When will the AE911 petition finally reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

When will the AE911 petition reach juggernaut strength of 1%?

  • 20 years

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • 50 years

    Votes: 2 0.9%
  • Never

    Votes: 80 36.4%
  • Who cares?….it's retarded anyway.....

    Votes: 135 61.4%

  • Total voters
    220
I have had some direct personal experience with some of the diehard AE911T guys... Jon Cole, Wayne Coste, Tony Szamboti. My sense is that they simply have blinders on and are so committed to their beliefs that it's unthinkable to admit error... so they soldier on with the core group cheering them on.

I wrote to Jon Cole a few years ago as I began to do my own research... if it can be called that about the twin towers and told him that the so called mysterious disappearance of the *spire* (post collapse surviving core columns) fell as a result of Euler buckling forces. His answer (brief)... was that he had forgotten about that. Odd that's he touted as a civil engineer professional go to guy. This explanation of why the remaining core fell makes perfect sense... yet Cole and AE never bothered to publish the explanation as to what explained the collapse of the *spire*. They left it out there as a unsolved mystery for their followers to believe it could only be explained by CD.

I've also written to several of the AE guys explaining ROOSD and again AE has not taken a position that it could explain the observations or it couldn't. They refuse to officially acknowledge this explanation as a possibility.

I do believe now they are just engaged in making money to make money to survive... and not interested in what actually explains the collapses. I personally believe that NIST made some mistakes and this is not helping and lay people are left with a false dichotomy with neither side being correct... though CD is really a huge leap of faith.

People will see what they want to see because it then reinforces their preconceived ideas... and that applies to professionals AND lay persons.
 
I have had some direct personal experience with some of the diehard AE911T guys... Jon Cole, Wayne Coste, Tony Szamboti. My sense is that they simply have blinders on and are so committed to their beliefs that it's unthinkable to admit error... so they soldier on with the core group cheering them on...
My only experience out of those three is with Tony Sz. Technically his "blinders" - all four of his papers or claims that I have dealt with - is a false assumption about context then limiting technical analysis to within that false context. Whether or not that is a deliberate trick or tactic it is an approach that a lot of debunker engineers also fall for. So we see prolonged discussion of minutiae details. The only problem being that the foundation assumptions are wrong. ("only" :rolleyes: - it is fatal to the argument.)
...I wrote to Jon Cole a few years ago as I began to do my own research... if it can be called that about the twin towers and told him that the so called mysterious disappearance of the *spire* (post collapse surviving core columns) fell as a result of Euler buckling forces...
I personally doubt that it was that simple - blow in the breeze bending failure equally likely IMO - but leave that for another occasion.
His answer (brief)... was that he had forgotten about that. Odd that's he touted as a civil engineer professional go to guy.
Never lose sight of the reality that the majority of engineers are out of their comfort zone trying to comprehend the dynamic events which were these collapses. Many have only practised engineering at the level of fill in the numbers in the formula or read the manual to derive a standard solution. Sure many can work from basic principles but these collapses were several orders more complex than what most engineers learn at uni or practice in their careers. And those comments only go the limits of technical expertise - add on top a pre-set commitment to believe CT and it is way beyond their capacity for self analysis of why they are thinking wrongly.
This explanation of why the remaining core fell makes perfect sense... yet Cole and AE never bothered to publish the explanation as to what explained the collapse of the *spire*. They left it out there as a unsolved mystery for their followers to believe it could only be explained by CD....
Their primary goal is NOT "explain what really happened".
...I've also written to several of the AE guys explaining ROOSD and again AE has not taken a position that it could explain the observations or it couldn't. They refuse to officially acknowledge this explanation as a possibility....
Be aware of the risks of using the acronym "ROOSD" on this forum. I like the acronym - wish I had thought of it. And the mechanism it describes is spot on what really happened. BUT on this forum the acronym is associated with Major_Tom. And therefore by definition must be wrong. The idea that someone the mob have declared a "truther" could get something right is beyond comprehension for many. Sure M_T is right on that he calls ROOSD - myself and others had identified the mechanism also but all of us who prefer to explain "what really happened" are outnumbered by the Bazantophiles.
I do believe now they are just engaged in making money to make money to survive... and not interested in what actually explains the collapses....
Agreed.
I personally believe that NIST made some mistakes and this is not helping and lay people are left with a false dichotomy with neither side being correct...
Because the those arguing from the truther side of the polarised 'Great Divide" make the same false global generalisation viz "NIST is totally wrong" - see many threads - this one current here on this forum. And the debunker side fails to call the illogic of the false generalisation - thereby condoning the false context - see the analogous comment I made on T Sz earlier in the post.
though CD is really a huge leap of faith....
Not a single leap - rather a couple of quantum leaps in (il)logic.
...People will see what they want to see because it then reinforces their preconceived ideas... and that applies to professionals AND lay persons.
Yes - because the main errors are in irrational thinking NOT the areas of technical expertise.
 
Last edited:
Ozzie,

I am not well versed in the board psychology here other than they seem to worship the ground NIST is built upon and can't imagine they could have made even a spelling error! I also see they have it in for Tom regardless of what he says... he's got to be wrong because he's perceived as a truther.

I don't care to engage with aggressive, irrational people who like to play gotcha and argue by snipping text from who knows where as if this is a scarlet letter. One thing I have learned since dipping into the 9/11 waters... that the more I understood the more my original (what were) preconception/beliefs fell by the way side. And so my understanding is constantly changing. And I think that's just fine. But it's not a credible position in the so called *debate*. You're either with us or against us and never the twain shall meet.

Your point about the complexity and the DYNAMIC nature of a deconstruction... and the inability of most professional engineers to have a clue about such things is spot on. Aside from demolition experts who pretty much blow things apart... there are not many experts in structural failures among the hundreds of thousands of licensed engineers. Engineers are conservative, work from tables and usually don't deal with failures as huge and complex as we saw on 9/11. It's well beyond most their expertise level.

And this makes the AE claim of building professionals who *support CD* a completely empty claim when you consider they haven't any training in such matters (forensic engineering of structural failures). None of them.
 
Ozzie,

I am not well versed in the board psychology here other than they seem to worship the ground NIST is built upon and can't imagine they could have made even a spelling error!
I think this is slightly hyperbolic - my perception is that most of the regulars here have no trouble admitting or assuming that NIST has some, or even many, details less than perfectly right. However with this...

I also see they have it in for Tom regardless of what he says... he's got to be wrong because he's perceived as a truther.
...and much of the rest of what you say I can agree.

...And this makes the AE claim of building professionals who *support CD* a completely empty claim when you consider they haven't any training in such matters (forensic engineering of structural failures). None of them.
This again is slightly hyperbolic. Doing a quick and dirty filter, I find 21 A&E who have the word "forensic" in their Bio, often even "forensic engineering". This does not in all, or most, cases pertain to "forensic engineering of structural failures", but I suppose a handful do. Try, for example
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=990704
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=969419
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=966072
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=969360
http://www2.ae911truth.org/profile.php?uid=974588
 
Ozzie,

I am not well versed in the board psychology here other than they seem to worship the ground NIST is built upon and can't imagine they could have made even a spelling error! I also see they have it in for Tom regardless of what he says... he's got to be wrong because he's perceived as a truther.

I don't care to engage with aggressive, irrational people who like to play gotcha and argue by snipping text from who knows where as if this is a scarlet letter. One thing I have learned since dipping into the 9/11 waters... that the more I understood the more my original (what were) preconception/beliefs fell by the way side. And so my understanding is constantly changing. And I think that's just fine. But it's not a credible position in the so called *debate*. You're either with us or against us and never the twain shall meet.

Your point about the complexity and the DYNAMIC nature of a deconstruction... and the inability of most professional engineers to have a clue about such things is spot on. Aside from demolition experts who pretty much blow things apart... there are not many experts in structural failures among the hundreds of thousands of licensed engineers. Engineers are conservative, work from tables and usually don't deal with failures as huge and complex as we saw on 9/11. It's well beyond most their expertise level.

And this makes the AE claim of building professionals who *support CD* a completely empty claim when you consider they haven't any training in such matters (forensic engineering of structural failures). None of them.

No training in such matters. Quite true.
Or nonprofessionals.
Or Structural Fire Engineering, a subspecialty of structural engineering. http://www.see.ed.ac.uk/fire/staff-asif.html

Here’s the kind of work that these professionals listen to:
Structures in Fire
Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference
http://www.egr.msu.edu/sif10/flyer of conf/SiF10 Conference Proceedings.pdf
 
I think this is slightly hyperbolic - my perception is that most of the regulars here have no trouble admitting or assuming that NIST has some, or even many, details less than perfectly right...
In your perception, what details of the NIST report are not perfectly right?
 
Who needs NIST? JSanderO, to post nonsense about JREF; A&E to attack

they seem to worship the ground NIST is built upon ...
A weak attack on JREF? lol

No one needs NIST but your old buddies in 911 truth. They have to attack NIST because they have no original work. They attack anything with the government.

You have not read NIST, so you can't support or defend NIST; so you make up the lie, "they seem to worship ... NIST". Total BS.

911 truth has to have NIST to make up lies. I understand steel fails in fire, fast. I don't need NIST, I am an engineer; but being an engineer could be overkill, since it takes only a grade school education to understand impacts and fire destroyed the WTC.

Go ahead do a poll, who worships NIST. You made a failed claims based on your own bias. Now Balsamo has officially labeled you a troll, have you retracted your statement JREF posters are jerks? Yes? No? Maybe?



Go ahead make my day; explain Major Tom's work, explain his conclusion. Maybe you are fooled by Major Tom's work, it is similar to what A&E have; nonsense.
 
Last edited:
In your perception, what details of the NIST report are not perfectly right?

Since this is entirely irrelevant to anything and everything, I won't be baited into continuing this derail :)
 
A weak attack on JREF? lol

No one needs NIST but your old buddies in 911 truth. They have to attack NIST because they have no original work. They attack anything with the government.

You have not read NIST, so you can't support or defend NIST; so you make up the lie, "they seem to worship ... NIST". Total BS.

911 truth has to have NIST to make up lies. I understand steel fails in fire, fast. I don't need NIST, I am an engineer; but being an engineer could be overkill, since it takes only a grade school education to understand impacts and fire destroyed the WTC.

Go ahead do a poll, who worships NIST. You made a failed claims based on your own bias. Now Balsamo has officially labeled you a troll, have you retracted your statement JREF posters are jerks? Yes? No? Maybe?



Go ahead make my day; explain Major Tom's work, explain his conclusion. Maybe you are fooled by Major Tom's work, it is similar to what A&E have; nonsense.
Interesting point in here Beachnut: if the NIST Report never existed, we could still look at FEMA, EPA, FBI, ARUP, Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat, Purdue University, University of Hawaii, countless physicists and structural engineers I have talked with, hundreds of published papers by qualified experts, etc etc etc. to get the data we need to support the conclusion of 9/11 natural collapse. And BTW many of us have stated that we believe there are specific areas where NIST made mistakes, but none major enough to say their whole study was worthless. NIST is just the most thorough study, and the one with the best collection of raw data and evidence.
 
Interesting point in here Beachnut: if the NIST Report never existed, we could still look at FEMA, EPA, FBI, ARUP, Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat, Purdue University, University of Hawaii, countless physicists and structural engineers I have talked with, hundreds of published papers by qualified experts, etc etc etc. to get the data we need to support the conclusion of 9/11 natural collapse. And BTW many of us have stated that we believe there are specific areas where NIST made mistakes, but none major enough to say their whole study was worthless. NIST is just the most thorough study, and the one with the best collection of raw data and evidence.

NIST is not all wrong... obviously. Most of the data is perfectly fine it seems. But there are mistakes and there are mistakes. It appears that the collapses were caused by heat weakening from fire plus some mechanical damage. This general point that is the thrust of NIST appears to be correct. I don't personally find their column 79 and the sagging trusses to be the initiation of what they term as the global collapse.. something they do not detail either.

Assuming (for the moment) that NIST et al got the main cause... heat weakening and mechanical damage correct, but the actual mechanism / location wrong.... does this matter? Could this matter? Why and how? Or is all one needs to know is mechanical damage, extensive heat, unfought fires can collapse a building?

I think that it IS important to get the location /mechanism correct because it may have implication for engineering design.

It also appears that the same *blunders* (my term) are not being made anymore...

Maybe
 
Interesting point in here Beachnut: if the NIST Report never existed, we could still look at FEMA, EPA, FBI, ARUP, Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat, Purdue University, University of Hawaii, countless physicists and structural engineers I have talked with, hundreds of published papers by qualified experts, etc etc etc. to get the data we need to support the conclusion of 9/11 natural collapse. And BTW many of us have stated that we believe there are specific areas where NIST made mistakes, but none major enough to say their whole study was worthless. NIST is just the most thorough study, and the one with the best collection of raw data and evidence.

So now it's a countless number?

MM
 
My thanks to JSanderO and Oystein for leading these responses to my post. The attempt to address the real issue of polarisation is a positive step IMO. (I will focus on JSO's and Oy's comments first - may reference other members later.)
Ozzie,

I am not well versed in the board psychology here other than they seem to worship the ground NIST is built upon and can't imagine they could have made even a spelling error!
I think this is slightly hyperbolic - my perception is that most of the regulars here have no trouble admitting or assuming that NIST has some, or even many, details less than perfectly right.
Agreed on the slightly hyperbolic. As for the acknowledgement of possible NIST errors in detail - I may say more later or in a subsequent post but - the issue when it comes to "debunker v perceived truther" debates is IMO that such debates see both sides taking polarised extreme positions. Those debunkers who would freely discuss possible detailed errors with other debunkers tending to back off to the pre-set extreme when confronted by a person who either is a truther OR one who they have decided to regard as a truther irrespective of the topic being discussed. There will be exceptions but it is rare for the recognition of detail errors to be admitted by debunkers in such stand offs. More important from my perspective is a failure to rigorously put the details into a proper context of relevance and significance - possibly more on that aspect later.
However with this...
... I also see they have it in for Tom regardless of what he says... he's got to be wrong because he's perceived as a truther...
...and much of the rest of what you say I can agree.
IMO Major_Tom is a distinctly different case. My position vis-a-vis M_T well documented on this forum and 911Forum. I won't diverge/derail into explaining the M_T specifics but being perceived as a truther is IMO only the secondary barrier to M_T. The real issue(s) for M_T are his refusal to enter discussion - even refusing to support his own OP - plus his arrogant and insulting attitude to other members. He has many times explicitly stated that he is playing psychological games. Dale Carnegie turn in your grave - that it not "How to Win Friends and Influence People" (unless you are seeking negative influence)

M_T gets rough treatment here but he largely brings it on himself. So let's set M_T aside for now and get back to the issue(s). :blush:

...This again is slightly hyperbolic. Doing a quick and dirty filter, I find 21 A&E who have the word "forensic" in their Bio, often even "forensic engineering". This does not in all, or most, cases ...etc
Take care to not conflate "qualifications" with "ability". The focus point in my post was that many engineers who may have equal qualifications lack the ability/skill/expertise to apply engineering principles in situations above routine. I identified three levels in earlier posts. Some qualified engineers are lost when they get above rote routine application. Some can apply principles to situations which are somewhat above normal routine. Some would get lost in forensic challenges of the complexity of WTC collapses.

Conversely many engineers can use initiative in applying basic concepts to novel situations such as WTC collapses. And those differences in ability apply to persons who have the same qualification. So please read what I am saying as referencing demonstrated ability NOT qualification.

..And this makes the AE claim of building professionals who *support CD* a completely empty claim when you consider they haven't any training in such matters (forensic engineering of structural failures). None of them.
Take care with the hyperbole of "completely", "None of them".

And also the reference to "training". In the context of my explanation the issue is not training - it is that nothing* published by AE911 is valid explanation or support of their global claim of CD. They are wrong* - notwithstanding either qualifications or training.

Finally:
Your point about the complexity and the DYNAMIC nature of a deconstruction... and the inability of most professional engineers to have a clue about such things is spot on.
Thank you.



* Yeah - I know - hyperbole. :o
 
Last edited:
In your perception, what details of the NIST report are not perfectly right?
Since this is entirely irrelevant to anything and everything, I won't be baited into continuing this derail :)
I agree with Oystein.

BUT with an explanation. The problem is not which details are wrong/not perfectly right. The problem is how people use or misuse any perceived error of detail.

Take one example - core led v perimeter led. NIST's explanation says "The perimeter went first". But there is persuasive argument that the core failed before the perimeter.

The relevant questions are "Why does it matter?" "To whom does it matter?" and "For what purposes does it matter?" (There could well be more - those will suffice.)

No one AFAICS has ever made a claim as to why the difference matters. Reality is that both towers fell when the impact and fire zone weakened and let the top portion of tower fall. At that point all columns had failed. The Top part of tower didn't care which column or beam was first, fifty second or last. It fell.

The problem is not which details are not perfectly right. The problem is how people use or misuse any perceived error of detail.
 
my hilite
NIST is not all wrong... obviously. Most of the data is perfectly fine it seems. But there are mistakes and there are mistakes. It appears that the collapses were caused by heat weakening from fire plus some mechanical damage. This general point that is the thrust of NIST appears to be correct. I don't personally find their column 79 and the sagging trusses to be the initiation of what they term as the global collapse.. something they do not detail either.

Assuming (for the moment) that NIST et al got the main cause... heat weakening and mechanical damage correct, but the actual mechanism / location wrong.... does this matter? Could this matter? Why and how? Or is all one needs to know is mechanical damage, extensive heat, unfought fires can collapse a building?

I think that it IS important to get the location /mechanism correct because it may have implication for engineering design.

It also appears that the same *blunders* (my term) are not being made anymore...

Maybe

NIST discarded the thesis that the diesel generators at the lower floors were the cause of the collapse because IIRC there was no heavy smoke coming out of the open fresh air louvers at the generator floors, and because most of the diesel in the tanks below grade was recovered during cleanup.
Also fire FEA time of collapse, floor of collapse, location of fire, column under penthouse, and column 79 merged. Proportion of the evidence favors NIST thesis.
 
Last edited:
my hilite

NIST discarded the thesis that the diesel generators at the lower floors were the cause of the collapse because IIRC there was no heavy smoke coming out of the open fresh air louvers at the generator floors, and because most of the diesel in the tanks below grade was recovered during cleanup.
......

There is a dearth of photos from the south side... and there are none of the inside of the mech floors 5, 6 & 7. There are no inspection surveys from this region during the day by FDNY as far as I know. We don't know what was going on in there.

There was the Jennings/Hess explosion in the region at about 10 am. I am unaware of the damage assessment of that explosion, regardless of cause or precise location.

I seriously doubt the claims of diesel recovery. How was this done? Was it recovered in the intact tanks? How much diesel was pumped up when the electricity in the building went down? How long did the back up system run the pumps? Would it run if there was a pressure drop in the system? If so it's possible the piping broke and was continuously spraying diesel into the region in question. Why would this have to be a conflagration which would produce obvious smoke? Couldn't it be a localized flame... like a torch? Weren't some of the diesel pipes running east west along TTF's north side? Was there a day tank in the region of TT1? SO how DID they recover the diesel fuel withj 200,000 tons of building debris over top of it? How much of it fueled fires smoldering under the rubble for months? Recall the hot spot under TT1 and TT2?

I find the dismissal of the diesel cause takes the heat of Con Ed, Silverstein Properties, and the City for placing the OEM generators down there within the region of key transfer structure members. How many other buildings have 30,000 gallon of diesel fuel *under them* in close proximity to major electrical equipment?

I am not satisfied with the lack of detail of the study of this region. Column 79 at flr 13 looks like a distraction to me.

Maybe
 
I seriously doubt the claims of diesel recovery. How was this done? Was it recovered in the intact tanks?
I don't have this information handy but, the company that did it and the details are documented in the NIST report.

Would it run if there was a pressure drop in the system?
Un-likely.The system where you are referring was a header system. It only used the amount of fuel in the piping to supply the gen-sets (this was due to the fact they could not use day tanks). In a system like this, there is a supply and a return. Any loss of pressure would signify a leak and the pumps would shut down. This is normally redundant by monitoring system pressure and current draw on the pumps (all automatic).

If so it's possible the piping broke and was continuously spraying diesel into the region in question.

Doubtful because of the reasons above and because the system pressures are low. It would not be a spray, more like a dribble or a slow flow. Remember, these systems are designed to supply the Gen-sets with the amount of fuel they consume. The specs for this are in the report.

Couldn't it be a localized flame... like a torch?
Not enough presure for this sort of thing. It would be like a burning puddle.
Weren't some of the diesel pipes running east west along TTF's north side?

No.

Was there a day tank in the region of TT1?
No, it was a header system.

I find the dismissal of the diesel cause takes the heat of Con Ed, Silverstein Properties, and the City for placing the OEM generators down there within the region of key transfer structure members.
Why Con Ed?
How many other buildings have 30,000 gallon of diesel fuel *under them* in close proximity to major electrical equipment?
Define "close proximity". WTC7 didn't have anywhere near this amount unless you want to consider in the same block.

I am not satisfied with the lack of detail of the study of this region. Column 79 at flr 13 looks like a distraction to me.

Noted. Just don't don't ignore the information that has been presented that seems to answer some of your concerns. ;)
 
There is a dearth of photos from the south side... and there are none of the inside of the mech floors 5, 6 & 7. There are no inspection surveys from this region during the day by FDNY as far as I know. We don't know what was going on in there.

There was the Jennings/Hess explosion in the region at about 10 am. I am unaware of the damage assessment of that explosion, regardless of cause or precise location.

I seriously doubt the claims of diesel recovery. How was this done? Was it recovered in the intact tanks? How much diesel was pumped up when the electricity in the building went down? How long did the back up system run the pumps? Would it run if there was a pressure drop in the system? If so it's possible the piping broke and was continuously spraying diesel into the region in question. Why would this have to be a conflagration which would produce obvious smoke? Couldn't it be a localized flame... like a torch? Weren't some of the diesel pipes running east west along TTF's north side? Was there a day tank in the region of TT1? SO how DID they recover the diesel fuel withj 200,000 tons of building debris over top of it? How much of it fueled fires smoldering under the rubble for months? Recall the hot spot under TT1 and TT2?

I find the dismissal of the diesel cause takes the heat of Con Ed, Silverstein Properties, and the City for placing the OEM generators down there within the region of key transfer structure members. How many other buildings have 30,000 gallon of diesel fuel *under them* in close proximity to major electrical equipment?

I am not satisfied with the lack of detail of the study of this region. Column 79 at flr 13 looks like a distraction to me.

Maybe

JSanderO, DGM . We should take this to another thread or we'll feel the wrath of the bulldogge.
 
Last month I was too lazy to do an update on the stats, although they had record numbers in April (but those were not all that "real")!

It turns out that a prediction I made about 1.5 years ago (I think) did not come true: I had predicted that the numbers of new signatures would continue to sink, and that AE911Truth would sink into oblivion, probably running into serious financial trouble this year. Seems I was wrong: Signatures had slumped until last summer, but following September, they rebounded.



So here are numbers for April and May:

A) Archtitects and Engineers

Mar 31: 1825
Apr 30: 1905
May 31: 1929

80 new signatures in April, or 2.67 per day, was actually the highest number ever since their kick--off in May 2007! Amazing, isn't it?
Well, they've been scraping the barrel - only one quarter of these, 20, actually signed in April, while more than half of those signatures were older than 5 months. Same thing as in March already, only with a larger number of signatures they scraped from the barrel and verified very late.

It looks like the barrel is mostly scraped empty, as may only got 24 newly verified signatures (and only 10 so far found actually signed within May). The median age of newly verified signatures dropped from 151 days to 46 days.

Here is a graphic that puts side by side the number of actual signatures within each month vs. the number they verified:



So the actual pace at which new A&E show up has been relatively steady at around 20 per month since November. Note that the number for May will definitely increase, as they are still in the process of verifying the latest signatures. The actual number for each month can rise retroactively.

And here a graphic to show when and how they scraped the barrel: It shows the mean and median age of signatures on the day I first found them verified and listed on the website. To explain how that comes about: Suppose you go today (June 3rd) to the AE911Truth website and fill out the form, claiming you are an Engineer. The system then assigns a Profile-ID. The IDs are numbered in decreasing order. You will be sent an email asking you to verify your email address. If you don't do that, your ProfileID will never be verified, and will never show up. I do this every othert day, and note the date and time when a ProfileID was assigned. This way, I know, with an accuracy of +/- 1 day at worst, on what day someone filled out the form.
Now, if you clicked the link and verified your email address, then the Profile still doesn't show. The AE Verification Team looks at every single form that comes in. "Other Supporters" are usually verified the same or next day, although it sometimes can take a few more days. Those that claim to be A or E however are contacted by the team and asked to scan their diploma or licenses and send them in. For this reason, A&E hardly ever show up on the website on the same day, however usually, half of them show up within 2 or 3 weeks. The rest takes somewhat longer, such that the average age for such signatures in last September - December was between 7 and 41 days.

But then...



...in January, they went back in time for earnest. While the median stayed under 40 days for two more months, the mean age jumped up, because they found a few very old signatures (over 500 days - 1.5 years - old!). Then im March and April, the median also jumped up, such that most of the 114 signatures they verified in those two months were actually from October 2012 and older.
In May, the trend reversed: Median and Mean are down, but not to back to normal. Seems they still have a little scrape left.

Considering that Gage wants to start September having reached 2000 signatures, they need some more scraping! At 20 actual signatures per month, with 3 Months to go, he'd miss the goal.


B) Other supporters

Mar 31: 16805
Apr 30: 17073
May 31: 17202

Other Supporters are mostly verified by the next day. However, when they craped for A&E in April, they also dug up some old OS:



This last happened in November. (Going into October, they had a backlog of about 100 signatures left from the previous month).

Between October and April, the number of actual OS signers was generally higher than they were in January-August 2012, so there was real recovery from a downward trend. May 2013 may be the start of a slow summer.


The trend reversal that refutes my prediction is perhaps best seen in the following graph, which shows the change in number of new signatures of each quarter relative to the same quarter in the year prior:



They had 10 quarters of decline in a row, but now two quarters back to back rebounding. (Two notes: Q2/2013 isn't over yet, but already it has more of both A&E and OS that Q2/2012. The sharp increase of A&E this current quarter is due to "scraping" the barrel, as this chart plots reported new signatures; however, actual signatures, too, rose both quarters).




ETA
Two last graphs that show that Gage has managed to avoid the decline I had predicted. They plot the increase in signatures from May to May of each year, so we can see that 2012/2013 is actually about as strong as the previous year, 2011/2012 - but still no match for the two years before that, 2009-2011:

 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom