What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Hi, yrreg. Actually, I didn't mean for my comments to be taken as questions. I accepted your definitions for the sake of argument and now I'm waiting for you to make whatever point you wanted to make.

The note set off by an asterisk was to make it clear that, although I accept your definition of universe for the sake of this discussion, it is not how I would normally define universe.

But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.

penis therefore god. Sorry.

:D
 
You concur on concepts, now the expedition, but still one word on assumption.

Originally Posted by yrreg
You have two questions the way I read you:

Q1. Where do we go from the concepts of God and the universe which you accept from me [ wherefore we do now have a concurrence on the concepts, good! ].

Q2. You want to know what are my assumptions in saying in our now concurred on concept of the universe, namely, the totality of created existence.


I think we must now first deal with Q2, what are my assumptions in saying that the universe is the totality of created [ by God ] existence.

Now, please don't think that I am being evasive, suppose you tell me what you understand by an assumption.


The road to concurrence on anything at all among humans is a long one and tortuous one, but with sincerity and dedication and with total application as we do have a brain, concurrence will be achieved on everything that does matter to the humans who want answers to questions, like is there a God uncreated creator of the universe?

So, again, to the work of concurrence, what is an assumption, you are the one bringing up that term, or you want to withdraw that term?


I am so glad that I don't have to deal with all posters here but you only for the present, until you also leave me -- and then I will see if someone will be available to take your place.



​


Hi, yrreg. Actually, I didn't mean for my comments to be taken as questions. I accepted your definitions for the sake of argument and now I'm waiting for you to make whatever point you wanted to make.

The note set off by an asterisk was to make it clear that, although I accept your definition of universe for the sake of this discussion, it is not how I would normally define universe.

But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.



You accept my concepts of universe as the totality of created [by God] existence and God as the uncreated creator of the universe, what is the point I am trying to make now that you concur with me on concepts?

Well, the point I am trying to make is that with the two concepts concurred on then we can go forward on an expedition to search for God the uncreated creator of the universe in the universe which is the totality of created [by God] existence.

Where do you want to start in the universe to search for God?

You will tell me since I am the one concerned with searching God and you are just following me, then I will say let us start with ourselves.


But let me now go to what you say about assumption, at the same time as we are now into ourselves in the universe where we have our also created existence: to search for God.

You say:

But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.​


Assumption has two directions: one is into fiction and the other one is into action.

If you assume that horses were wishes then beggars would ride, that is an assumption into fiction.

Now the assumption that there is an uncreated creator of the universe, that is an assumption into action, to launch on an expedition to search for God.


Back to our expedition then to search for God starting, with your concurrence if I may, with our nose.

Do we find God in our nose?

Well, the assumption is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe which is the totality of the created by God universe: so we should find God in the nose, because the nose is a part of the universe, so it follows that God the uncreated creator of the created by Him universe must be there keeping it from falling off if we so much as sneeze.

What do you say, are you finding God in the nose, in your nose as also in my nose?


Yrreg
 
Do we find God in our nose?
No, that's The Great Green Arkleseizure. We await the coming of the Great Hanky.

Well, the assumption is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe which is the totality of the created by God universe: so we should find God in the nose, because the nose is a part of the universe, so it follows that God the uncreated creator of the created by Him universe must be there keeping it from falling off if we so much as sneeze.
That assumption is a fiction. The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe, as you agree, and was destroyed in its making.

What do you say, are you finding God in the nose, in your nose as also in my nose?


Yrreg
How would anyone fine The Flying Spaghetti Monster in their nose? That's just silly. The maker of the universe was destroyed making the universe, as you agree.
 
You accept my concepts of universe as the totality of created [by God] existence and God as the uncreated creator of the universe, what is the point I am trying to make now that you concur with me on concepts?

Well, the point I am trying to make is that with the two concepts concurred on then we can go forward on an expedition to search for God the uncreated creator of the universe in the universe which is the totality of created [by God] existence.

Where do you want to start in the universe to search for God?

You will tell me since I am the one concerned with searching God and you are just following me, then I will say let us start with ourselves.


But let me now go to what you say about assumption, at the same time as we are now into ourselves in the universe where we have our also created existence: to search for God.

You say:

But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.​


Assumption has two directions: one is into fiction and the other one is into action.

If you assume that horses were wishes then beggars would ride, that is an assumption into fiction.

Now the assumption that there is an uncreated creator of the universe, that is an assumption into action, to launch on an expedition to search for God.


Back to our expedition then to search for God starting, with your concurrence if I may, with our nose.

Do we find God in our nose?

Well, the assumption is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe which is the totality of the created by God universe: so we should find God in the nose, because the nose is a part of the universe, so it follows that God the uncreated creator of the created by Him universe must be there keeping it from falling off if we so much as sneeze.

What do you say, are you finding God in the nose, in your nose as also in my nose?


Yrreg

yrreg, are you saying that, if we assume God created the universe, we must also assume that God continuously maintains the universe?
 
You accept my concepts of universe as the totality of created [by God] existence and God as the uncreated creator of the universe,
No, absolutely not. There is no god. If your concept of god has no creator, why cannot the universe have no creator?

what is the point I am trying to make now that you concur with me on concepts?
Beats me. It seems you don't have a point to make, except to pretend that the atheists conceded in some way, which is false.

Well, the point I am trying to make is that with the two concepts concurred on
They were not so conceded or concurred.
then we can go forward on an expedition to search for God the uncreated creator of the universe in the universe which is the totality of created [by God] existence.
There is no need to search for that which does not exist.

Where do you want to start in the universe to search for God?
Evidence. Got any?

You will tell me since I am the one concerned with searching God and you are just following me, then I will say let us start with ourselves.
You can start with a beetroot. Same difference.


But let me now go to what you say about assumption, at the same time as we are now into ourselves in the universe where we have our also created existence: to search for God.

You say:

But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.​
False. It is your assumption, not mine.

Assumption has two directions: one is into fiction and the other one is into action.
Which are yours?

If you assume that horses were wishes then beggars would ride, that is an assumption into fiction.
Just like if wishes were fishes, one could feed thousands, no?

Now the assumption that there is an uncreated creator of the universe, that is an assumption into action, to launch on an expedition to search for God.
No, it is a human invention.

Back to our expedition then to search for God starting, with your concurrence if I may, with our nose.
Nope. Not "our" search.

Do we find God in our nose?
Found a bogie, does that count?

Well, the assumption is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe which is the totality of the created by God universe: so we should find God in the nose, because the nose is a part of the universe, so it follows that God the uncreated creator of the created by Him universe must be there keeping it from falling off if we so much as sneeze.
Assumes a grab bag of facts not in evidence.

What do you say, are you finding God in the nose, in your nose as also in my nose?


Yrreg
No, just snot.
 
Assumption has two directions: one is into fiction and the other one is into action.

If you assume that horses were wishes then beggars would ride, that is an assumption into fiction.

It's nonsense, is what it is. You have the saying backwards, it should be, "If wishes were horses, then beggars would ride". In your case, "If assertions were facts, then God would exist".
 
Just as an experiment, try reading the below with the voice of Dr Sheldon Cooper.
...Well, Weak Kitten, we have come to our concurrence.

You will ask where do we go from here?

If you are a scientist you continue to search for knowledge of the whole created universe by observation and experimentation with the certainty that there is order and stability in the universe created by the uncreated God.

Now, I am into thinking about atheists, how they can be so blind and so self-blindered in their brain and heart: so I continue to wonder how they can be so blind and so self-blindered, and to continuously come to the conclusion that it is their peculiar psychology which is self-inured as to be so blind and so self-blindered as to choose to not be rational. ...


... with the two concepts concurred on then we can go forward on an expedition to search for God the uncreated creator of the universe in the universe which is the totality of created [by God] existence.

Where do you want to start in the universe to search for God?

You will tell me since I am the one concerned with searching God and you are just following me, then I will say let us start with ourselves.


But let me now go to what you say about assumption, at the same time as we are now into ourselves in the universe where we have our also created existence: to search for God.

You say:

But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.​


Assumption has two directions: one is into fiction and the other one is into action.

If you assume that horses were wishes then beggars would ride, that is an assumption into fiction.

Now the assumption that there is an uncreated creator of the universe, that is an assumption into action, to launch on an expedition to search for God.


Back to our expedition then to search for God starting, with your concurrence if I may, with our nose.

Do we find God in our nose?

Well, the assumption is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe which is the totality of the created by God universe: so we should find God in the nose, because the nose is a part of the universe, so it follows that God the uncreated creator of the created by Him universe must be there keeping it from falling off if we so much as sneeze.

What do you say, are you finding God in the nose, in your nose as also in my nose?...
 
Last edited:
You accept my concepts of universe as the totality of created [by God] existence and God as the uncreated creator of the universe, what is the point I am trying to make now that you concur with me on concepts?


No, Rougarou accepted ("for the sake of argument") that "if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator."

This does not mean that it is your God. It applies just as much to the Flying Spaghetti Monster, the Great Green Arkleseizure, or any of the wide variety of other creator gods that are available.

To go back to the original point of the thread, that is what is wrong with your definition.

And, of course, it brings us back to the question that you keep running away from in terror, because it reminds you that the only reason you believe in your God is that the society you live in has told you to:

How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?
 
Last edited:
You accept my concepts of universe as the totality of created [by God] existence and God as the uncreated creator of the universe, what is the point I am trying to make now that you concur with me on concepts?

Well, the point I am trying to make is that with the two concepts concurred on then we can go forward on an expedition to search for God the uncreated creator of the universe in the universe which is the totality of created [by God] existence.
Your concepts are only accepted for the sake of argument. This means that while people do not agree with your definitions or concepts, they will temporarily act as if they did agree, in order to move the conversation along. This thread now runs to 42 pages, and nobody is any further forward than they were in February 2009 when this thread started; hence people are willing to accept your concepts for the sake of argument so that we can see where you are going next.

Where do you want to start in the universe to search for God?
You are the one wanting to search for God, you tell us where you want to start.

You will tell me since I am the one concerned with searching God and you are just following me, then I will say let us start with ourselves.
Okay, we start with human beings.


But let me now go to what you say about assumption, at the same time as we are now into ourselves in the universe where we have our also created existence: to search for God.

You say:

But to answer your question about assumptions, I think that if someone says that something has been created, the assumption is that there must have been a creator.​


Assumption has two directions: one is into fiction and the other one is into action.
Really? How do you know which is fiction and which not?

If you assume that horses were wishes then beggars would ride, that is an assumption into fiction.
You have that wrong; it's "If wishes were horses, beggars would ride". As zooterkin points out, your proof of God follows this pattern exactly. "If yrreg's assumptions were true, God would exist."

Now the assumption that there is an uncreated creator of the universe, that is an assumption into action, to launch on an expedition to search for God.
No, it's just an assumption that an uncreated creator exists. It's just as likely to be true as wishes magically turning themselves into horses.

Back to our expedition then to search for God starting, with your concurrence if I may, with our nose.

Do we find God in our nose?

Well, the assumption is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe which is the totality of the created by God universe: so we should find God in the nose, because the nose is a part of the universe, so it follows that God the uncreated creator of the created by Him universe must be there keeping it from falling off if we so much as sneeze.

What do you say, are you finding God in the nose, in your nose as also in my nose?

No. The nose came about by a process of evolution by natural selection, God is unnecessary.

You are adding more assumptions on top of your previous ones, by stating that God is "in" every part of the universe that he created. Previously, the assumption was just that he created the universe. Now you are extending that to put God everywhere and in everything. Nobody has agreed with that assumption, nor are they likely to do so except for the sake of argument.

If God is in the nose, can a maxillofacial surgeon see God during an operation on a nose? Whereabouts does this God thing reside in the nose - is he in the nostrils? The nasal bone? Does he reside in the cells of the body? You want us to search for God but "in the nose" isn't specific enough for anyone to find him.
 
Last edited:
Yeah the "perfectly designed by an almighty God" human body has:

- A vestigial tale.
- Teeth that once allowed us to chew heavy fibrous plant material that now don't even come in all the way in many people.
- An organ in my digestive track (again once used to eat fibrous plants) that serves no purpose but might one day just decide to swell up with poison until explodes and kills me. So that's two things so far that allow me to eat plants I can't eat, one of which might kill me, the other of which caused me to have to undergo dental surgery to remove. Tan-tucking-fastic.
- Nipples that don't allow me to do anything because I'm a male.
- A blindspot on the back of my eye brought on by the fact that all the blood vessels are inside my eye and have to exit my eye socket. Oh and apparently God likes squids better because their eyes evolved differently and don't have that.
- Muscles that allow me to move my nearly non-movable ears. I guess God decided it was vitally important I be able to wiggle my earlobes. I guess the all mighty decided everyone needs a tell in Poker.
- Remanants of a third eyelid.
- A large (exact number unknown) percent of my DNA serving no function.
- A single pipeway for both my respiration and food consumption for no reason other then to give me the option to choke to death.
- Goosepumps that raise when I'm afraid to poof out the fur I don't have to scare away the predators I don't have.
- Vestigial parts of a completely separate but non-functioning sense of smell.

You know even if we had never found a single fossil ever, if animals just left no remains and poofed out of existence in a puff of smoke when they died even the most cursory examination of the human body should tell you this wasn't designed.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom