What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Dear Mojo, just let us talk about evidence for the existence of God, by firstly that we two come to concurrence on what is evidence, what is the target of evidence, and how evidence operates.
It's clear that you still have a basic misunderstanding of the meaning of the English word "evidence". If you have any evidence for God, why not simply present it instead of wasting time on redefining words which already have perfectly good and widely understood definitions?

You have a lot in your mind as to risk being scattered-brain, but to be systematic first let us talk about evidence, that is very important to you and all atheists who think that they have discovered evidence to be the death of God.
Is scattered-brain your latest insult?

Atheists do not think they have discovered evidence to be the death of God; it appears that despite years of patient (and not so patient) explanations from thousands of atheists on many different discussion boards, you still don't understand the meaning of the word atheist.

As English is not your first language, people are generally happy to explain and correct you when it becomes clear that you are using an English word incorrectly. However, it behooves you to accept these corrections from native English speakers, and use the words in their correct context thereafter.

For your reference:

Evidence is any fact which makes a proposition more or less true.

Atheists lack belief in any and all gods.

Now, if you have any evidence for the existence of God, please present it. For the avoidance of doubt, evidence would be any facts that would make the existence of God more true.

I do not understand why you spend so many pages copy-pasting the same irrelevancies and misunderstandings, when all you have to do to convert atheists into theists would be to enumerate a list of facts.
 
Don't send a post telling people to look up a later post coming next.

Just write the post when you have your thought already made up, and send it.
Sorry, I meant this:

In answer to your trichotomy

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?

None of the above. The universe began through a purely natural process. It was not created by some third party, it did not "create itself" (whatever that might mean) and it hasn't always been around. This is consistent with all the evidence that humans in their ingenuity have been able to gather.
 
Last edited:
You say the concept of God in the Christian faith is not valid, prove it.

But to be rational you have to first examine it, in order to prove it not valid.





Yrreg

Is this your best attempt at ineptly switching the burden of proof? Prove that The Flying Spaghetti Monster didn't create the universe and was destroyed in its making.
 
Take two, you say concept of God in Christian faith not valid, prove it.

But keep in mind that you must examine it in order to prove it not valid.



Yrreg

Take two. The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and was destroyed making it. Title your post in answer to this one "This post contains logic." only if you use logical arguments. Otherwise I'll know not to read your posts which are logical fallacies.
 
Okay, let that pass about Buddhism, and about my being a liberal Christian...


We are or I am interested to know what is your concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.

Please don't tell me that because don't accept the existence of God then you don't have to entertain any information about God.

Now, are you going to ask me why you must have information about God in order to not accept God's existence?

[ I give up. ]




Yrreg

Do you have the correct concept in your mind about The Flying Spaghetti Monsters? Don't pretend to not have the correct concept of The Flying Spaghetti Monster in mind. Go ahead, ask my why you must have the correct concept of The Flying Spaghetti Monster in order to accept The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence.
 
We, you and I, were going in that direction but you took back your words on facts.



Yrreg

Remember taking back your words about drinking? It has been pointed out to you many times with links to the posts where you were unable to choose which one you were... well, you know.

That was when you took your last voluntary vacation, when you didn't have an answer for why you... you know.

You remember, before you ran away the last time.
 
Last edited:
Make up any word, call it the answer to everything, and do brain surgery with all that vast knowledge you just made up.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
It would have looked rather different to the way it looks now, but it was the same universe.

I didn't say it wasn't the same universe. :) But I don't think you'd recognise it if you were there.

Your other point about whether it has 'always' existed is arguable either way; while I agree that talking about what came 'before' the singularity is like talking about what is north of the North Pole, it's also possible to say that if the universe had a beginning (the big bang), then from another viewpoint that means it has not always been in existence. (I think arthwollipot is taking a similar view when he says "it hasn't always been around.")
 
Anyone read the Discovery article I linked about the theory of the cyclical, always-existing universe? I know Yrreg has not and will not. Anyone else?
 
Irrelevant post, into ignorance again, so I will not bother with you.


Just the same, irrelevant analogy, the existence of the universe is not somebody having stolen something.


Try again, do another analogy.


At the same time, give serious attention to figure out what it is to explain something.




Yrreg

In other words, you haven't the slightest comprehension of what I was getting at. I wasn't offering an analogy for the existence of the universe, I was offering an analogy for your simple-minded assumption that one has to offer a specific gnostic claim about the nature of the universe in order to reject your claim. I was attempting to explain to you that it is better to admit that we can't yet know something than to make up an answer. The reason I used a simple analogy was because it is clear that you have difficulty understanding the concept of the null hypothesis. I tried to explain it to you as I would to a child, or an uneducated person who doesn't know enough to mix warm and cold water to get the desired temperature for drinking.
 
Dear Mojo, just let us talk about evidence for the existence of God, by firstly that we two come to concurrence on what is evidence, what is the target of evidence, and how evidence operates.


You have a lot in your mind as to risk being scattered-brain, but to be systematic first let us talk about evidence, that is very important to you and all atheists who think that they have discovered evidence to be the death of God.


You've already had (at least) two threads about the nature of evidence, both of which you bailed out of. This thread is about the merits of your definition of God.

Now, why should your definition of god be preferred to all the alternatives?
 
In other words, you haven't the slightest comprehension of what I was getting at. I wasn't offering an analogy for the existence of the universe, I was offering an analogy for your simple-minded assumption that one has to offer a specific gnostic claim about the nature of the universe in order to reject your claim. I was attempting to explain to you that it is better to admit that we can't yet know something than to make up an answer. The reason I used a simple analogy was because it is clear that you have difficulty understanding the concept of the null hypothesis. I tried to explain it to you as I would to a child, or an uneducated person who doesn't know enough to mix warm and cold water to get the desired temperature for drinking.


Worth noting, perhaps, that a crime being committed, and the conclusions that could be drawn from the available evidence, was an example that yrreg himself used in one of his threads about the nature of evidence. He didn't seem to get the idea that if there isn't enough evidence it may not be possible to reach a definitive conclusion there either.
 
You've already had (at least) two threads about the nature of evidence, both of which you bailed out of.

It's standard MO for Woo Slingers. Start topic, get argued into a corner, bail out, wait a few weeks, start exact same topic again completely ignoring everything you were told in the previous one.

DC Comics doesn't hit the reset button as often as Woo Slingers do.
 
Take two, you say concept of God in Christian faith not valid, prove it.
No. It's your delusion, you get to prove it's real. No god-botherer has managed this yet.


Irrelevant post, into ignorance again, so I will not bother with you.
Evasion noted.

I will prove it if you join me in the expedition to prove it.
Again, the onus is on you to prove you god exists.


Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?
Why are you limiting the options to these three?


My experience with atheists is that they will always run away from any expedition.
Why would any rational personal waste time with your "journey" when you haven't produced one jot of evidence for your god?


Now, you will say that history proves I have left this forum time and again.
Yes. You regularly flee when the questions become too much for you to handle.

I have not run away but left it in order to be busy with more productive undertakings.
:rolleyes:

Then I come back again and also now when I have the inspiration to put aside some time to see whether they are atheists here who are like Antony Flew, but so far it is the same people who are always into irrelevancies.
You mean people who keep asking you for evidence of your assertions?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom