When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
I am not doing half-month updates like I used to. Just dropping a few notes for mid-February:

Nothing interesting on the A&E Petition. Going slow but steady as ever.

The Feb 08 news of that woman scribbling "AE911" on a famous French painting had a big impact that day - and none whatsoever past the day:
- They had 38,000 page hits that day (midnight to midnight on the US west coast), but averaged only about 4,800 per day on the other 13 days - less than the average for any month since november 2011.
- They got 33 signatures that day from Other Supporters, but averaged only 4.7 per day (max: 8) on the other 13 days

In January, fundraising via those ChipIn.com widgets on the left corner of the homepage was unusually strong, drawing a number of many large single donations of 1000 and 500 dollars. So far, February is the opposite: Been the weakest fundraising fortnight I have so far seen

I have started to monitor their Facebook page a few days ago. They are at a currently little over 121,000 "Likes", and add around 250-300 new "Likes "per day. The comments that people post there are depressingly stupid,

They have had this "President Obama, please watch our film" petition in the right column of the homepage. Like other petition, this ad been in decline from after the first month, June 2012, to mid-January. But now it is going fairly strong again. It had gone down to under 5 signatures per day, but for the last 4 weeks has been getting almost 20 per day. I don't know what caused this increase.
 
One fundraiser ended today:

Air WTC 7/Ed Asner on PBS
Purpose: "Re-air 5-min „Spotlight-on“ video with Ed Asner on Solving the Mystery pgWTC7 on PBS – guaranteed 500 PBS airings to 9 million viewers! (Short version of the mini-DVD)"

Started: Jan 19
Ended: Feb 18 (31 days)
Target: $ 7400
Raised: $ 3549 (48% of target)
Number of Contributions: 31

The 31 contributions can be split into big ones and small ones:
- 3 big for $1000 (jan 21), $1000 (jan 24) and $500 (feb 06) - 70% of total
- 28 small for a total of $1049 - average $37.46
 
So I see a lot of different numbers offered in this thread and was looking for some accurate figures to throw at twoofers when they mention all these "experts".

How many CIVIL ENGINEERS are in this group? (which should mean someone who is qualified as a structural/building engineer, not just someone with an engineering degree)

How many LICENSED ARCHITECTS are in this group? (which sets aside all the individuals they accept who merely work at architectural firms, like the janitor, the file clerk, etc)

(In short, how many architects and engineers) I think best guess is actually a couple of hundred? Not that that even encompasses anyone qualified to do structural failure analysis.

If we can determine that what is the ratio of these people vs their industry colleagues? I saw a figure of 1 in 2000 tossed in earlier, I thin that was actual building engineers not the whole 1500.
 
So I see a lot of different numbers offered in this thread and was looking for some accurate figures to throw at twoofers when they mention all these "experts".

How many CIVIL ENGINEERS are in this group? (which should mean someone who is qualified as a structural/building engineer, not just someone with an engineering degree)

How many LICENSED ARCHITECTS are in this group? (which sets aside all the individuals they accept who merely work at architectural firms, like the janitor, the file clerk, etc)

(In short, how many architects and engineers) I think best guess is actually a couple of hundred? Not that that even encompasses anyone qualified to do structural failure analysis.

If we can determine that what is the ratio of these people vs their industry colleagues? I saw a figure of 1 in 2000 tossed in earlier, I thin that was actual building engineers not the whole 1500.

Hi batvette,

This page lists all their current "Architects and Engineers", minus a handful (usually no more than 5, sometimes 0) who have recently edited their profiles and whose edits haven't been approved yet:
http://www2.ae911truth.org/signpetition.php
That page is update infrequently, a handful of times per month. Sometimes no update in over 2 weeks, sometimes 3 updates in 4 days.

The current version, of Feb 20, has 1776 names (at the same time, the front page said "1780 Architects and Engineers", so there are 4 under review right now; of these I know three).

Of these 1776, they list
- 281 licensed architects
- 97 architects (degree only, no license)
- 343 licensed professional engineers
- 636 engineers (degree only, no license as P.E.)
- 419 non-US architects and engineers (degreed; licensed or unlicensed)

The list does NOT contain "janitors, file clerk" or such, unless they have a degree as architect or engineer. It does however of course contain people who don't practice achitecture or engineering - because they are retired, or they found success or fun in another career (Gage himself being the most prominent example).
Also, a number have their licenses expired or otherwise not current.

I generally find very few misfiled or with incorrect credentials: There is the odd patent agent or engineering intern who is erroneously listed as "licensed engineer", but conversely I am sure they have licensed people who are listed as "degreed only". So by and large, these people are legit. Certainly more than 97% of them, which I thinkis excellent. They really have put in a lot of effort into verification. I even frequently find "other supporters" that boast an engineering degree but aren't listed under A&E - perhaps oversight, but also perhaps they failed to show proof of their degree. The AE911 Verification Team mails every A&E signatory and asks them to send a scan of their diploma.
Only thing is, I suspect that more signers have died since 2007 than have been removed for that reason.


I have taken a particularly close look at the "licensed engineers" = Professional Engineers, for two reasons:
  1. I think engineers (particularly, as you also think, civil and structural engineers) are more likely qualified to make informed judgement than engineers
  2. I can look up their licenses in State registers, and also, in many states, get full rosters or counts of Professional Engineers, so I can compute what percentage of those have signed the Petition.

That does not mean that I consider the P.E.s to be generally qualified, or the non-P.E.s to be generally unqualified! I just know no way to estimate the total number of people with engineering degrees in the USA.


So from that study of P.E.s, I found that somewhat more of half of them are civil or structural engineers - make that roughly 190 or 200.
It's not straightforward to assess how many of these are specifically qualified as "structural" engineers - my best estimate is around 40.
I did indeed find that this group of 343 Professional Engineers represents between 1 in 5000 and 1 in 2000 of all PEs, depending on state. It doesn't matter much what engineering branch these hail from.
There are relatively few with a civil engineering degree among the non-licensed enginners, because generally, to practice civil engineering, you must be licensed, whereas the same is not the case for, say manufacturing or agricultural engineers.
The AE911Truth Petition has been the most successful, relatively, in the rugged, mountainous states (CO, AK, MT, ID), on the west coast (WA, CA, OR) and New England (NH, VT), and least successful in the Deep South (LA, SC; but TX is an exception), the Upper South (TN, KY, MO) and around the Great Lakes.

Among the Non-US signers, it's more difficult to tell qualifications apart, obviously, as different countries have different kinds of degrees, different terms, different requirements for licensing. So I have no count of civil engineers among them, but a quick and dirty search for certain text strings brings up about another 40 structural engineers in that group.

So US-and non-US taken together, there are perhaps 80 structural engineers.

The AE911Truth Petition has been the most successful, relative to populations, in the USA of course, followed by Denmark, then Canada. Predictably, English-speaking countries are nearer the top than their neighbors, and northern and western Europe leads all other continents.
 
Last edited:
Update for the month of FEBRUARY


I have to say: The AE911Truth Petition has gained relative strength lately.
Relative.
The numbers are better than a year ago, and already their A&E growth on the quarter is better in two months than last year's in three. Part of the reason however is that they have again dug deep into their database and verified some that signed up longer ago.


A) Architects and Engineers

Jan 31: 1769
Feb 28: 1791

(And already in the first two days of March, they verified 4 more, which I leave out in this update). 22 newly verified A&E is the best they had since october, which was when most of those signing around the 9/11 anniversary were verified. It's equivalent to one new signature each existing A&E once on 5.7 years - that's actually the best growth rate since September 2011!
22 is actually 24 new signatures minus two deleted.
Some of those 24 however were rather old: The mean age of the signature on the day they were verified was over 80 days, the median was 48 day. Two signed before July 1st, nine more before January 1st, and only 10 were younger than a month. In previous months, the median was always under 25, and the mean under 41.


B) Other Supporters

Jan 31: 16391
Feb 28: 16571

180 new signatures in 28 days is 6.43 per day - more than what they got in December and January, but less than September through November. It's equivalent to 6,5 new signatures per year per existing signature.

Now, there was this incident in France where deranged woman scribbled "AE911" on a national treasure. Newspaper linking to ae911truth.org generated one day of traffic and signatures that were increased by a factor of 5 and more. If I leave out that day, you're down to 5.44 signatures.


C) Page Hits

Traffic to the ae911truth web site has been generally slow in february, with two exceptions:
- Feb 08 saw 38,000 visitors instead of the usual under 6,000 because of the Louvre incident in France
- Feb 27 had about 10,000 extra visitors; I don't know the reason for this, this was day too late to have been cause by the coverage of the Tony Rooke trial in England

The average for February was 6,047 "Content View Hits" per day, which is pretty much the same as previous months; but if you discount the Louvre incident - which was really the only measurable boost the traffic got since 9/11/2012, the average drops to 4,875 per day, and that would have been the worst since April 2011.


D) Facebook "Likes"

I have only started momitoring this number in mid february. Somebody had posted on the 3rd that they had "almost 118,000" Likes at that time. By the end of the 13th, that was up to 120,526, or ca. 278 new Likes per day.
This rate stayed constand (was between 245 and 295) for six days, then suddenly dropped to between 50 and 80. This level was steady for seven days, then the rate suddenly increased to around 165 for three days, then around 115 the next few days. Strange!

They currently have a Fundraiser for "Social Media Advertising". They write there that they "expect to more-than-double our 100,000fans with this". I suspect that the jumps in average numbers of Likes is due to starts and ends of such advertising campaigns (or their effective scopes), but I don't know where and how this happens.


E) Fundraisers

January had been a pretty successful fundrasing month, as far as these "ChipIn" widgets are concerned that they always have on the top left of the home page, with almost $21,500 from a few big donations and almost $1,500 from 35 small donations ($43 per donation, $48 per day).

February hasn't been successful at all:
They had three fundraisers going and here is how they fared in February:

Only 1 large contribution of $500
42 small contributions (5-200 dollars) for $1497.55 ($36 per donation, $53.5 per day)
For a total of just under $2,000. The long-term average is over $3,000 per month.
 
I don't get it.. if anybody can sign the petition under "other" supporter, then why are there 120,000 'likes' on facebook and only 18,300 signatures on the petition?
 
I don't get it.. if anybody can sign the petition under "other" supporter, then why are there 120,000 'likes' on facebook and only 18,300 signatures on the petition?

Maybe it's because you can buy Facebook likes ?
 
Maybe it's because clicking "Like" takes 1 second, filling out the form takes 2 minutes and requires you to type a personal statement and give your phone number and all that effort?
 
Maybe it's because clicking "Like" takes 1 second, filling out the form takes 2 minutes and requires you to type a personal statement and give your phone number and all that effort?

The more likely situation. Truthers seem to be content in doing as little as possible to support or spread their belief.
 
Maybe it's because you can buy Facebook likes ?
Maybe it's because clicking "Like" takes 1 second, filling out the form takes 2 minutes and requires you to type a personal statement and give your phone number and all that effort?
The more likely situation. Truthers seem to be content in doing as little as possible to support or spread their belief.

Don't discount the "buy Facebook likes" option yet. As Gage is currently collecting money for advertising to boost Facebook Likes, that is at least his plan. Also, the "new likes per day" doesn't seem to be a random walk, even though my data base is still fresh and not very solid yet:

20130305_FBae911truth_LikesPerDay_zpsc4518159.png


Kinda strange how there seem to be pretty constant levels for some days, then abrupt jumps to the next level. This seems as if some sorts of "advertisements" get switched on and off.


I observed a similar thing with the other petition they have been running at change.org since last June: It started with 31.4 signatures per day in June, dropped to 9.4 and 5.1 in July, jumped to 15.4 in September (mainly bossted by the 9/11 anniversary), before dropping back to an average of 4.4 in October, November December. By mid-january, this was doan to 1.7 per day.
Then I didn't follow this petition for about 3 weeks, during which the average had shot up to 13.3, and the remainder of february clocked in at an amazing 26.1 signatures per day - that's better than the best ever month of the original petition! The last 3 days of february even had over 60 signatures par day.
And then
March rolled in
and suddenly
Signatures are trickling again: Only 6 in almost 4 days, or 1.6 per day.
So it would seem that, for a few weeks ending on Feb 28th, this petition must have been featured prominently somewhere (on the Change.org start page? I never checked), and that certainly was no accident. Not unreasonable to consider that such a featuring costs money.
 
Just for the record:
I woke up this morning and found that the Petition has reached the mark of 1,800 A&E.
I recorded 1,700 on, or in the days before, June 15, 2012, so it took them 265-280 days for 100. The 100 before that took only a little less, 249-264 days.

(Other Supporters: 16,613)




But the big story today is their "Family Petition" at change.org: I received an AE911Truth "action alert" email tonight at 1:58am Central Europe Time / 7:58pm ET / 4:58 PT:
http://www.ae911truth.org/actionalerts/2013/03/action_Family_Petition.php

And now that petition is receiving more signatures than ever:
http://www.change.org/petitions/pre...h-9-11-explosive-evidence-experts-speak-out-2

24 hours ago it was 2,613 signatures since june, receiving only 1 or 2 new ones per day, now it shot up to 3474 and gets almost 1 signature a minute (during the past hour). I haven't seen it "featured" at the change.org frontpage. Gotta check if the new signers are predominantly old AE911Truth Petition Signers alerted by the same email: Of the first 16 I checked, I could match 6.

Gage writes: Help us reach 1 Million Signatures!
:D
 
Last edited:
Oh!! No more Fundraisers!

I just noticed that the service ChipIn at http://chipin.com has been discontinued for good per March 7th. With this, the little fundraiser widgets on the left side of Gage's frontpage are gone.

The last two they had open yesterday were:

Booth at June AIA Nat'l Con
Started: Jan 16
Contributions: 31
Raised: $1155.55

and

Social Media Advertising
Started: Feb 12
Contributions: 7
Raised: $253

That's $22.66/day and $37.28/contribution for the former, $10.54/day and $36.14/contribution for the latter - making these the two worst drives since they started these fundraisers 4 years ago (33 fundraisers total). There wasn't a single contribution in the last week.


Gage raised more than $30,000 each year that way. Difficult to assess how much of that he will lose because of the service shut-down.
 
I am checking about once an hour and then look up a handful of the most recent signers of that "family petition".

So far I found 24 of 50 "family petition" signers on the old AE911Truth Petition. That means that at least half of the action is generated by their having sent an email yesterday. There could be several reasons why I can't find some recipients of the email in my database:
1. My last complete "Other Supporters" download was in november. I don't find those who signed up since.
2. Some may spell their name differently, or have perhaps changed their names
3. Some have very common names; if they have moved since signing the old petition, I can't be sure to find the same person
4. You can sign up for the newsletter without signing the Petition

Currently, the pace is about 33-38 signatures per hour.

I predict that within 24 hours, this will be very much down, as emails age quickly. They will have reached something around 5000 tomorrow, and not grow fast from there. 1 million?? Not in a lifetime!


So far they haven't posted this on Facebook. But on wednesdey (03/06) they posted a fresh link to the old Petition, and this has boosted new signatures there a bit - by a good dozend perhaps. That's one signature per 10,000 likes :p
 
Okay thanks for nailing down some solid numbers for me. As for my claim regarding:

The list does NOT contain "janitors, file clerk" or such, unless they have a degree as architect or engineer.

I don't remember where I read that but I had heard those were the relaxed standards initially proposed, that someone merely produce proof they are employed at an architectural company.

FWIW I am acquainted somewhat with one of their engineer signatories, a female with a degree in electrical engineering who is in her late 60's and has not had any relevant professional experience in her field in 30 years.
She is an activist promoting a conspiracy theory of "organized stalking", devotes much time to maintaining a website "educating" the public about her stalkers and the microwave auditory devices they beam bells and other noises into her head with to ruin her life. She does approach that with some rationality but then abandons that when it conflicts with her distorted perception driven beliefs.
She is no more qualified or even rationally able to analyze the structural failure of the towers than your average junior high school science class student.

Sorry to say after perusing that website there are only a few of these "experts" who I would listen to for 30 seconds. The bulk of them think signing a petition declaring they have "doubts about the official story" is supposed to be something which adheres to the scientific method?
The only thing they could do with any credibility would be to offer a point by point rebuttal of whatever faults they find in the NIST report, and/or offer a complete, detailed alternative hypothesis to be published in a relevant professional journal. Or even compile their professional opinions and present it at a meeting of their professional society.
They won't do anything of the sort and just sign a petition saying the gubmint is full of bull huckey?
That's not professional- why do they insult our intelligence by even offering up their credentials?

I base my harsh criticisms simply on a couple of tenets of the scientific method:

Mere doubt or nay saying of a prevailing theory held by consensus is NOT a credible position, you must offer a detailed alternative hypothesis to be held to equal scrutiny.

and... You grasp vast consensus and reject a small minority fringe amongst colleagues.
 
Probably April 1 if the following is anything to go by (Thanks to Brainster)...

http://911blogger.com/news/2013-03-...-truth-proudly-announces-operation-tip-planet

Now we’re at a turning point, thanks to years of grassroots outreach, and with your help, are finally ready to “Tip the Planet.”
Fast forward to September:
For the entire month… a single message appears all around the world – on billboards, subways, and highway overpasses… On lawns, office windows, storefronts, bulletin boards, tee shirts, bumper stickers, and even televised sporting events… On Facebook, Twitter, YouTube… In places like New York City, Washington, D.C., Woburn Massachusetts, La Mesa California, Tokyo, Madrid, Montreal, Buenos Aires, London – and countless other cities…
This is the concept behind Operation Tip the Planet, the first-ever global 9/11 Truth anniversary event. Be sure your city is included!
Join me in making 2013 the year of 9/11 truth.
 
Probably April 1 if the following is anything to go by (Thanks to Brainster)...

http://911blogger.com/news/2013-03-...-truth-proudly-announces-operation-tip-planet


Eh. Almost a carbon copy of this:

http://rememberbuilding7.org/10/

Their goal was 1 million in two weeks for advertising in the NYC metro area and a couple of smaller campaigns in other cities. The reality was 85K in six months or so, and scrapping the whole thing.

This time:

With your support, we’ve already raised close to $100,000 in matching funds, almost half of the $200,000 we need for our billboard, subway, and grassroots-to-global multi-city campaign!

So now they need only 200K for a global multi city ad campaign, when last time they needed 1 million for practically a one city campaign?

I bet the "close to $100,000 in matching funds" are the 85K from the remember building 7 campaign.

Another yawner.
 
Last edited:
Similar story here: They wrote an article on March 7 under the headline "Help us reach 1 Million Signatures!"

A day later, March 08, I wrote this:

I am checking about once an hour and then look up a handful of the most recent signers of that "family petition".
...
Currently, the pace is about 33-38 signatures per hour.

I predict that within 24 hours, this will be very much down, as emails age quickly. They will have reached something around 5000 tomorrow, and not grow fast from there. 1 million?? Not in a lifetime!...

They actually held that pace for more than half a day, but by March 10th, the pace was down do some 6 or 7 per hour, and now it's just over 1 per hour.

They surpassed 5,000 later than I predicted, on March 14 rather than the 9th.

And are now at 5,168.


In visuals: In red the number of signatures - left-hand y-axis scaled to the goal of 1 million. In blue signatures/day - right-hand y-axis scaled to the approximate number they'd need every single day to reach 1 million within one year.

20130317_changeOrg_million_zps68c41bb3.jpg


The number hasn't really gone significantly beyond zero - 5,168 is only 0.5168% of 1 million :D
And the new/day are returning to practically zero.


What an abject failure!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom