So I see a lot of different numbers offered in this thread and was looking for some accurate figures to throw at twoofers when they mention all these "experts".
How many CIVIL ENGINEERS are in this group? (which should mean someone who is qualified as a structural/building engineer, not just someone with an engineering degree)
How many LICENSED ARCHITECTS are in this group? (which sets aside all the individuals they accept who merely work at architectural firms, like the janitor, the file clerk, etc)
(In short, how many architects and engineers) I think best guess is actually a couple of hundred? Not that that even encompasses anyone qualified to do structural failure analysis.
If we can determine that what is the ratio of these people vs their industry colleagues? I saw a figure of 1 in 2000 tossed in earlier, I thin that was actual building engineers not the whole 1500.
Hi batvette,
This page lists all their current "Architects and Engineers", minus a handful (usually no more than 5, sometimes 0) who have recently edited their profiles and whose edits haven't been approved yet:
http://www2.ae911truth.org/signpetition.php
That page is update infrequently, a handful of times per month. Sometimes no update in over 2 weeks, sometimes 3 updates in 4 days.
The current version, of Feb 20, has 1776 names (at the same time, the front page said "1780 Architects and Engineers", so there are 4 under review right now; of these I know three).
Of these 1776, they list
- 281 licensed architects
- 97 architects (degree only, no license)
- 343 licensed professional engineers
- 636 engineers (degree only, no license as P.E.)
- 419 non-US architects and engineers (degreed; licensed or unlicensed)
The list does NOT contain "janitors, file clerk" or such, unless they have a degree as architect or engineer. It does however of course contain people who don't practice achitecture or engineering - because they are retired, or they found success or fun in another career (Gage himself being the most prominent example).
Also, a number have their licenses expired or otherwise not current.
I generally find very few misfiled or with incorrect credentials: There is the odd patent agent or engineering intern who is erroneously listed as "licensed engineer", but conversely I am sure they have licensed people who are listed as "degreed only". So by and large, these people are legit. Certainly more than 97% of them, which I thinkis excellent. They really have put in a lot of effort into verification. I even frequently find "other supporters" that boast an engineering degree but aren't listed under A&E - perhaps oversight, but also perhaps they failed to show proof of their degree. The AE911 Verification Team mails every A&E signatory and asks them to send a scan of their diploma.
Only thing is, I suspect that more signers have died since 2007 than have been removed for that reason.
I have taken a particularly close look at the "licensed engineers" = Professional Engineers, for two reasons:
- I think engineers (particularly, as you also think, civil and structural engineers) are more likely qualified to make informed judgement than engineers
- I can look up their licenses in State registers, and also, in many states, get full rosters or counts of Professional Engineers, so I can compute what percentage of those have signed the Petition.
That does not mean that I consider the P.E.s to be generally qualified, or the non-P.E.s to be generally unqualified! I just know no way to estimate the total number of people with engineering degrees in the USA.
So from that study of P.E.s, I found that somewhat more of half of them are civil or structural engineers - make that roughly 190 or 200.
It's not straightforward to assess how many of these are specifically qualified as "structural" engineers - my best estimate is around 40.
I did indeed find that this group of 343 Professional Engineers represents between 1 in 5000 and 1 in 2000 of all PEs, depending on state. It doesn't matter much what engineering branch these hail from.
There are relatively few with a civil engineering degree among the non-licensed enginners, because generally, to practice civil engineering, you must be licensed, whereas the same is not the case for, say manufacturing or agricultural engineers.
The AE911Truth Petition has been the most successful, relatively, in the rugged, mountainous states (CO, AK, MT, ID), on the west coast (WA, CA, OR) and New England (NH, VT), and least successful in the Deep South (LA, SC; but TX is an exception), the Upper South (TN, KY, MO) and around the Great Lakes.
Among the Non-US signers, it's more difficult to tell qualifications apart, obviously, as different countries have different kinds of degrees, different terms, different requirements for licensing. So I have no count of civil engineers among them, but a quick and dirty search for certain text strings brings up about another 40 structural engineers in that group.
So US-and non-US taken together, there are perhaps 80 structural engineers.
The AE911Truth Petition has been the most successful, relative to populations, in the USA of course, followed by Denmark, then Canada. Predictably, English-speaking countries are nearer the top than their neighbors, and northern and western Europe leads all other continents.