieg the social media with the hashtag #censoredbysefi.
Somehow I don't see that coming...

I don't do Twitter at all. Is there a way to monitor the use of hashtags? I'd love monitor the flowing and ebbing of this storm :D


More:
facebook/ae91truth on July 31
http://censoredbysefi.org/ (actually, this page doesn't have more - no update since it was first set up earlier in July)
 
Oh - I didn't do AE statistics for July.

Well, nothing new:

A&E Petition - still no new signature - they haven't added a single new signature since late April now (One signature that was dropped on May 1st is back)
Others Petition: 20261 signatures at the end of June, 20327 at the end of July, that's +66 (3.9% annual groth rate, or each signer convincing a new disciple once ever 26 years). This is among the better results this year (only March was better with +75), but would have been below average in every year and every quarte year since 2008 and until september 2014.
Facebook-Likes: +26/day, after +18/day in June. This increase is due to two days with outliers - +125 and +169. All others had between -23 and +57, for an average of +18. Still much much less than the long-term averages that were between +160 and +280 prior to March.
Homepage hits: Up 26% from previous month, but down 46% from last year's July.

More importantly, I don't see that they are building up to any noteworthy events surrounding the 9/11 anniversary in September. Yes, you can now buy their PR brochure "Beyond Misinformation" at bulk rates and hand them out. D'uh.

I think Gage's organization, his office, is worn very thin.
 
...
Somehow they want to blitzkrieg the social media with the hashtag #censoredbysefi.
Somehow I don't see that coming...

I don't do Twitter at all. Is there a way to monitor the use of hashtags? I'd love monitor the flowing and ebbing of this storm :D
...

It's a tidy little storm so far:
https://twitter.com/hashtag/censoredbysefi?f=tweets

Something line 25 Tweets by Wayne Coste and Mike Smith ("Georgia Activists") themselves between July 28 and August 01, then one more on August 05 by "Weedseed" (@karenskimo) - and that's it!

What a mighty movement this is!
 
It's a tidy little storm so far:
https://twitter.com/hashtag/censoredbysefi?f=tweets

Something line 25 Tweets by Wayne Coste and Mike Smith ("Georgia Activists") themselves between July 28 and August 01, then one more on August 05 by "Weedseed" (@karenskimo) - and that's it!

What a mighty movement this is!

August 8, the day for the *********, came and went - and it brought not 2,000 tweets, not 200,000 tweets, not 2 million tweets, but an unprecedented...








... 2 tweets!!! :jaw-dropp


Haha: https://www.facebook.com/events/1430050757325750/
The date for this event has now been moved to August 22nd :D


Where are the laughing dogs?? :D
 
The AE911Truth "Petition" appears to be in very long-term coma - still not a single architect or engineer added to the list since late April. That's four months now during which Gage's "Verification Team" simply hasn't worked (they allegedly had 150 signatures at the AIA convention in May, and I don't believe the form doesn't work anymore).

No one asks a question about this, no one comments, no one seems worried. Bit I think, AE911Truth is in an existential crisis as an organization. I hear rumour that Gage isn't even running the show and calling the shots any longer, that his administrative head lady, Kelly David, simply doesn't get things done, that former key activists are abandoning ship.


Their web sites are still up and have traffic.
The ae911truth.org Content Hit Counter clocks in a steady stream of between 3500 and 4000 hits per day - with no sign of picking up heat in the run-up to the 9/11 anniversary:




Their Facebook page had a sudden increase of daily new "likes" - before August 13, there had been more than 3 months when the number of new likes never exceeded 100 per day (with two isolated exceptions at 125 and 169), and then suddenly that jumped up between 200 and 700 likes per day after August 14, with an average of about 425/day, which brought the average for the entire month of August to 271:





I see no action anywhere that would indicate that any of this is real. I am sure somebody started buying "Likes" again.


ETA:
Oh, and the "Twitter Storm & Facebook Blitz for AE911Truth Engineering Ethics Paper Censored by SEFI, August 1-22" quite obviously didn't happen on August 22, either. Last activity on that Facebook page was August 10, and I see a lone comment on August 22. On Twitter, one lonely tweet with the hashtag #censoredbysefi on August 22, by the initiator themselves (). I almost feel pity for those losers. No one at all cares for their dismal failure!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom