When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
Very odd, the odds of this happening are quite small.



Hard to believe this is a coincidence, 2 of the 3 came from a state home to 1 in 80 Americans. Promethean Genesis is based in the city of Enterprise, OR there a few in the OR White Pages but all hundreds of miles away; I imagine Jamison is a rich truther (trust-fund baby?) who isn't listed





Hmmmm. Any named Jamison or from near Enterprise?

I wonder if Robert Jamison is this guy:



Here is his purported bio:

Robert Jamison was a U.S. Air Force 1st Lt. when he commanded an ICBM Combat Targeting Team at Malmstrom AFB, Montana, from January 1965 to October 1967. He then became a missile targeting instructor at Chanute AFB, Illinois, from October 1967 to October 1970, and finally served as targeting section commander at Minot AFB, North Dakota, before separating from active duty with the rank of Captain in July 1972. He entered inactive Reserves and received his Honorable Discharge in 1981.

Jamison graduated from Fresno State College (now named California State University, Fresno) in 1959. Upon leaving the Air Force, he worked as a traffic engineer technician for Fresno County, California, in traffic safety. He returned to college part-time and received a BS in Civil Engineering and registration as a professional Civil Engineer (California). In 1991, he began employment with the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), retiring in March 2006.
 
Last edited:
Very odd, the odds of this happening are quite small.
Yes, but not impossible. Much better than 1:288,893, as the expectation before the publishing of this form was that that revenue from contribution would be just somewhat down. getting the same dollar amount would thus be more likely than getting 1 or 100 oder half the old amount.

Hard to believe this is a coincidence, 2 of the 3 came from a state home to 1 in 80 Americans. Promethean Genesis is based in the city of Enterprise, OR there a few in the OR White Pages but all hundreds of miles away; I imagine Jamison is a rich truther (trust-fund baby?) who isn't listed

Hmmmm. Any named Jamison or from near Enterprise?

Nope. In fact, they have to date 631 signers from Oregon, but not a single one from Enterprise directly. It's a pretty remote town. The nearest other towns are Baker and La Grande, from where there are 3 signers:
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=999854
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=996117
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=975001
None of these particularly recent, and none linkable to this Jamison fella.

The most recent (since november 20th) signers from Oregon are
(all of these, except 1, "other supporters")

Still no Robert Jamison from Oregon. Only a Jordan Jamison Willard, student, from Eugene, OR:
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=981148
 
Last edited:
I wonder if Robert Jamison is this guy...

That would be the Bob Jamison of UFO fame (specifically the "UFO-nukester" brand of woo). He and Bob Hastings ran a dog-and-pony show for a while about Jamison's alleged role in the Malmstrom incident, until other information showed that Jamison had been lying all along. He tried for a year or so to rehabilitate his claims, but then eventually bowed out. I had a rather rip-roaring debate with his handler, Bob Hastings, over at BAUT.

Hijack aside, The UFO Jamison would be quite at home with people who beg for money to support their idle lie-telling and their self-indulgent public appearances, in the name of "disclosure." So it's plausible.

Here is his purported bio:

If he really was a PE for CalTrans, he'd be registered in California and not Oregon. He may have retired to Oregon.
 
That would be the Bob Jamison of UFO fame (specifically the "UFO-nukester" brand of woo). He and Bob Hastings ran a dog-and-pony show for a while about Jamison's alleged role in the Malmstrom incident, until other information showed that Jamison had been lying all along. He tried for a year or so to rehabilitate his claims, but then eventually bowed out. I had a rather rip-roaring debate with his handler, Bob Hastings, over at BAUT.

Hijack aside, The UFO Jamison would be quite at home with people who beg for money to support their idle lie-telling and their self-indulgent public appearances, in the name of "disclosure." So it's plausible.



If he really was a PE for CalTrans, he'd be registered in California and not Oregon. He may have retired to Oregon.

License lookup for California: http://www.pels.ca.gov/consumers/lic_lookup.shtml
For Oregon: http://www.oregon.gov/OSBEELS/Pages/Search_License.aspx

I find a Robert Clifford Jamison, Civil Engineer, active, from Clovis CA in the California roster, but no Robert Jamison in Oregon.
 
Last edited:
Still waiting on proof that Richard Gage is actually has a real degree from an accredited university. I demand he post it. Until then, he's clearly a paid shill.
 
His facebook shows him traveling to Shanksville, PA with signs that say "Flight 93 was shot down." How nice for the other memorial visitors. Like those ghouls that hang out by the book depository in Dallas, selling their theories.

I was thinking maybe Gage had discovered the Westboro Baptist business model: show up at the scene of a tragedy, shove incendiary literature in the faces of grieving people, then sue everyone who reacts.

Look at that picture again. Doesn't he just like a Westboro protestor? Except they can get a group together.
 
Last edited:
I was thinking maybe Gage had discovered the Westboro Baptist business model: show up at the scene of a tragedy, shove incendiary literature in the faces of grieving people, then sue everyone who reacts.

Look at that picture again. Doesn't he just like a Westboro protestor? Except they can get a group together.

The pic is of Oleg Kis, not Gage, if I understand correctly.
 
Oystein,

Do your records indicate when Stephen B. Barasch joined AE911T? It would have been in or before June 2008.
 
Oystein,

Do your records indicate when Stephen B. Barasch joined AE911T? It would have been in or before June 2008.

I can't pinpoint it exactly. My best estimate would be late April 2008. Mid-April or the first days of May 2008 are also possible.
 
Last edited:
December Update!

Since this is the end of a quarter and a year, I'll follow up with more posts full of stats and graphs - for now, just the numbers for december:


A) Architects and engineers:

Nov 30: 1752
Dec 31: 1756

4 new signers in 31 days, 0.129 per day, that's an annual growth rate of 2.72% and equivalent to each existing signer talking one peer into signing once every 36.7 years. This ties july and august 2012 for their worst month ever, only june 2012 and august 2007 were worse with only +2 signers. 2012 had 9 of their 16 worst months ever, and 6 of their worst 9 months.

You might note that in my mid-month update, I had reported 1759 A&E on December 16th - so they apparently lost three members in the final fourtnight of the year. I found two of those A&E whose names were deleted, and suspect that the third wasn't actually a deleted profile but correction of a miscount.
The deleted members are
David W. Aossey, Electrical Engineer
Sebastian Canaday, Engineer Staff

(Of course they had 7 new signers - only 1 of these actually from december, the others signed earlier and were only verified in december by Gage's team)


B) Other Supporters:

Nov 30: 16,090
Dec 31: 16,227

137 new signatures in 31 days, 4.4 per day, is below average in a bad year. The annual growth rate of 10.5% is equivalent to each existing signer convincing one new "member" once every 9.5 years.


C) Page Hits:

Traffic to ae911truth.org was down towards the end of the year, probably due to holiday.

20121231ae911truthOrgPageHits2012Aug-Decjpg_zpsf5d08376.png



D) Fundraisers:

3 of those were running in december.

The first, ESO on PBS and Cable TV, had raised US$ 676 in december (10 contributors), 1,825.11 total (26 contribs) towards a goal of 8,800

The second, College Newspaper Ads, started on december 14 with a goal of US$ 10,000, which a truther named Oleg Kis promised to double. It had reached $ 1,193 from 17 contribs by the end of the month.

The third, Support our volunteers, started on december 14 with a goal of US$ 5,400. It had reached $ 280 from 8 contribs by the end of the month.

So in sum, they 2149 dollars from 35 contributions in december. Averages:
$61.4 / contribution
$71.63 / day
Nothing remarkable.

Remarkable however is that in early january, somebody payed up the targets in full to the two open ones and to a new one that started in january - I'll write a separate post about that.
 
Some graphs for the year:

Total number of new signers per year:

2012AEOSSignersPerYear_zps47485ca6.png


These numbers are nornalized to a year with 365 - mainly to extrapolate the 2007 numbers to a full year, as they started only in may 2007.

The number of new Architects and Engineers signing up to the woo-fest peaked in 2009, and has now been declining for 3 straight years, reaching a new all-time low in 2012, which was down 56% from the previous year.

The number of new Other Supporters peaked in 2010, and declined for 2 straight years. Was down 40% from 2011 to 2012.


Number of new signers every month:

Architects and Engineers:

2007-2012AElineargrowthmonthly_zpse2354bbe.png


There are quite extreme changes from month to month every year, but the maxima and minima in 2012 were both lower than in all previous years. The thin grey line is an exponential trend from the beginnings in 2007 to March 2010, the thin orange line the exponential trend since then.

Note how in each year there is distinct peak in September, the 9/11 anniversary month. In 2012, it was smeared over to October, as they were a little late verifying many signatures. In 2009, I have no data for July and August, and so the peak you see on September is actually an average for 3 months, and I strongly suspect that if I had the data for all three months, then september would be much higher and the summer months lower.


Other Supporters:

2007-2012OSlineargrowthmonthly_zps0fabeccb.png


Same cut-off date for the trend lines: March 2010.


Number of new signers every quarter:

Cumulating the monthly figures to quarters gives a cleaner picture. For the A&E, I'd like to note that while the last quarter of 2012 was the best quarter in 2012, it would have been the worst quarter in all previous years. In other words, all four quarters of 2012 were worse than all quarters 2007-2011.

Architects and Engineers:

2007-2012AElineargrowthquarterly_zpsece987bf.png


Trend line cut-off time is Q1/2010


Other Supporters:

2007-2012OSlineargrowthquarterly_zps141c9190.png


Trend line cut-off time here is Q3/2010


Again, there are ups and downs from one quarter to the next, with usually a peak in Q3 for the anniversary (which, again, was shifted to Q4 in 2012 because Gage's office was late verifying signatures). Here however is a graph that shows how sustained the decline of signers is: I compare each quarter to the same quarter of the previous year, to see by which factor a quarter is up or down from a year ago. This view cancels out the seasonal differences:

2007-2012AEOSchangequarterfrompreviousyear_zpsf387d182.png


You see that all bars are below zero since the last quarter of 2010: Numbers have been declining steadily now for 9 quarters in a row! The A&E have been retreating from Gage even since Q2/2010 - eleven quarters in a row!

Here is another way to view the same thing - plotting the four quarters of separately for each year:

2007-2012AEnumberquarterlyeachyear_zps6f2cf73b.png


See how the dark blue line for 2010 is below the dark gray 2009 line since Q2; the bright blue 2011 curve is completely below 2010, and 2012 (red) completely below 2011. (It almost reaches the Q4/2011 value only because a number of september signers were counted in Q4 instead of Q3/2012)


Comparing Architects and Other Supporters

AE911Truth pretends to be an organization of "professionals", and in the early days, a large proportion of the signers were indeed architercture or engineering graduates. But as the years went by, that changes, and the Petition appeals less and less to the professionals. While all demographic groups are in decline, the professionals abandon Gage even faster than the amateurs, as the following graph shows, where I simply divided the number of new "A&E" by the number of "Other Supporters":

2007-2012newsignersAEdivbyOSannually_zpsce0ed506.png


In the A&E peak year 2009, they had under 7 amateurs per professional, in 2012 it was almost 19 amateurs - a factor of almost 3.


Web Traffic:

Alexa.com measures how what proportion of internet users visit a certain website. Here is how the world has been drawn to ae911truth.org during the last 2 years - the max time that Alexa looks back:

20130107_Alexa_ae911truth_DailyReach_zps6cb75e0c.png


Internet users go to 9/11 woo sites on the anniversaries, and the rest of the year - noise. The 9/11 peak in 2012 is very much down from 2011, and the traffic level the page sees the rest of the year was lower after september 2001 than before. Note though that the graph plots the visitors relative to traffic on the entire internet. If worldwide site visits increase absolutely, then absolute numbers for AE911T would look better than this.




SUMMARY:

The hard numbers show that Gage's brand of woo is drawing less and less attention from all population, but that the decline is especially marked among the target population of A&E professionals, where he is still below 0.05% of all Professional Engineers in the USA - clearly a tiny fringe. The total number of just under 18,000 signers that they had at the end of 2012 is an abysmally poor showing, after 5 1/2 years, during which they earned over a million dollars that they spent on marketing efforts. More than $50 spent on each signature, less than 10 signers per day to a petition that is open to all 7 billion humans on the planet - what a failure!

At least Gage made >$320,000 in salary to his personal wallet so far. Not bad for such a terrible job performance!
 
January Update

A) Architects and Engineers

December 31, 2012: 1,756
January 31, 2012: 1,769

That's a difference of 13 in the reported number (that they show on the front page). That number has little to do with actual signing activity. It came about like this:
+ 6 new signees who actually signed in january
+ 4 new signees who signed in december, but were verified in january. Those two categories are normal
+ 2 who signed last september - quite a delay, but happens
+ 2 who signed in april and may - unusual
+ 3 who signed in the fall of 2011 - that's scraping the barrel!
-----
Sum: + 17 newly verified signatures

- 5 deleted signatures
- 1 signature set to "pending verification"
+ 2 set to "verified" who had been "pending" for a meantime
-----
Sum: - 4 old and changed signatures

Not sure why the deleted profiles were deleted. 5 in a month is probably a record. I will monitor if that was a one-off, or the beginning of a trend (I had 3 deleted in november, and 1 in december, none in the three months before that)


B) Other Supporters

December 31, 2012: 16,227
January 31, 2012: 16,391

That's a reported plus of 164. But again, that has to be taken with some care:
Of these
- 147 actually signed in january (most Other Supporters are verified within a day)
- 8 were verified who had signed in december
- 4 were verified who had signed in november
- 5 were verified who had signed september

Of the 147, 24 (16%) didn't fill out the form on the website, because they did not enter a bio and personal statement - you can't submit the signature form without filing those fields! All of these 24 are from Oregon (21), or from Vancouver, WA (3). Obviously, these are added manually to the database. I don't know yet where these come from - Since august, at least 116 signatures from Oregon and Vancouver, WA, have thusly been added to the petition (27 in august, 36 in september, 12 in october, 14 in november, 3 in december). Looks like there is a concerted and sustained effort going on in Oregon to collect signatures apart from the ae911truth website.
An additional 82 of 1004 OS signatures from the USA that do have personal statement and bio filled out are from Oregon, that's 8.2% from a state that has 1.2% of the US population.
This Oregon-activity started ca. towards the end of june, 2012, and has contributed an estimated 12% of all OS signatures from the USA (9-10% of all Other Supporters)


C) Content View hits

This statistics of their web traffic, as shown on the bottom of their starting page, is rather uninteresting:

December 2012: 5,902 hits / day
January 2013: 5,881 hits / day

Both months were slightly less busy than october and november and slightly more busy than august. This is largely due to the holidays: from december 21 to january 08, most days were below 5,000.


I'll write about fundraisers in a separate post.
 
Fundraisers in January 2013

There were no fewer than six fundraisers on the AE911Truth homepage that ended or started in January.

One main reason I am monitoring AE911Truth is to predict their financial development. Ca. a year ago, I had hypothesized that Gage's total fundraising would correlate positively with new signatures, and that consequently he should have earned less in 2011 than in 2010, much less in 2012, and should be running into existential troubles in 2013.

When the IRS form 990 for 2011 came out in november, I had to concede that income isn't directly tied to the petition; and when I summed up the results of their little fundraising widgets at chipin.com, I found that those, too, seemed not to be tightly dependent on petition success.

I think I now know why: Sustaining big supporters.

Here is why:
I see in most of the recent fundraisers that they have a low level of small donations, but a consistent flow of big donations of $500, $1,000 and even more. Details:

1. College Newspaper Ads
By Dec 31, this had 17 contributions for a sum of $1,193
On Jan 01, there was one donation of $1,000 (and another of $20)
Between Jan 01 and 03, there were three donations totalling $7,687! I suppose there may have been two "normal" donations, and one big spender donating the balance to the target of $10,000
These 10,000 are supposed to be doubled by Oleg Kis

2. Support our volunteers
By Dec 31, this had 8 contributions for a sum of $280
On Jan 03, a single donation added $2,000
The same day, another single donation added $3,120 to fulfill the target of $5,400

3. ESO Film Festival Entries
This started on Jan 03, and had reached 101% of its target 8 day later on just two donations: A small one of $28. and a big one of $2,800

4. Inform every police chief
Started on Jan 11, this initially had 2 small donations for $132, then a big one of $1,000 on Jan 13. A day later, 3 more donors had combined for $1,950! Don't want to speculate how those were distributed, but there most probably was one of $1,000 or more among them.
The fundraiser ended on Jan 15 at its target of $3,200, after two more small contributions added up for $59.

5. Booth at June AIA Nat'l Con[1]Started on Jan 16 and scheduled to rum through Mar 15, this is interesting in that it hasn't been spoiled by any big donor! So far, after 16 days, it has 11 donations for $410, that's only $25.63 per day, $37.27 per donation - both would be the lowest values of any of the 30+ fundraisers since 2009. It shows that the mass of small donors isn't able to feed those campaigns!

6. Air WTC 7/Ed Asner on PBS
Started on Jan 19, its first five donations averaged $56. Then, on ca. Jan 22, somebody gave $1,000.
By the 24th, seven more contributions combined for $1,235. I can't be sure, but would think it's likely that $1,000 of these came from 1 or 2 big spenders, $235 from 5 or 6 small spenders (that would be an average of 39 to 47 dollars - fairly ordinary numbers).


Sums for january
FR|# total|$ total|# big spender|$ big spender|# small spender|$ small sp.
College Newspaper Ads|6|8,807|2|8,700|4|107
Support our volunteers|2|5,120|2|5,120|0|0
ESO Film Festival Entries|2|2,828|1|2,800|1|28
Inform every police chief|8|3,200|2|2,800|6|400
Booth at June AIA Nat'l Con |11|410|0|0|11|410
Air WTC 7/Ed Asner on PBS|15|2,550|2|2,000|13|550
SUM | 44 | 22,915 | 9 | 21,420 | 35 | 1,495
Quite amazing: Big donors account for 93.5% of the fundraising income that Gage cashed in this January! They gave, on average, up to 2,380 dollars.
And this is not even counting Oleg Kis' addition of $10,000!

Small donors on the other hand provided only 6.5% - $43 per donation, $48 per day on all six fundraisers combined.



So I see that Gage's money income seems to be nicely decoupled from the decline of his popular success!



[1] I am not making this up - check it out: They really call it the "Nat'l Con" - who said Gage isn't a Con man?? :D
 
I think I now know why: Sustaining big supporters.

Personally, I think he's feeding these campaigns with the sustaining members alone. It would explain why his contributions were exactly the same to the dollar as last year (2010).
 
Last edited:
Personally, I think he's feeding these campaigns with the sustaining members alone.
Not alone, but to a significant, and probably increasing degree.
He is certainly not rejecting the small donations. Even if those made up only 6.5% of donations via ChipIn (4.5% if you count in Oleg Kis), it was still almost 1500 dollars last months. I sure wouldn't reject those!

It would explain why his contributions were exactly the same to the dollar as last year (2010).
I disagree - big spenders change somewhat from year to year, and of course he has this steady flow of small donations.
The ChipIn fundraisers last year added up to approximately 32,000 dollars, from approximately 350 individual donations. Throughout the year, I'd guess that perhaps 40% to half of this came from smaller contributions (under, say, 250 dollars). You can't controll that very tightly, I'd think.
These 32,000 should be included in the $288,893 from "Contributions and Grants". It's only like 11% of that sum, so it can only serve as an indicator that's observable. Gage solicits more donations, and encourages people to make that regular "membership" fees, for general purposes in the right-hand column of the homepage.
 
I believe what he does is uses the "fundraisers" to show a continued interest, while all of the money actually comes from the sustaining members. The new signers are just that, signers that are not willing to give up any cash. You have to admit, as a asset (If you accept his claimed goal) he is not performing well or really achieved any of the expected goals.

If you notice on page 9 (line 1-c) of his 990 he does not list any income from fundraisers. I believe at this point his only real variable income is from program revenue and sales.

Naturally I can't prove this but, that exact to the dollar contributions is just too much of a coincidence for me to accept. ;)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom