What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Yes, God continuously maintains the universe, in effect and ultimately.




Yrreg

What I'm wondering, though, is how we get from our definitions to the conclusion that God continuously maintains the universe.

Even if we accept that God is the uncreated creator of all things and that the universe is created by that god, which we have in this discussion, doesn't that premise leave open for discussion God's relationship with the universe after it was created, allowing for possibilities such as these:

(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.

Any of these statements can answer the question "If God created the universe, then what?" How do we get to your conclusion as opposed to any of the other possibilities?
 
If God, the unmoved mover, the uncreated creator, continually maintains the integrity and functionality of our bodies, I propose that he alse thinks our thoughts and presently moves my fingers. This is the WORD OF OF GOD!

But of course everything everyone here thinks are the thoughts of God, and every word ever written in this forum is a word of God.

Seems God has a hard time convincing Himself that He exists...
 
Yes, God continuously maintains the universe, in effect and ultimately.

Then he needs to get his thumb out of his arse and abolish famine, disease and wars. If god is maintaining the Universe, why do stars eventually die, instead of being renewed?
 
Last edited:
There is one question now, and quite a few people have already mentioned it.

Stating that god is the uncreated creator of the universe really doesn't tell us anything about god. It basically supposes a being who just created this universe and then...what?

We have no idea of any aspect of this being and no way of knowing the aspects of this being since we have not stated what features of the universe would show evidence of this being. If we go simply from what we know of the universe at this moment then we can only conclude that this god cares exactly the same amount about bacteria or gas clouds or humans or any other thing in this universe. It plays no favorites and does not interfere with the current universe in any detectable way.
 
And if there had been such a force that created this universe (for the sake of argument), it is equally likely that it was consumed or destroyed in its making.
 
Actually, quite a few creation stories have the destruction of the creator as part of their core. I've always found it to be one of the more dramatic forms of creation story, an ultimate sacrifice for the benefit of the future.
 
It fits yrreG's definition of god(s) as being a creator of the universe. Kind of like dynamite is creator of a big hole in the ground. But he always pouts whenever I mention it.
 
If god created "the universe", is he then part of that universe or will he remain outside fit?

What are the boundaries (spatial, temporal, functional...) of that universe?

If a universe is defined as the set of all things that can interact with each other somewhere in space and time, and god is outside of this universe, then he can't maintain anything, for example my nose, inside this universe, as that implies interaction now and here. If he is however part of the universe, then he is not uncreated, as the universe is created and he is part of it.
 
God is beholden to man completely and all the time owing to creator's responsibility

Originally Posted by yrreg
Yes, God continuously maintains the universe, in effect and ultimately.
​
What I'm wondering, though, is how we get from our definitions to the conclusion that God continuously maintains the universe.

Even if we accept that God is the uncreated creator of all things and that the universe is created by that god, which we have in this discussion, doesn't that premise leave open for discussion God's relationship with the universe after it was created, allowing for possibilities such as these:

(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.

Any of these statements can answer the question "If God created the universe, then what?" How do we get to your conclusion as opposed to any of the other possibilities?


God does not engage in all these opotions:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.

​

because that is all how we humans would consider to be against creator's responsibility.

It is like as we humans would call command responsibility.

Only in the present case it is creator's responsibility.

However, man is free to do what he chooses to do even against the creator.



Yrreg
 
God does not engage in all these opotions:
(1) God created the universe and then abandoned it.
(2) God created the universe and observes but does not interfere.
(3) God created the universe and occasionally interferes.
(4) God created the universe and personally maintains it.

​


He doesn't engage in any of them. An imaginary being cannot engage.​
 
God is beholden to man completely and all the time owing to creator's responsibility


Yrreg

Well, yes. Man created god(s) so those imaginary beings would be beholden to man completely for creating god(s).

It's good that you can agree with me. Is tonight spaghetti night at your house? You pay homage to The Flying Spaghetti Monster on spaghetti night.
 
Last edited:
God being creator says everything about God that man can and does know about God.

There is one question now, and quite a few people have already mentioned it.

Stating that god is the uncreated creator of the universe really doesn't tell us anything about god. It basically supposes a being who just created this universe and then...what?

We have no idea of any aspect of this being and no way of knowing the aspects of this being since we have not stated what features of the universe would show evidence of this being. If we go simply from what we know of the universe at this moment then we can only conclude that this god cares exactly the same amount about bacteria or gas clouds or humans or any other thing in this universe. It plays no favorites and does not interfere with the current universe in any detectable way.

Actually, quite a few creation stories have the destruction of the creator as part of their core. I've always found it to be one of the more dramatic forms of creation story, an ultimate sacrifice for the benefit of the future.


You say:
Stating that god is the uncreated creator of the universe really doesn't tell us anything about god. It basically supposes a being who just created this universe and then...what?
​

As a matter of logical implication it tells us everything we as humans can know and thus do know when we do genuine thinking.

If you want to know anything about God which is not connected with his creation of the universe and of man, then you have to be God or have access to the mind and heart of God Himself, which is the same as being God.

As regards creation stories where God is destroyed, I submit that is not the correct concept of God: insofar as the Christian faith is concerned in God's fundamental relation to the universe which is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.

In all those such stories their God is not a genuine God, whatever uncreated entity that destroys their God is the genuine God.



Yrreg
 
You say:
Stating that god is the uncreated creator of the universe really doesn't tell us anything about god. It basically supposes a being who just created this universe and then...what?
​

As a matter of logical implication it tells us everything we as humans can know and thus do know when we do genuine stop thinking.

ftfy :wink: I snipped the rest of it as unevidenced assertion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom