Re: Double Standard?
I'm not claiming that anecdotes are not evidence.
OK.
I'm saying that if you don't accept anecdotal evidence for one side of an argument
And there's where you're twisting things again. I think you realize perfectly well that what is being collected here is not "anecdotes as evidence for one side of an argument". But perhaps you don't.
What is being collected here is evidence about PARTICULAR pychics causing harm in PARTICULAR cases. The question of "are all psychics full of baloney" is not being addressed here, and we are not collecting anecdotes as evidence to test that hypothesis. If we were attempting to bolster that claim, you would be correct that this set of case histories was anecdotal evidence.
But you are wrong to imply that there is a double standard in collecting stories as evidence of harm by INDIVIDUALS, since as I pointed out exactly the same procedure is used to collect evidence of harm by INDIVIDUALS when what is being investigated is murder, conventional fraud, or medical malpractice.
So there is no point to be made about "why are you guys accepting anecdotes as evidence when you don't..." since exactly the same standard of evidence applies here as in those other cases.
But they would not be evidence that belief in standard hospital practices was dangerous. That seems to me more analogous to the situation here.
Yes, it is. In which case nobody would argue that videotapes and personal testimony were "anecdotal" evidence that was invalid.
So again, since we'd accept such evidence against hospitals for exactly the same purpose, your claim that we are applying a standard to psychics that we wouldn't apply to hospitals is wrong, wrong, wrongity-wrong.
Agreed?
I'm not claiming that anecdotes are not evidence.
OK.
I'm saying that if you don't accept anecdotal evidence for one side of an argument
And there's where you're twisting things again. I think you realize perfectly well that what is being collected here is not "anecdotes as evidence for one side of an argument". But perhaps you don't.
What is being collected here is evidence about PARTICULAR pychics causing harm in PARTICULAR cases. The question of "are all psychics full of baloney" is not being addressed here, and we are not collecting anecdotes as evidence to test that hypothesis. If we were attempting to bolster that claim, you would be correct that this set of case histories was anecdotal evidence.
But you are wrong to imply that there is a double standard in collecting stories as evidence of harm by INDIVIDUALS, since as I pointed out exactly the same procedure is used to collect evidence of harm by INDIVIDUALS when what is being investigated is murder, conventional fraud, or medical malpractice.
So there is no point to be made about "why are you guys accepting anecdotes as evidence when you don't..." since exactly the same standard of evidence applies here as in those other cases.
But they would not be evidence that belief in standard hospital practices was dangerous. That seems to me more analogous to the situation here.
Yes, it is. In which case nobody would argue that videotapes and personal testimony were "anecdotal" evidence that was invalid.
So again, since we'd accept such evidence against hospitals for exactly the same purpose, your claim that we are applying a standard to psychics that we wouldn't apply to hospitals is wrong, wrong, wrongity-wrong.
Agreed?