What's The Harm?

On healthypages yesterday :
Sorry to change the subject but...when a tarot reader reads the cards for someone, is it usual to tell the person that someone is going to die?

I ask because a while ago after a recomendation, i had a tarot reader come to my house. I heard that she was very good and i must admit she was spot on with a lot of things.

What surprised me most was that she knew that my sister was very ill and said that she had a neurological illness. She also said that eventually she would be listened to and get help. I couldn't help but cry with relief, and she then went on to other things.

After a while, after looking again at the cards she said, 'You do know that her illness is going to eventually kill her don't you?'. I was in a state of shock and just nodded yes, but to be honest, it had never entered my mind.

I was glad when she left and i would never want to see her again. I could hardly talk on the phone to my other sister as i was crying so hard. It took a long time for me toput this tothe back of my mind..which i had to do as every time that i looked at my sister who's ill, i couldn't fight back the tears. I had to make up excuses why i was so upset as i didn't want her to know.

Aura
 
Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
I would like to point out that what you are collecting here is anecdotal evidence. That doesn't make it invalid, nor does it mean that no harm occurs, but I think it wise to consider the opposite side. If someone were to be collecting similar evidence regarding the benefits of the paranormal, how would you respond? Would you consider it equally valid? Or would you dismiss such evidence as unreliable and unconvincing?

I'm a little confused about your point. The original request was for "examples" of where belief in the paranormal has caused harm. If posting case histories where belief in the paranormal has caused harm is not a response to a request for "examples", then what is?

What's the other side? Oh, are there people who felt that paying money to a psychic was worth it, caused benefit to them? I wouldn't be surprised if you can find a great deal of such testimony.

How does that affect the claim that there have been deaths directly attributed to belief in the paranormal? Would you offer evidence that Dr. X, MD was a wonderful guy as counterevidence in the malpractice trial of Dr. Y, MD, who kills a patient through incompetence?
 
Re: Re: Double Standard?

rppa said:
I'm a little confused about your point. The original request was for "examples" of where belief in the paranormal has caused harm. If posting case histories where belief in the paranormal has caused harm is not a response to a request for "examples", then what is?

My point was that if you don't consider personal testimony or case histories as evidence for one side (i.e. benefits) then you can't consider it to be any more valid for the other side (harm). Generally, most people posting here do not consider anecdotal evidence valid, so why set up thread collecting evidence that isn't typically considered valid?

What's the other side? Oh, are there people who felt that paying money to a psychic was worth it, caused benefit to them? I wouldn't be surprised if you can find a great deal of such testimony.

Exactly. While I have no doubt there is evidence of harm, there is equally valid and compelling evidence of benefit. For example - consider all of 'John of God's' satisfied patients. If you don't consider thier case histories as evidence of benefit, you can't turn around and consider similar stories as evidence of harm.

How does that affect the claim that there have been deaths directly attributed to belief in the paranormal?

I don't think it affects that claim at all, any more than examples of harm affect the claim that benefits occur. Few things are entirely good or bad, it's a matter of degree. Does the benefit outway the harm? For example, it's a documented fact that many people die every year due to errors committed by doctors and nurses working in hospitals. Does that mean that hospitals are not a good place to get care when ill?

Beth
 
Beth Clarkson said:
While I have no doubt there is evidence of harm, there is equally valid and compelling evidence of benefit. For example - consider all of 'John of God's' satisfied patients. If you don't consider thier case histories as evidence of benefit...
If satisfaction was proof of benefit, then you'd have to believe that all sorts of things were beneficial. People used to be "satisfied" by the medical effects of kerosene, radium, mercury... satisified enough to go on taking them until the cumulative dose was lethal. But these substances are not beneficial. Nowadays, quackery's less likely to kill you, but something like homeopathy, say, has satisfied customers in their millions --- and no evidence at all that it's beneficial. It's just not the same thing.
If you don't consider thier case histories as evidence of benefit, you can't turn around and consider similar stories as evidence of harm.
But these are not similar stories. We're not talking about people who visisted a medium, fortune-teller, psychic, quack, or whatever and were merely dissatisfied. We're talking about actual harm. Candace Newmaker was not dissatisfied with her quack therapy --- she was murdered by it. A similar but opposite story would have to involve a quack psychotherapist returning a dead child to life. If you have "valid and compelling evidence" for this ever happening, let us know.
 
Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

Beth you are actually being a bit of an idiot now. It is once again clearly obvious that you have a desire to believe in these things and this is causnig you to become overly defensive about all things paranormal.

Most of these stories have perfectly clear backed up evidence and links. They are not anecdotal. Most aren't examples of someone posting "This happened to my cousin" etc.

example, it's a documented fact that many people die every year due to errors committed by doctors and nurses working in hospitals. Does that mean that hospitals are not a good place to get care when ill?
This is a ridiculous and tired argument. Without hospital and doctors care people often will die or be in severe pain or any number of unpleasant situations. The choice is go to the doctor or stay at home and get worse.
The same cannot be said for paranormal treatments.
Also if doctors and nurses cause deaths due to mistakes or incompetence they should expect to be held accountable for it.
So should these peddlers of the paranormal.
Or is it only Doctors and nurses who should have to answer for their mistakes?

And if someone is lying to recently bereaved parents about their child you think that's acceptable do you?

The question was where's the harm. We are providing examples of the harm, but you really don't want to see it.
Fine don't read this thread. But these things aren't as harmless and fluffy as people often make out.

It is people who deny it, like you Beth, that can put other people at risk.

I suggest you look at the advice provided in the homeopathy forums if you want to see real risks to life that can be prevented.

That you can read some of these stories and question this thread only goes to show that you are so committed to finding something magical, paranormal and exciting that you would willingly ignore the negative aspects of these issues.
 
Re: Re: Re: Double Standard?

My point was that if you don't consider personal testimony or case histories as evidence for one side (i.e. benefits) then you can't consider it to be any more valid for the other side (harm).

Since I believe you have scientific training, I find your pretending to misunderstand "anecdotes are not evidence" disingenuous.

In a murder trial, testimony about the murder, an actual videotape of the murder, is clearly evidence. It's also clearly an "anecdote" in the sense in which you're trying to use it. After all, we're just talking about one victim and one alleged murderer. So how can we use those "anecdotes" as "evidence"?

Generally, most people posting here do not consider anecdotal evidence valid....

I think you have the training to complete this sentence. "Most people posting here do not consider anecdotal evidence valid for proving....".

We have a case cited above where a person was videotaped murdering a child. Do you really think that's invalid as evidence for the murder? Do you really think anyone would so claim?

...so why set up thread collecting evidence that isn't typically considered valid?

The evidence is clearly valid for establishing that the people cited committed harmful acts. Are you really contesting that?

For example, it's a documented fact that many people die every year due to errors committed by doctors and nurses working in hospitals. Does that mean that hospitals are not a good place to get care when ill?

Hospitals where a statistically significant number of patients die due to errors, beyond the norm, are indeed bad places to get care when ill. That's why there are mechanisms to decertify hospitals and doctors with such records. Anecdotes of gross malpractice on the part of a doctor can indeed function as evidence that THAT PARTICULAR DOCTOR might need his license revoked, even if he has hundreds of satisfied patients.

The original poster asked for case histories where psychics committed harm. The stories collected are clearly evidence that these particular people committed these particular harmful acts. If somebody similarly asked for stories about criminally negligent malpractice in hospitals, and got them, those "anecdotes" would certainly be evidence that the hospital committed those acts.

In other words, the phrase "anecdotes are not evidence" should not be deliberately misconstrued in the way you're trying. And I think you know it.
 
Several times I have seen the claim that India uses a lot of homeopathic and 'alternative' medicine (particularly from Gavinmurthy).

Here are some health figures for India that I have posted before:
Ashles said:
Do they live longer?
Life expectancy figures

Hmm no, it seems not.
135th on the list? Seemingly below every Western country? Not too good. In fact for its wealth it's an extremely poor performance.

Infant mortality in Asia
About 90/1000. Relatively high even for the region.

Let's compare with Europe
European infant mortality
So it's higher even than the worst European figures, and much worse than most (eg the UK is about 7/1000).

Well okay, so infant mortality is very high, life is short, but maybe Indians are healthy throughout life?

Healthy life expectancy figures
If I sort the data by male life expectancy lost with the countries with the least life expectency lost from ill health at the top (Denmark as it happens) then India comes.... 60th.
60th in the world, again quite a way below just about every western country.

If I sort for FEMALE life expectancy India rates...
160th.
One hundred and sixtieth!

Below Nigeria. Below Sudan and Senegal. Below Uganda.

So a relatively rich country like India has a shockingly low level of health.
India is not a poor country. These health statistics are very poor.
We ask what's the harm. There could be a country of a billion people suffering because of their beliefs in false treatments.

Maybe those treatments give them comfort. But they don't appear to help their health.
 
Homeopathy/Alternative medicine isn't considered paranormal.

Also sceptics keep mentioning psychics being hired by the police. Some psychics have actually helped solve murderers and point out the guilty.
 
jambo372 said:
Homeopathy/Alternative medicine isn't considered paranormal.

Also sceptics keep mentioning psychics being hired by the police. Some psychics have actually helped solve murderers and point out the guilty.
Sigh.
You have an example of this?

Was it
A) In Russia
B) On a documentary you once saw?
 
Ashles said:
Sigh.
You have an example of this?

Was it
A) In Russia
B) On a documentary you once saw?

What has Russia got to do with anything ? Have sceptics got a problem with Russians or something ? As a matter of fact it wasn't in Russia, it was in my hometown, less than a mile from my house. I started a thread about it previously but it was removed because of accusations it made.

To cut a long story short and not get into gory forbidden details a girl named Moira Anderson went missing in the fifties. A medium named William was called in to help with the investigation 50 years on and lead them to a place. A local pervert recently made a deathbed confession and said that the body was ... exactly where the medium previously said it would be. He also accused another pervert of being involved ... this second paedophile denies accusations but his own daughter thinks he did it and wrote a book about it. Even his own father believes he did it, when he died he told him to own up. He still denies it and no charges have been brought against him to date. The confession also accused an unnamed party ... most people suspect this third anonymous offender was high up in the local police force ... this would explain why the police did so little to help at the time. They suspect he was a police officer because of this and because one of the other child fiddlers was friends with many of the police.

For more details you can read 'Where There Is Evil' by Sandra Brown.
 
To cut a long story short and not get into gory forbidden details a girl named Moira Anderson went missing in the fifties. A medium named William was called in to help with the investigation 50 years on and lead them to a place.

Was there a body there when he took the police there?

A local pervert recently made a deathbed confession and said that the body was ... exactly where the medium previously said it would be.

And was it?

Why does the Moira Anderson Foundation consider her case still to be unresolved?

http://members.aol.com/sandra7510/pics/brochure.JPG
 
rppa said:
To cut a long story short and not get into gory forbidden details a girl named Moira Anderson went missing in the fifties. A medium named William was called in to help with the investigation 50 years on and lead them to a place.

Was there a body there when he took the police there?

A local pervert recently made a deathbed confession and said that the body was ... exactly where the medium previously said it would be.

And was it?

Why does the Moira Anderson Foundation consider her case still to be unresolved?

http://members.aol.com/sandra7510/pics/brochure.JPG

The pond is very deep and full of plant debris and junk, they sent divers in but they could only go down so far. Also the body will have been decomposing for decades.
 
jambo372 said:
The pond is very deep and full of plant debris and junk, they sent divers in but they could only go down so far. Also the body will have been decomposing for decades.
So the body hasn't been found, the case hasn't been solved, no-one has been prosecuted and a psychic has come up with the old "body of water" prediction.

And that's the best you can do is it Jambo?

Thanks for providing another example of the harm mediums can do.

And I remember your original thread - all the claims were thoroughly disposed of.
 
Double Standard?

rppa said:
Since I believe you have scientific training, I find your pretending to misunderstand "anecdotes are not evidence" disingenuous.

I'm not claiming that anecdotes are not evidence. I'm saying that if you don't accept anecdotal evidence for one side of an argument (and most posters here do not accept such evidence in regard to the benefits of such beliefs), it's a double standard to turn around and accept it as evidence for the other side.

The evidence is clearly valid for establishing that the people cited committed harmful acts. Are you really contesting that?

No, I'm not.

The original poster asked for case histories where psychics committed harm. The stories collected are clearly evidence that these particular people committed these particular harmful acts. If somebody similarly asked for stories about criminally negligent malpractice in hospitals, and got them, those "anecdotes" would certainly be evidence that the hospital committed those acts.

But they would not be evidence that belief in standard hospital practices was dangerous. That seems to me more analogous to the situation here.

In other words, the phrase "anecdotes are not evidence" should not be deliberately misconstrued in the way you're trying. And I think you know it.

I think you are mistaken about the point I was trying to make. Perhaps I expressed myself poorly, but I was not trying to misconstue anything.
 
Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
I'm not claiming that anecdotes are not evidence. I'm saying that if you don't accept anecdotal evidence for one side of an argument (and most posters here do not accept such evidence in regard to the benefits of such beliefs), it's a double standard to turn around and accept it as evidence for the other side.
But in what sense is this anecdotal? If someone asks for evidence that airships aren't always safe, and they are directed to the R101 disaster, in what sense is this an "anecdote"? It happened. It's a fact.

The R101 really crashed. It's a well-documented historical fact. This is indeed solid evidence that airships aren't always safe.

The Xhosa really killed their cattle at the behest of Nongqawuse. It's a well-documented historical fact. This is indeed solid evidence that belief in the supernatural is not always harmless.

Will you give an example of a well-documented historical fact which sceptics dismiss as "anecdotal evidence"?
 
Here's a particularly jaded view of psychic detectives, but I suppose if you lost your daughter and had these folks hanging around you might develop such a view. This was written by one of Polly Klaas' parents:

http://www.klaaskids.org/pg-mc-hazards.htm

Beth Clarkson said:
I would like to point out that what you are collecting here is anecdotal evidence. That doesn't make it invalid, nor does it mean that no harm occurs, but I think it wise to consider the opposite side. If someone were to be collecting similar evidence regarding the benefits of the paranormal, how would you respond? Would you consider it equally valid? Or would you dismiss such evidence as unreliable and unconvincing?

How would I respond to "similar evidence regarding the benefits of the paranormal"? Show me some, and I'll let you know.

"[W]ould you dismiss such evidence as unreliable and unconvincing?"

Perhaps. If the evidence were unreliable and unconvincing, why yes, I'd call it that, and dismiss it.
 
Re: Double Standard?

Beth Clarkson said:
But they would not be evidence that belief in standard hospital practices was dangerous. That seems to me more analogous to the situation here.

Have you ever wondered why there is much more litigation in scientific medicine than there is in alternative medicine? That's because scientific medicine is always held up to extremely high standards - there are evidence-based standards of care that have to be met, or else the doctor risks being litigated against for doing a slightly less efficient job that he/she ought to have done.

On the other hand, when it comes to alternative medicine, the only times one ever hears of legal action is when the practitioners commit horrific acts - like in the 'rebirthing' tragedy. That's because there's simply no evidence-based standard of care, the reason being that there's no evidence. Alternative medicine is an 'anything goes' kind of field. The fact that homeopaths routinely ask diabetics to stop their insulin doses (which have been repeatedly proven to be extremely effective at reducing morbidity and mortality) and take instead their homeopathic medications (which have never been shown to pass a proper trial) is something that seems to escape those who feel that 'standard' alternative medicine is harmless.

In my opinion, the best thing in the world would be for alternative medicine to be exposed to the same kind of litigative stress as scientific medicine. That seems like the only way to force it to put up or shut up. When that happens, either there'll be flurries of wondrous and astonishing studies and publications, proving that crystal therapy and reiki and energy auras were real after all. Or quacks will be forced to draw the shutters once and for all. Forgive me for taking a wild guess - I think it'll be the latter.

Even if we decide to ignore the cases mention here and talk instead just of 'standard' alternative medicine, we are still left with the fact that it is dangerous and downright unethical to expose a patient to a form of medicine that is untested and unproven when there are tested and proved medications available - unless the patient provides complete consent to participating in an experimental drug study. And how many homeopaths have we seen who tell their patients, "You know Stephen, we've been trying for 200 years but haven't been able to ever actually show that this pill works. Anyway, take two in the morning and two in the evening and see me in a fortnight."?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom