What's The Harm?

Re: Double Standard?

I'm not claiming that anecdotes are not evidence.

OK.

I'm saying that if you don't accept anecdotal evidence for one side of an argument

And there's where you're twisting things again. I think you realize perfectly well that what is being collected here is not "anecdotes as evidence for one side of an argument". But perhaps you don't.

What is being collected here is evidence about PARTICULAR pychics causing harm in PARTICULAR cases. The question of "are all psychics full of baloney" is not being addressed here, and we are not collecting anecdotes as evidence to test that hypothesis. If we were attempting to bolster that claim, you would be correct that this set of case histories was anecdotal evidence.

But you are wrong to imply that there is a double standard in collecting stories as evidence of harm by INDIVIDUALS, since as I pointed out exactly the same procedure is used to collect evidence of harm by INDIVIDUALS when what is being investigated is murder, conventional fraud, or medical malpractice.

So there is no point to be made about "why are you guys accepting anecdotes as evidence when you don't..." since exactly the same standard of evidence applies here as in those other cases.

But they would not be evidence that belief in standard hospital practices was dangerous. That seems to me more analogous to the situation here.

Yes, it is. In which case nobody would argue that videotapes and personal testimony were "anecdotal" evidence that was invalid.

So again, since we'd accept such evidence against hospitals for exactly the same purpose, your claim that we are applying a standard to psychics that we wouldn't apply to hospitals is wrong, wrong, wrongity-wrong.

Agreed?
 
Vikram
In my opinion, the best thing in the world would be for alternative medicine to be exposed to the same kind of litigative stress as scientific medicine. That seems like the only way to force it to put up or shut up. When that happens, either there'll be flurries of wondrous and astonishing studies and publications, proving that crystal therapy and reiki and energy auras were real after all. Or quacks will be forced to draw the shutters once and for all. Forgive me for taking a wild guess - I think it'll be the latter.
Any ideas on how this could be brought about? I’m not volunteering to go do something stupid, but if a homeopathic expert were to ‘prescribe’ a course of action to cure a mild ailment and it failed – in comparison to one prescribed by a physician, time limit, severity, etcetera – would that be a strong enough basis to start a legal action?

Ossai
 
Re: Re: Double Standard?

rppa said:
And there's where you're twisting things again. I think you realize perfectly well that what is being collected here is not "anecdotes as evidence for one side of an argument". But perhaps you don't.
Actually, I think there is something to this point. What do you think this thread will be used for? I predict;) that skeptics will take this list of particular instances where woo-ism caused great harm and use it to argue against believers. This would really be somewhat of a double-standard.
The only way I see it being valid to use this in an argument would be to say
"Hey, that's a nice story about the psychic who found a body in a pond. Unfortunately, it isn't true and here's why. Also, here's another kind of anecdote, only this one is supported by numerous verifiable facts and it shows how much damage psychics can do."

Basically, I think this list could be really useful for discussions with believers but it has the potential to be used instead of real evidence - which would be a double-standard.
 
Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Harlequin said:
Basically, I think this list could be really useful for discussions with believers but it has the potential to be used instead of real evidence - which would be a double-standard.
I'm just not getting this. A lot of these stories are verifiable fact.

If believers had stories with as much checkable fact as many on this thread then they would be in a much stronger position to argue for the existence of paranormal abilities.

We argue that anecdotal evidence from believers is useless as we have no way of checking it. Most of the stories on this thread can be checked and verified.

These stoies absolutely can be used as evidence to show the harm that has arisen as a result of certain paranormal beliefs.

Believers are welcome to challenge the facts if they doubt any of the stories.

Sceptics often contact newspapers, reporters, official organisations etc, to find out the truth behind stories.
Believers tend not to (almost by definition). We actually wish they would do it more.
 
Ossai said:
Any ideas on how this could be brought about? I’m not volunteering to go do something stupid, but if a homeopathic expert were to ‘prescribe’ a course of action to cure a mild ailment and it failed – in comparison to one prescribed by a physician, time limit, severity, etcetera – would that be a strong enough basis to start a legal action?

I don't know. Any lawyers here who could comment on the legal validity of such a claim?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Ashles said:
Sceptics often contact newspapers, reporters, official organisations etc, to find out the truth behind stories.
That's what I was thinking about, too. Then I realized that with all our discussions of bias in the media, it seems likely that you can pull out newspaper stories, reporters, official organisations, etc. that will confirm all kinds of woo-ist beliefs.

Look at all the insurance companies that cover homeopathy! Why would they do that if it doesn't work? I've read lots of articles in several reputable newspapers about how well homeopathics help you get over a cold faster. There are even sientifik studies (not scientific, but close :D ).

How is our "evidence" better than theirs? Obviously, ours is right and theirs isn't, but this is not always easy to prove. If you don't really understand how to properly set up an experiment, you'll never understand why one experiment is "more valid" than another one.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Harlequin said:
That's what I was thinking about, too. Then I realized that with all our discussions of bias in the media, it seems likely that you can pull out newspaper stories, reporters, official organisations, etc. that will confirm all kinds of woo-ist beliefs.
But could you? That there are beliefs aren't in doubt, and those beliefs are widely reported. But how many examples can you provide of the media actually saying some paranormal ability has actually happened?
It doesn't seem like it but the media is surprisingly careful about not looking too stupid and reporting something as fact that may well turn out to be a hoax, fraud, mistake etc.
They couch these stories in opinions and claims.

Look at all the insurance companies that cover homeopathy! Why would they do that if it doesn't work? I've read lots of articles in several reputable newspapers about how well homeopathics help you get over a cold faster. There are even sientifik studies (not scientific, but close :D ).
But in those cases we can provide scientific evidence (reams of it) that directly contradicts those claims.
It should become obvious to anyone without a vested interest what the mvast majority of evidence nidicates.
And if someone is going to take an insurance company's attitude towards something as scientific evidence then there is no way you ever going to convince them otherwise.
Insurance companie refer to "acts of God" - is this to be taken as proof that God must exist?
This thread will not provide any guidance to people who would take such things as evidence.

How is our "evidence" better than theirs? Obviously, ours is right and theirs isn't, but this is not always easy to prove. If you don't really understand how to properly set up an experiment, you'll never understand why one experiment is "more valid" than another one.
I would hope we can describe the relative merits of scientific experiments.
But some people aren't going to accept contrary evidence at all. There's nothing you can do to convince those people and there is no point in trying.

But I notice that there hasn't been any actual criticism of any of the specific posts on this thread. Just a generalised vague generic claim that it must be wrong somehow.

If anyone has issues with any of the stories I wish they would deal with them on an individual basis (as the sceptics have done on these forums over and over again) rather than just dismissing them all equally for no good reason.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Ashles said:
These stoies absolutely can be used as evidence to show the harm that has arisen as a result of certain paranormal beliefs.

I don't doubt the veracity of the stories reported here, at least no more so than I would for any other similar story. The problem is in accepting these stories as evidence of harm due to belief in paranormal stuff. They are the same quality of evidence as verifiable stories of someone healed by John of God or cured by a homeopathic medicine.

If you don't accept such stories as evidence for the benefits of belief, discounting them as due to other causes such as placebo effect or spontaneous remission, then how can you accept the stories here as evidence of harm rather than discounting them as being due to other causes as well?

You can accept such anecdotes as evidence if you like - they do constitute evidence of a sort - but I don't think you can accept them for one side but not the other without applying a double standard to what evidence you consider valid.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
I don't doubt the veracity of the stories reported here, at least no more so than I would for any other similar story. The problem is in accepting these stories as evidence of harm due to belief in paranormal stuff. They are the same quality of evidence as verifiable stories of someone healed by John of God or cured by a homeopathic medicine.
They are absolutely not. But this has been explained to you in this thread Beth and you are choosing to ignore the difference. You are actually clearly obviously playing stupid.
'Other causes'? You really are clutching at straws now.

But if you don't doubt the veracity of any of the stories then there isn't a problem, is there.

You are arguing against the validity of stories whose validity you don't doubt. Strange behaviour. I wonder why that would be?

It is not a double standard and you know this full well.

You are providing a perfect example of someone who claims to understand the potential problems with these claims, then wants to try to totally hide or ignore them when they happen.
You are almost endorsing the cases we have outlined here.
As a result I find your additions to the thread actually quite useful as an illustration of how defensive people get when their fantasy belief systems are questioned.

It's one of the reasons these beliefs end up getting propogated so much. Believers' pretense that it is all good and never bad.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Ashles said:
I'm just not getting this. A lot of these stories are verifiable fact.
I guess the problem is that this is exactly the same thing as the believers say about paranormal events. Obviously their wrong, but I think it is still a useful caveat to say be careful how you use this list, as you could come across similar to this:
"How can you argue with this, it's a fact, Sylvia already passed the JREF test, but Randi refused to pay. Look here are six kooky websites that back me up. Randi is just playing dumb when he denies it."
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
If you don't accept such stories as evidence for the benefits of belief, discounting them as due to other causes such as placebo effect or spontaneous remission, then how can you accept the stories here as evidence of harm rather than discounting them as being due to other causes as well?
Please suggest the causes for the death by suffocation of Candace Newmaker other than her prolonged suffocation at the hands of woowoos. Please suggest other causes for the starvation of the Xhosa other than that they destroyed their herds and crops at the behest of a woowoo. Would you like to explain it through "the placebo effect", or "spontaneous remission"?

Or what "other causes" did you have in mind?

Personally, I only offer "other causes" for any suggested phenomenon when I can think of "other causes" which I know to exist and be operative in that area. For example, the placebo effect and remission, not to mention regression, apply to the field of medicine, which is why in medicine we always require proof which exludes such possibilities as the source of encouraging data.

Knock yourself out. Was Candace Newmaker killed by hours of torture, or by being given a placebo? Or perhaps, through a "spontaneous remission" of life, she was going to suffocate at that precise moment anyway, and it's just coincidence that at the moment she died of suffocation she just happened to be being tortured by suffocation. Are these the "other causes" you had in mind?

I don't think the defense counsel offered up anything so flimsy to defend the torturers, but do you want to have a go? Maybe they're innocent after all... condemned by unwillingness to consider the possibility that Candace Newmaker died of "the placebo effect". I'd be interested to hear your arguments.

(Oh, and please suggest causes for the deaths of the people in the R101 disaster other than that it crashed. Placebo? Spontaneous remission?)

Feel free.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
I don't doubt the veracity of the stories reported here, at least no more so than I would for any other similar story. The problem is in accepting these stories as evidence of harm due to belief in paranormal stuff. They are the same quality of evidence as verifiable stories of someone healed by John of God or cured by a homeopathic medicine.

If you don't accept such stories as evidence for the benefits of belief, discounting them as due to other causes such as placebo effect or spontaneous remission, then how can you accept the stories here as evidence of harm rather than discounting them as being due to other causes as well?

You can accept such anecdotes as evidence if you like - they do constitute evidence of a sort - but I don't think you can accept them for one side but not the other without applying a double standard to what evidence you consider valid.
You still seem to be missing the point. Look again at the thread title. These references and citations (they are not anecdotes) are not intended to be part of a body of evidence or proof of a claim, they are a series of refutations of the common believers' claim that "even if [insert favorite pseudoscience/paranormal concept] doesn't really do anything, what's the harm in it?" Believers often say that when backed into a corner about whether their pet concept is real or not. They claim that there is no harm in practicing homeopathy or folk remedies even if it has no real effect, without considering the consequences of people refusing proper medical treatment (in the case of homeopathy) or young boys having their genitals brutally torn off and then left to die in an attempt to make (or more likely) sell a worthless folk remedy. They claim that there is no harm in what so-called mediums and psychics do even if they aren't real, without considering the grief and suffering caused to parents of missing children or the wasted time of legitimate law enforcement investigators. These examples show that they are wrong. They are not evidence to support some claim that skeptics are making. They debunk the false notion that "there is no harm" in bizarre practices and rituals or pseudoscienfic procedures.

If you don't know the difference between an anecdote and a description of a factual event, look at that article about the dog-twisting ritual in the Bulgarian village. Those villagers will say "When we do this, it brings us luck. Last year, after the dog-twisting, my butter churn worked much better than before," or whatever. That's an anecdote, and its worthlessness should be painfully obvious. On the other hand, what's taking place in that village is real. Look at the disturbing photographs. What we are saying with this example is that animals are indeed being harmed for the purpose of a misguided folk ritual. That is a fact, a datum, not an anecdote.

And please learn the difference between a tried and tested useful medical procedure or drug that carries a certain level of risk, and irrational chicanery that can have only harmfull effects if any at all. The two are not the same.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Harlequin said:
That's what I was thinking about, too. Then I realized that with all our discussions of bias in the media, it seems likely that you can pull out newspaper stories, reporters, official organisations, etc. that will confirm all kinds of woo-ist beliefs.

Look at all the insurance companies that cover homeopathy! Why would they do that if it doesn't work?
You're not going to start going on about 100,000 doctors can't wrong are you? The answer wrt why insurance companies (and the UK's national health) cover alternative remedies, is, of course, money.

If popular demand is "proof" of homeopathy's efficacy, then why is it that McDonalds "restaurants" don't have any Michelin stars?
 
Yet another parent tells of the pain that psychics delivered.

The following passage is a quotation from John Tate, whose daughter Genette disappeared 25 years ago and has never been found. It says all that has to be said about these fraudsters who exploit grief.
...

"Many people came to us offering threads of hope. We clutched at them desperately in the early days … But the promises of the psychics were all lies. They raised false hopes in us. At times we really believed we were onto something. The suggestions and ideas preyed on our minds … But always, when it came to the crunch, the so-called leads and ideas led absolutely nowhere but into a pit of despair ...

We soon found that the psychics who came up our garden path were ‘foot-in-the-door’ types who, once they had wormed their way in, were very reluctant to leave again. They were strong characters who were not afraid to assert themselves. They rode rough-shod over our feelings – which were in a desperate state already. In one week, our emotions and normal grip on life had gone through a wrenching upheaval, and the influence of psychics started to have an unpleasant effect. Even when we didn’t want them they were there, on our doorstep, always expecting to be met with an open door ...

We discovered that the work of the psychics was not just ludicrous and laughable. It was sinister and evil. Once we got into that web of deceit – and that is what it was – we found it very hard to struggle free. None of it ever led anywhere except to despair and disappointment, misery and confusion. We had become enslaved to the suggestions of the psychics."
 
Yet another Biblical Interpretation claims a victim

A MOTHER-of-five in an extreme Christian fundamentalist movement is dead and her newborn baby is in hospital after she refused medical treatment. The 31-year-old woman was following Born in Zion principles that destiny should be controlled by God alone when she refused help at the unassisted home birth of her fifth child five weeks ago. She died three weeks later. ... The Coroner has not handed down a finding on the woman's death but has told a member of the family that the woman would have been in excruciating pain for the three weeks after the birth when she refused medical attention. It is understood her body was disfigured as a result of the medical complications.

The Born in Zion principles are preached by Carol Balizet, the American founder of the Home of Zion Ministries in Tampa, Florida. The dead woman's mother said her daughter had appeared seriously ill straight after the birth. ... "I asked (her daughter) what would happen if she died and she said it would be God's will and she was adamant," the woman's mother said.
...
Before she became pregnant with the couple's fourth child, which was born at home without complications, she began to investigate the teachings of Ms Balizet. Ms Balizet has interpreted the Bible to mean that humans should not interfere with the will of God. ... Her teachings have been linked to a sect in Attleboro, Massachusetts, which is under criminal investigation into the deaths of two sect children. Ms Balizet made two trips to Perth and the woman met her on both occasions. Soon after learning about the Zion movement, the woman decided to turn her back on medical treatment.
I guess god just wasn't quite clear enough... (and Carol Balizet is quite a story on her own... more on that in a moment).
 
Another Infant pays the ulimate "harm" for their parent's beliefs. (Carol Balizet continues to spread the 'good word')

When the infant son of an obscure cult died after being denied solid food for almost two months, the father said he believed he was following God's will.

But prosecutors called it murder.

Prosecutors say that Jacques Robidoux intentionally starved his son to fulfill a religious vision that his sister said she had regarding the baby's diet.

The defendant's sister, Michelle Mingo instructed Robidoux's wife Karen to drink only almond milk in order to eliminate vanity — and told her that she should only feed the child breast milk.

For 52 days, Jacques and Karen adhered to the regimen — only to find baby Samuel dead on April 26, 1999, just three days before he reached his first birthday.
...
Eventually, Roland came across a book, "Born in Zion," that was written by Carol Balizet, a former nurse who became a spiritual midwife. She urged a complete withdrawal from society because it was dominated by what she termed "Satan's seven counterfeit systems" — education, medicine, commerce, banking, entertainment, schools, and government. Balizet proposed living life according to God's directions, to obey God without objections or concerns with the outcome.

The book also says that women should shy away from the established medical system when giving birth.
 
Ashles said:
So the body hasn't been found, the case hasn't been solved, no-one has been prosecuted and a psychic has come up with the old "body of water" prediction.

And that's the best you can do is it Jambo?

Thanks for providing another example of the harm mediums can do.

And I remember your original thread - all the claims were thoroughly disposed of.

Finding the body is irrelevant to this - Galogley CONFESSED to sexually abusing and strangling her and claimed Alec Gartshore ( another well known pervert ) assisted him. He said they had dumped her remains in the tarry burn (Witchwood Pond), exactly where the psychic said it would have been. A thorough search of the pond would be impossible ( I should know, I only live round the corner from it ). It has all the junk and gunk of the day dumped in it - rats, toxic waste, furniture and plant debris.

William didn't simply predict the body was near a body of water. The police drove him around the whole of Coatbridge in a car ( he is not at all accustomed to the area ), the police nearly passed by a street ( Gartgill Road ), William stopped them and told them to drive along it, at the other end of the isolated street was the pond, he told them to stop, her body was in the pond, he vomited and said he felt a STRANGLING sensation.

He didn't just say a 'random body of water' - he directed them straight to the place ( in an area he had never set foot in before ).

Even if he didn't help solve the Moira case ( and he did give evidence later confirmed by Galogley's deathbed confession ), he has still done no harm.
 
Some of the details of what Miss Cleo was up to

Subcontractors, referred to as "bookstores" by insiders, recruit, train and manage thousands of psychics who handle the calls spurred by Miss Cleo's commercials.
...
Each psychic reader is paid by the subcontractor on a call-by-call basis
...
As the South Florida psychic reader who has worked with Feder since 1996 told Courttv.com, calls are distributed according to a priority system (explained more here), a high-pressure tactic that sends customers to the psychic with the highest average.
...
According to the Florida psychic, the pressure placed on psychic readers is passed on to the customer. "Most psychics don't even look at the cards," he says. "With so much pressure to keep people on the line and get their information, you need to tell the customer a lot of ********. But you can hurt people. You can hurt people very very deeply."

Still, the psychic admits to manipulating customers into staying on the phone. One effective way to keep callers on the line, he says, is to reveal a tidbit that piques their curiosity. One failsafe topic: Tell them their loved one is cheating.

"If you say there is cheating, there are a ton of questions they will want to ask," the psychic said
Do you think that accusing spouses of infidelity simply to keep the caller on line might cause some harm to the relationship???
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom