What's The Harm?

The pond is very deep and full of plant debris and junk, they sent divers in but they could only go down so far. Also the body will have been decomposing for decades.-Jambo372

On the contrary, Jambo. It can't be both very deep and full of junk. It's full because it's fairly shallow. Most of the ponds in the area , of which Witchwood is by far the smallest, are remnants of periglacial kettleholes. None is more than thirty feet deep, most less than ten feet.

This pond could be dredged - indeed entirely removed- using easily available commercial pumps and a bulldozer, inside 48 hours.

And at 1.3km long, in a town about 3-5km across, Gartgill Road is one of the longest roads in Coatbridge, leading out of town into part wooded countryside - just the place to dump a body. It's hard to believe the police would overlook it if they were serious in driving the man around.

As for him not knowing the area., Jambo. There are such things as maps. (You'll find the pond on OS Landranger sheet 64, at Ref 723666. )
Link:- http://www.getamap.co.uk/getamap/
Click the Get A Map button, then type Coatbridge in the search box. The pond is near the top, above the word "Depot". (A container depot- it would not have existed in 1957)

Edit to fix the link.
 
Soapy Sam said:
The pond is very deep and full of plant debris and junk, they sent divers in but they could only go down so far. Also the body will have been decomposing for decades.-Jambo372

On the contrary, Jambo. It can't be both very deep and full of junk. It's full because it's fairly shallow. Most of the ponds in the area , of which Witchwood is by far the smallest, are remnants of periglacial kettleholes. None is more than thirty feet deep, most less than ten feet.

This pond could be dredged - indeed entirely removed- using easily available commercial pumps and a bulldozer, inside 48 hours.

And at 1.3km long, in a town about 3-5km across, Gartgill Road is one of the longest roads in Coatbridge, leading out of town into part wooded countryside - just the place to dump a body. It's hard to believe the police would overlook it if they were serious in driving the man around.

As for him not knowing the area., Jambo. There are such things as maps. (You'll find the pond on OS Landranger sheet 64, at Ref 723666. )
Link:- http://www.getamap.co.uk/getamap/
Click the Get A Map button, then type Coatbridge in the search box. The pond is near the top, above the word "Depot". (A container depot- it would not have existed in 1957)

Edit to fix the link.

There's a fly in your ointment.
You still haven't debunked him. Galogley confessed to dumping the body there after he, along with Alec Gartshore and an unidentified third party gave her chloroform, felt her up and strangled her to death.
 
jambo372 said:
There's a fly in your ointment.
You still haven't debunked him. Galogley confessed to dumping the body there after he, along with Alec Gartshore and an unidentified third party gave her chloroform, felt her up and strangled her to death.
Jambo, for the last time, the psychic has solved nothing. Anyone can guess at the location of the body in a murder investigation. Even if they guess right it proves nothing.

In this case we don't even know if they have guessed right as thy haven't found the body.
So the psychic has not solved the case or provided any evidence.
As per usual the case is going through a perfectly normal process of investigation, and suspect interrogation and confession.

And, irrelevant to anything an attention seeking 'psychic' buzzes away on the periphery adding no knowledge, evidence or useful information.

So you claim some psychics have helped solved murders. And we still ask, name one. Because you haven't yet.

And please respond on this other thread.
 
I knew Dennis Avery when he was alive.
He and his entire family are dead.
I do not consider this 'anecdotal' evidence.

The Kirtland Slayings

And maybe surprisingly, not a life changing event either.
This did not shock me into unbelief.

It bothered my parents more than me, they were close friends of the Avery's parents. Dad was the one who voiced aloud if our beliefs did not sow the seeds of this tragedy. 'Not monsters, but nurturers of monsters'.
 
jambo372 said:
Homeopathy/Alternative medicine isn't considered paranormal.


I beg to differ. Randi qualified homeopathy for The Million Dollar Challenge on Horizons. Read the transcript here.
 
Re: Double Standard?

Beth said:
I would like to point out that what you are collecting here is anecdotal evidence. That doesn't make it invalid, nor does it mean that no harm occurs, but I think it wise to consider the opposite side. If someone were to be collecting similar evidence regarding the benefits of the paranormal, how would you respond? Would you consider it equally valid? Or would you dismiss such evidence as unreliable and unconvincing?

I believe Beth has a valid point here, in a number of respects.

Firstly that this is a collection of anecdotal evidence in the sense that it is evidence which has not been collected as part of a controlled sceintific study (though it is not all evidence in the form of anecdotes.

Secondly, these examples in no way show that it is generally the case that paranormal beliefs are harmful.

As a means to answer questions of the form, "what harm could it do?" I think these examples have a purpose but let us not be careful not to think that they help us to win the argument that belief in the paranormal is generally or necessarily harmful.
 
Vikram said:
I don't know. Any lawyers here who could comment on the legal validity of such a claim?

It could be made, either as malpractice if the healer holds him/herself out as a professional or standard negligence if not. The alternative medicine crowd like to include disclaimers prospectively limiting their liability if/when the victim finds out the "cure" doesn't work, however. Lawyers generally cannot do it; I don't know how doctors view the practice (Thirdtwin, any info you can contribute?). If a liberal judge is hearing the case, one could use unconscionability to get around that.
 
Hastur said:
It could be made, either as malpractice if the healer holds him/herself out as a professional or standard negligence if not. The alternative medicine crowd like to include disclaimers prospectively limiting their liability if/when the victim finds out the "cure" doesn't work, however. Lawyers generally cannot do it; I don't know how doctors view the practice (Thirdtwin, any info you can contribute?). If a liberal judge is hearing the case, one could use unconscionability to get around that.

I am not a lawyer. It occurs to me however that in order for the alternative medicine practicioner to be found guilty of mdeical malpractice we would have to allow that what they are practicing is actually medicine (quite distinct from alternative medicine). There may be an inherent paradox of the form "if it works it's medicine and you can sue for malpractice, if it doesn't it it's not and you can't".

In England, a disclaimer would be irrelevant if the way in which the service is offered and advertised makes it clear that it is claimed to work (and if there is no such claim, what exactly is the service being offered?) Given this, if it could be shown that as of a matter of course an alternative medicine practice does not work and a reasonable person given access to the information the practitioner has would conclude this then the practitioner could be sued for obtaining money by deception, fraud, false advertising etc.
 
Throg said:
I am not a lawyer. It occurs to me however that in order for the alternative medicine practicioner to be found guilty of mdeical malpractice we would have to allow that what they are practicing is actually medicine (quite distinct from alternative medicine). There may be an inherent paradox of the form "if it works it's medicine and you can sue for malpractice, if it doesn't it it's not and you can't".

In England, a disclaimer would be irrelevant if the way in which the service is offered and advertised makes it clear that it is claimed to work (and if there is no such claim, what exactly is the service being offered?) Given this, if it could be shown that as of a matter of course an alternative medicine practice does not work and a reasonable person given access to the information the practitioner has would conclude this then the practitioner could be sued for obtaining money by deception, fraud, false advertising etc.

Thay may very well be in England, I'm talking about US law. In regards to malpractice, I said if the AMP held him/herself out as a professional (i.e. claiming to have medical education), then maybe a plaintiff can sustain a malpractice claim. If the healer wants to be so stupid as to claim to be a doctor, s/he can be treated like one when s/he screws up. And if the judge won't allow it, there is bog standard negligence for any actual harm incurred, and yes, there could also be claims of fraud and false advertising.
 
Re: Re: Double Standard?

Throg said:
I believe Beth has a valid point here, in a number of respects.

Firstly that this is a collection of anecdotal evidence in the sense that it is evidence which has not been collected as part of a controlled sceintific study (though it is not all evidence in the form of anecdotes.

Secondly, these examples in no way show that it is generally the case that paranormal beliefs are harmful.

As a means to answer questions of the form, "what harm could it do?" I think these examples have a purpose but let us not be careful not to think that they help us to win the argument that belief in the paranormal is generally or necessarily harmful.

I can live with that. :)

Swallowing a hundred homeopathic pills all at once is probably harmless. But taking homeopathic pills in place of seeking real medical treatment for a treatable disease is harmful.

But my saying it is harmful to forego real medicine in favor of homeopathy is just an intellectual exercise. So what I am looking for are actual illustrations of the harm paranormal beliefs have wrought.

Taking homeopathic pills as a preventative medication probably does no harm. Watching John Edward talk to someone's dead grandma probably does no harm most of the time. One could argue these things plant seeds which could later blossom into harmful behavior.

The most harm paranormal beliefs cause is to the wallet and to the mind, in my opinion.
 
My original post on this subject is long gone, disappearing in one of the forum database crashes of yore, but...

In the book Alive : The Story of the Andes Survivors , author Paul Piers Read relates how several of the families of those missing spent their own money to hire airplanes to continue the search long after the official search had concluded. Upon the advice of a 'psychic,' they concentrated their search in an area hundreds of miles from where the plane had actually crashed.

For those who have not read the book or seen the movie, out of the 45 original passengers and crew, only 16 made it off the mountain alive.

So to the question 'What's the harm?', in this case the answer would be starvation, cannibalism, and death.
 
What's the harm with homeopathy?

Reader Gard Simons in The Netherlands, writes:

We too, in the Netherlands, cannot escape the frauds. I would like to bring to your attention a particularly annoying person, Joke Damman, who goes under the name of "Jomanda." She's a "healer." She conducts so-called healings which draw large crowds of sick and impaired people.

Recently she made a huge mistake. A well-known Dutch television personality, Sylvia Millecam, was diagnosed with breast cancer. Ms. Millecam, not being overly intelligent, wanted to have nothing to do with regular doctors. The tumor was relatively small and very well treatable with a large chance of success, as is common in the treating of "mammacarcinome," today. Ms. Millecam, however, turned to the "alternative circuit."

I quote from the report of the Dutch Healthcare Inspector:

Important in this is, that from the ranks of the alternative community, the diagnosis of breast cancer was contraindicated, and the patient was told she could be cured with unproven methods of treatment.
http://www.randi.org/jr/042205modern.html
 
How about people being refused jobs after the interference of a psychic, tarot reader or numerologist in their interview procedure:

Psychics in recruitment

Once a psychic deludes themselves far enough they may often feel there is nothing they can't pass judgement on, including deciding whether random strangers have secret drug problems, criminal records, psychological problems etc.
And denying them jobs as a result.
 
Here's a recent news story illustrating the consequences of people not undergoing effective treatment for infectious diseases:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4528543.stm

OK, there's no evidence that this particular patient was coming off his treatment because he was using CAM, but it illustrates that there can be consequences for people other than the patient if effective treatment is not sought.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom