What's The Harm?

Luke T.

Unregistered
Joined
May 2, 2003
Messages
14,716
I think it would be a good idea to archive here in this topic some clearcut examples of when belief in the paranormal actually causes harm. Over time, I think we can build a substantial case file so when someone suggests psychics and other paranormal beliefs are harmless, we can direct them here.

Please provide links to news items and such. And since these news items may not remain on their host sites forever, quotes from the salient parts of the articles.

Brevity is the key. Let the items speak for themselves.

I'll start with an example that was provided by Lavie Enrose in Community and Da Chew here in General Skepticism and the Paranormal:

http://www.ananova.com/news/story/sm_1285693.html?menu=news.quirkies

Clairvoyant 'sacked' workers

A supermarket chain in Hungary has fired dozens of shop assistants for stealing - on the evidence of a clairvoyant.

According to a report by the Hungarian Trades Union Federation, managers at Penny Market took the personnel files of employees to the clairvoyant and fired more than two dozen she identified as thieves.
 
I think psychics who meddle with Police investigations are incredible harmful. Not only to the deperate and vulnerable relatives, but to the actual police investigation.

There are many examples of this but I'll first offer up Dennis McKenzie as a 'psychic' who likes to get involved in high profile cases.

Dennis McKenzie involving himself in the hunt for a Killer in Wichita

He tried to solve a really unpleasant widely reported series of murders over in Wichita.
Haven't heard a peep since.
A short follow up thread about Dennis

There are also links on that page to anotgher case where Dennis tried to solve the case where a six year old boy named Elliott Forde was hit and killed by a hit-and-run driver.
Dennis involved himself in the case and actually said he 'saw' a vehicle that was different from the one described by an eyewitness.

That case also remains unsolved.

But what damage might his interference have done to the case? And what did he put the parents through? False hope, then... failure.
These people should be prosecutable for wasting police time.
 
A queensland boy has been missing since December 2003. The TV program "Australian Story" ran this interview with the parents on Monday April 19, 2004 : Into Thin Air

DENISE MORCOMBE – DANIEL’S MOTHER: The last few weeks, I've received a few letters from psychics. Some of them have been very distressing. They say that Daniel may be in a local barn in the area close by, or in a country town. I've had one letter saying that Daniel's head's been shaved and he hasn't got many days left. Bruce tells me to put them aside and don't look at them, but they do go through my mind, what if it is true?
 
And another similar story : He Who Waits

DON SPIERS (Father of murdered girl): Our situation's a little bit different to the Glennons' and the Rimmers', because their two girls have been found. We still haven't had either of the questions answered as to where Sarah is and what's actually happened to her. Another big problem that we've had has been clairvoyants. They have been a huge torment to myself and my family in giving cryptic clues as to where Sarah might be. I remember one night in the early days I was down Salter Point, you know, thrashing around the swampy areas down there at 11 o'clock at night. Um...probably walking around bawling my eyes out and getting nowhere. I mean, a lot of times I've known I shouldn't have listened, but I've always thought that maybe they're using that excuse of being a clairvoyant to give me some honest facts.
 
A dead Infant from homeopathy
(link requires registration)

Isabella Denley, 13 months, died at her home in Kew on October 19 last year.
...
The inquest heard that Isabella was diagnosed with epilepsy by Mark Mackay, a neurologist with the Royal Children's Hospital and was prescribed anti-convulsant medication. But Mr and Mrs Denley refused to treat their daughter with the drugs, citing harsh side-effects such as sleep loss and hyperactivity.
...
In his police statement tendered to the court, Mr Denley, an information technology contractor, said Isabella was "purely" on homeopathic medicine in the weeks before her death. "This was the happiest and healthiest she had been since the seizures had started," Mr Denley said.
...
Bruce McTaggart, for the Royal Children's Hospital, said the evidence of Dr Mackay and another doctor, Richard Leventer, had given Mr Byrne "irresistible" evidence that Isabella died from an epileptic seizure.
 
A dead 10 year old girl after failed "rebirthing"

Some extracts from a video of the "rebirthing" procedure that lead to her death :

17:07 -- (Labored breathing) Get off. I'm sick. Get off. Where am I supposed to come out? Where? But how can I get there?

Watkins: Just go ahead and die. It's easier . . .It takes a lot of courage to be born.

18:26 -- You said you would give me oxygen.

Watkins: You gotta fight for it.

19:50 -- (Candace vomits) OK, I'm throwing up. I just threw up. (Vomiting) I gotta poop. I gotta poop.

21:24 -- Uh, I'm going in my pants.

Ponder: Go ahead.

Watkins: Stay in there with the poop and vomit.

23:22 -- Help! I can't breathe. I can't breathe. It's hot. I can't breathe.
...
32:25 -- 33:44 -- Jack McDaniel repositions himself on a pillow over Candace's head.

Ponder: Candace? (No response) (Takes another pillow from Newmaker.) She needs more pressure over here so she can't. . .so she really needs to fight.

Watkins: Getting pretty tight in here.

Ponder: Yep. . .less and less air all the time.

35:39-40:00 -- Ponder and McDaniel reposition themselves again.

Ponder: She gets to be stuck in her own puke and poop.

Watkins: Uh huh. It's her own life. Quitter.

40:01: No. (This is Candace's last word.)

Ponder: Quitter, quitter, quitter, quitter, quit, quit, quit, quit. She's a quitter.

(Watkins leaves, Newmaker leaves. McDaniel takes Watkins' place. Watkins returns.)

McDaniel: This baby doesn't want to live. She's a quitter.

(Watkins tells McDaniel and St. Clair to take a break.)

(Ponder and Watkins discuss someone who is stressed, then chitchat about their dream homes and a million-dollar property nearby that is being remodeled.)

Watkins: Let's talk to the twerp.

(They unwrap Candace.)

01:09:53 - Watkins: Oh, there she is sleeping in her vomit.
 
Double Standard?

I would like to point out that what you are collecting here is anecdotal evidence. That doesn't make it invalid, nor does it mean that no harm occurs, but I think it wise to consider the opposite side. If someone were to be collecting similar evidence regarding the benefits of the paranormal, how would you respond? Would you consider it equally valid? Or would you dismiss such evidence as unreliable and unconvincing?
 
Beth, I can assure you that Dennis McKenzie's behaviour is not anecdotal - the links and facts are fully checkable.

And psychics repeated involvement in police cases and the way they are reported in the media is exactly the problem I am complaining about.

Also you have to remember that anecdotal evidence of paranormal abilities is highly suspect as the abilities have never been shown to actually exist.

Whereas sadly, fraud, stupidity, deception, misperception, ignorance, stubbornness, dogmatism, vulnerability and delusion are fairly certainly known to exist.

But if you can cast doubts on any of these stories please go ahead and do so. But please do it it a different thread and link there so as not to clog up the purpose of this thread.

Many paranormal beliefs ARE actually harmful, and we would like to be able to create a list of examples of such instances without having believers try to muddy the waters.

Most people, believers included (I would have thought) ought to be quite positive about a thread such as this as a useful warning about the potential dangers of these beliefs.
Edited for clarity
 
Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
I would like to point out that what you are collecting here is anecdotal evidence. That doesn't make it invalid, nor does it mean that no harm occurs, but I think it wise to consider the opposite side. If someone were to be collecting similar evidence regarding the benefits of the paranormal, how would you respond? Would you consider it equally valid? Or would you dismiss such evidence as unreliable and unconvincing?

May I ask what evidence would you require to show that there are instances of fraud in the paranormal?

Insofar as first-hand evidence for the benefits of the paranormal, I can give you two. Both involved psychics here in Brooklyn. I asked them both about my only sister, whom I haven't heard from in years. They assured me that she's fine and living a normal, healthy life.

Not bad, except that she died five years before I was born, when she was six months old, of pneumonia. Now I admit I asked this question to both of them as a control, knowing full well that she died. I figured if they could accurately see that she died in 1960, then we have a winner. Neither of them did. Now if I were someone who accepted what the psychics had told me and didn't know that she died, how would that be beneficial? They proved that they didn't know that she died, and yet were willing to tell me that she was fine.

So where is the benefit of knowingly lying?

Michael
 
Ashles, I am not doubting the veracity of the stories that have been posted. I am pointing out that rejecting anecdotal evidence in one direction and accepting it in another is a double standard. Do you really think that is appropriate? If so, what is your justification for accepting anecdotal evidence for harm but not for benefit?

Beth
 
Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
I would like to point out that what you are collecting here is anecdotal evidence.
True, and hopefully most readers will take this into account when viewing the material.
[...] I think it wise to consider the opposite side.
Any chance this can happen on a separate thread? Thx. :)
 
Well anyone who reads this thread and wishes to disregard the ones they consider to be anecdotal is welcome to do so. We are not trying to scientifically prove anything here.

In fact, we would actively encourage anyone who doubts any of these stories to do their own research into the subjects.
That's the spirit of scepticism and critical thinking.

Don't take our word for it. Read as much as you can from as many respectable scientific sources as you can.

And some stories on this thread are clearly not anecdotal. For example could anyone doubt that Dennis McKenzie has involved himself in Police cases and has subsequently produced no useful results?

Anyway, let's not debate this any further here - if you wish to start a new thread about it please do.
 
Beth Clarkson said:
Ashles, I am not doubting the veracity of the stories that have been posted. I am pointing out that rejecting... evidence in one direction and accepting it in another is a double standard.
So it would be.

If, for example, you were to post a link to a well-verified story from a reliable source of an occasion where a psychic has brought benefits to some person or persons commeasurate with the amount of money paid, and we were to "reject" it (how? refuse to look at it? say it wasn't true despite the authenticity of the source?) --- then that would be applying a double standard.

However, you have posted no such link to no such story.

Are you going to?

That way you could find out if we apply a double standard, rather than assuming we do and complaining about it. That's not polite, or clever.

Ashles, for example, has given instances of "psychics who help the police" being worse than useless. Can you post one authentic case of a psychic successfully helping the police? As attested to by, say, the officer in charge of the case? Then fire away.

And... "anecdotal"? If you say that all primes are odd, is citing 2 as an even prime an "anecdote", which therefore doesn't count? In order to refute the idea that "psychics and other paranormal beliefs are harmless", what else can one do except cite particular cases in which individual bogus psychics have caused harm? What other evidence could there be against this proposition? How does one refute a general proposition except by producing counterexamples?

Hey?

Any ideas?
 
Exercise caution when thinking about taking your loved one to see entities channelled from other plains of existence.

Vid clip (.avi, 2mins, 22Mb, DivX 5.2.1 encoded).

If you want to see the clip and the link's broken, pm me.
 
Perhaps this isn't paranormal, but alternative medicine is a close cousin, and can prove quite dangerous as well:

http://www.cancer-talk.com/Netherlands_to_crack_down_on_complementary_medicine-97046-3-a.html

The Netherlands is considering tougher laws on practitioners of
complementary medicine after government health inspectors who were
investigating the death from breast cancer in 2001 of the actress and
comedienne Sylvia Millecam severely criticised her treatment.

The investigators found that alternative practitioners contradicted the
diagnosis of breast cancer made by her doctors and offered her instead
the prospect of a cure with "unfounded methods of treatment."

The report concluded that "various individual carers" had "offered such
irresponsible care" that disciplinary action or criminal proceedings are
likely. Their role prevented a cure or an extension of Ms Millecam's
life, and she died from untreated breast cancer.
The investigators' report found that between September 1999 and her
death nearly two years later, when she was aged 45, Ms Millecam was
treated by 28 different practitioners and institutions. Though
mainstream care was available she exclusively chose alternative
treatments.

Her general practitioner had first identified a lump of 1 cm radius in
her breast. She was referred to a hospital radiology department, but the
tests were inconclusive. She was referred to a surgeon, but instead she
chose a doctor who practised alternative electro-acupuncture. She was
assured that nothing was the matter.

The next May breast cancer was diagnosed, and surgery was recommended.
Instead she saw a popular faith healer who said she did not have cancer
and advised against chemotherapy. She then began regular visits for
"healings." Over the next year she sought various cures, including "cell
specific cancer treatment" at a Swiss clinic and "salt therapy," and
visited a psychic healer. She was told on at least two occasions that
she did not have cancer but a bacterial infection.
 
If you're including paranormal "medicine", read about Richard Edwards' experience. People bringing animals back for years for ineffective treatment, and paying through the nose for it. People being "brainwashed" into believing that their animals were better when they actually weren't. People being charged £10 for a handful of sugar pills that cost "pence" to produce.

Rolfe.
 
Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
I would like to point out that what you are collecting here is anecdotal evidence. That doesn't make it invalid, nor does it mean that no harm occurs, but I think it wise to consider the opposite side. If someone were to be collecting similar evidence regarding the benefits of the paranormal, how would you respond? Would you consider it equally valid? Or would you dismiss such evidence as unreliable and unconvincing?

My wife and daughter (who both should know better) frequently ask, "what's the harm?" These reports are being collected to show the harm that "psycics", faith healers, homeopathy and "alternative" medicine do.

It is bad enough but unavoidable that some people are unscientific, superstitious and mistrustful of science. However, they never seem to be able to keep their ignorance to themselves. If the anti-vaccination crowd have their way, for instance, public health would be set back not decades but centuries.
 
Loki's post is awful. Its played on my mind for a couple of days now. How any believer can want or dare to post anything after it is beyond me. I don't even want to quote it becuase it would mean reading it again.

Beth, Janice, etc... read it and consider please...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom