When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
Yeah, the past 8 days they averaged a bit over 30 signatures per day - excellent for a 9/11 truth petition, but at that pace it will take over 30,000 days to reach 1 million, or 84 years :D
 
End of Quarter update

The numbers of "Architects and Engineers" and "Other Supporters" shown on the top left of the ae911truth.org homepage have grwon faster and faster the last three months.

A) Architects & Engineers:

End of Dec 2012: 1756
End of Jan 2013: 1769 (+13)
End of Feb 2013: 1791 (+22)
End of Mar 2013: 1825 (+34)

Q1/2013: +69

The march growth of 1.1 new signatures per day is the best since september 2011, and, excluding septembers which are exceptional every year due to the 9/11 anniversary, the best since august 2010. The gain of 69 makes it the best quarter since Q3/2011.

A) Other Supporters:

End of Dec 2012: 16,227
End of Jan 2013: 16,391 (+164)
End of Feb 2013: 16,571 (+180)
End of Mar 2013: 16,805 (+234)

Q1/2013: +578

The march growth of 7.55 new signatures per day is the best only since november, and only 4th best during the last 12 months. The gain of 578 makes it the worst quarter since Q3/2012.


So how come the A&E are improving so much more than the others?

-> Because the AE911Truth Verification Team is scraping the barrel.

During this first quarter of 2013, the newly verified 77 A&E signatures (and deleted a handful, too, hence the difference to the +69 gain stated above). In the previous quarter, Q4 2012, they newly verified only 44 signatures for a net gain of +36. But while in all of the last quarter they verified mostly fresh signatures, they turned to ever older, yet unverified, signatures in the last three months.

As a matter of fact, the average actual sign-up date for signatures verified in Q4/2012 was november 5th, the average actual sign-up date for signatures verified in Q4/2012 was october 18th!

You see, here is the process of how they verify and count signatures:
  1. Person fills out and submits the Petition form.
  2. Immediately, an email is sent to person, indicating the ProfileID. A profile is created, but remains invisible. ProfileIDs are assigned in descending numerical order. I can determine from the ProfileID on which date this person submitted the form (with an error of +/- 1 day)
  3. Presumably very soon (mostly minutes) later, person clicks verification link in that email, to verify address. Signatures is not visible and counted yet!
  4. For Other Supporters, the Verification Team, as soon as they get to it, set signature to "verified" - Profile is now visible, and counter increased by 1
  5. For A&E, Verification Team checks the content of the signature, and usually send the person another email, asking for them to submit a scan or photo or whatever of their A&E diploma, and presumably, if applicable, professional license
  6. Person may take time to comply with that request. Eventually send required proof of degree and license
  7. Verification Team, as soon as they get to it, check proof, and if ok, set profile to "verified". Profile becomes visible and A&E counter is increased by 1. Most of the time, I catch an check newly verified A&E profiles the next day, I may be late by a couple more days in a few instances.
  8. Infrequently, between 2 and 6 times a month, they update the roster at http://www2.ae911truth.org/signpetition.php. This means that many new signatures are counted before they are listed (but the Profile is visible anyway). I will catch all newly verified A&E signatures no later than the day the list is updated; I catch quite a few earlier.
Signatures become visible and are counted most often the same or next day for Other Supporters, but generally take anywhere between a day and over a year for Architects & Engineers. Normally, it seems, the median delay between filling out form and being verified is two or three weeks, and the mean delay is somewhat more, perhaps three to four weeks. This was the case in Q4, but it very much was not so in Q1/2013!

A couple of graphics to illustrate what I mean:

20130331AEavgageofverifiedsigsquarterly_zps631a2d32.png
20130331AEavgageofverifiedsigsmonthly_zps42190bea.png


The mean age of signatures at the time AE011T got around to verifying them was 130 days in the last quarter - the maximum in the quarter before that was 148. The median increased from 17 days to 102 days, in other words, last fall, half of the 44 signatures they added to their count were younger than 2.5 weeks, while half of the 77 added this winter quarter were older than 3.3 months.

Put another way: Only 28 of the 77 signatures they verified in jan-mar were from jan to march; 16 were from Q4/2012; 22 from Q1-Q3/2012; and 6 even from 2011!


Another graphic shows this grwoing discrepancy between reported (counted) signatures in each month, and the number of actual signatures:

20130331AEnewperdayactualvsreported_zps59496680.png


The red column is a final value - it's how many new signatures appeared as verified in each month. As march is over, nothing can be added there.
The blue column can grow retro-actively: A signatures submitted in, say january, and verified in, say, april, would increase the red column ifor april, and the blue column for january.

What we see is a a trend of decreasing actual numbers, but increasing reported numbers!
Again, the actual number can increase retroactively abnsnd surely will, but by usual standards, they should already have counted most at least for february and january.


I have no idea how and why they found a couple of dozend old, unverified signatures and verified them now. Could be a genuine effort to re-contact A&E's who had not responded earlier, could be a lowering of standards. Could even be some tweeking of profiles.


ETA: This effort at scraping the barrel isn't turning this current "business year" (looking at June-May, as Gage started the Petition in May 2007) into a successful one: It's still the worst year for the A&E count, while the Other Supporters are trailing behind the previous three years.

2007-2013AEnumbermonthlyeachyearmay-may_zps3e76ba0c.png
2007-2013OSnumbermonthlyeachyearmay-may_zps5ca64346.png
 
Last edited:
In the meantime, the ae911truth.org homepage has lately seen less traffic:

20130331ae911truthOrgPageHits2012Aug-2013Mar_zps88c393dd.png


This is the average per day increase of the "Content View Hits" counter at the bottom of the page, usually for 2-day periods. The big peak around 9/11 is, obviously, the anniversary frenzy. The second big peak at February 9th was generated by the European media reports about this deranged woman who defaced a famous painting by scribbling "AE911" on it.
The recent newsletter campaign that generated a lot of signatures to another petition, and also put a spike to the "Other Supporters" count of the main petition on March 8th generated only a mild peak in Page traffic:

20130331ae911truthOrgPageHits2013-03_zps58fa41a7.png


On a month-by-month basis, March was the slowest month since october 2010!

20130209ae911truthOrgPageHitsmonthly2010Feb-2013Mar_zpseb8c6c19.png






And finally, their Facebook-page:

Daily new "likes" since I started monitoring that midway through February:

20130331_FBae911truth_LikesPerDay_zpsbb7e425c.png


You can get some monthly FB stats via links such as https://www.facebook.com/ae911truth/timeline/2013/3 going back to July 2011. The entry "Persons who like this" may be the number of new likes within that month, it's plausible, but I am not sure yet. Anyway. This is how that stat developed over a couple of years:

20130331_FBae911truth_LikesTotalAndPerMonth_zpsdc97362f.png


I don't have a comment on that yet.
 
Thanks for the excellent update, Oystein. Much appreciated!

Thanks for the note of appreciation :)


They keep scraping the barrel - i.e. they are actively revisiting old but yet unverified signatures:

In April, only 6 days old in California, so far the A&E count has increased by a whopping 18 signatures - that's more than they verified in all of March and April 2012 combined - but again, the mean and median age of those signatures is about 5 months! 3 of these are new from April, 2 each signed in March and February, and all the rest is from 2012 (and possibly even older - I haven't found one or two yet). They even re-classified an old signature from 2008 from "Other Supporter" to "A&E".


They are also now scraping the "OS" barrel: On one of my bogus signatures, I just received a couple of email: The automated "verify your email address" mail sent again, accompanied by a personalized mail from David A. Fura (Profile, FB), an electrical engineer apparently doing duty on their verification team. I have a lot of bogus signatures; most have "personal statements" that actually criticize Gage and his outfit, but the one I received mail for (from a few weeks ago) had a personal statement I copied and pasted from another signer.

As a consequence, about 20 of the about 70 OS signatures they added to the count within this firs week of April were from 2012 or older.

Also, there is yet another drive to manually enter signatures from Oregonians. I had reported on that a few times before - such signatures (Example) share the peculiarity of having no actual "Biography" and "Personal Statement", and well, they are almost all from Oroegon. As David A. Fura is from Oregon, I think he (and his local group) is probably responsible for much of this OR influx. Oregonians without Bio made up 15% of all "Other Supporters" in August, 16% in January, 9% in November, and so far 44% in April.

If I discount those manual entries and also the days on which some extraordinary event (newsletter mailing, art defacation) generated one-off spikes, then the number of signatures per day has been pretty constant since last august - the first month I have detailed data for - at between 4.5 and 6.0 per day. With September, the anniversary month, being a clear exception at 18.2 per day.
 
This is incredible. Thanks for the work.

As an aside, if you go through Dr. Fura's Facebook, he has likes for Ron Paul and Gary Johnson. Both of them are Republicans. He also has likes for Freedom Works, which is a right-wing astroturfed organization set up by 2 billionaire brothers who supported Mitt Romney.

It's very hard to see Dr. Fura as anything other than a right-wing Truther.

He has a FB like for We Are Change Eugene and is FB friends with Dick Gage, Erik Lawyer, and a guy named Chris Dorsey who describes himself as a Constitutional Restoration Specialist at Americans for Constitutional Enforcement.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the note of appreciation :)


They keep scraping the barrel - i.e. they are actively revisiting old but yet unverified signatures:

In April, only 6 days old in California, so far the A&E count has increased by a whopping 18 signatures - that's more than they verified in all of March and April 2012 combined - but again, the mean and median age of those signatures is about 5 months! 3 of these are new from April, 2 each signed in March and February, and all the rest is from 2012 (and possibly even older - I haven't found one or two yet). They even re-classified an old signature from 2008 from "Other Supporter" to "A&E".


They are also now scraping the "OS" barrel: On one of my bogus signatures, I just received a couple of email: The automated "verify your email address" mail sent again, accompanied by a personalized mail from David A. Fura (Profile, FB), an electrical engineer apparently doing duty on their verification team. I have a lot of bogus signatures; most have "personal statements" that actually criticize Gage and his outfit, but the one I received mail for (from a few weeks ago) had a personal statement I copied and pasted from another signer.

As a consequence, about 20 of the about 70 OS signatures they added to the count within this firs week of April were from 2012 or older.

Also, there is yet another drive to manually enter signatures from Oregonians. I had reported on that a few times before - such signatures (Example) share the peculiarity of having no actual "Biography" and "Personal Statement", and well, they are almost all from Oroegon. As David A. Fura is from Oregon, I think he (and his local group) is probably responsible for much of this OR influx. Oregonians without Bio made up 15% of all "Other Supporters" in August, 16% in January, 9% in November, and so far 44% in April.

If I discount those manual entries and also the days on which some extraordinary event (newsletter mailing, art defacation) generated one-off spikes, then the number of signatures per day has been pretty constant since last august - the first month I have detailed data for - at between 4.5 and 6.0 per day. With September, the anniversary month, being a clear exception at 18.2 per day.

Gage's Promethean Genesis financial backers are in Oregon.
 
Gage's Promethean Genesis financial backers are in Oregon.

I still can't construct a link between PG and the Portland AE911 Group, or Fura's manual entering (or import) of signatures, other than the state. Could be coincidence for all I know.
 
I still can't construct a link between PG and the Portland AE911 Group, or Fura's manual entering (or import) of signatures, other than the state. Could be coincidence for all I know.

Are your searches for a link restricted to what is publicly available on the internet? People get around, and have private correspondance. They also meet at other events and fundraisers.
 
Are your searches for a link restricted to what is publicly available on the internet?
Why do you think I am searching for a link? :D I just don't see any, or haven't come across any.
But: Yes. My analysis of AE911Truth is mostly restricted to what is publicly available on the internet

People get around, and have private correspondance. They also meet at other events and fundraisers.
True, and I would not be privy to that unless it surfaces publicly somewhere.

Occasionally I mail some AE911Truth staffer with a question or two, but nothing systematic, really.
 
Why do you think I am searching for a link? :D I just don't see any, or haven't come across any.
But: Yes. My analysis of AE911Truth is mostly restricted to what is publicly available on the internet


True, and I would not be privy to that unless it surfaces publicly somewhere.

Occasionally I mail some AE911Truth staffer with a question or two, but nothing systematic, really.

No problem, I know we are not professional researchers anyway. Despite what others might say... :rolleyes:

This all did get me looking into Mr. Fura's background. His facebook likes include a bio of Marine Corps General Smedley Butler, who was central to the alleged "Business Plot" to stage a coup way back when. Our Mr. Fura seems enamored to the CT side of things. I also see his central comment of proof is centered on the whole "Free Fall" chestnut, which shows he lacks an understanding of measurement certainty, graphical analysis and physics as well. Some engineer there...

Enough of the derail, back to your great social media campaign analysis. I find it useful and informative for many reasons, many not having nothing to do with 9/11.
 
This is incredible. Thanks for the work.

As an aside, if you go through Dr. Fura's Facebook, he has likes for Ron Paul and Gary Johnson. Both of them are Republicans. He also has likes for Freedom Works, which is a right-wing astroturfed organization set up by 2 billionaire brothers who supported Mitt Romney.

It's very hard to see Dr. Fura as anything other than a right-wing Truther.

He has a FB like for We Are Change Eugene and is FB friends with Dick Gage, Erik Lawyer, and a guy named Chris Dorsey who describes himself as a Constitutional Restoration Specialist at Americans for Constitutional Enforcement.

He's also friends with Brandon J Raub, who we've discussed before in CTs:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=242218
 
Mid-month update

...
They keep scraping the barrel - i.e. they are actively revisiting old but yet unverified signatures:

In April, only 6 days old in California, so far the A&E count has increased by a whopping 18 signatures - that's more than they verified in all of March and April 2012 combined - but again, the mean and median age of those signatures is about 5 months! 3 of these are new from April, 2 each signed in March and February, and all the rest is from 2012 (and possibly even older - I haven't found one or two yet). They even re-classified an old signature from 2008 from "Other Supporter" to "A&E".


They are also now scraping the "OS" barrel: ...

I didn't want to do mid-month updates, but the first 2 weeks of April have seen an "unprecedented" (one of Gage's favorite buzz-words :D) degree of scraping the barrel:

So far, in 14 days, the A&E count has increased from 1825 to 1867 - that's +42 Architects & Engineers, or 3 per day. They have never ever had a full month with 3 sigs per day - and the total, 42, is already the best value since September 2011 (the 10-year anniversary), and second-best since September 10.
But very little of that is current action.

So far, I have only found 35 of these 42 - the 7 I am missing so far must be older than October 01, 2012, or more than half a year in the past.
Of the 35, one was verified as an "Other Supporter" in 2008 and only now been re-classified as "A&E". Of the other 34, 16 are older than Oct 01. 4 more signed between October and December. Only 14 signed up in 2013; 6 of these in April.

The median sign-up date of the 42 they verified this April must lie in September.


Similarly, they verified 150 "Other Supporters" in the last 2 weeks, but only 63 of these actually signed in April. 31 signed in Jan-Mar, 8 in Oct-Dec, and the rest, 48, must be more than half a year old.


Now I am not saying these signatures are not legit - I assume they are - just shows that they are rather desparate for some reason to pimp their numbers. I speculate that Gage has set a target: To reach 2,000 A&E, or 20,000 total signatures, ASAP. This masks the fact that they are actually getting less than 7 total signatures per day, which is about the same as 2012, their worst year, and less than half of the 2010 pace.
 
Oystein I hadn't been keeping up with this thread and just dropped in to see why it was so high on the threads list. Incredible work, obviously. I notice that what looks like a real drop in activity in AE911's internet activity seems to parallel the drop in activity on 9/11 threads here on JREF. I certainly haven't done a statistical analysis of the threads here, but they are noticeably thinner. Generally, there seems to be less interest all around in things 9/11.

And speaking of statistics, my YouTube videos (see links on my signature below) have had a total of 38946 viewings, or about a tenth of the numbers AE911 gets. In addition, many people have copied my videos and it is now easier to find them on the YouTube search engine on these copied versions than on my own site! I would very roughly guess that there have been around 70,000 views if you count all viewings. My rebuttals are easily found on web searches so many people who type in Experts Speak Out, Richard Gage, or Blueprint for Truth can access these if they want to look. So very roughly, I think around 10% of the people exposed to Gage's videos also check out mine. There are many many other videos on YouTube by other "debunkers" so who knows... maybe the figure is more like 25%. Sadly, one of my most powerful videos, with a real live 9/11 first responding firefighter testifying publicly for the first and only time that temperatures NEVER exceeded around 1800 degrees F in the debris pile, has also been one of my least-watched videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gijCzs9SWH4

Finally, there is the uncompleted website www.911Theories.org/ChrisMohr, where people on the 9/11 Truth side wanted to continue the debate on the 238 reasons for natural collapse I had come up with in my YouTube videos. I don't have a count on that, but very few people even know of its existence (even though I spent a couple hundred hours adding more and more links to further cover every point). What happened there? Some 9/11 Truth folks responded to my points, and I responded back with more links and arguments (with a lot of input and help from several JREF people here). The 9/11 Truth side was going to get the last word in the "fourth box" but in most cases they never took it. After repeated inquiries went nowhere, I realized the project had been dropped altogether. Nevertheless, even in its incomplete state it is a great compendium of links to articles videos etc on both sides.

This is nowhere near as thorough as Oystein's analyses, but it is clear to me that the percentage of people who really investigate both sides of this argument is not overly high. Still, 70,000 views of my videos tells me that the effort is worth something.
 
...
I speculate that Gage has set a target: To reach 2,000 A&E, or 20,000 total signatures, ASAP. This masks the fact that they are actually getting less than 7 total signatures per day, which is about the same as 2012, their worst year, and less than half of the 2010 pace.

D'uh.
I missed this article from April 06:
Architects and Engineers: Help Us Reach 2,000 A&E Petition Signers by September - Refer a Colleague to AE911Truth

Besides the staggering number of old signatures from half a year and longer ago that they just now come around to verifying, I have noticed that, among the not-so-many "Other Supporters" that they are also late to verify, there are some that have entered "Engineering" as their professional "discipline", and some even claim engineering degrees, yet they are not verified as engineers. Not sure what to make of this. I believe this shows they are really contacting folks again that claimed engineering degrees, and ask for copies of their diploma etc. Some turn out to have boasted without justification, and are rejected as A&E.

Very few of those late verifications are licensed architects or P.E.s. The vast majority are "Engineers (degreed only)", and almost all the rest are Non-U.S. A&E. Since Feb 01 they have verified 68 A&E signatures that were 3 months old or older at the time. Currently, they have 1873 listed.
Category|recent late verifications|total A&E
All|68|1873
Lic. Architects|1.5%|15%
Arch. (degreed only)|---|5%
Lic. Engineers|3%|19%
Eng. (degreed only)|59%|37%
Non-U.S. A&E|37%|24%
 
What of course is odd... is how the supporters uncritical cite and of course assume that the 1,700 or whatever the current number is... are all practicing licensed architects and structural engineers who have studied the details of these WTC. Nothing could be further from the truth. The slight of hand marketing is bought hook line and sinker by the *supporters* who use this as the *argument of authority*.

But why would those who find the collapses did not involve CD be organized to sign petitions? Who would such petitions be directed at or appeal to? WHat would such a petition be asking for?

In my own ramblings through this *debate* I've not encountered a single architect or engineer who seems to be familiar with the design details of the structure of these buildings with the exception of Tony Szamboti and William McCord. Some, such as Ron Avery seems to make things up out of whole cloth.

So much for building professionals.
 
What of course is odd... is how the supporters uncritical cite and of course assume that the 1,700 or whatever the current number is... are all practicing licensed architects and structural engineers who have studied the details of these WTC. Nothing could be further from the truth. The slight of hand marketing is bought hook line and sinker by the *supporters* who use this as the *argument of authority*.
A large number of them - I can't provide a figure immediately, but it is very significant[ETA: see footnote] - has professionally, nothing at all to do with building construction and the engineering principles of steel structures,. or what fire can and cannot do: All of the electrical and electronic engineers, the agricultural, chemical, environmental, sanitary etc. engineers. The many of mechanical, geological, naval, marine, petroleum and nuclear engineers probaby do things with steel and temperature, but hard to assess af and how relevant their expertise really is.

Some even state in their personal statements outright that they are NOT experts.

A large number of the rest - and again, I can't provide a figure immediately, but it is very significant - is demonstrably ill informed: Only partially informed (have all their "knowledge" from the woo side of life) or incorrectly informed (believe in bulk amounts of molten steel, or freefall of the twins, etc.). A staggering example of the latter is that more than half of the signers who have the word "foot print" or "footprint" in their personal statement have explicit or implicit language to effect that the twin towers fell "into" their footprints - which is not only contrary to facts, but also contrary to what AE911T itself disseminates (according to them, the twins fell outward, which is supposed to be proof of CD, and only Bldg 7 fell inward, which is also supposed to be proof of CD).

But why would those who find the collapses did not involve CD be organized to sign petitions? Who would such petitions be directed at or appeal to? WHat would such a petition be asking for?
Those who do believe in CD aren't organized either - AE911Truth is basically a one-man vanity act with varying supporting personel - and, contrary to the language of the "petition", the last thing Gage wants is a new investigation, or Congress seizing the issue. Basically, the aim now is to perpetuate the "movement". In part for monetary gain, in part to keep a sense of purpose and religious righteousness.

In my own ramblings through this *debate* I've not encountered a single architect or engineer who seems to be familiar with the design details of the structure of these buildings with the exception of Tony Szamboti and William McCord. Some, such as Ron Avery seems to make things up out of whole cloth.

So much for building professionals.
Gage has a handful of A&E who do provide some input based on own work, or who show up at his talks as supporting speakers. Those also appear in his "ESO" DVD - I think around 40 are featured there, not all of who are really active beyond speaking in the video. John Cole, Robert Bowman, Wayne Coste come to mind. Not sure we can estimate their grasp of the NIST reports.

Interestingly, Tony Sz. disagrees with some of Gage's claims. For example, he thinks that the claim "heavy steel section were laterally ejected" should not be used, as there are obvious non-explosive ways to explain what was observed.


[ETA: footnote] I just drew a random sample of 45 signers (those whose profile-ID ends with "18" or "68"). Among those
  • 2 don't reveal their engineering discpline (4%)
  • 13% are civil or structural engineers - the only discipline that's really relevant
  • 22% are architects - expertise wrt steel structures uncertain, but at least "building professionals"
  • 29% are engineers with some material construction background (mechanical, aerospace etc)
  • 31% have zero material construction background (electrical, computer, chemical...)
This snapshot is perhaps from a too small sample, and my assessment of expertise may be questioned, but it highlights a trend: only 1/3 of the signers actually work with building structures, while 1/3 does not at all work with anything where steel must resisting loads of any kind. I am pretty sure that most of those in the "middle" group haven't actually done any calculations or designs on structures sufficiently similar to steel-frame buildings to boast any 9/11-relevant expertise at all, and even among the architets and civil engineers there are certainly some whose actual, real-life practice is irrelevant to the subject.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom